2017 글로벌 정보보호 산업시장 동향 조사 Symantec, McAfee, Check Point, EMC, Fortinet, HP Security, Cisco, Trend Micro, Palo Alto Networks, Blue Coat Systems, Check Point Technology, ... Ingram Micro, A1

  • Published on
    09-Apr-2018

  • View
    286

  • Download
    28

Transcript

  • 2017 The Research on Global Security Market Trends

    : ()

    2017. 11.

    KISA-2017-0036

  • 2017

    .

    2017 11 30

    :()

    : / ()

    : ()

    ()

    ()

    ()

    ()

    KISA: ()

    ()

    ()

    KISA : ( )

    ( )

    ( )

    ( )

  • - i -

    1.

    , , , IT

    o (IoT) IoT /

    (surface attack)

    o

    ICT

    o CIO 2017

    EU CIO IT

    : Morgan Stanley(2017.1)

  • - ii -

    5 12.9%

    o IT Technavio ,

    2016 1,003 6 5 12.9% 2021

    1,839 6

    ( : )

    : Technavio(2017.9)

    Memoori Business Intelligence

    , (Surveillance)

    2016 284 4,000

    o Memoori 2015 4.5% ,

    5 8.2% ,

    5 5.6% 2021 374 3,000

  • - iii -

    1) ( : )

    : Memoori Business Intelligence, The Physical Security Business 2016 to 2021(2016.4Q)

    2.

    o

    o

    5 , 30

    (5) - , , , ,

    (8) - , , , , , , ,

    (5) - , , , ,

    (6) - , UAE, , , ,

    (6) - , , , , ,

    1)

  • - iv -

    3.

    o 1 , 2 ,

    3 3

    - 1 , ,

    - 2 30

    - 3

    30

    II

    1.

    1)

    o () ITU (GCI) 2

    , ,

    -

    -

    , ,

    o ( ) 1/3

    ,

    - (DoD), (DHS)

    - (TIA)

    , '17 635

    - ,

  • - v -

    - Barnes & Co. ,

    , 2017 188 8,690

    o ( ) ,

    - Symantec, McAfee, Check Point, EMC, Fortinet, HP Security, Cisco, Trend Micro,

    Palo Alto Networks, Blue Coat Systems, Check Point Technology, Kaspersky Lab

    - Barclays CIO Palo Alto Networks Fortinet

    Cisco, Check Point Juniper

    - 2

    , ADT Security Service, Ingram Micro, A1

    Security Cameras

    o ( )

    - Upwork, IT

    2(1 ) .

    13 10 5 (17.12)

    - AWS, GuardDuty , . AWS

    AWS

    (17.11)

    - Oracle '17 10 Larry Ellison Oracle

    IT .

    Oracle Management Cloud ,

    (17.10)

    - MS '14 Hexadite 1

    . Hexadite 35

    , (17.05)

    - RSA 2017 Fortinet, McAfee, Palo

    Alto Networks, Symantec (Cyber Threat Alliance,

    CTA) (17.02)

    - IBM, (AI)

    Watson for Cyber Security (17.02)

  • - vi -

    o ()

    M&A,

    2)

    o () 2017 GCI 11

    , 2020

    ,

    o ( ) 2020

    ,

    '13

    - '16 4,704 , /, IP

    ,

    (, '17.2) - '16 4.0% 9,327

    9,000 ((JNSA), 17.6)

    o ( ) IP

    , Trend Micro Symantec, McAfee

    3 90%

    - Fujitsu, Hitachi, Mitsubishi, NEC, Oki, Panasonic, Toshiba, Sony

    - Trend Micro, Symantec, McAfee

    o ( )

    - , , , ,

    1/2, 1/2

    - '16 ,

    '20

    - ,

    - ,

  • - vii -

    o () , SI ,

    2

    3)

    o () (IRA)

    o ( )

    - '16 49 9,400 , '17 52 3,500

    ( , '16)

    - '15 11 '16 3

    , CCTV

    o ( )

    4

    - , ICT ,

    HW/SW , VAR(value-added reseller)

    -

    - HD CCTV,

    ,

    ,

    o ( )

    - (Infrastructure)

    4%

    1,700 ('17.8)

    - ,

    (Cyber health check) ('17.8)

    - , (Supply chain)

    8 (17.8)

  • - viii -

    o () , , ,

    R&D

    4)

    o () '15 11 '16 3

    o ( ) '13 2020 5%

    (, 15.11)

    - '15 IS

    - '10

    '16 45% '15 11% ( , 16.10)

    - '16 10% (PAC, '16.9)

    o ( ) 4,500~10,000

    ,

    - 4,500 470~600,

    3,900~4,000

    - Securitas AB

    Securitas France 15% ,

    Groupe Seris

    o ( )

    - Thales, Gemalto .

    '17 Thales

    Gemalto ,

    ('17.12)

    - , Cybermalveillance.gouv.fr .

    ,

    2019 250 ('17.5)

    o () , ,

  • - ix -

    5)

    o () 2017 GCI 24

    o ( ) '11-'15 9.5% , '15~'20 ICT

    - 2015 32.9% 2020 323 6

    (MarketLine, 15.11)

    - 2008 20 IT 2015 37

    6% (Statista, 16)

    o ( ) ,

    (Reseller)

    - AV-TEST

    Avira, Giesecke & Devrinet

    - , , , Cisco,

    IBM, Symantec, Northrop Grumman, Check Point, Trend Micro

    - Bosch, MOBOTIX, Honeywell Sanyo

    Panasonic

    o ( )

    - '18 5 GDPR ,

    (DPO) ('17.7)

    - ,

    ('16.7)

    o () 4.0

    R&D

    2.

    1)

    o () , ,

    ,

  • - x -

    o ( ) 3 20% ,

    10%

    - '16 20.9% 495 8,000

    ( ()), 17.8) - , , ,

    , 2014 60%

    - '16 5,400 11%

    , GDP 7%((CPS), 17.1) - , ,

    o ( )

    - , Venustech

    5.5% (CCID Consulting, '15)

    -

    (UBS, '16.11)

    - CCTV Hikvision() Dahua Technology() '15 1, 2 (Morgan

    Stanley, '17.7)

    o ( )

    - , .

    CCTV

    (17.07)

    - ,

    ,

    .

    , ,

    ,

    (17.07)

    - '16 11 () (

  • - xi -

    ) '17 6 1 . 7 29

    ,

    (17.06)

    - , (17.05)

    - '14 10 (16.11)

    o ()

    , ,

    ,

    2)

    o () ,

    o ( ) ,

    - '16 111 (SDI, 15.8), 17

    12% 15 '18 17

    (Gartner, 17.8)

    - '16 54 4,200 , '18 63 5,100

    (Barnes Reports, 17.1)

    o ( )

    ,

    - Honeywell Bosch Security India

    OEM

    - (organized) 700 ,

    (unorganized) 1,500

    o ( )

    - '09

    (Aadhaar) .

    Aadhaar

    '17 3 11

    - Arun Jaitley '17 6

  • - xii -

    (17.8)

    - ,

    (17.8)

    o () /

    ,

    3)

    o () Trend Micro ,

    , 2017 GCI 70

    o ( ) IDC '14

    4 1,790 , 3 ,

    7 1,770

    - / '14 7,600

    , '20 31% 2 9,400

    (Frost & Sullivan, '16)

    - '15 12 7,000

    , 12 10% (Barnes Reports, 15)

    o ( ) IT IT

    ,

    - IT EMC, HP, Cisco, VMware, Redhat, Radware,

    Sophos, WildPackets, RUCKUS

    - Check Point, Trend Micro, Fortinet, ARUBA Networks,

    McAfee, HP Security

    - ,

    AvTech, Axis Communications, Bosch Security Systems,

    Dahua, Hikvision, Hanwha( Samsung) Techwin, Honeywell, Mobotix,

    Panasonic, Pelco by Schneider, VIvotek

    o ( )

    - ID-SIRTII/CC, Indonesia Cyber Security Report 2017 '16 9 50% 1 3,567

    ('17)

  • - xiii -

    - , 10

    200 ('17.5)

    o () , ,

    , ()

    4)

    o () MS , '16

    , Kaspersky Lab, Symantec

    10

    o ( ) 10%

    - '16 (Secutech VIetnam) 15%

    - '16~'22 12.4%

    (6Wresearch, '16)

    - 15% '16 6,750

    (MIC, 14)

    o ( ) Symantec,

    IBM, McAfee, Cisco 4

    , BKAV

    - '13 600

    Kaspersky Lab(47.6%)

    , BKAV(32.%), Symantec(14.7%), McAfee(13.3%) (MIC, '13)

    - SW BKAV SW

    5 , 1,000

    o ( )

    - 5,300 BullGuard

    . Bao Tin Technology, 1+1 6

    ('17.7)

    - , .

  • - xiv -

    ('17.6)

    - VNPT

    Novicom MOU ('17.4)

    o ()

    5)

    o ()

    ,

    o ( )

    ,

    - 5

    (IDC, 16)

    - 10% 400

    ,

    (Robert Bosch SEA)

    o ( )

    ,

    SI

    - CambodiaSoft '05 IT , , ,

    , ,

    - '14 40, CCTV

    30 (KOTRA, '14)

    o ( )

    - '18

    (Pub Street) CCTV 30 ('17.7)

    - , 6 .

    '17 2 20 3 3 , , , ,

    (JICA)

  • - xv -

    ('17.3)

    o () , , , .

    , ODA, EDCF

    6)

    o () (Allianz Global) 2

    (Bangkokpost, '16.6)

    o ( ) ,

    - '17 37 ( 1 1 )

    , '18 10~12% (MarketsandMarkets)

    - CCTV '13~'17 21.5%

    ,

    (RNCOS)

    o ( ) Trend Micro, McAfee, Check Point, Symantec, Sophos,

    Kaspersky

    -

    ,

    o ( )

    - Tobias Feakin ,

    (17.6)

    - Thailand 4.0 (16.5)

    o ()

    7)

    o ()

  • - xvi -

    ITU 2017 GCI 1

    o ( )

    - '20 9 ( 6 )

    (PwC, '16.12)

    - 200

    , , ,

    o ( ) ,

    - McAfee,

    Kaspersky Lab, Websense, Trend Micro, Norman

    - 200 , ,

    o ( )

    - (NUS), Kaspersky Lab

    (R&D) (APT)

    ('17.10)

    - (CSA) 11 (CII)

    ('17.7)

    - (SAF)

    24

    (Defence Cyber Organisation, DCO) ('17.3)

    o ()

    , , SK,

    NSHC

    8)

    o () ITU 2017

    GCI 3

    o ( )

    IT

  • - xvii -

    - '16 2 4,290 5

    21.1% 21 6 3,260 (IDC, '17.8)

    - (Managed Security Service) 16 7,320

    21 2 2,390 25.1%

    o ( ) Kaspersky Lab, Symantec, Websense, Trend

    Micro, Panda Security ,

    - Kaspersky Lab Panda Security

    - Websense, ClearSwift, Consentry Networks

    , , ,

    ,

    o ( )

    - CREST(Council of Registered Ethical Security

    Testers) PPKS(Association of Cyber Security Testers for Kuala

    Lumpur, Selangor and Putrajaya) MOU ('17.7)

    - (MDEC) PGI(Protection Group International)

    . PGI

    , , ,

    GCHQ ('16.12)

    o () ,

    .

    3.

    1)

    o () 2

  • - xviii -

    o ( ) ,

    - '16 1,103, 73,000

    ( (National Council of Private Security), '17)

    - 31.6 GDP 1.2%

    (IHS Markit, '16)

    o ( )

    - ESET, AlienVault, Kaspersky Lab

    Trend Micro

    -

    LockState, Rocky Mountain

    o ( )

    - '17 3, 6.07%

    ,

    Win32/Fuery(Microsoft, 17.8)

    o () ICT ,

    ,

    2)

    o () ,

    o ( ) ,

    - , IT , , GDP

    '17 1,700

    - '16 CCTV 1,718 ,

    1.05%

  • - xix -

    o ( )

    - , Akamai, IBM, HP

    SOC , Deloitte

    - Cristhian Fernando Carballo Sanchez, Grupo MR Dos Seguridad S.A, Kruma

    Consultores RD S.A

    o ( )

    - ' 2014-2018' '

    2015-2021' (, 17.10)

    - , , 3

    '17

    (, 17.7)

    o ()

    .

    3)

    o () 1964

    o ( )

    - 1964 52 CCTV

    - The Safety and Security Resource Guide(13)

    4~5%

    - , , , , ,

    o ( ) , ,

    , , ,

    - '16 , , 3,500-3,600

  • - xx -

    - Microsoft ,

    2 CyberArk

    o ( )

    - '16 (FARC) FARC ('17.6)

    -

    ,

    o () ,

    AS , (SI)

    4)

    o ()

    ,

    ,

    o ( ) ,

    ,

    - '14 2 5,000 ,

    15% '16 3

    (, 3 )

    - 5 11%

    o ( ) '16 1,560

    , 100

    10

    -

    - Automatec, Casmar Electronica Chile S.A, Davantec Technologias Y Consultorias

    Limitida, Support Services Limitida

    o ( )

    -

    ('17 1), '17 12

    -

  • - xxi -

    Digital Agenda 2020( ) (16.1)

    o () ,

    .

    5)

    o () ,

    o ( )

    10%

    -

    - '14 750

    (Technavio, 15)

    o ( )

    -

    Intelligente Solution 9

    - 300-400

    10

    o ( )

    - ('17 11 5 ) 1(PLC)

    (17.9)

    o ()

    ,

    4.

    1)

    o () 2000

  • - xxii -

    2015

    o ( ) 2,550 ,

    4,830 7,380

    - '14~'17 GCC

    8 3,400 15%

    - GCC CCTV

    o ( ) ,

    ,

    - Thales Lockheed Martin

    - First Information Security, Sachin Technologies LLC, Vision Innovative Technologies

    LLC, Gulf Business Machines(GBM) Oman

    o ( )

    - OCERT, FIRST(Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams)

    (17.6)

    FIRST

    - ISO/IEC 17025 (17.4)

    - Oman Airports Management Company(OAMC),

    Lockheed Martin BEONTRA Suite (16.3)

    o ()

    , , AS .

    '16

    2) UAE

    o () UAE

    , ,

    o ( ) UAE

    ,

    /

  • - xxiii -

    - 16 UAE 16.6 (SDI, '16)

    - 13.6 , 2.4 , 6

    82%

    o ( ) UAE ,

    - UAE , Thales,

    IBM, UTC( GE Security), Honeywell, Schneider/Pelco, Siemens, Johnson Controls,

    Cisco , Kaspersky Lab, Trend Micro

    o ( )

    - UAE

    (Dubai Electronic Security Center) (17.5)

    - '17 5 Smart Grid Security Summit

    (17.5)

    - du, du(du Enterprise Security Operations Center)'

    (16.10)

    o () , , ,

    , SOC,

    , UAE

    3)

    o () '22

    ,

    o ( ) ,

    - '16 3 8,000 , 353

    - '25 1.58%

    (SDI, '16.10)

    o ( )

    - , , IT ,

  • - xxiv -

    ,

    G4S

    o ( )

    - ,

    (17.7)

    - UAE

    (17.5)

    o () , ,

    . ,

    ,

    4)

    o ()

    ,

    o ( )

    ,

    ,

    - 4 4,000 (Barnes Reports, '15.12)

    -

    ,

    o ( ) 16 1

    - 5,810 ,

    4,260, 636

    (628), (145), (141)

    o ( )

    - , ICT

    (17.8)

    - 17 5~7 2 2 PC

    o ()

  • - xxv -

    AS . , , ,

    .

    ,

    5)

    o () 2030(National

    Transformation Program and Saudi Vision 2030)

    o ( ) GCC , UAE, , ,

    ,

    - 15 6 3 15 ~ 25 3.07%

    2025 8 5,500 (SDI, '15)

    - CCTV , 14~19

    23%

    o ( ) IT

    - GCC Thales, IBM, UTC( GE

    Security), Honeywell, Schneider/Pelco, Siemens, Johnson Controls, Cisco, ARINC

    Axis Communications

    o ( )

    - (NCSC),

    (17.2)

    - 5 Shamoon 16

    11 ~17 1

    o ()

    ,

    6)

    o () ITU (GCI 2017) 20 (mature)

    ,

    o ( ) ,

  • - xxvi -

    - 15 1 8,700 ,

    3.73% 25 2 7,000 (SDI, '16.3)

    - '16 , CCTV

    , ,

    o ( )

    - Check Point, CyberArk, Comsec

    - NICE Systems

    , 350

    o ( )

    - TD .

    , TD (17.10)

    -

    (17.7)

    o () R&D

    5.

    1)

    o () ICT ,

    o ( ) '14 380, '15

    1,823

    - , , ,

    , (SERIANU, 16)

    -

    - CCTV '16 397

    o ( ) NRD(Norway Registers Development) East Africa

    Ltd. Lumension, IBM Security,

    AccessData, Qualys, FireEye, Fortibet and Vasco

  • - xxvii -

    - IT , ICT ,

    , ,

    - Kiwango Security Guard, Cyberoam , Raha, Benson

    Security Systems(BSS)

    o ( )

    -

    (17.10)

    -

    (17.7)

    - 3 Tigo (17.2)

    o () , ,

    .

    , , AS .

    , ODA, EDCF

    2)

    o () ICT ,

    (RDB) ICT(Ministry of Youth and ICT)

    o ( ) 2017 (NCSA)

    - '17 280

    - CCTV '10 , '16

    176.3

    o ( ) CCTV

    - CCTV

    o ( )

    - Kagame, Huawei Ms. Sun

    Yafang(Chairwoman) ICT

  • - xxviii -

    Huawei MoU (17.3)

    - WISeKey International Holding, 17

    /IoT

    (17.3)

    o () SOC, PKI ,

    . Joint Venture

    3)

    o ()

    (Kenya Security Survey 2016)

    o ( ) ICT

    ,

    IT

    - '17 2,330

    - '15 10 (SDI, '16)

    o ( ) Symantec Cyberoam

    ISP

    - ,

    - Symantec, NetGuardians, Cyberroam

    Pamoja, Sofgen, BusinessIT Africa

    - IT Naisoft

    - AccessKenya Security Risks Solution

    Internet Solutions Kenya Managed Security Service(MSS)

    o ( )

    - 2016(Computer and cybercrime Bill)' (17.4)

    o ()

    .

    , , AS

  • - xxix -

    4)

    o () ,

    , ICT

    o ( )

    - ICT GDP

    '17 420

    o ( )

    - Microsoft, IBM, Cisco IT

    - IPX Gabon , VSAT

    30

    o ( )

    - ANINF Kaspersky Lab

    MOU (16.6)

    - Microsoft CityNext

    (16.3)

    o () 1

    .

    5)

    o ()

    o ( )

    - ICT GDP

    '17 430

    - CCTV ,

    '16 57.8

  • - xxx -

    o ( ) IT Microsoft, Cisco, IBM IT ,

    -

    IBM IT

    - DVR, ,

    1 ,

    2 ,

    o ( )

    - , ,

    (CDP) (17.3)

    - ,

    (16.1)

    o () .

    ODA,

    EDCF 2~3

    6)

    o ()

    10 10%

    ,

    o ( )

    - ICT GDP

    '17 2,410

    - CCTV '16 436 ,

    1 4,031

    o ( )

    IT 2~3

    - (INSA) Kaspersky

    Kaspersky

  • 1

    1. 1

    2. 6

    3. 7

    8

    1. 8

    . 10

    . 72

    . 101

    . 151

    . 199

    2. 238

    . 240

    . 275

    . 298

    . 330

    . 352

    . 365

    . 383

    . 405

    3. 430

    . 432

    . 460

    . 476

    . 501

    . 525

    4. 541

    . 543

    . UAE 569

    . 593

  • . 611

    . 633

    . 654

    5. 691

    . 693

    . 720

    . 754

    . 771

    . 783

    . 796

    809

    1. 809

    2. 30 811

    3. 814

    867

  • - 1 -

    I

    1.

    m , , , IT

    (IoT) IoT /

    (surface attack)

    - IT Gartner , IoT 1997~2016 20 60

    , 2017~2019 3 210

    - IoT 2013-2020 24% ,

    2020 8 4,100

    IoT (: )

    : Gartner(2016)

    - Gartner 2017 9 2020

  • - 2 -

    90

    - 2016 HummingBad 8,500 , QuadRooter 9 , Godless Malware 85

    ICT

    m ICT

    CIO 2017

    - Morgan Stanley EU 100

    CIO 1 , 2 ,

    EU CIO IT

    : Morgan Stanley(2017.1)

  • - 3 -

    - Piper Jaffray CIO

    80% 2017 IT

    2017 IT

    : Piper Jaffray (2017.1)

    5 12.9%

    - IT Technavio , 2016

    1,003 6 5 12.9% 2021 1,839 6

    - 2016 347 ,

    305 6 , 216 8

  • - 4 -

    ( : )

    : Technavio(2017.9)

    Memoori Business Intelligence

    , (Surveillance)

    2016 284 4,000

    * Memoori

    - Memoori 2015 4.5% , 5

    8.2% , 5 5.6%

    2021 374 3,000

    - Memoori 2014 252 8,000

    , 134 8,000 ( 53%),

    61 8,000 (24%), 56 2,000 (23%)

    - 2014 7.5% , 9.9% ,

    IP ,

    10%

  • - 5 -

    2) ( : )

    : Memoori Business Intelligence, The Physical Security Business 2016 to 2021(2016.4Q)

    ,

    - ICT , ,

    -

    2)

  • - 6 -

    2.

    1)

    - , , ,

    , , ,

    - ,

    , , , ,

    *

    2)

    5 , 30

    (5) - , , , ,

    (8) - , , , , , , ,

    (5) - , , , ,

    (6) - , UAE, , , ,

    (6) - , , , , ,

  • - 7 -

    - 3(, , )

    - G3

    , 4 ,

    , , ,

    - 2 , FTA

    , , ICT ,

    - ICT

    ,

    UAE, 2022 ,

    -

    , , , , ,

    3.

    1 , 2 , 3

    3

    - 1 , ,

    - 2 30

    - 3

    27

  • - 8 -

    II

    1.

    m

    ,

    - GDP 18 6 , 1 GDP 57,4674(2016)

    , , , 3

    -

    - , , ,

    (2016 )

    (US$ )

    (US$ )

    1948. 8. 695 432, , , ,

    ,

    , , , ,,

    1965. 12. 244 475

    , , ,

    , , , ,

    1886. 6. 64 189

    , , , ,

    , /

    , , ,

    ,

    1884. 4. 63 52, , ,

    , , , ,

    1883. 11. 25 58, ,

    , ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    : Kotra-, 2017

  • - 9 -

    (ITU) , ICT

    (, ) ICT

    (ICT development Index, IDI)

    - 2016 ICT (ICT Development Index, IDI)

    ICT IDI

    8.57 5, 10, 12

    ICT(IDI)

    IDI(2016) (access) (use) (skill)

    15 8.17 19 8.27 18 7.57 1 9.18

    10 8.37 10 8.80 8 8.14 35 7.97

    12 8.31 5 9.09 21 7.49 23 8.36

    5 8.57 3 9.24 9 8.09 29 8.18

    16 8.11 12 8.70 17 7.61 36 7.94

    1 8.84 8 8.99 3 8.57 3 9.08

    : ITU, Measuring the Information Society Report 2016(2016)

  • - 10 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) , , ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.919 2

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 10%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 8.17 15 8.84 1

    (Access) 8.27 19 8.99 8

    (Use) 7.57 18 8.57 3

    (Skills) 9.18 1 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.919 2 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.842 12 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.8 5 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) 127% LTE 70%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    121,530 37.1 28,035 56.1

    106,072 32.4 20,555 41.1

    416,684 127.2 61,295 122.7

    76.18% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 19,417.10

    '17 () 326,625

  • - 11 -

    1)

    )

    m

    ITU 2017 Global Cybersecurity Index(GCI)

    0.919 2 , 1

    - , 5

    , ,

    -

    1.0 0.9

    ,

    - 2017 4, Symantec , 2016

    , , 23.96% 1

    - 2 9.63%, 3 5.84%

    - NexusGuard DDoS , 2016 2 DDoS

    83% 159,704 76,462

    DDoS 3

    -

    - , ,

    Symantec , 36%

  • - 12 -

    - 64% , 34%

    , 266% ,

    1,077

    m

    ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    -

    ,

    - , ,

    - ,

    ,

    - , , ,

    - , ,

    2

  • - 13 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 1.3% 1 2,153

    ( 37.96%)

    -

    - AT&T, Verizon, Century Link Inc. ,

    (44.1%) (29.9%)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 1.0% 1 1,470

    , 32.4%

  • - 14 -

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 9.5% 4 1,668

    , 127.1%

    - Strategy Analytics ,

    Verizon, AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile 80%

    - Buddecomm , Mobile-Only 2008 18% 2017

    49%

    - LTE 5G

    97% 3

    2000 88%

  • - 15 -

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    - Strategic Defence Intelligence( SDI) ,

    2024 50%

    ,

    - 1/3 IT

  • - 16 -

    - ,

    (DoD), (DHS)

    - 2010 130

    , 2016 10 140

    - (TIA) , (

    ) , 2017 635

    - 2017 (Critical Infrastructure)

    124 , 105

    ,

    ,

    - 10%

    ,

    (VPN)

    - ,

    ,

    (SIEM, Security Information & Event Management)

    - IT PC

    - , 2013~2023

    ,

    34%

  • - 17 -

    2013~2023

    Einstein intrusion detection system

    - 2010~202113 5 (~2014), 38

    Cyber Genome project

    - 2010~2013 7,700

    Automated Program Analysis for Cybersecurity(APAC)

    - 2012~2015 4,000

    Mission-oriented Resilient Clouds(MRC)

    - 2011~2020 -

    Active Authentication Program(AAP)

    IAM - 2013~2016 -

    National Cyber Range(NCR)

    - 2011~2015 5,400

    Sensor Shadow - Cyberspace Operations Program

    General Dynamics Advanced Information Systems(GD-AIS)

    2012~2014 500

    Agile Cyber Technology(ACT) programme

    L-3 Stratis 2012~2017 300

    Cyber Analytical Information Technology Services

    Point One Inc 2010~2015 6,832

    Cyber Camouflage, Concealment and Deception

    - 2011 -

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025(2016.3)

    ,

    - , ,

    5,000

    -

    ,

    - 300

    - , ,

  • - 18 -

    ,

    -

    OEM

    - ,

    - ,

    - ,

    ,

    , ,

    : Ken Research, The US Electronics Security Industry Outlook to 2017(2013.6)

    m

    SDI 3), 2015 67

    , 2025 (CAGR) 2.70% 87

    - 2023 2023

    -

    3) SDI, 'The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025: Market Brief'(2016.3)

  • - 19 -

    - 3%

    (Identity & Access)

    (2015~2025)

    (: )

    6.77.6

    8.3 8.6 8.38.9 8.9

    9.7 109.3

    8.7

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2015

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025(2016.3)

    Markets and Market , 2016

    2,475 , 2021 4,565

    - 2017 317 , 18%

    - Frost & Sullivan 2020

    ICT 100

    - 2017 180 5 4.4%

    2022 220

    ,

    - (Software as a Service, SaaS)

    ,

    - SECaas(Security-as-a-Service)

    , ,

  • - 20 -

    - (SIEM: Security

    Information & Event Management) , SIEM

    SDI , 2016 2,320

    2025 3,505

    - 1.01%

    (: )

    : SDI, 'United States Defense Spends on Homeland Security'(2016.8)

    Barnes & Co. ,

    , 2015 163 6,180 2016 175 5,900

    2017 188 8,690

    -

    - ,

    DIY

    - 2020 DIY 15 ,

    (Security) 58%

  • - 21 -

    (2013~2017)

    (: )

    14682.215507.3

    16361.817559

    18886.9

    0

    2000

    4000

    6000

    8000

    10000

    12000

    14000

    16000

    18000

    20000

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

    : Barnes Reports, '2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Security Systems Services

    Industry' (2016.5)

    -

    - /

    - IT

    - , Cisco IT

    , (managed security)

    - ,

  • - 22 -

    )

    m

    57% ,

    31% 2, 16%, 14%

    - SDI , 2015 35

    2015 2025 489

    - 2015 14 2025 18

    - 2015

    70%

    - , 2015 8 8,600

    2025 3.27%

    (2015~2025)

    (: )

    2015 2025

    (2015-2025)

    (2015-2025)

    3.5 4.8 48.9 3.32%

    1.4 1.8 22.0 2.73%

    0.925 1.4 14.9 4.55%

    0.886 0.636 9.2 -3.27%

    6.7 8.7 94.9 2.70%

    : SDI, 'The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025'(2016.3)

  • - 23 -

    (2017)

    : SDI, 'The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025'(2016.3)

    -

    - Symantec, McAfee, Kaspersky Lab, Trend Micro

    ,

    - (On-Premise)

    - , (IoT), ICT

    - Cisco, Juniper, F5 (Virtual Private Network, VPN)

    VPN

    IT

    - 2015 9 2,500 2025

    4.55% 149

    -

  • - 24 -

    - ,

    - (On-Premise)

    ,

    IBIS World ,

    61.6% , ,

    5

    - 29.1%

    - 9.3% ,

    2017 5 Morgan Stanley CSO(Chief Security Officer)

    , Firewall

    3

    - 2017 6% 3 IT

    4% 9%

    - 30% CSO 2017 Firewall

    2016 27% . CSO

    APT

    - ,

    , (Cloud Access Security

    Brokerage Solution)

    Barclays CIO(Chief Information Officer) , 7

    12 71

    - , , 2015

    1~3

  • - 25 -

    - APT 2015 13 2016 17

    - , , DDos , Firewall 2015

    CIO ( 12 )

    : Barclays, 'US Software-Security, Design & VSS: Stock-Pickers Market in 2017, 2017.01

    - ()

    ,

    - ( ) IAM

    ,

    - ( /) SIEM/Data Analytics

    1) , 2) 3~5

    - ( ) CIO ,

    SaaS

    - ( ) CIO , (Firewall) 12 ,

    2017 ~2018

  • - 26 -

    m

    B2C

    B2B

    -

    - , ,

    (SI)

    - ,

    (Distributor/Retailer)

    -

    , 2000

    -

    - IT SW (Wholesales) PC ,

    (Retailer) , 2004

    - IT (Distributor) Ingram Micro, Tech Data, Avnet,

    Arrow Electronics, SYNNEX

    - ,

    Best buy, Circuit City, OfficeDepot, Staples

    - , SaaS(Software as a Service)

    SaaS

    Ingram Micro Avent IT

    70%

  • - 27 -

    IT

    Ingram Micro, Inc. IT Peripherals, Systems, Software(15~20%), Networking

    Avnet, Inc.Electronics, Technology Solutions, Logistics, Managed

    Technologies

    Tech Data Corp. IT Peripherals, Systems, Software, Networking

    Arrow Electronics, Inc.

    Semiconductors, Computing Solutions, OEM

    Computing solutions, Passive, electromechanical and

    connectors

    Tyco International

    Hardware and software products, application

    development, asset and lifecycle management, product

    procurement, systems integration, and training

    SYNNEX Corporation PCs, servers, and software

    IKON Office Solutions, Inc.

    Scopiers, printers, fax machines, office supplies,

    document management outsourcing, electronic file

    conversions, facilities management

    ScanSource, Inc.

    Automatic identification and data capture (AIDC)

    products, point-of-sale(POS) products, voice and data

    communications products and electronic security

    equipment

    Newegg Inc.

    Cell phones, digital cameras, home appliances,

    networking devices, peripherals, DVDs, accessories, and

    software

    MA Laboratories, Inc.

    Memory modules, hard drives, motherboards, modems,

    power supplies, and graphics cards, monitors, software,

    GPS systems, network cards, digital cameras, notebook

    computers, wireless networking gear, digital music

    players, etc

    : Wikipedia, Google Finance

    - (ISV), VAR(Value-added reseller),

    (MSP) (channel partnership)

    -

    m

    , , , . ,

    . ,

  • - 28 -

    - Barnes & Co. ,

    2017 () 119 200

    , 2 1,370

    -

    58 900

    - 8 2,600 , 3,780

    - 4 6,920 ,

    4 2,000

    (2017)

    (: )

    (2014)

    (2017)

    (2017)

    (2017) 10,713.0 11,902.5 21,370 98,103

    5,302.0 5,890.7 3,190 20,284

    378.2 420.2 730 3,780

    743.5 826.0 3,151 12,886

    422.3 469.2 706 2,897

    : Barnes Reports, '2016 U.S. Industry & Market Outlook: Security Systems Services

    Industry' (2016.5)

    Barnes & Co.(Barnes Reports) , 2017

    61%, 31%, 4%, 3%,

    2% , 2014

  • - 29 -

    (2017)

    : Barnes & Co.

    5

    - (28.1%): ,

    28.1%

    - (22.4%): 22.4%

    - (16.6%): 16.6%

    - (14.5%): 14.5%

    - (18.4%): 18.4%

    : IBIS World

    - , , ,

  • - 30 -

    - 1:2

    ,

    -

    -

    - (Electronic Access Control System)

    - ,

    - , ,

    5

    - 2013

    (Office of Biometric Identity Management)

    - 2016 14.0%

    5 7.8%, 54

    -

    -

    ,

    ,

  • - 31 -

    , ,

    - ,

    VSaaS

    IP

    - , ,

    CCTV'

    - IP DVR

    - CCTV CCTV

    ,

    - CCTV AI CCTV CCTV AI

    , , &

    m

    (Wholesales)

    - ,

    -

    ,

    - ,

    OEM

    -

  • - 32 -

    55%

    -

    -

    -

    ,

    - 3D

    ,

    - 15.0%

    - , ,

    14.0%

    , ,

    GSA (GSA

    contractor)

    - GSA contractor /

    - GSA contractor

    ,

    - GSA contractor

    ,

    ,

    - ADT Security Service

  • - 33 -

    - Ingram Micro

    ADT Security Service

    -

    , 400

    - 200

    Ingram Micro

    - IT,

    - 48 162 150

    17 (Best Busy, Future shop, Staples )

    - Sony, HP 1,400 ,

    OEM

    PELIKANCAM- GSA

    - CCTV , DVR, IP &

    A1 Security Cameras

    -

    - GSA , , ,

    -

    : Wikipedia, Google Finance

    )

    m

    q

    ,

    - EMC, Check Point, Fortinet, McAfee, HP Security, Cisco, Symantec, Trend Micro,

    Palo Alto Networks, Blue Coat Systems, Check Point Technology, Kaspersky Lab

    - Symantec, McAfee, Check Point 3 2011 35.4%

  • - 34 -

    2016 32.8%

    - D.C. ,

    -

    (M&A) ,

    - AI() Symantec, IBM

  • - 35 -

    (: )

    2017.05.24 Microsoft Hexadite N/A 100

    2016.09.20 Fortinet AccelOps N/A 28

    2016.09.18 Oracle Palerra N/A N/A

    2016.09.07 TPG Intel Security (51%) N/A 3,100

    2016.07.28 Oracle Netsuite N/A 9,300

    2016.06.28 Cisco Systems CloudLock N/A 293

    2016.06.12 Symantec Blue Coat Systems 7.8 4,650

    2016.06.01 Vista Equity Partners Ping Identity Corp. N/A N/A

    2016.02.20 IBM Resilient Systems N/A N/A

    2016.01.30 Fire Eye iSIGHT Partners N/A 275

    2016.01.15 IBM IRIS Analytics N/A N/A

    2015.11.09 Blue Coat Systems Elastica Inc. N/A 280

    2015.09.08 Microsoft Adallom N/A N/A

    2015.07.30 Blue Coat Systems Perspecsys Inc. 13.3 44.7

    2015.05.27 Palo Alto Networks CirroSecure N/A 18

    2015.03.31 CipherCloud Anicut Systems N/A N/A

    2015.02.05 Intuit Inc. Porticor Ltd. N/A N/A

    2014.06.12 CloudLock Innovode Ltd. N/A N/A

    2014.02.06 Imperva SkyFence Networks N/A 60

    2014.01.15 CipherCloud CloudUp Networks N/A N/A

    2013.11.07 HyTrust HighCloud Security N/A N/A

    2013.10.03 Cloud Security Corp. App Ventured LTD N/A 2

    2013.09.26 Intermedia.net SaaSID N/A N/A

    2013.07.23 Cisco Systems Sourcefire N/A 2,700

    : 451 Research, Oppenheimer Research, (2017.9)

    Barclays ,

    (Firewall) Palo Alto Networks Fortinet

    Cisco, Check Point Juniper

    - Palo Alto Networks 2013 5.3% 2015 10.1%

  • - 36 -

    2013 2014 2015

    Cisco 19.6% 19.4% 18.1%

    Check Point 14.9% 14.4% 14.1%

    Palo Alto Networks 5.3% 7.5% 10.1%

    Fortinet 6.7% 7.4% 8.4%

    Juniper 6.4% 4.7% 4.1%

    47.1% 46.5% 45.1%

    100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

    : Barclays, US Software Security, Design & VSS: Stock-Picker's Market in 2017

    Barclays CIO , 12

    Palo Alto Networks 2015

    Check Point Symantec

    - Palo Alto Networks 2015 25 2016 50

    , Firewall

    - FireEye, Cisco Systems, Trend Micro, Splunk 2015

    2016 2 5

    - , 2015 1 Check Point 2016 9,

    Symantec 2015 2 2016 6

    - , F5 Juniper , 2016 2015

  • - 37 -

    CIO (2015 ~2016 )

    2016 2016 2015

    Palo Alto Networks 50 36 25

    FireEye 47 48 39

    Cisco Systems 41 47 16

    Trend Micro 25 22 12

    Splunk 24 24 14

    Symantec 24 34 45

    F5 19 21 38

    Fortinet 18 6 5

    Check Point 15 16 60

    Juniper 11 15 24

    Proofpoint 8 5 3

    Imperva 5 5 3

    Barracuda Networks 3 1 1

    Sophos 3 6 6

    Hewlett-Packard Enterprise 2 NA NA

    Rapid7 2 0 0

    CyberArk 1 0 0

    Qualys 1 1 0

    Radware 1 0 0

    : Barclays, US Software Security, Design & VSS: Stock-Picker's Market in 2017

    q

    IT

    - 300~400

    , ,

    5,000

    - United Technologies, Honeywell International,

    Tyco International 3

    - Assa Abloy(), Checkpoint Systems, L-3 Communication, Robert

  • - 38 -

    Bosch(), Safran()

    -

    - ,

    2010

    - Diebold Security Stanley Black & Decker

    ,

    m

    q

    Symantec Corporation

    - Symantec 2016

    - , , ,

    1

    - 2016 6 Blue Coat Systems

    - ,

    ,

    - Symantec Norton

    - , ,

    - Norton

  • - 39 -

    - Symantec Mobile Security iOS, Android Windows OS

    - , , SMS

    , Symantec Mobile Management Platform

    - Symantec ATP Suite

    , ()

    - Technology Business Review(TBR) '2015-2020 (Enterprise

    Security Market Forecast) , Symantec

    2

    2020 4

    - 2016 11, AI SEP 14

    (Symantec Endpoint Protection 14) 100

    ,

    90 AI

    Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro , , , ,

    , , ,

    - , Symantec, McAfee

    , , (Virtualization),

    , (APT), (IoT)

    - Amazon AWS Microsoft Azure Trend

    Micro 2014 Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro , ,

    ,

    - (stand-alone) , Trend Micro Control Manager

    Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro 2017 3, NSS Labs

  • - 40 -

    Palo Alto Networks

    - 2007

    (APT)

    - (IPS), , URL

    Wildfire Traps

    - 2014 Cyvera

    Traps

    - 2016 ,

    -

    R&D

    - , ,

    - (APT) Wildfire

    , , SecaaS

    (CASB)

    - Palo Alto 2017 10

    (SaaS)

    Cisco Systems

    - , Service Provider

    Video, , ,

    - Cisco Systems 2015

    (Security Everywhere)

    -

    -

    (Before) (During) (After)

  • - 41 -

    - 2013 Sourcefire 2014 Open

    DNS 2015 Ericsson

    - 2015 10

    Lancope

    - 2016 6 CloudLock 2017

    1 Cisco

    - , , ,

    M&A

    Check Point Software Technologies

    - Check Point Software Technologies

    4

    - 10 ,

    - , , ,

    -

    2012

    - Check Point , (VPN),

    (IPS), , URL , , , ID

    -

    - 2016 CheckPoint R80

    , ,

    -

  • - 42 -

    Fortinet

    - Fortinet Unified

    Threat Management(UMT)

    - , , , MSSP

    - , FortiGate , VPN, , ,

    , , , DLP, WAN , WLAN

    - FortiGate ,

    2

    McAfee( Intel Security Group)

    - Intel 2011 McAfee

    2016 TPG 51%

    - Intel Security Group 2017 McAfee

    - Intel McAfee

    ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    ,

    q

    Tyco Integrated Security

    - Tyco International Ltd. ,

    - ,

    - , , ,

  • - 43 -

    Stanley Convergent Security Solutions

    - Stanley Black & Decker

    , , .

    - 30

    - , , , ,

    - , CCTV/ , ,

    ,

    Vivint Inc.

    -

    -

    ,

    - , , , ,

    Monitronics International

    - , 450

    - 2010 Ascent Capital Group

    - , , ,

    ,

    Dieblod Security

    - , ,

    -

    - ATM ,

    Vector Security Incorporation

    - 10

  • - 44 -

    ,

    - 26

    - , , , ,

    Guardian Protection Services

    - 1950 ,

    , 25

    - , , , , , ,

    Raytheon

    - 4 , , , ,

    , ,

    -

    (supply registration)

    )

    MS 2014 Hexadite 1 ( 1,119

    ) (2017.5)

    - Hexadite 2014 ,

    35

    -

    RSA 2017 Fortinet, McAfee, Palo Alto

    Networks, Symantec (Cyber Threat Alliance, CTA)

  • - 45 -

    (2017.2)

    - CTA

    (cybersecurity coordinator) (Michael Daniel)

    - , Check Point Cisco Systems CTA

    - CTA

    ,

    (STIX/TAXII)

    IBM (AI) (Watson for Cyber

    Security) (2017.2)

    - IBM

    , , ,

    - IBM

    IBM

    - IBM Watson

    IBM X-Force 8

    ,

    DNS , IoT (2016.10)

    - Dyn

    - (Mirai)

    ,

    - , , (IoT)

    ... (2016.10)

    - Nationwide 80%

  • - 46 -

    - 2015

    , 60% 1

    - 2,800

    2016 9

    (Improving Small Business Cyber Security Act)

    Intel, TPG Intel Security (2016.09)

    - Intel Intel Security 51% TPG 31

    2017 McAfee

    - Intel 2011 McAfee 77 2014 Intel Security

    - Intel PC

    , TPG

    IT , VSA (2016.09)

    - 9 IT

    (Vendor Security Alliance, VSA)

    - VSA Uber, Twitter, Dropbox, Docker, Palantir, Atlassian, GoDaddy, Square,

    Airbnb

    - VSA

    , VSA

    3

    Symantec, Blue Coat Systems (2016.08)

    - Symantec

    - Blue Coat Systems 2015 Elastica

    (Cloud Access Security Broker, CASB)

  • - 47 -

    Auto-ISAC, (2016.07)

    - Auto-ISAC

    -

    - Auto-ISAC

    - ,

    Cisco, CASB CloudLock 2 9,300 (2016.06)

    - CloudLock IaaS, PaaS, SaaS

    Cisco

    - (IoT), , ,

    Cisco

    - , Cisco 2013 (IPS) Sourcefire ,

    ThreatGRID, Open DNS, Lancope

    ICSA Lab, IoT (2016.05)

    - ICSA Lab

    - , IoT

    6

    -

    IoT

  • - 48 -

    3)

    )

    m

    1988

    , 3

    1991

    - 1996 (Presidents Commission on

    Critical Infrastructure Protection, PCCIP)

    - 1996 (National Information Infrastructure Protection Act of

    1996)

    - , ,

    ,

    ,

    9.11

    (USA PATRIOT ACT of 2001)

    -

    -

    -

    -

    2013 6

    NSA (FISA)

    2008

  • - 49 -

    - 2005

    2002 11

    (DHS)

    - 17 ,

    2 3 2

    10 (Information Security)

    - 3 2 (Critical Infrastructure

    Information Act)

    ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    - FBI (NIPC), (NCS),

    (CIAO)

    , (GSA) (FedCIRC)

    -

    2002

    (Federal

    Information Security Management Act, FISMA)

    -

    -

    - (NIST)

    , NIST

  • - 50 -

    (Cyber Security Enhancement Act) 2002

    - 225 (Computer Fraud and

    Abuse Act. CFAA) 1030

    -

    20 ,

    -

    (ISP) ,

    ,

    2009

    2015

    - , ,

    - (Cybersecurity Advisory Panel)

    -

    ,

    2015

    (Cyber Security Act 2015)

    - 2015 (CISA, S.654), (PCNA, H.R.1560), (NCPAA, H.R.1731) 3

    - (Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act, CISA) 2 2015 (Cybersecurity Act of 2015)

    -

    ,

  • - 51 -

    - , ,

    (, )

    - ,

    (cause of action) ,

    - ,

    (

    )

    -

    - (National Cybersecurity and Communications

    Integration Center, NCCIC) ,

    -

    ,

    - ,

    , ,

    2016

    -

    (cyber incidents)

    (Defense Industrial Base Cybersecurity Activities)

    11 3

    -

    , , , , ,

    -

    (covered defense information) 72

  • - 52 -

    ,

    , , , ,

    - ,

    , (DOD Cyber

    Crime Center)

    m

    q (1998~2002)

    2001 9.11

    - 1998 5, (PDD, Presidential Decision Directive) 63

    ,

    - 2001 9.11

    (EO, Executive Order)

    - 13228(01.10.8 ) (Office of Homeland

    Security) (Homeland Security Council) (01.10),

    PDD-63 13231(01.10.16 )

    q (2003~2008)

    2003 3(Homeland Security Act

    (DHS)

    - , ,

    ,

    - 2008 1 23(NSPD-54/HSPD-23, National Security

    Presidential Directive-54/Homeland Security Presidential Directive- 23) ,

    (CNCI, Comprehensive National

  • - 53 -

    Cybersecurity Initiatives)

    q (2009~2016)

    2009 1

    - 2009 2

    (CNCI)

    (NSC, National Security Council) (Homeland Security

    Council)

    - 2009 5 (Cyberspace Policy Review)

    - 2009 12 2003

    -

    (Cybersecurity Directorate)

    - 2010 , (

    CNCI)

    -

    ,

    ,

    - 2011 5

    , , ,

    3

    (International Strategy for Cyberspace)

    2013 2 , ,

  • - 54 -

    -

    -

    , ,

    - , (State, Local, Tribal, Territorial Entities, SLTT)

    - , ,

    2015 2 (Promoting

    Private Sector Cybersecurity Information Sharing EXECUTIVE ORDER 13691)

    - (1) (2)

    (3)

    - (Information Sharing and Analysis Organizations:

    ISAOs) (DHS)

    - ISAO , ,

    ,

    -

    -

    (ISAOs)

    - (National

    Cybersecurity and Communications Integration Center, NCCIC) ISAOs

    ISAOs

    - ISAOs

    ,

    ''(Fair Information Practice Principles, FIPP)

    - 2015

  • - 55 -

    )

    (Cyber Security Coordinator, CSC)

    - 2009 12

    - 2003

    (President's Critical Infrastructure Protection Board)

    2016 Michael

    Daniel

    - , ,

    - ,

    (Cybersecurity Directorate)

    ,

    - (National Economic Council, NEC)

    (Office of Management and Budget, OMB)

    (Office of Science and Technology Policy, OSTP)

    (Department of Homeland Security, DHS)

    - 2003 3 (Homeland Security Act)

    (DHS)

    - , ,

    -

    - 2009 10 30 IT

    (NCCIC: The National Cybersecurity and Communications

  • - 56 -

    Integration Center)

    -

    (National Cybersecurity

    Center, NCSC) (US-CERT) (National

    Coordinating Center for Telecommunications, NCC)

    - 1998 5

    (Presidential Decision Directive-63, PDD-63)

    (National Infrastructure Protection Center, NIPC)

    - (FBI) , 2003

    - ICS-CERT

    (Department of Defense, DOD)

    - 2010 10 (U.S. Strategic Command) , , ,

    (U.S. Cyber

    Command, USCYBERCOM)

    - 2009 1 (Network-Centric Warfare,

    NCW) , ,

    - (DOD) (DHS) ,

    , , 2011 7

    (DOD)

    - 2016

    (Department of Justice, DOJ)

    - (FBI) (Cyber

    Division) , , , ,

    5

    -

    / ,

  • - 57 -

    - FBI 22

    (National Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST)

    - (Federal Information Security

    Management Act, FISMA) ,

    - 2010 3 , (NICE,

    National Initiative for Cybersecurity Education)

    - 2014 2

    (Cybersecurity Framework)

    - 2015 6 , , , ,

    - 2016 4

    R&D

    - 2016 7 (NIST SP 800-63B )

    SMS 2

    - NIST,

  • - 58 -

    2013~2023

    Einstein intrusion detection system

    - 2010~202113 5 (~2014), 38

    Cyber Genome project - 2010~2013 7,700

    Automated Program Analysis for Cybersecurity(APAC)

    - 2012~2015 4,000

    Mission-oriented Resilient Clouds(MRC)

    - 2011~2020 -

    Active Authentication Program(AAP)

    IAM - 2013~2016 -

    National Cyber Range(NCR)

    - 2011~2015 5,400

    Sensor Shadow - Cyberspace Operations Program

    General Dynamics Advanced Information Systems(GD-AIS)

    2012~2014 500

    Agile Cyber Technology(ACT) programme

    L-3 Stratis 2012~2017 300

    Cyber Analytical Information Technology Services

    Point One Inc 2010~2015 6,832

    Cyber Camouflage, Concealment and Deception

    - 2011 -

    : SDI, 'The Cyber Security Market in the United States to 2025'(2016.3)

    )

    2017 7,

    ((Medical Device Cybersecurity Act of

    2017,S.1656)

    -

    - (report card)

    ,

    - HIMSS4)

  • - 59 -

    (MSD2)

    5)

    ,

    - , (Federal Communications Commission,

    FCC) UL(Underwriters Laboratory)

    - CC(Common Criteria)

    (Office of Management and Budget,

    OMB), (National Institute of Standards and Technology,

    NIST), (Chief Information Officer, CIO)

    - (OMB)

    (CIO)

    - (NIST)

    / ,

    - (CIO) , (OMB)

    NIST

    4) Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society IT

    , MSD2

    5)

  • - 60 -

    : KHNP

    q FCC(Federal Communication Commission)

    (Federal Communications

    Commission, FCC)

    - FCC

    - , CD, DVD

    (Radiation) FDA

    -

    - 10KHz~3,000GHz

    ,

    (EMI)

    - FCC

    ,

    - FCC , //

    , , , , PC ,

  • - 61 -

    , (, , )

    - ,

    FCC

    FCC

    - , (Certification)

    , , FCC

    - , (Verification)

    FCC

    FCC

    - Communication Act( ) 47 CFR(The Code of

    Federal Regulations: ), FCC CFR(Code

    of Federal Register) Title 47 (Telecommunications)

    - FCC , FCC

    - FCC FCC ID

    ID Grantee Code

    - FCC ID FCC

    FCC 4~6

    q UL(Underwriters Laboratory)

    UL UL UL

    - 295 ,

    UL UL

    -

  • - 62 -

    UL

    - UL

    - UL ,

    , ,

    - UL ,

    UL

    q CC(Common Criteria)

    ,

    CC

    - , 4(, , , ), TCSEC(Trusted

    Computer Security Evaluation Center)( 1985 ), ITSEC(Information

    Technology Security Evaluation Criteria)( 1992 ), CTCPEC(Canadian

    Trusted Computer Product Evaluation Criteria)( 1993 )

    - CC

    , ,

    - EAL1~EAL7

    ,

    - (APE), (ASE),

    (ACM), (ADO), (ADV), (AGD), (ALC),

    (ATE), (AVA)

    q (FedRAMP)

  • - 63 -

    -

    - (GSA) 2012 6 FedRAMP

    (Federal Risk Authorization and Management Program)

    -

    (Third Party Assessment Organization, 3PAO)

    - FedRAMP 1 8

    ,

    - ,

    FISMA , FedRAMP SSP

    Security Controls (Documents) FedRAMP

    FedRAMP

    - FedRAMP NIST, CIO , ,

    2

    - IT

    FedRAMP ,

    -

    q USGCB(U.S. Government Configuration Baseline)

    PC

    IT PC PC

    - , PC

    PC

    ,

    - PC

    PC

  • - 64 -

    - USGCB SCAP(The Security Content Automation), FISMA(Federal

    Information Security Management) IT

    IT

    q

    SAFETY 2002 Homeland Security Act

    -

    - Applicant Account Application SAFETY Act

    (NSA) NIAP(National Information Assurance Partnership)

    - ,

    -

  • - 65 -

    )

    (SELF DRIVE Act)6)

    (2017.7)

    - IT ,

    -

    ,

    7)

    - ,

    - , ,

    ( , / )

    ,

    8) IoT

    , IoT

    (2017.8)

    - 2020 IoT 200 IoT

    DDoS , IoT

    - IoT ,

    - 180 IoT

    6) H.R 3388 "Self Drive Act" Safely Ensuring Lives Future Deployment and Research In Vehicle

    Evolution Act"

    7) (NHTSA) 2015 7.7% 1966

    94%

    8) executive agency. , ,

  • - 66 -

    (CIO)

    SB 90 (2017.7)

    - CIO

    CIO , CIO

    - IT

    CIO , IT CIO

    , ,

    , (2017.6)

    -

    -

    - ,

    (DHS)

    9)

    (Hack the DHS Act) (2017.6)

    -

    180

    (2017.5)

    - FBI, FCC, FAA

    9)

  • - 67 -

    - 2)

    , (NIST)

    3)

    (Ransomware) 1)

    10) (2017.2)

    - 2016 3 (MedStar Helath)

    - (extortion)

    1,000

    1,000

    (FCC)

    (Report and Oredr) (2016.11)

    -

    - (Customer Proprietary

    Network Information, CPNI), ,

    (Department of Defense) (cyber incidents)

    (Defense Industrial

    Base Cybersecurity Activities) (2016.10)

    -

    ,

    -

    10) House Bill 340. Criminal Law - Extortion Unauthorized Software

  • - 68 -

    , (2016.10)

    -

    (Continuous Diagnostics and Mitigation Program, CDM)

    - (DHS) CDM ,

    10 1

    - CDM (DHS)

    ,

    - ,

    CDM

    , (2016.09)

    - 15 9 20 ,

    -

    -

    ,

    - , , ,

    NHTSA ,

    - ,

    ICIT, (2016.08)

    - ICIT(Institute for Critical Infrastructure Technology)

    (Hacking Elections is Easy! Part 1: Tactics, Techniques

    and Procedures)

    - (XP)

  • - 69 -

    - ,

    - , (FBI) ,

    - ,

    ,

    , (2016.08)

    - (DOT) (FAA) (The Small

    Unmanned Aircraft Regulations/Rules) 2016 8 29

    -

    , FAA

    -

    (Homeland Security Act of 2002) 2016

    (Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Protection

    Agency Act of 2016) (2016.6)

    - (National Protection and Programs

    Directorate, NPPD) '

    (Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Protection Agency)'

    , (2016.04)

    - (Eastwest) ICS-ISAC(

    )

    -

  • - 70 -

    - ,

    - ,

    ,

    , (Hack the Pentagon) (2016.03)

    -

    - 4 18 5

    12 ( 488)

    -

    ,

    - 100 ,

    - ,

    (GAO), (DHS) (EINSTEIN) (2016.01)

    - (GAO) (DHS) (NCPS)

    , DHS 5

    - , DHS (EINSTEIN)

    09 12

    - GAO NCPS 9

    NSD NCPS ,

    NSD NCPS

  • - 71 -

    US-CERT

    US-CERT

    (CDM)

    US-CERT ,

    (CS&C) NCPS

    , , ,

    , ,

    (CS&C)

    NSD CDM

    , DHS NCPS /

    NSD

    (ISP)

    ICS-CERT, 7 (2015.12)

    - ICS-CERT ,

    7

    - ICS-CERT 7

    AWL(APPLICATION WHITELISTING)

    / :

  • - 72 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 2016 5 , 2017

    2 11

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.786 11

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 10%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 8.37 10 8.84 1

    (Access) 8.80 10 8.99 8

    (Use) 8.14 8 8.57 3

    (Skills) 7.97 35 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.786 11 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.844 11 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.6 10 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) (ICT)

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    64,025 50.6 28,036 56.1

    39,842 31.5 20,556 41.1

    164,265 129.8 61,296 122.7

    92.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 4,812

    '17 () 126,702

  • - 73 -

    1)

    )

    2020 ,

    ,

    - ,

    2016 5 2 6

    - , TV ,

    - 2009 ,

    2015 3,831

    2015 6 125

    ,

    - (IPA) 2015 10

  • - 74 -

    )

    -

    - ITU , 2016 3,984 2,000

    2.4%

    - , ,

    - ITU 2011 100% , 2016

    1 6,426 5,000 120%

    - , 2016

    2.3%

    - 3G 4G LTE

    , (IoT), ,

    ICT

    : 2014-2016

    : ITU(2017.6)

  • - 75 -

    2)

    )

    m

    2020

    - 2013 3 ,

    - () 11) , ,

    - ,

    , 2011

    , 2014 ,

    - PC

    - ,

    - , IoT

    m

    , 2016

    4,704 , /, IP,

    11) , , 2015.11

  • - 76 -

    12)

    - , IP NVR,

    (: )

    : (2017.2)

    , ,

    (JNSA)

    13) , 2016 4.0%

    9,327 9,000

    - JNSA 2016 4,705 ,

    4,260 4.8%, 8.1%

    5.0%

    12) , , /, , , 6 . 2015 11

    13) 2017, 2017.6

  • - 77 -

    ( )

    : (JNSA),(2017.6)

    - , ,

    , ID , ,

    - , ,

    , ,

    2016 37.6%(1,767

    )

    - ID (17.9%), (14.9%)

  • - 78 -

    2016

    : (JNSA)(2017.6)

    2016

    40.7%(1,812 )

    - (31.2%), (18.2%)

    2016

    : (JNSA)(2017.6)

  • - 79 -

    m

    , 2019 5,570 2016

    17.8%

    - /

    2016 2015 4.4% 4,704

    - ,

    - , ,

    , ,

    - ,

    - , 2016 5 2 6

    2019 10 ,

    - 2017

    - 2018

    (: )

    : (2017.2)

  • - 80 -

    JNSA 2017 5.0% 9,795

    - 5,099 , 4,697

    4.5%, 5.6%

    - 2017

    36.5%(1,862 ) , ID

    (18.2%), (15.2%)

    - 2017

    40.5%(1,903 ) ,

    (31.1%), (18.6%)

    (: )

    : (JNSA)(2017.6)

    )

    m

    -

    , TV ,

  • - 81 -

    -

    - , ,

    - IP

    - 2020 ,

    -

    IP

    - IP

    - IP NVR(Network Vedio Recorder) , NAS(Network

    Attached Storage) ,

    -

    - 4K ,

    , ,

    , ,

    -

    , ,

    - IP , , ,

    - , HD-SDI(High Definition Serial

  • - 82 -

    Digital Interface) , HD-SDI

    - ,

    - , ,

    PC

    - .

    , ,

    - PC

    /

    - 2015 2016

    - ,

    - , 2015

    /

    -

    - 2016

    -

    - ,

  • - 83 -

    - 0.5%

    ,

    -

    -

    ,

    - , ,

    ,

    -

    - ,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    -

    - / ,

    m

    -

    ,

  • - 84 -

    -

    ,

    -

    ,

    -

    -

    (13.7%) ,

    18.6%

    ID

    - ID

    (J-Sox) 2015

    , 2016

    17.9%

    -

    (CAS) ID

    - (APT, Advanced Persistent Threat)

    , ,

    - , ,

    , /

    /

    -

  • - 85 -

    ,

    2016

    : (JNSA)(2017.6)

    m

    - 2016 30%

    2 3

    -

    -

    15.4%

    - 2016 1,812 ,

    40.7% 2 1

    - ,

    ,

    (incident)

    - SOC( )

  • - 86 -

    -

    ,

    , SI,

    - 2005 4

    2008 4 (J-Sox) 2004

    10 () (BCP)

    -

    , (P) (ISMS)

    -

    , ,

    - ,

    , 2014 2015

    - , ,

    3~5

    2016

    : (JNSA)(2017.6)

  • - 87 -

    )

    m

    IP

    - IP

    ,

    - Fujitsu, Hitachi, Mitsubishi, NEC, Oki, Panasonic, Toshiba, Sony

    IP

    - ,

    ,

    IP

    Trend

    Micro 46.1% 56.4%

    2015

    : (2015)

  • - 88 -

    - Symantec 24.8%, McAfee

    19.5% 2 , 3~4

    90%

    m

    q

    Mitsubishi

    - , , ,

    ,

    -

    NEC

    - NEC

    (NeoFace Monitor)

    - PC InfoCage PC Security

    - 2017 2 IC MultiWrite

    8300

    Oki Wintech

    - Oki Electric Industry() , ,

    - , ,

    -

  • - 89 -

    Photosynth

    - Photosynth 2014

    - Akerun

    - Akerun

    q 14)

    Trend Micro

    - 1989 1992

    Trend Micro ,

    1

    - 2016 8

    VirusBuster

    - 2017 8 HITRUST

    (HITRUST Cyber Threat Management and Response Center)

    -

    HITRUST Cyber Threat XChange(CTX)

    Fujitsu

    - Top 3 Fujitsu

    - 2016 8, Fujitsu AZCloud SaaS Discussion

    () - ,

    - Fujitsu , 2015 10

    , ,

    14)

    NEC, Fujitsu, Hitachi SI NTT, KDDI

    . IT , ,

    IT SI , SI SI

  • - 90 -

    - 2016 9 Fujitsu Biometric Authentication PalmSecure-F Pro

    Fujitsu Biometric Authentication Palm Vein Authentication Board

    - 2017 7

    Automated Indicator Sharing(AIS)

    - Fujitsu 2016 8

    , , AIS

    Hitachi Solutions & Hitachi Systems

    -

    Hitachi (finger vein)

    , Fujitsu

    - Hitachi MS SharePoint

    SharePoint 2016 10

    - SharePoint Online

    - ,

    , 2016 4

    Cylance AI Cylance

    PROTECT

    - , Hitachi

    - Hitachi Systems 2017 3

    IoT

    - Security Brain IoT

    Vinx

    - IT ,

  • - 91 -

    - Hybrid Series

    Hybrid Security , ,

    )

    m

    , , , ,

    1/2, 1/2

    - () ,

    2016 ,

    2020

    -

    - IT , ,

    - ,

    - ,

    m

    ,

  • - 92 -

    -

    -

    , 2018

    ,

    - ATM 80%

    - Fujitsu

    1

    - ,

    3)

    )

    m

    - 2012 8,

    -

    - 2014 6, IT

  • - 93 -

    - 2003 IT

    IT

    - IT 2014 6 () 2015 ,

    () - , 2015 9

    3

    -

    - 2014 11,

    2015 1 9

    -

    ,

    -

    - ' '

    -

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    - 2017 2,

  • - 94 -

    - 2015 9 2017 5 30

    ()

    -

    -

    m

    - 2010 5 2020

    - ,

    ,

  • - 95 -

    - - -

    - //

    -

    - -

    /

    - - -

    - , ASEAN, EU -

    - NISC

    - -

    - / -

    : (2010.5)

    - 2011 7

  • - 96 -

    2012

    - 2012 7 (National Information Security Center, NISC)

    IT

    2012

    -

    , , SNS, M2M

    - , ,

    , , , , ,

    ,

    IoT 2017

    - 2020 IoT ,

    IoT

    2017

    - 5 (TF) ,

    (speed-up), ,

    - IoT 2017

    - 2015 1 (NISC)

    CYDER

    - 2015 12

    )

    -

  • - 97 -

    - 2013 2 15 3

    IT

    -

    2001 1 '

    (IT )'

    - IT (NISC)

    -

    CSSC(Control System Security Center)

    - (APT)

    2012 3 , Hitachi, Toyota,

    Toshiba, Trend Micro

    -

    - ,

    (NISC)

    - NISC , , ,

    ,

    - , (NSC) IT

    -

  • - 98 -

    JPCERTl (JPCERT/CC, Japan Computer Emergency Response Team Coordination Center)

    - ,

    (CSIRT, Computer Security Incident Response

    Team)

    - 1996 , 2009 6

    - FIRST(Forum for Incident Response and Security Teams)

    CSIRT, CSIRT APCERT

    - , (ISDAS, Internet Scan Data Acquisition

    System) ,

    - , CSIRT

    - (IPA, Information-technology Promotion Agency)

    Japan

    Vulnerability Notes(https://jvn.jp/)

    - 2015 9 , 2016 1 3

    - ,

    - 15)

    -

    ,

    )

    JISEC ()

    15)

    . , 2015.9

  • - 99 -

    - 2001 'ISO/IEC 15408'27) '

    (Japan Information Technology Security Evaluation and Certification Scheme,

    JISEC)'

    -

    CC(Common Criteria)

    - , ,

    CC

    - 3

    (IPA)

    - 'ISO/IEC 15408' 'JISEC'

    (JATE)

    - JATE

    3

    - , ,

    (Japan Industrial Standards, JIS)

    - , JIS

    JIS

    - JIS

    JIS

    - JIS Z 9902(ISO 9002)

    (S-Mark)

    - ,

    S-Mark

    S-Mark

  • - 100 -

    - S-Mark 3

    S-Mark

    -

    ,

    - , CS(Cloud

    Security)

  • - 101 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.783 12

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 5%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 8.57 5 8.84 1

    (Access) 9.24 3 8.99 8

    (Use) 8.09 9 8.57 3

    (Skills) 8.18 29 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.783 12 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.919 1 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.7 8 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) (ICT)

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 33,510 52.2 28,036 56.1

    25,153 39.2 20,556 41.1

    78,529 122.3 61,296 122.7

    92.8% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 2,496.76

    '17 () 64,430

  • - 102 -

    1)

    )

    (IRA)

    - 3

    EU

    -

    ,

    CCTV EU

    ,

    - 2016 5

    19 ( 23 )

    -

    ,

    -

    - ,

    - (IS)

    ,

  • - 103 -

    )

    m

    (IDI ; ICT Development Index)

    - 2018

    ITU 2010

    10 2016 5

    -

    (Access) (Use)

    - (Skills) 2016 29

    ,

    m

    2010 1.6%

    - ITU

    2000 2010 53.8% 2016 52.2% 1.6%

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 104 -

    - British Telecom(BT), KCom, Cable & Wireless

    - British Telecom(BT) 170

    , , IT

    2016 89%

    - 2018

    -

    10Mit/s 2015 92% 2016 95%

    - 2016 89% (30Mbit/s

    ) ,

    (%) (Mbit/s)

    2015 2016 2015 2016 83 89 29 37 84 90 30 38

    77 83 28 34 73 83 27 35

    79 85 23 29

    : Ofcom, Connected Nations 2016(2016.12.16)

    m

    - ITU 2005 100% ,

    2016 2015 0.9% 9,852 9,373

    122.32%

    - ,

    (SIM)

  • - 105 -

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - `

    , Orange T-Mobile Everything Everywhere(EE)

    , BT 2016 1

    - (SIM) 2014 140% 2017 150% ,

    2

    - Sky MVNO SkyMobile , MRT 2018 5

    - 4G 2017 93%

    - (MNO) 3G , 5G

    , Vodafone 2020 3G

    LTE 5G

    - Ofcom MNO 2017 99%

    ,

    1 5

    - 2.6GHz 800MHz 4G 23 4 , Ofcom

    2018 5G 5G 4

    - 2015 , 2 EE(29%), O2(27%)

    , Vodafone(19%) H3(11%) , MVNO

    (Tesco Mobile, Virgin Mobile, Lycamobile, Lebara) 14%

  • - 106 -

    (2015 )

    EE* 29.0%

    O2** 27.0%

    Vodafone** 19.0%

    H3 11.0%

    14%

    100%

    * EE 2010 Orange T-Mobile BT 2016

    ** O2 Vodafone MVNO GiffGaff(O2 ),

    Talkmobile(Vodafone )

    : Buddecomm(2017.1)

  • - 107 -

    2)

    )

    m

    -

    ,

    - 2007 CCTV CCTV

    , 2013 (surveillance roadmap)

    - Big Brother Watch 2012

    CCTV , , 46.6% 5 1,500

    2 7,700

    -

    , 2017

    16)

    ,

    - , ,

    , (Gibralta)

    - , ,

    e-borders

    - (Gatwick)

    MF

    16) Surveillance Camera Commissioner, A National Surveillance Camera Strategy for England and

    Wales, 2017.3.

  • - 108 -

    -

    ,

    - 17)

    - Netcraft ,

    (malware)

    - , Netcraft

    - 2016 6 34,550

    200

    - (National Security Strategy) 1

    - , ,

    (UK Defense Cyber Operations Group)

    ITU 12

    - 2017 11 ITU 12

    (13) , , ,

    4

    - 2015

    -

    ,

    17)https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/active-cyber-defence-tackling-cyber-attacks-uk

    https://news.netcraft.com/archives/2016/11/01/the-chancellor-of-the-exchequer-sets-out-plans-for-the-uk-government-to-work-with-netcraft.html

  • - 109 -

    -

    -

    18)

    -

    , , ,

    Silicon:Safe

    -

    ICT ,

    - 2020

    (IoT) 19)

    - 2015 BMW

    - , 2015

    , , , 20)

    - 2015

    2

    - 2013 Foscam

    ,

    -

    - , (IoT)

    21)

    18) How early-stage UK cybersecurity finally upped its game, Cybersecurity Ventures, 2017.3.9.

    19) , , Kotra , 2016.8.23.

    20) , , Kotra , 2015.12.17.

    21) , Kotra , 2017.1.9.

  • - 110 -

    - (RAND Europe) IoT

    , IoT

    55%

    - (IoT)

    ,

    m

    22) 2016 49

    9,400 , 2017 52 3,500

    - ,

    - 2016 5 5

    29 ,

    (National Cybersecurity Centre)

    - 50 ,

    - 2/3

    - 2015

    - EU (General Data Protection Regulations,

    GDPR) ,

    4% 2 5

    22) United Kingdom Cyber-Security, U. S. International Trade Administration, 2016.7.21.

    https://www.export.gov/article?id=United-Kingdom-Cyber-Security

  • - 111 -

    (2017)

    : U. S. International Trade Administration, United Kingdom Cyber-Security(2016.7)

    - 2017 ID

    36% , 32%, 30%

    , ,

    (2017)

    : U. S. International Trade Administration, United Kingdom Cyber-Security(2016.7)

    Homeland Security Research 2017 5 ,

    2015-2020 11.3% 23)

    23) UK Homeland Security & Public Safety Market 2017-2022, Homeland security research, May

    2017.

  • - 112 -

    - ,

    (ISIS)

    - 2015-2020 11.3%

    2010-2015 2~3% 4

    - ,

    ,

    - , ,

    ,

    - 2015 , 2016

    HD CCTV

    - IP CCTV, CCTV, , ,

    , CCTV HD

    2016 CCTV 550~600

    - 2015 11 2016 3

    ,

    CCTV

    )

    m

    CCTV

    - 2007 CCTV 1

    400

    - 2009 28.2% CCTV 2008

    2010

  • - 113 -

    - 2011 8

    2012

    2

    (low-scale)

    - (low-scale) ,

    DVR, , , CCTV

    m

    4,800

    26

    -

    - 5 15% 20

    , 100 2%

    - 100

    1,000 , 500

    1

    - 20~49 , 500

    1,000

    -

  • - 114 -

    - Barnes Reports , 70%

    10% 492

    m

    -

    - 2011-2015

    BAE Systems 13

    (NCSP : National Cyber Security Programme) ,

    ,

    2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025

    302 322 345 368 393 420 449 479 512 546 583

    - 6.6 7.1 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.9 6.7 6.9 6.6 6.8

    ( : , %)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    - SDI 2015

    3 200 ,

    1 3,500 9,000

    , 5,000 , 2,700

    - , 6.5%

    , 2025 2 5,300 ,

  • - 115 -

    7% 2025 1 7,700

    -

    2025 9,400

    5,800

    2015 20252015-25

    2015-25

    (%) 135 253 2,100 6.50

    90 177 1.400 7.00

    50 94 774 6.50

    27 58 449 8.00

    302 583 4,700 6.79

    ( : )

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    m

    2015~25

    - SDI 2015~25

    44% 30%, 16%

    10%

    -

  • - 116 -

    ( :, %)

    2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2025

    322 345 368 393 420 583 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 6.6 7.1 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.8

    144 153 163 174 185 253 45 44 44 44 44 43 6.7 6.3 6.5 6.7 6.3 6.3

    96 103 110 118 126 177 30 30 30 30 30 30 6.7 7.3 6.8 7.3 6.8 7.3

    53 57 61 65 69 94 17 17 17 17 16 16 6.0 7.5 7.0 6.6 6.2 6.8

    29 32 34 36 40 59 9 9 9 9 9 10 7.4 10.3 6.3 5.9 11.1 7.3

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    )

    m

    q

    -

    -

    SI

    -

    ,

    - , ,

  • - 117 -

    - HD CCTV,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    -

    q

    - ,

    , 4

    -

    , ,

    HW/SW

    -

    - (MoD), (M15),

    (M16)

    - 2015 3 7,600

    SDI

    2023 12%

  • - 118 -

    2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

    376 411 453 498 548 613 687 790 908 12%

    ( : )

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    - 2013

    9,300

    32% 2023

    2 9,400

    2013 2023 13-23

    93 294 1,900 12.3

    80 240 1,600 11.6

    70 214 1,400 11.8

    50 160 1,000 12.4

    293 908 5,900 12.0

    ( : , %)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the United Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    -

    - : (Department for Work and Pensions), (Ministry

    of Justice)

    - :

    ,

    IT

    - , , :

  • - 119 -

    -

    , , ICT

    , HW/SW, VAR

    -

    SW

    - ,

    - A/S

    ,

    - HW/SW

    -

    , ICT , HW/SW , VAR

    - ,

    m

    G4S plc

    -

    , , , , , , ,

  • - 120 -

    - , , , ,

    ,

    - , , ATM ,

    - , , , , ,

    - : Home Page - http://www.g4s.com/

    Tel.- 44(0)208-770-7000

    Exclusive Networks

    - VAD(Value Added Distributor)

    20 SW

    - , , , , . , , ,

    , , , ,

    - 20 SW FireEye, Fortinet, SafeNet, Aerohive,

    Arbor, Aruba, Bit9, Palo, Alto 13

    - : e-Mail -info@exclusive-networks.co.uk

    Home Page - www.exclusive-networks.co.uk

    Tel. - 0845-521-7217, Fax - 01420-544799

    Sophos

    - 1985

    - : (UTM : Unified Threat Management), , ,

    , , SW/HW , 1985

    - Sophos

    - , , , , 12, 1700

    - : Home Page - http://www.sophos.com

    e-Mail : sales@sophos.com

  • - 121 -

    Nexor

    - 1989 1992

    - ,

    ISODE(ISO Development Environment)

    (MMHS : Military Message Handling System)

    - : Home Page - http://www.nexor.com/nexor-ukti

    Tel. -44(0)115-952-0500, e-Mail : info@nexor.com

    Intercede

    - 1992 ID MyID

    24

    - Lutterworth ,

    - MyID GSA ID

    - , , ,

    ID

    - BT, Gemalto, HP, Microsoft, Safenet, Symantec Thales

    - : Home Page - http://www.intercede.com

    Tel.- 44(0)1455-558-111, e-Mail infor@intercede.com

    ECSC

    - 2000 200

    (Managed Security Services, MSS)

    2016 20%

    - ECSC ,

    (Penetration Testing), (Payment Card

    Industry, PCI) ISO 27001

    - ECSC , , , ,

    e-commerce

    , FTSE 10024) 10%

    - : Home Page - https://www.ecsc.co.uk/

    Tel.- 44 (0) 1274 736 223, e-Mail INFO@ECSC.CO.UK

    24) FTSE 100: 100

  • - 122 -

    Norbain

    - 30

    17 ISO 9001.2000

    - 77 300

    - HID, GE, Panasonic

    ,

    2012 Newberry Investment Ltd. 100%

    - CCTV, IP , ,

    - : Home Page - www.norbain.co.uk

    Tel. - 0118-912-5000, Fax - 0118-912-5001

    ADI-Gardiner

    - 50

    - 200 -

    - : e-Mail - websupport.uk@adiglobal.com

    Home Page - https://uk-eshop.adiglobal.com.

    Tel. : 01706-343-343, Fax : 44(0)207 902 7910

    SSED Ltd. T/A Hunters Wholesalers

    - 2005 , CCTV

    - , Honeywell MK, Honetwell ADE,

    Cooper Security, ICS Security, Fike, Klaxon, ESP UK, Visionic, Cytech Comfort

    Alarms, CDV, ICS Philex, Labgear

    - : Home Page - www.hunters-wholesalers.co.uk

    e-Mail - sales@hunters-wholesalers.co.uk

    Tel. - 01628-669124, Fax - 01629-667710

  • - 123 -

    Bosch Security Systems Inc.

    - CCTV, ,

    - CSS Group PL

    - : Home Page -http://cssgroupplc.com/

    Tel. : 01489 566101, FAX : 01489 565375

    Securitas

    - Securitas 2015 10 Diebold

    , 2016 4

    CCTV, Draht & Schutz CCTV

    - Securitas , 2015

    2

    - : Home Page http://www.securitas.uk.com e-mail: comms@securitas.uk.com

    25)

    Darktrace(2013 )

    - ,

    - BT , Mike

    Lynch 2017 7 7,500

    8 2,500

    - Darktrace GCHQ(Government Communication

    Haedquarters) ,

    , 23

    CybSafe(2015 )

    -

    25) The UK's 13 most promising cybersecurity startups, Techworld, 2017.7.11.

    http://www.techworld.com/picture-gallery/security/uks-10-most-promising-cybersecurity-startups-2016-

    3634620/

  • - 124 -

    - ,

    - Oz Alashe

    ZoneFox(2010 )

    - ZonFox ,

    (AI)

    - Archangels A ,

    ZoneFox 3 ,

    - Rockstar Games, Zenith , ,

    ,

    StatusToday(2015 )

    - StatusToday ,

    - 2016 2 Notion Capital seed

    1 , (GCHQ)

    Digital Shadows(2011 )

    - Digital Shadows

    - , , (GitHub) 27

    1

    - 2 2011 2013 2 , 2015

    VC Storm Ventures 8

  • - 125 -

    CyberLytic(2013 )

    - BAE Systems

    CyLon

    SQR Systems(2011 )

    - CyLon SQR ,

    , ,

    Silicon:Safe(2013 )

    -

    ,

    Wandera(2013 )

    - Wandera (Saas)

    SaltDNA(2015 )

    - Queens University Belfast , SaltDNA

    ,

    - 3

    Corvid(2015 )

    - Corvid Ultra Electronic spin-in

    Security-as-a-service

    Ripjar(2015 )

    - Ripjar ,

  • - 126 -

    GeoLang(2013 )

    - 2016 (Infosecurity Show)

    (Most Innovative Small Cyber Security Company) GeoLang

    (SI)

    - IBM, HP IT IT CSC

    CGI IT IT

    - CGI 2012 4 Logica 17

    ,

    - Thales, BAE Systems,

    Northrop Grumman

    -

    SW HW

    ,

    BAE Systems

    - BAE Systems 93,500

    - 2014 Siversky ,

    2010 Stratsec Net Pty Ltd

    , 2010

    SpecTal, LLC

    Thales UK

    - Thales 50 , ,

    , , , 68,000

    , 1970

    - Thales 45% , 23%

  • - 127 -

    - 2013 ,

    , ,

    - (battle lab)

    Northrop Grumman UK

    - Northrop Grumman ,

    , , , , ,

    ,

    - Northrop Grumman ,

    2012 M5 Network

    Security Pty Ltd.

    - Sophos

    - KPMG

    (KPMG 200

    )

    - Symantec

    - MIicrosoft, SAP, Oracle, Dell SW SW

    :

    - , IT

    - BT

  • - 128 -

    1,800 ,

    )

    (Brexit)

    - 2016 6 23 EU

    , ,

    - ,

    4

    -

    2 EU

    Chatham House, 26)

    - , , , , , ,

    , ,

    -

    , , ,

    - (jamming), IP

    (spoofing), (hacking) ,

    -

    26) , Space, the Final Frontier for Cybersecurity(2016.9.22.)

  • - 129 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Data Protection Act 1998)

    -

    - , , , ,

    , ,

    - , ,

    , , ,

    ,

    - 2016 11 27)

    (Computer Misuse Act 1990)

    - : 1990. 06. 29, 1990 Chapter 18

    : Police and Justice Act 2006

    - :

    , ,

    : 12

    ,

    21 ( 18)

    5

    27) www.legislation.gov.uk

  • - 130 -

    (Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000)

    - : 2000. 08. 01

    - :

    , , , ,

    5 ,

    (Fraud Act 2006)

    - : 2006. 11. 08, 2006 Chapter 35

    -

    ,

    12

    (,

    6 ), 10

    28)

    m

    q

    - 2009

    (Cabinet Office)

    -

    (CSIA: Central Sponsor for

    Information Assurance), (OCSIA: Office of Cyber Security and

    28) www.legislation.gov.uk

  • - 131 -

    Information Assurance), (CSS)

    -

    (Home Office):

    (Foreign Commonwealth Office):

    (Department for Business Innovation and

    Skills):

    (Defense Intelligence Staff): 5

    (M15) 6(M16)

    - EU EU

    EU

    - 2016 6 23

    - EU 2

    EU

    q

    EU

    - EU EU

    EU , EU

    - , EU

    EU

    2013 2 EU

  • - 132 -

    EU

    - - , , - - (Multi-stakeholder) -

    - (resilience) - - - - EU EU

    : EU (Cybersecurity Strategy of the European Union)(2013.2)

    EU

    : EU

    - 1998 (Data Protection Act 1998)

    , 2009

    6

    -

    2011 11 -

  • - 133 -

    -

    - 2013 (National CrimeAgency)

    - (Serious

    Organised Crime Agency)

    -

    -

    -

    -

    - ITU, (OSCE: Organization for

    Security and Cooperation in Europe)

    ,

    -

    EU

    ,

    ,

    -

    -

    -

    - ,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    2016-2021(National Cyber Security Strategy 2016-2021)29)

    - 2016 11 (National Cyber Security

    29) National Cyber Security Strategy 2016-2021

  • - 134 -

    Strategy2016-2021) ,

    5 19

    ( 23 )

    - 1 6 5

    (Defence and Cyber Innovation Fund)

    - 8 6

    2011

    -

    , ,

    (defend): ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    (deter): ,

    , , , , , ,

    (develop): ,

    ,

    ,

    - (National Cyber Security Centre)

    30)31)

    - 2017 2 (Department for Business, Energy and

    Industrial Strategy, BEIS)

    (Civil Nuclear Cyber Security Strategy)

    -

    , ,

    , ,

    30) Department for Business, Energy &Industrial Strategy, Civil Nuclear Cyber Security, 2017.2.

    31) KISA, , , 2017.3.20.

  • - 135 -

    - ,

    , ,

    - 2016 11

    , ,

    - , , , ,

    , ,

    -

    ,

    -

    Year1-2016/17:

    Year2-4-2017-2019/20:

    Year5-2020/21: ,

    - :

    - :

    - (Nuclear Decommissioning Authority):

    - : ,

    - : ,

    - :

    - :

    - : ,

    - : , ,

  • - 136 -

    q

    - 2015 73%

    3

    -

    90% 5 3

    2017 95%

    2 5

    2

    Super-Connected Cities Programme

    - Super-Connected Cities Programme 2010 6 300

    2Mbps

    1 5 22

    - 2011 1 , 2012 5,000

    2017 95%

    ,

    - 28

    2015-18

    - (Innovate UK)SMS 2018

    - 2020 , ,

    ,

    - 4 3,000 1 2,000

  • - 137 -

    1,500

    - Digital Catapult Centre, Open Data Institute Tech City UK

    1,500 32)

    )

    m (Cabinet Office)

    - 2009

    -

    , ,

    -

    :

    32) KOTRA (2015.07.07)

  • - 138 -

    m

    (OCSIA : Office of Cyber Security and Information Assurance)33)

    - (Cabinet Office) (National

    Security Council)

    -

    -

    Get Safe Online Cyber Security Challenge

    , ,

    ICT

    (OGSIRO: Office of the Government Senior Information Risk

    Owner)

    - , , EU

    (Ofcom)

    - Ofcom(Office of Communication) : , TV

    , 2003

    - TV , , ,

    (ICO : Information Commissioner's Office)34)

    - ,

    33) ocsia@cabinet-office.x.gsi.gov.uk34) http://ico.org.uk/for-the-public

  • - 139 -

    (CPNI: Centre for the Protection of National Infrastructure)35)

    - ,

    - : ,

    - : , , , ,

    ,

    - , ,

    - : , , , ,

    , , , , (), , ,

    -

    ,

    ,

    (National Cyber Security Centre)36)

    - , ,

    -

    -

    GovCertUK( ) CERT-UK(

    )

    )

    m

    37) : EU

    EU

    35) http://www.cpni.gov.uk/about/cni/

    36) http://www.ncsc.gov.uk37) EU, Cybersecurity Strategy of European Union, 2013

  • - 140 -

    , , , , ,

    , , , ,

    EU 5

    (Cyber Resilience)

    EU

    m

    q

    : (NCSC : National Cyber Security Centre)

    -

    2015 11

    - (CPA: Commercial Product Assurance) :

    (Foundation Grade)

    CPA ,

  • - 141 -

    NCSC

    , CPA

    (CPA)

    (CC: Common Criteria) (

    (Foundation Grade)

    ,

    - (CC) :

    NCSC

    (CLEF: Commercial Evaluation Facility)

    NCSC

    (CC) NCSC (CD:

    Certification Body) ,

    - NCSC

    (CLEF) (CC)* ,

    4, 6

    * CC CC

    q 38)

    : (IISP : Institute of Information Security Professionals)

    -

    38) www.cybersecurityconference.co.uk/partner/institute-information-security-professionals

  • - 142 -

    - IISP 2,500 31 17

    - IISP

    - IISP IISP

    (IISP Skills Framework)

    - (CESG: National Technical

    Authority for Information Assurance)39) ,

    q 6 (CC : Common Criteria)

    , 4(, , , ), 6

    - 6 1985 TCSEC(Trusted Computer Security Evaluation

    Center), 4 1992 ITSEC(Information Technology Security

    Evaluation Criteria), 1993 CTCPEC(Canadian Trusted Product

    Evaluation Criteria)

    -

    (CC: Common

    Criteria)

    - CC ,

    - EAL1 EAL7

    , ,

    39) www.cesg.gov.uk

  • - 143 -

    CC

    - , , , ,

    , , (, ,

    ATM), , ,

    - (, , , ), (, ,

    , ), , ,

    , , , PKI

    - (, , ), DB, ,

    : TTA (CC)

    )

    (Cyber health check)

    (2017 8)40)

    - 350 2/3

    (68%), 1/2

    (54%)

    - FTSE 350( 350 ) 10 1

    (10%), 1/3

    (31%)

    - 2017 ,

    (33% 53%),

    (49% 57%)

    - , ,

    -

    40) Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport and The Rt Hon Matt Hancock MP, Two in three

    bosses at Britains biggest businesses not trained to deal with a cyber attack, 2017.8.21.

  • - 144 -

    - (Data Protection Bill)

    , 2018 5 GDPR

    - ,

    -

    (97%)

    GDPR

    6% , 1/3 (71%)

    GDPR

    13% GDPR

    45% GDPR

    (2017 8)41)

    -

    -

    4% 1,700

    - 2018 5 (Network and Information System,

    NIS) (Department

    for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport)

    - (NIS) GDPR

    ,

    - ,

    IT

    - , , , , ,

    41) Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport and The Rt Hon Matt Hancock MP, New fines for

    essential service operators with poor cyber security, 2017.8.7.

  • - 145 -

    ,

    , , IT

    - ,

    , , ,

    ,

    ,

    (2017 8)42)

    - (Department for Transport)

    8

    -

    (Centre for the Protection of National Infrastructure, CPNI)

    , ,

    , , 3

    ,

    3

    42) Department for Transport, The key principles of vehicle cyber security for connected and

    automated vehicles, 2017.8.6.

  • - 146 -

    (2017 7)43)

    - (Gloucester) (Cyber Works)

    , 90

    - (Lockheed Martin) , ,

    - ,

    CyberFisrt

    - 5 19 ,

    - 1

    - 650 , , ,

    - National Offensive Cyber

    Planning ,

    - 8

    - 2018 1 (MOD) (Shrivenham)

    ,

    , 2017 (2017 4)44)

    - (Finantial Conduct Authority, FCA) Nausicaa Delfas (executive

    director) 2017

    -

    TV, , , (IoT)

    DDoS

    -

    43) Ministry of Defence and Harriett Baldwin MP, Defence Minister opens 3M Cyber Security Centre

    in Gloucester, 2017.7.13.

    44) Financial Conduct Authority news, Expect the unexpected: cyber security in 2017 and beyond,

    2017.4.27

  • - 147 -

    -

    85% :

    ,

    , DDoS

    ,

    : 13

    , ,

    EU

    - 2016 6 23 52% 48% EU

    EU 2

    EU

    - EU 4 2015 12 EU

    , 2016 2 GDPR

    , EU

    - 2017

    2

    - EU

    4%

    ,

    -

    ,

  • - 148 -

    - EU

    2

    EU

    EU

    EU (2016 5)45)

    -

    - 72

    ,

    4%

    - , 2018 5 25

    -

    (Data Protection Officer) , EU

    EU

    -

    IT 5G , ,

    - 2016/17 ,

    ,

    - (NIC ; National Infrastructure Commission)

    5G 2017

    -

    45) http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/ KOTRA (2016.05.16.)

  • - 149 -

    (Hub)

    - IT

    ,

  • - 150 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 9 2017 GCI 1

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.819 8

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 16 ICT

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 8.11 16 8.84 1

    (Access) 8.70 12 8.99 8

    (Use) 7.61 17 8.57 3

    (Skills) 7.94 36 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.819 8 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.846 10 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.3 24 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) (ICT)

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    39,006 59.7 28,035 56.1

    27,664 42.4 20,555 41.1

    67,571 103.5 61,295 122.7

    85.6% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 2,488.28

    '17 () 66,836

  • - 151 -

    1)

    )

    , ,

    46)

    - PwC 11 ,

    150 59% 2017

    - Orange Cyberdfense 250 20%

    (Agence nationale de la scurit des systmes dinformation, ANSSI) , , , 2016

    2016

    3,235 47)

    - 2016 6,

    2,000

    - Kaspersky Lab 2016 Locky

    114 (3,989) (2,372)

    3 976 1, 2 ,

    - 2016

    DOWNSEC( Anonymous )

    ,

    (Notre

    Dame-des-Landes , El

    Khomri )

    46) www.slate.fr, Cyberscurit : la France, bonne lve?(2017.04.21.) 47) ANSSI, Rapport annuel : ANSSI 2016

  • - 152 -

    (GCI) 8, 2 ,

    100

    3

    0.99 0.82 0.85 0.94 0.64 0.84 1

    0.94 0.96 0.6 1.0 0.61 0.81 2

    0.96 0.89 0.64 0.80 0.57 0.81 3

    : ITU,Global Cybersecurity Index & Cyberwellness Profiles(GCI)(2017)

    2015 1 (Charlie Hebdo) 11

    , 2016 7

    - 8,500

    - 2017 7 15 11 1

  • - 153 -

    )

    m ICT

    , ,

    48)

    2000 GDP 2.3%

    1998 156,000 2006

    122,000, 2015 118,400

    VoIP,

    ICT

    2014 2015 201915-19

    (%) 649.4 680.8 778.2 3.4

    108.2 108.5 115.6 1.6

    87.3 89.5 98.7 2.5

    58.5 60.4 69.4 3.7

    57.7 59.0 65.3 2.5

    (: )

    : BMI Research, Information Technology Report(2015)

    ITU ICT (IDI)

    - ,

    (Plan France Trs Haut Dbit)

    - ITU

    48) BuddeComm Telecoms Research(2017.2)

  • - 154 -

    ICT

    2016 2010 2016 2010 2016 2010 2016 2010 (4.94) (4.14) (5.58) (4.83) (3.91) (2.21) (5.74) (6.61)

    1(8.84)1

    (8.64)8

    (8.99)10

    (8.64)3

    (8.57)1

    (8.02)3

    (9.08)2

    (9.87)

    5(8.46)10

    (7.62)3

    (9.24)8

    (8.75)9

    (8.09)12

    (5.99)29

    (8.18)31

    (8.65)

    10(8.37)9

    (7.73)10

    (8.80)15

    (8.03)8

    (8.14)7

    (7.02)35

    (7.97)34

    (8.57)

    12(8.31)17

    (7.28)5

    (9.09)7

    (8.77)21

    (7.49)21

    (5.34)23

    (8.36)50

    (8.17)

    15(8.17)16

    (7.30)19

    (8.27)25

    (7.59)18

    (7.57)14

    (5.90)1

    (9.18)5

    (9.52)

    16(8.11)18

    (7.22)12

    (8.70)14

    (8.15)17

    (7.61)17

    (5.66)36

    (7.94)37

    (8.50)

    ) ( )

    : ITU, Measuring the Information Society Report 2016(2016.11)

    m

    - ITU 100

    2010 64.2% 2016 59.7%

    -

    (2016)

    100

    100

    2010 2016 2010 2016

    64.2 59.7 33.7 42.3

    63.7 53.7 31.5 38.0

    53.8 52.2 30.9 39.1

    58.9 56.1 35.5 41.1

    51.5 50.5 26.8 31.47

    47.9 37.0 27.1 32.37

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 155 -

    m

    ,

    , (MVNO) , ( )

    , , LTE ,

    MVNO

    - 2012 Free Mobile 2012

    11.5% 2013 26.6%. 2014 10.6%, 2015 5.5%

    49)

    EU

    - Orange, SFR, Bouygues Telecom, Free Mobile

    (MVNO) (2016 9,

    10.8%)

    100

    100

    2010 2016 2010 2014

    91.4 103.4 36.2 66.2 106.5 114.53 25.5 63.6

    123.6 122.32 43,2 98.7

    104.8 122.65 97.7 108.6

    96.8 129.75 87.6 121.4

    91.3 127.16 60.1 97.9

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    49) , , (2017.02.21)

  • - 156 -

    m

    (%)

    (%)1

    (Bit/)

    2014 2015 2014 2015 2014 2015 81.6 81.5 83.0 82.6 119203 129973

    90.6 91 89.5 90.3 103877 117540

    89.0 89.9 89.9 91.3 361057 374554

    78.3 77.1 98.5 98.8 43358 46764

    79.3 80.0 96.4 96.5 49150 62618

    81.5 87.3 79.9 82.2 84931 99017

    : ITU, Measuring the Information Society Report 2016(2016.11)

    m

    , 2009

    - Caisse des Dpts et Consignations

    2016 9 3.3% 2,740

    120 510

    2006

  • - 157 -

    - DSL(Digital Subscriber Line) HFC(

    ) 4

    - DSL

    - 100Mbps 9%

    122 30Mbps~100Mbps(HFC VDSL+ )

    191 33%

    - 2016 9 1/3

    (27%) 30Mbps( DSL)

    2016 9 1 36 2,230

    2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    22,749

    (35.78)

    23,980

    (37.51)

    24,940

    (38.79)

    25,969

    (40.17)

    26,867

    (41.34)

    27,664

    (42.35)

    17,860

    (36.65)

    18,253

    (37.25)

    18,738

    (38.04)

    19,199

    (38.78)

    20,024

    (40.25)

    20,555

    (41.13)

    35,096

    (28.04)

    36,132

    (28.39)

    36,724

    (28.88)

    37,789

    (29.76)

    38,663

    (30.49)

    39,842

    (31.47)

    20,589

    (32.98)

    21,686

    (34.54)

    23,040

    (36.49)

    23,730

    (37.38)

    24,084

    (37.72)

    25,153

    (39.18)

    88,317

    (28.04)

    92,514

    (29.14)

    96,031

    (30.06)

    97,810

    (30.32)

    102,516

    (31.53)

    106,072

    (32.37)

    27,757

    (32.88)

    27,957

    (33.76)

    28,642

    (34.62)

    29,573

    (35.78)

    30,707

    (37.19)

    31,377

    (32.05)

    ( : , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 158 -

    2)

    )

    m

    q

    2015 IS

    - Technavio , 2014 15

    4,000 , 13 8,000 29 2,000

    , 50)

    - 1/10

    , ,

    - 2015 2 3,000,

    4,300 , 450-600,

    3,900 26 7,000

    - 19 2,300, 26 2,000, 17

    7,000

    50) UBS 43

  • - 159 -

    (2015)

    ()

    ( )

    () Major1 3,201 1,627 16,350 Minor2 478 805 3,381

    ,, 109 57 630 ,, 472 113 2,148 ,, 106 64 483

    4,366 2,666 22,992

    : Barnes Reports, 2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems(2014.12)

    - 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014

    4%, 2.8%, 1.8%, 2.1%

    - , , ,

    4%

    - 2013

    2020 5% 2020

    5%

    - 2013 , 53 ,

    124

    -

    31

    (2013)

    ( ) ( )

    5.33 35.3

    12.43 71.5

    3.14 18.5

    20.9 125.3

    : (Direction gnrale des entreprises, DGE), Analyse du march et des acteurs de la filire industrielle franaise de scurit(2015.11.19)

  • - 160 -

    (Alliance pour la confiance numrique, ACN) 2017 7 (Confiance Numrique) 51) , (, ,

    , , ) (,

    , ,

    )

    - (Nouvelle France Industrielle)

    9

    - 2013 700 2016 850

    90 ( 45, 43), (

    , , ) 2014 12%

    - 10 9 500 8 50

    5000 20

    55%

    - , (, , safe city( ), ),

    2/3 , ,

    , 18~26%,

    q

    Technavio 2014 13

    8,000

    - , ,

    IS ,

    GDP

    -

    51) ACN, Observatoire ACN 2017 de la filire de la Confiance Numrique en France(2017.07.26.)

  • - 161 -

    - , ,

    ( ) 2013-20 (%) 5,750 0.5

    705.9 0.0 27.0 0.0

    425.9 4.0 778.2 5.0

    84.1 7.0 837.9 8.0 359.3 7.5

    8,969.2 2.3

    : (Direction gnrale des entreprises, DGE), Analyse du march et des acteurs de la filire industrielle franaise de scurit(2015.11.19)

    , ,

    , , , ,

    , , ,

    50% (

    )

    - , , , ,

    (

    , )

    , , , ,

    , , , ,

    50%

  • - 162 -

    q

    - 2014 15 4,00

    - , ,

    - 2015 11

    IS

    -

    ,

    ,

    Hexatrust 19 , , (1 1,000

    ) 30%

    m

    q

    2016 10 (Insee) 52)

    , ,

    ( )

    - ,

    3.0%, 4.2%

    - ,

    19.5% ( 77.5%)

    52) Insee, La scurit : un secteur toujours en plein essor(2016.10)

  • - 163 -

    -

    2010 2016 45%

    2015 11%

    2010~2016

    * ,

    : (Insee)

    - 2016

    - 2015~2016 ,

    2016 2016

    ( +3.9%, +3.3%)

    - 2016 ( ), 2017

    ,

    ,

    60%

    - ,

    CCTV, GPS, GSM

    , , ,

  • - 164 -

    , , ,

    q

    2013 12 (Loi de programmation militaire),

    (NIS) , GDPR

    PAC ( CXP group ) 53)

    2016 10%

    2014~2015 IT 2015

    : PAC, SITSI Cyber Scurit France, 2016

    53) PAC, SITSI Cyber Scurit France, 2016

  • - 165 -

    - (Entreprises de service

    numrique, ESN) ,

    q

    2015 1 8,900 10

    2025 3 9,600 2015

    2025 31

    - 7.68%

    10.31%

    2015 20252015-2015

    2015-2025

    87 172 1,400 7.05

    57 120 936 7.73 30 64 502 7.87

    15 40 285 10.31 189 396 3,100 7.68

    (: , %)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

    2016 2 1,200

    2015 1 8,900 12.2% 2022

    3

    2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025

    189 212 227 242 267 271 293 314 335 358 396

    (: )

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

  • - 166 -

    2025

    (: %)

    2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025

    / 46 45 45 45 44 44 45 45 44 44 43

    30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30

    16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16 16

    8 9 9 9 10 10 9 9 10 10 11

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

    - , ,

    CCTV

    - 2015 8,700

    7.05% 2025

    1 7,200

    14

    - ,

    ,

    , Thales

    -

    2015 2020 2025

    : A 189 271 396

    : B ,, 90.72 119.24 170.28

    (B/A) % 46 44 43

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

  • - 167 -

    10 9 3,600

    - Cyber Defense Plan , 3

    4,100

    -

    2

    10 2025 7.73%

    - 2015 5,670 2025 1 1,880

    -

    - SDI

    2015 2020 2025

    : A 189 271 396

    : B ,, 56.7 81.3 118.8

    (B/A) % 30 30 30

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

    -

    - 2015 3,034

    2025 6,400

    -

  • - 168 -

    10 1

    2015 2020 2025

    : A 189 271 396

    30.24 43.36 63.36

    (B/A) % 16 16 16

    (C) 15.12 27.1 43.56

    (C/A) % 8 10 11

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the France to 2025_Market Brief(2016.3)

    )

    m

    2011 7.1%

    2014 4.9%, 2015 5.2%, 2016 5.5% 54)

    - 2016 70%,

    10%, 8.5%, 4.5%, 4.5%,

    3%, 0.7%

    54) https://fr.statista.com, www.epnc.co.kr

  • - 169 -

    2016

    : https://fr.statista.com (2017.10)

    - , 2016

    Oliver Wyman 2015 1

    5,500 2015 6 2,200 ( )

    - (5,800 ), (5,000 ),

    (3,900 ), (3,900 ), (2,800 ), (2,500

    ), (2,200 ), (800 ), (400 )

  • - 170 -

    2015~2025

    : Oliver Wyman (2016)

    - 2015 , DVR

    ,

    55)

    - 2013 53 3,000 2020

    3.3%

    - 18 8,800

    ,

    - 2013 35,300

    55) http://blog.econocom.com

  • - 171 -

    2013 ( )2013-2020

    (%) 1,207.6 3.0

    1,636.1 3,0

    , 191.7 2.0

    1,888.4 4.0

    406.0 3.0

    5,329.8 3.3

    : , L'Industrie Francaise de Scurit(2015.11.19)

    124

    -

    - 44 5,200

    22 1,500

    -

    2013 ( )2013-2020

    (%) 4,452.1 7.0

    1,134.5 2.0

    2,215.7 4.0

    381.0 4.5

    1,180.5 7.0

    722.1 5.0

    250.0 18.0

    1,004.3 5.0

    517.4 6.0

    220.9 8.0

    350.0 7.0

    12,428.4 6.0

    : , L'Industrie Francaise de Scurit(2015.11.19)

  • - 172 -

    m

    - 2015 26 43

    2 3,000 5

    - Barnes

    - 2015 4,568 2.6%

    2014 6.9%

    - 2015 26 5,800

    6-7%

    - 2015 2 3,000

    2014 1.9%

    - 4% 2015

    58 2,000

    2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    (%)4,144

    (-)4,195(1.2)

    4,274(1.9)

    4,568(6.9)

    4,687(2.6)

    (%)2,221

    (-)2,346(5.6)

    2,490(6.1)

    2,658(6.7)

    2,853(7.3)

    (%)1,744

    (-)1,843(5.6)

    1,956(6.1)

    2,088(6.7)

    2,241(7.3)

    (%)21,820

    (-)22,094(1.3)

    22,509(1.9)

    22,942(1.9)

    23,538(2.6)

    : ( )

    : Barnes Reports, 2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems(2014.12)

    50

    -

    500 2 ,

  • - 173 -

    250~499 4 50

    - 100 1,000 500

    1

    - 2015 100~249 131, 250~499

    290, 500 1,000

    ()

    1-4 5-9 10-1920-49

    50-99

    100-249

    250-499

    500

    2014 638 221 180 123 41 23 4 2 3,041 4,2742015 682 236 193 132 44 25 4 2 3,251 4,5682016 699 243 198 135 45 25 4 2 4,687

    ( )

    2014 130 119 244 441 326 486 251 362 131 2,4902015 139 127 261 472 348 520 268 383 140 2,6582016 150 137 280 507 375 559 289 407 151 2,853

    ()

    2014 1,773 1,427 2,730 4,133 2,739 3,219 1,138 1,970 3,382 22,5092015 1,807 1,454 2,782 4,212 2,792 3,281 1,160 2,007 3,447 22,9422016 1,854 1,492 2,854 4,322 2,864 3,366 1,190 2,060 3,537 23,538

    : Barnes Reports, 2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems(2014.12)

    m

    -

    -

    ,

    , , ,

  • - 174 -

    - 2015 4,568 478

    8 500 3,381

    - 2014 ,

    43

    ,

    26

    16

    m

    - , ,

    ,

    - ,

    56)

    56) Pipame:Analyse du march et des acteurs de la filire indutrielle farnase de securit, pp20-23

  • - 175 -

    ( ) 2013-2020 (%)

    19.5 14.0%

    102.0 6.0

    45.0 9.0

    23.0 12.0

    406.0 4,0

    379.0 7.0

    974.5 6.1

    , , 433.0 14.0

    811.0 10.0

    855.0 13.0

    42.0 8.0

    2,171.0 12.1

    3,145.5 10.4

    : , L'Industrie Francaise de Scurit(2015.11)

    )

    m

    -

    - ,

    , ,

    ,

  • - 176 -

    -

    IS

    ,

    ,

    - 2015 3% 2016

    11 4% 57)

    -

    - ICT

    , , SNS

    ,

    m

    , 4,500~10,000

    4,500

    - 470 600

    , 3,900~4,000

    -

    58)

    57) www.batiactu.com 58) European Security Services (2016.08.30.) pp43

  • - 177 -

    2015

    ( )(%)

    Securitas 625 15 x

    Groupe Samsic 230 5 O

    Seris ,, 220 5 OFiducial Private Security ,, 200 5 O

    Groupe ONET ,, 190 4 O

    : UBS, European Security Services - UBS Evidence Lab: Secure in the

    digital era?(2016.8.30)

    59)

    Securitas France

    - Securitas AB

    - , , , , ,

    - : www.securitas.fr Tel. : 33248670388

    - 3

    Groupe Samsic

    - Samsic Samsic Scurit - , , ,

    - : www.samsic.fr

    Groupe Seris

    - Securitas France IT

    - , , , ,

    - : www.seris-group.com

    Fiducial Private Security

    - 500 5,000

    59) U.S. Commercial Service, Safty and Security Resource Guide

  • - 178 -

    - , , ,

    ,

    - : www.fiducial.fr/fr/

    Groupe ONET

    - ONET Office nouveau du nettoyage

    - , , ,

    , , ,

    - : fr.groupeonet.com, en.groupeonet.com

    Thales Communications & Security(FR)

    - Thales Group

    10 7000

    - , , , , ,

    ,

    - : www.thalesgroup.com

    Morpho

    - Safran

    - , , , ,

    - : www.safran-na.com, www.morpho.com

    Gemalto

    - 47

    14,000

    - , , ,

    - 2017 12 Thales Group

    - : www.gemalto.com

    Vinci

    - 100 28 18 5

  • - 179 -

    - , , , , ,

    ,

    - : www.vinci.com

    Spie(FR)

    - Spie

    - , , , ,

    - : www.spie.com

    Brink's France

    - Brink's Incorporated

    - , , , ,

    - : www.brinks.fr

    Cassidian

    - EADS

    - 1989 ,

    - : www.cassidian.com

    - Tel.: 331420481, Fax : 33142048170

    Sperian Protection

    - Honeywell Security (Honeywell Safety Products France SAS)

    - ,

    - : http://www.honeywellsafety.com/FR

    : hsp@honeywell.com Tel. : 33149907979, Fax : 33149907104

    UTC Fire & Security France

    - United Technology

    - , , , , ,

    , ,

    - : www.linkedin.com

    Capgemini

    - 40 18

  • - 180 -

    119

    - , , , (IoT),

    - : www.capgemini.com

    Sagem Security - , ,

    - : www.sagem-securite.com

    Panasonix France -

    - ,

    - : www.panasonic.fr

    Cegeles Sud Est - 1940 ,

    - : www.cegeles.com : michael.cano@cegelec.com

    - : Tel. -33-4-4202-3213, Mr. Michael Cano

    ADI Global Distribution - 1973 , , ,

    - : www.adi-gardiner.com

    : denis.castanet@adiglobal.com

    - : 33-1 5802-0202, Mr. Denis Castanet

    Gerard et Peysson - 1930

    - : www.gerardetpeysson.fr

    : oliver.peysson@gerardetpetsson.fe

  • - 181 -

    - : 33-4-7633-3189, Mr. Oliver Peysson

    )

    ICT

    - 2016 4 Orange ,

    Lexsi

    - 1999 Lexsi 2,300 , 170

    - 2016 3 Thales

    Vormetric , 2017 12 Gemalto

    ,

  • - 182 -

    3)

    )

    m 60)

    , (Loi relative l'Informatique aux Fichers et aux Liberts, 78-17)

    - 1978 1 1979 7

    (La Libert d'Accs au Documents Administratifs, 78-753)

    - , 2004 8

    (La Protection des Personnes Physiques l'gard des Traitements de donnes a Caractre Personnel, 2004-801)

    - EU (Directive 2000/31/EC)

    (Directive 2002/58/EC) 2004

    (Law No. 2004-575; Reinforcing trust in the digital economy(2004.

    06.21)

    - 1998 (Law No. 1998-19, Lutte contre la Fraude

    Informatique aux TIC (1998. 01. 05) 2004

    (Law No. 2004-204, Portant Adaptation de la Justice aux volutions de la ceiminalit)

    60) www.ssi.gouv.fr

  • - 183 -

    - 2009 6 13 (HADOPI ;

    Haute Autorit pour la diffusion des oevres et la protection del droits sur internet)

    -

    HADOPI

    - 2010 9 HADOPI

    1

    - 2013 5 TV

    , HADOPI ,

    (CSA)

    - 2013 7 8 331-21

    2

    - 2014 10 (Code de la propiete intellectuelle)

    (Code du patrimoine) ,

    , 3 EU

    -

    -

    1 1 50

    70

    3

    - 2014 5

    3

    -

  • - 184 -

    , ,

    3

    - 3 (CNCTR)

    - 2004 Loi de Commercie Electronique no. 2004-575

    (2004. 06. 21) 2016 (ECPX 0200175L, 2016. 09. 28)

    - 2004

    2016

    - EU

    - Recommendation no. 901(1994 3)

    (PSSIE : La Politique de Securit des Systemes D'information de l'Etat)

    - , ,

    - 2004 12 9

    (Legal Simplication Law) 2005 12 8

    Teleservices ordinance ,

    -

    2008

    - ,

  • - 185 -

    ,

    -

    (e-Communications Legislation)

    - 2009 12 18 (Postal and Electronic

    Communications Code) 61)

    - 1978

    1 6 (Loi d'informatique et des Libertes; Law on

    Informatics and Liberty)

    -

    - (CNIL)

    - 1978 (Loi

    d'informatique et des Libertes: Information Technology and liberty Act)

    - 1988 1 5 (Goldfrain Act ; Loi Goldfrain)

    ( 323-1/323-7)

    - 2004 6 21 (Loi du 21 Juin 2004 pour la

    Confiance dans l'Economie Numrique) - , ,

    ,

    61) www.legifrance.gouv.fr

  • - 186 -

    22

    - 2013 12 2014~2019 (Loi de programmation militaire, LPM)62)

    ANSSI

    - 22 (Oprateur d'importance vitale, OIV)63) , ANSSI

    (OIV)

    m

    2015

    (Stratgie Nationale pour la Scurit du Nurique)

    - , ,

    - , , ,

    -

    - , ,

    -

    (ANSSI) (CNIL)

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    - , ,

    62) 2014-2019 No. 2013-1168(13.12.18.)

    63) 200 ,

  • - 187 -

    1978 ,

    1979

    2000 2004

    - 2008 (CERT-FR) 2011

    (Defence and Security Strategy) 64)

    (ANSSI)

    - 2008

    (Livre Blanc)

    2013 ,

    -

    -

    - (ICS: Industrial Control System)

    ISO 27000 ANSSI IGI 1300(Instruction Gnrale Interministrielle No. 1300)65)

    64) www.legifrance.gouv.fr(2011.11.30.)

  • - 188 -

    -

    3

    - Class 1:

    (Healthy

    Network Guide)

    - Class 2:

    ,

    - Class 3: ,

    ,

    Google

    2013 2022 100Mbps

    (Plan France Trs Haut Dbit; The National Broadband Plan)

    - (Ministre de l'conomie de l'Industrie et du Numrique) (Agence Numrique) (Autorit de Rgulation des Communications lectroniques et des Postes)

    - 200

    65) ANSSI 2011.11.30

  • - 189 -

    - 2017 7 2022

    2020

    - 80% 20%

    DSL

    2022

    - 4G

    )

    m

    (SGDSN : Secrtariat Gnral de la Dfense et de La Scurit Nationale)

    -

    (ANSSI : Agence Nationale de la Scurit des Systmes d' Information - French Networks and Information Security Agency)

    - Decree no. 2009-834(2009. 01.01) (ADCSSI:

    Central Directorate for Information System Security)

    2009 7 8

    - ,

    ,

  • - 190 -

    24 ,

    - IT

    ,

    - (CERT)

    -

    - CERT

    - : http://www.ssi,gouv.fr

    (CNIL : Commission Nationale de l'informatique et des Libertes)

    - 1978 2014 3

    ,

    - , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    -

    - : 2012. 03. 30

    2012-436

    -

    ,

    -

  • - 191 -

    - : CCTV

    - 2013 3 Google, Facebook, Amazon

    -

    ,

    -

    ,

    ,

    - : http://www.cnil.fr

    (CERT-FR : Centre Governemental de Veille d'Alerte et

    de Rsponse aux Attaques Informatiques) - ANSSI ,

    - (SDLC/OCLCTIC),

    (BEFTI), (ISB),

    (C3N)

    - : http://www.cert.fr

    (ARCEP: Autorit de Rgulation des Communications letroniques et des Postes)

    - EU

    EU

    - : http://www.cnil.fr

    (OCLCTIC : Office Central de Lutte contre la Criminalite liee aux

    Technologies de l'information et de la Communication)

    - 2000 5

  • - 192 -

    ,

    -

    - , ,

    IT

    - : www.pointdecontact.net

    (DUI : Dlgation aux Usages de l'internet) -

    , ,

    , ICT

    - : http://www.delegation.internet.gouv.gr

    (DDM : Direction du Dveloppement des Mdias) - (Ministre de la Culture)

    , Signal Spam Initiative

    - : http://www.ddm.gouv.fr www.signal-spam.fr

    (DGME : Direction gnrale de la Modernization de l'Etat) - 2005

    ,

    - : www.modernisation.gour,gr

    (Ministre de l'Economie, Industrie et de l'emploi) -

    - (Agence Numrique)

  • - 193 -

    (Autorit de Rgulation des Communications lectroniques et des Postes)

    - : www.economie.gouv.fr

    (Ministre de l'interieur) -

    2014

    - ; www.inyerieur.gour.fr

    (MAEDI : Ministere des Affaires Etrangeres et du Developpement Internacional)

    - , NATO, UN, OECD, EU

    - 2011

    m

    (COSSI : Centre Oprational pour les Systmes et Scurit de l'Information)

    - COSSI ANSSI

    - COSSI (CERTA)

    - : http://www.ssi.gouv.fr www.cerca.ssi.gouv.fr

    (CERT-Renater)

    - 1995 , ,

    , ,

    -

    - : http://www.renater,fr

  • - 194 -

    - APOGEE SecWatch(Devoteam):

    : www.devoteam.com

    - (CERT-IST: Computer Emergency Response Team): 1998

    4

    : http://www.cert-ist.com

    )

    m

    - 2006 (Ministry of Economy, Industry and

    Employment HFDS : Haut Fonctionnaire de Dfense et de Scurit)

    - ,

    -

    m

    (Certification de Scurit de Premier Niveau, CSPN) - (Critres Communs)66) ANSSI

    2008 , IT ANSSI IT

    (CESTI) ANSSI

    66) , , ,

  • - 195 -

    CNIL (authorisation de la CNIL)

    - ,

    (Commission Nationale de l'Information

    et des Liberts, CNIL) (dclaration), (demande d'authorisation) (demande d'avis)

    - , (dclaration) (authorisation) ( 25, 54, 64)

    -

    CNIL (avis) ( 26, 27)

    CNIL (Labels CNIL)

    - (Loi Informatique et Liberts) CNIL , ,

    , ,

    (1) (Label Formations) : (

    )

    (2) (Label Audit de traitements) :

    , ,

    (3) (Label Coffre-fort numrique) : (intergrity),

    * ,

    (data warehouse)

    (4) (Label governance informatique et liberts) : (correspondant Informatique et Liberts)

    SecNumCloud

    - 2014 Secure Cloud ISO27001

    ANSSI 2016 5 2

  • - 196 -

    (1) 1( ) :

    (2) 2( ) :

    ANSSI label SecNumedu

    - (licence), (licence pro), ,

    France Cybersecurity

    - 2015 France Cybersecurity , ,

    (1) : (DGA), (DGE),

    ANSSI

    (2) : (ACN), (Hexatrust)

    (3) : (CIGREF), (GITSIS),

    (CESIN), (CLUSIF)

  • - 197 -

    )

    GDP 7.4% 2015 2016

    8.1%

    - 2016 , ,

    1,550 CCTV

    ,

    9,000

    -

    2017 7 , CCTV

    , , Scuri-Site

    - 7 , 7~9

    216 CCTV 131 CCTV

    2017 5 30, , ,

    Cybermalveillance.gouv.fr

    - , (

    )

    -

    - 100 ANSSI 2019 250

    75%

    ( ,

    , )

    2015 5,000 10,000

    OS PC

    NOgend NOpol 60,000

  • - 198 -

    safe city CCTV ,

    - 10%

    18%

    - , ,

    - 7 ENGIE Ineo MOU 2020 CCTV 2,000 , ,

    , 2016

  • - 199 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    24,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.679 24

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 175

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 8.31 12 8.84 1

    (Access) 9.09 5 8.99 8

    (Use) 7.49 21 8.57 3

    (Skills) 8.36 23 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.679 24 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.821 15 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.6 15 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    90%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    44,310 53.7 28,035 56.1

    31,377 38.1 20,556 41.1

    94,432 114.5 61,295 122.7

    89.7% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 3,423

    17 () 80,595

  • - 200 -

    1)

    )

    m

    ITU 2017 4 (GCI) 2017

    * 0.679 24

    * , 5

    , 0.782 13

    ,

    2015 IT ICT

    - 2016 9 , 2016 8

    NATO

    ,

    - 2015 6,

    2

    - 5

    ,

    - 2013 2 Spiegel ,

    ,

    2012 1,100

    - 2010

    Siemens

    'Stuxnet' Siemens (PCS7)

    2015 2020 ICT

    ICT

  • - 201 -

    - 2015 3 2015 2020

    1.8 ( 2,320 ) ICT

    - ICT , ,

    ICT ,

    2017 6 30

    G20

    - (BSI) Arne Schnbohm Anonymous LulzSec

    24 ,

    2

    - BSI ,

    Vote-Meter

    m

    2~3

    2017

    - Securitas 2016

    - ,

    2015 10 28.5% 2016 1

    30.5%

    ,

    2016 22

    - 2016 2 27 ISIS 10

    1

  • - 202 -

    - 2016 4 15,

    3

    - 2016 7 18, ISIS

    5

    - 2016 7 22,

    9 35

    - 2016 7 24, 45

    ,

    15

    - 2016 12 19, 12

    48

    CCTV ,

    - CCTV

    - ,

    CCTV

    - CCTV

    - ,

    CCTV

    )

    2014, IT

    - 2018 50Mbps

    200

    2016 9,433 2015 9,636 200

    , 2015 116.71% 2.18%

    114.53%

  • - 203 -

    2016 3,138 38.05%

    , 2015 3,071 65 , 2015

    0.86%

    - Deutsche Telekom, Vodafone D2

    2016 89.65%, 2015 87.59% 2.06%

    -

    , e-Book

    2016 2/4 ARD/ZDF

    , 2015

    - 2016 5 14 84%

    5,800

    - 60 89%

    , 60 56.6%

    - ,

    2016 2015 2% 65.1%

    - .

    2016 153 ,

    2015 127 26

    - 2015

    ,

    2016 104

    2015 91

    - ,

    ,

  • - 204 -

    57% , 44 %

    , 66%

    - 14 29

    , 86%

    - , 30 49 65%, 50

    69 31%

    - 68%

    , 33%

    - ,

    - 83% 1 ,

    81% , 68%

    - 2015 ,

    67% 1 1

    - 40%

    , 26%

    2016

    : ARD / ZDF Medienkommission

  • - 205 -

    2016

    : ARD / ZDF Medienkommission

    2015 8, TNS Emnid ,

    28% Netflix, Maxdome, Amazon Prime VoD

    - 1,049 , 25-34

    47%, 16-24 42%

    - 69% , 56% YouTube

    MyVideo

    Statista , 2015 6

    25.6

    - SNS 5 ,

    SNS

    - , ,

    77%

    - (66.7%), (50%), (46%), (42%),

    (36%), (33.4%)

  • - 206 -

    AT Kearney 2015 4

    Spiegel online ,

    - 30 (Global Retail E-commerce Index)

    , , ,

    ,

    2)

    )

    m

    BITKOM , 2015 IT 37

    2014 35 6.5%

    - IT 78% ,

    , , (Access security),

    - , e-Commerce

    ,

    - 2013 BITKOM

    33% IT , 2014

    57%

    2014 , IT IT

    IT

    - IT IT

  • - 207 -

    IT

    - (BITKOM) IT

    (state-of-the-art) IT

    2,000 ,

    11

    - IT 40% 7

    IT

    IT

    * =172

    : BITKOM, Studie Security as a Service(2011.10)

    2011-2015 (CAGR)9.5% , 2015~2020 ICT

    - ICT

    ICT

    - ICT ICT 10%

    2007 (KMU-innovativ)

  • - 208 -

    2016 5, (BITKOM) 504

    , IT

    - 1/4 IT

    , 56% IT

    - ,

    10-99 46%, 500 42%

    IT

    m

    MarketLine ,

    IT

    - 2015 243 6 2011-2015 (CAGR) 9.5%

    - 9.9% 3.1% 2015 770

    108 6

    - IT

    - (Security Guard) 2011-2015 0.2%

    2015 167,300

    - 2020 166,200 2015-2020

    0.1%

  • - 209 -

    2011~2015

    : MarketLine, Security Services in Germany(2015.11)

    MarketLine , 2015

    32.9% 2020 323 6

    - 2015-2020 5.8%

    2015~2020

    : MarketLine, Security Services in Germany(2015.11)

    Statista 2016 , 2008 20

    IT 2015 37 6%

  • - 210 -

    - IT 78% , 2015 10%

    - 2015 TNS , 46%

    IT

    IT

    : Statista(2016)

    UBS , 68

    4% , 3~4%

    -

    Securitas, Kutter VSG

    - 2015

    - ,

  • - 211 -

    (2015 )

    (: )

    : UBS, European Security Services(2016.8.30)

    1995-2015

    : UBS, European Security Services(2016.8.30)

  • - 212 -

    2006-2015

    : UBS, European Security Services(2016.8.30)

    , 2015

    313

    - IT 34% 106 , 30% 95 2

    , , 10%

    - 2011 110 4 , /

    48 6 ,20 8 , 35 , 6

    2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

  • - 213 -

    2015, 12

    - / 6 9 1

    2007-2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

    2015 17 2

    - / 10 6 1

    2007-2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

  • - 214 -

    2015 IT 106 4

    - 51 6 , 54 8

    2007-2015 IT

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

    2015 // 185

    - 83 1

    2007-2015 //

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

  • - 215 -

    2015 // 18 7

    - 8 1 , 6 5 2

    2007-2015 //

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

    2015 10 2

    - 5 5 1

    2007-2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

  • - 216 -

    2015 28 6

    - 15 6 1

    2007-2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

    2015 9 2

    - 7 7 1

    2007-2015

    (: )

    : US DoC, Global Safety and Security Resource Guide(2013-14 edition)(2013.2)

  • - 217 -

    )

    m

    - 905 80% 3

    - UBS , 2000~2014

    4%

    - , 2015 60

    Art.34a

    80 40

    Securitas 14% 1 , 2 Kotter

    2

    - 3

    1996-2014

    : UBS, European Security Services(2016.8.30.)

  • - 218 -

    MarketLine , 2015 45

    7,000

    IHS Markit , 2016 80 CCTV

    2016 520

    -

    , ,

    - ,

    2016 8, ,

    - ,

    -

    2016

    - Deutsche Bahn

    -

    2017 CCTV

    - 2015

    2017

    -

    -

  • - 219 -

    B2C B2B

    - 300~500

    -

    B2C B2B

    -

    ,

    -

    - IfD 2012 ,

    2009 2,228

    2012 1,988

    m

    , , , IT

    MarketLine , 2015 244

    - IT 141 57.8%

    103 42.2%

    2015

    : MarketLine, Security Services in Germany(2015.11)

  • - 220 -

    2015~2016

    : UBS, European Security Services(2016.8.30.)

    )

    m

    q

    TeleTrust IT , ,

    - TeleTrust IT , ,

    - TeleTrust European Telecommunications Standards

    Institute (ETSI)

    AV-TEST

    Avira, Giesecke & Devrinet

    -

    OEM

  • - 221 -

    , ,

    - Cisco Systems, IBM, Northrop Grumman, CSC, Symantec

    -

    , (Reseller)

    -

    -

    - /

    ,

    : KISA, 2013 (2013.12)

    q

    Bosch, MOBOTIX, Honeywell Sanyo

    Panasonic

  • - 222 -

    - ,

    45.3%

    A/S OEM

    - A/S

    ,

    OEM

    CCTV 47% , 53% 35%

    , 24%

    - (VdS)

    , .

    CCTV

    CCTV , , ,

    -

    A/S

    - CCTV OEM

    2015 135,000 79%

    - , ,

  • - 223 -

    m

    q

    Avira

    - Avira 1986 (Tettnang)

    Avira

    2010

    - 1 ,

    - OPSWAT 2013 10 , Avira

    6.8% 6

    - Avira , , 20

    2009 , , 7

    - ABI 'Avira Antivirus Engine' 25,000

    3,500~7,000 DB

    - Avira iOS Avira Mobile Security 2016

    Ashampoo GmbH & Co. KG

    -

    - (Firewall)

    - Ashampoo Anti-Virus 1 $39.99 ,

    - Anti-Virus V3

    AV-TEST GmbH

    -

  • - 224 -

    AV-TEST

    - AV-TEST

    (22 ) 3

    - AV-TEST AV-TEST

    - AV-TEST

    Giesecke & Devrinet

    - 1 2008

    17

    - 1852 G&D ,

    ,

    - 80%

    4 (Gemalto, G&D, Oberthur, Morpho)

    - 30 49

    (www.gi-de.com)

    - ( )

    - KT 2008 , KT

    (UICC, Universal Integrated Circuit Card)

    - G&D G+D Mobile Security , ,

    , , ,

    ID

    G Data Software AG

    - 'G Data AntiVirus'

    -

  • - 225 -

    - 50

    Android

    Gate Protect

    -

    2012 8

    VPN IT

    - Gate Protect ISO-9241

    eGUI

    -

    q

    Bosch Sicherheitssysteme GmbH

    - 45 12

    - CCTV

    - 10 2016 IT

    - Bosch (Full

    Closed)

    - Bosch ,

    - IFA2017 Bosch Alexa 360

    Siemens Building Technologies GmbH & Co. oHG

    - 36% , 58%,

    / 6%

    - , ,

  • - 226 -

    -

    Siemens IBS((Intelligence Building System)

    - Siemens TBS , , , ,

    , (Access Control, CCTV),

    - , 101

    - 2017 9 Siemens Fraport Group 14

    13

    Securiton GmbH

    - Securitas Securiton AG

    - , 3D ,

    Securiton

    : www.securiton.de

    Dallmeier electronic GmbH & Co. KG

    - , , , , 10 30

    - , , , , CCTV/IP

  • - 227 -

    Dallmeier

    : www.dallmeier-electronic.com

    Honeywell Security Deutschland GmbH

    - Honeywell 2005 Novar GmbH Esser

    - Honeywell 100 CCTV, DVR

    Honeywell Security Deutschland GmbH

    : https://www.security.honeywell.de/

    MOBOTIX AG

    - MOBOTIX CCTV OEM

    - Mobotix ,

    CCTV

    - CCTV , 2010 2

  • - 228 -

    , 4

    MOBOTIX : H.264 Camera Line Mx6

    : https://www.mobotix.com/

    )

    2015 3, , Deutsche Telekom

    CeBIT

    -

    2015 9 4 Volkswagen, Allianz, BASF Bayer

    (Deutsche Cyber- Sicherheitsorganisation DCSO)

    - DCSO

  • - 229 -

    Deutsche Cyber- Sicherheitsorganisation DCSO

    : https://dcso.de/en/our-services.html

    2016 4, Securitas Draht+Schutz

    - Draht+Schutz

    2016

    ,

    - 2015 GDP 4

    120

    - 2015 2016

    - , ,

    - 2

  • - 230 -

    2)

    )

    m

    2015 6 7, IT 2016

    5 , 2

    - IT ,

    , , ,

    - IT , (Critical Infrastructure) 2

    1) , , (BSI)

    , 2)

    3) 2 BSI

    10

    - IT , ,

    ,

    .

    [ ] 1) 3,700 Gwh 2) 25

    [ ] 1) 50 2)

    22 m3 , 3) 22 m3

    [ ] 1) 434,500 2) 3 5

    [ ] 1) 10 2) 5Mw

    , 3) 25,000 (), 4) 75,000 ()

  • - 231 -

    (Data Retention Act)

    - 2015

    2017 7 1

    (Data Retention Act)

    - , ,

    , IP

    - 2017 6 22

    North Rhine-Westphalia

    (Bundesnetzagentur,BNetzA)

    2016 11 22 (German Federal Data Protection Act)

    2

    - 2016 9 1 EU

    2

    - 2 , 2018 5 25

    - ,

    , EU

    - CCTV

    ,

    Art. 2 Abs. 1 () Art.14 GG()

    22, 23 KunstUrhG ()

    BDSG ()

    BetrVG() PersVG()

  • - 232 -

    2011 2,

    De-Mail

    - De-Mail , ,

    (, 2011.04)

    - 2010 7 8 De-Mail , Deutsche Telekom,

    Web.de, GMX ,

    1 10~20

    - , 2010 7 15 (Deutsche Post) E-Postbrief

    ,

    , 1 55

    m

    16

    - EU (Hightech

    Strategy), e 2.0 , , ,

    2009 40

    - 16

    - , IT

    - 100

    - , ,

    5 1 , EU 7 14 2007

    Homeland Security

    -

    (ZVEI, Zentralverband Elektrotechnik und

    Elektronikindustrie) Homeland Security

    - Homeland Security 80%,

  • - 233 -

    20%

    - Homeland Security

    (CCTV, DVR)

    RFID

    (BSI) 2011 / (Smart

    Grid/Meter)

    - BSI , , PC

    CCTV

    - 1983

    CCTV

    - CCTV

    4

    - CCTV

    - EU

    2003 2

    - , , 2005 3 23

    , 3 24

    -

    , , ,

    - 2005 11 24 ,

    -

    ,

  • - 234 -

    -

    , 5

    )

    (BMI) (BSI)

    - (BMI, Bundesministerium des Innern)

    CIO(Chief Information Officer)

    IT

    - (BSI, Federal Office for Information Security)

    5

    , 2

    - 1991 BSI

    -

    (IT-Grundschutz-die Basis fr IT-Sicherheit)

    - BSI 2011 /(Smart Grid /Meter)

    (BSI)

    : (BSI)

  • - 235 -

    (Bundesnetzagentur fr Elektrizitt, Gas, Telekommunikation, Post und Eisenbahnen, Bundesnetzagentur)

    - (ICT) ,

    - IT , ,

    (Bundesnetzagentur)

    : (Bundesnetzagentur)

    (National Cyber Security Councile, NCSC)

    -

    (Federal Government Commissioner for Information Technology,

    BfIT)

    - , , , , ,

    DFN-CERT(Digital Freedom Network Computer Emergency Response Team)

    ,

    , , - CERT IT

  • - 236 -

    )

    (GSG)

    - GS

    -

    - 1968

    ,

    - GS GS

    ,

    GS

    - , VdS ,

    BG-PRFZERT

    (GDV, Gesamtverbands der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft)

    VdS

    - VdS

    4~6 ,

    ISO 9001

    CE

    - CE ,

    ,

  • - 237 -

    )

    2016 8,

    - 2017 400

    -

    2016 7,

    - 7

    - BFV 8,650

    , 800

    260

    - BFV 500

    - 2001 11 ,

    2016 4 ISIS Angela Merkel

    -

  • - 238 -

    2.

    m

    4,398,

    60% 43 ,

    -

    - ,

    ,

    (2016 )

    (US$ )

    (US$ )

    1992. 8 124,430 86,980,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    1973 11,590 4,180,

    , ,

    , , ,

    1973 6,609 8,285, ,

    , , /

    , , , ,

    1992. 12. 32,630 12,495,

    , ,

    , , , ,

    1997.10. 573 240,

    ,

    , , , ,

    1958.10 6,481 4,562,

    , ,

    , , ,

    1975.8 12,495 6,806, ,

    , ,

    , , ,

    ,

    1962.2 7,532 7,505

    , , , ,

    ,

    , , , ,

    : Kotra-

  • - 239 -

    (ITU) ( , ) ICT

    (, ) ICT

    (ICT development Index, IDI)

    - IDI

    - 2016 ICT (ICT Development Index, IDI)

    ICT

    - 20, , IDI

    100 , 100

    ~140

    ICT(IDI)

    IDI(2016) (access) (use) (skill)

    81 5.19 91 5.45 67 4.58 92 5.89

    138 2.69 139 3.32 142 1.25 122 4.29

    115 3.86 107 4.71 120 2.19 109 5.48

    105 4.29 110 4.60 92 3.51 114 5.25

    125 3.12 122 4.21 121 2.09 149 3.00

    82 5.18 89 5.50 71 4.33 80 6.21

    20 7.97 11 8.70 19 7.54 56 7.27

    61 6.22 66 6.75 46 5.86 94 5.87

    1 8.84 8 8.99 3 8.57 3 9.08

    : ITU, Measuring the Information Society Report 2016(2016)

  • - 240 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 5

    , , ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.624 32

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 5.19 81 8.84 1

    (Access) 5.45 91 8.99 8

    (Use) 4.58 67 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.89 92 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.624 32 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.607 63 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.2 59 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    206,624 14.7 28,036 56.1

    322,597 22.9 20,556 41.1

    1,364,934 96.9 61,296 122.7

    53.2% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 11,937.50

    '17 () 1,379,302

  • - 241 -

    1)

    )

    , ,

    ,

    - Rising() 2016 16.5%

    4,327 , PC 1,356

    - 2016 6 2016

    2015 2016 , ,

    , 915 ( 137 2,200

    )

    - 1 , , 1

    133( 20) , 3.6

    , 9% 1,000(150)

    12 5 (2010~2015)

    - 2012 2013 11

    2014 2

    - 2015 2017 6

    , (

    )

    -

  • - 242 -

    ,

    -

    , , ,

    - , 2016 4

    5 3,900

    (), () ,

    - 2~3

    -

    )

    m

    2017 8 (CNNIC, China Internet Network Information

    Center) 40 2017 6

    7 5,100 , 54.3%

    - 7 2,400 2016

    95.1% 6 96.3%

    - 10-39 72.1%

    , 20-29 29.7%

  • - 243 -

    (2012.6~2017.06)

    : CNNIC, (2017.8)

    m

    CNNIC 2017 6

    91.1% ,

    (83.1%) (81.1%)

    - () (92.3%) 1

    , (82.4%) (81.9%), (67.6%)

    -

    -

    ,

    - 2017 6 1 2,600

    6 2,724

    -

    ,

    ,

  • - 244 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    3 20%

    - (), (), () ,

    - IT

    , ,

    IT

    ,

    - 2014 IT 2%

    , , 10~14%

    - 10 1

    ,

    - UBS 2016~2020 25~30%

    (CAGR)

    2014 IT

    : (2016.7)

  • - 245 -

    , , ,

    , 2014 60%

    - , , ,

    , , , () , , ,

    -

    -

    , ,

    - , ,

    , (), ()

    - , Hikvision, Dahua

    Alibaba, Xiaomi, 360

    m

    q

    () 2016 20.9% 495 8,000

    - 248 8,600 ,

    135 8,500 , 111 900

  • - 246 -

    (2007~2016)

    : g(2017.8)

    SDI 2016 2015

    9 5,900

    - 3 3,100 ,

    2 9,600 , 1 7,000 ,

    1 6,100

    q

    CPS() Dahua 2016 2016 5,400

    11% , GDP 7%

    - ,

    10%

    - 1900 ,

    962, 266, 260

  • - 247 -

    2012~2016 (: )

    : www.cps.com.cn(2017.01)

    m

    CCID Consutling 2016 6

    , , ,

    - 2018 920 4,200 ( 138 )

    , 2016~2018 3 31.9%

    - , Gartner

    80%

    2016~2018

    : CCID Consulting(2016.1)

  • - 248 -

    SDI 5.77%

    , 2015 9 5,900 2025 17

    - 2015 3 3,100 2025 5 8,000

    5.76%

    - 2015 2 9,600 5.80%

    2025 5 2,000

    - 2015 1 7,000 2025

    2 7,000 , 4.7%

    - 2015 1 6,100 2025 3 1,000

    , 6.77%

    (2015~2020)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the China to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    10%

    - 50%

    11%

    5 50% 5

    500 ( 75 )

    - 5G

  • - 249 -

    )

    m

    2016

    50.2%, 27.4%, 22.4%

    - 15% ,

    ,

    -

    (CAICT) 2015

    2014 ( )

    - 2014 68 ( 10 2,270 ),

    40 2,341 ( 6 )

    - 56 7,440 ( 8 5,350 )

    , 33 7,126 ( 5 700 ),

    22 4,803 ( 3 3,800 ), / 2,900

    ( 436 )

    , , ,

    - 2014 , ,

    60%

  • - 250 -

    27%

    (UTM) 41%

    (IDS) 12%

    (IPS) 34%

    51%

    50%

    35%

    : IDC, CFSG(2016.3)

    , SDI 2015

    35% , 31%,

    18%, 17%

    -

    , ,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    - , 2015 4

    ,

    e-ID

    ,

  • - 251 -

    (2015~2025)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the China to 2025:Market Brief(2016.3)

    PC Baidu Qihoo 360 ,

    Qihoo 360 1

    - Baidu 1 Baidu

    - PC 3 Tencent PC ,

    , , QQ

    Qihoo 360 Tencent

    , 2013 6 Baidu

    - Baidu 2014 2

    ,

    - iiMedia Research 2016 4 Qihoo 360

    66.7% , Tencent 35.4%, Baidu 12.0%

    - , 2016 4 5 3,900

    6.1%

  • - 252 -

    m

    (www.chyxx.com) 2016

    5,000 , 1,900

    - 50% ,

    21%, 13%, / 8%, 5%

    2016

    : (chyxx.com)(2017.8)

    CCTV

    - AI,

    ,

    , IP, ,

    - 720p, 1080p , 2K, 4K

    , ,

    IP

    - , , ,

    , , , ,

  • - 253 -

    ,

    -

    ,

    , ,

    2010

    , 90%

    - 50% ,

    , , , ,

    , Apple

    - ,

    Qianzhan Research 2016 10

    25% CAGR 2021 51

    , 12.5

    2015 20%

    , 2015 8%

    -

    , ,

    - 2010 Dahua Technology

    , ,

  • - 254 -

    )

    m

    q

    - CCID Consulting 2015

    , Venustech 5.5%

    - UBS

    2014 600, 1

    20

    - , PC Qihoo360, King Soft, Tencent

    90%

    (2014 )

    5

    /FW Topsec(20%), H3C(15%), Huawei(14%), Venustech(9%), Cisco(8%)

    /UTM Venustech(20%), Hillstone(14%), Huawei(13%), Fortinet(9%), H3C(8%)

    /IDS Venustech(28%), NSfocus(22%), Neusoft(13%), LinkTrust(9%), Topsec(3%)

    /IPS NSfocus(23%), H3C(14%), Topsec(13%), Venustech(12%), Cisco(6%)

    Sangfor(42%), Netentsec(23%), NSfocus(8%), Cisco(7%), H3C(6%)

    VPN Sangfor(40%), ArrayNetwork(11%), H3C(10%), Juniper(5%), Cisco(7%)

    Symantec(26%), Trend Micro(12%), Rising(11%), Kaspersky(6.5%), Kingsoft(4.5%)

    JIT(24%), Koal(16%), IBM(11%), EMC(9%), Oracle(7%)

    NSfocus(24%), IBM(22%), Venustech(13%), HP(9%), Qualys(5%)

    : (2016.7)

  • - 255 -

    90% , 2014

    1~6 , , , , ,

    90%

    -

    ,

    ,

    M&A

    - 2014 2015 30 ( 5 )

    M&A , Venustech 2014 5

    Sursen, Unimas

    - M&A

    M&A

    /

    Venustech

    ()

    Sursen() 9180 ( 51%) 2014Unimas() 1 7,800 ( 51%) 2014

    Anfanggaoke() 2 2,200 2014

    NSFocus

    ()

    Kingsoft Security() 4450 2015

    Esafenet() 4 9,800 ( 100%) 2014DBsec() 970 ( 25%) 2014Deepin() 2,000 ( 10%) 2014

    Lagou() 441 2014EQmail() 990 ( 55%) 2014

    Westone

    ()

    30San() 1 5,300 ( 93.98%) 2014

    30Ruitong() 2 ( 94.41%) 2014

    30Javee() 1 2,800 ( 85.74%) 2014

    VRV() Huatech( ) 1 ( 100%) 2014

    Meiya Pico

    ()

    Tax Software() 6 2,00 ( 100%) 2015New Gateway() 2 6,000 ( 49%) 2015

    Videtek() 3,315 ( 51%) 2015

    : ()(2015.12)

  • - 256 -

    q

    CPS() Dahua 2016 2016 22,000 (31%)

    (23%) , 160

    - 60%

    ,

    -

    ,

    DVR ,

    ,

    2016 7,000

    50 55% , 50~100 30%,

    1,000 1%

    - 41%

    12%, 14%, / 12%,

    7%

    - Hikvision, Dahua, Uniview , 10

    1%, 56% 1,000

    - CCTV

    , Panasonic, Sony, () ,

    Honeywell, Bosch

  • - 257 -

    : CPS, Dahua(2017.1)

    , (TF Securities) 2015

    1 ( 1,500 ) 100,

    - Hikvision, Dahua

    - 15~20% ,

    , , , ,

    4~5

    m

    q

    Venustech()

    - /UTM,

    (IDS), , /UTM,

    (IDS/IPS) , (SOC) 1

    - UBS Venustech R&D

    2015 5.5% 2020 6.8%

  • - 258 -

    - , , , , , ,

    , 80%

    - 500 60%

    , ,

    90%, China Mobile, China Telecom, China Unicom 3

    VenusTtech (2015-2020)

    : UBS(2016.11)

    NSFocus()

    - , , , ,

    , Web

    - 22% 28%

    , 2014 Kingsoft Security, Deepin

    - IDC NSFocus

    , Frost & Sullivan 2010 IDS/IPS

    - NSFocus , ,

  • - 259 -

    Westone()

    - 2008 ,

    , ,

    , , ,

    - 2014 , , 3

    ,

    TopSec()

    - 1995 TopSec 1996

    2014 20% 1

    , 3% 5

    - , , , , , ,

    VPN,

    - TopSec

    q

    Hikvision()

    - 2016

    21.4%

    (CETC)

    - 2016 20,000 R&D 9,366 46% ,

    30.4%

    - IHS inc Hikvision 6 CCTV

    5 ,

    , HD CCTV , DVR/NVR

    1

    - (Back-end) (Front-end)

    (Solution) , HW SW

  • - 260 -

    50%

    - Hikvision , 2016

    , , ,

    25

    - ,

    CCD(Charge-coupled Device)

    (Machine Vision)

    Hikvision

    : Credit Suisse(2015.9)

    Dahua Technology()

    - 2001 2008 5 , A&S

    Magazine 2016 Hikvision, Honewel, Bosch

    4

    - , , . , , ,

    , , 6, ,

    ,

    - 2

    , , , , 35

  • - 261 -

    - , HW SW (R&D) 2011

    700 2017 6,000 , 2014 10%

    R&D

    - , , (VR),

    (AR) ,

    Dahua Technology

    : Credit Suisse(2015.9)

    Univew()

    - H3C 2011

    Univew IP

    , Hikvision, Dahua

    3

    - IP , NVR, /, IP SAN(Storage Area Network)

    - Univew R&D , 15% R&D

    , 2015 1916 R&D

    - 2013 , 2016 5

    Netposa()

    - 10 CCTV

  • - 262 -

    , 21%

    - , CCTV

    - , , , ,

    , , , , ,

    - , Hikvision Dahua

    ()

    - 2016 Netposa 2 2,680 45.7% 2011

    609%

    )

    , (2017.7)

    -

    - CCTV

    - 5 300

    , , ,

    2014 10 (2016.11)

    - PwC 12 2,600

    , 2014 969%

    -

    , PwC 440 34%

    -

    57% , 2016 7.6%

  • - 263 -

    , (2016.9)

    - 2020 500 1

    ( 182 )

    - 2015

    320 ,

    - 2018 ,

    123 CCTV (2016.05)

    - 2015 9 CCTV 1,2 Hikvision Dahua 3

    Uniview

    - Hikvision Dahua 2016 3

    - Hikvision 7~8 CCTV

    OEM B2B, B2C

    , Dahua

    CCTV

    - Univew 90%

    ,

    , (2016.05)

    - 2015

    2015

    12 6,916 1.26

    - , ,

    , (loophole)

    -

    , 2015

    ,

    - 2016

    ,

  • - 264 -

    '' (2016.04)

    -

    + 16 3

    - 1.49m, 78kg 18km ,

    1km 8

    - , , , ,

    , ,

    -

    ,

  • - 265 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (-State Council, 1994.02)

    (-State Council, 1997.12)

    (, 2000.12)

    (, 2003.08)

    (, 2007.03)

    (///, 2007.06)

    (, 2009.02)

    (, 2010.01)

    (, 2010.04)

    (,2015.07)

    () (,2016.11)

    :

    ()

    - 2015 7 1 12 15

    ,

    - 1

    - ,

    ,

    ,

    - ,

    -

  • - 266 -

    ,

    ,

    ()

    - 2016 11 () 2017 6 1

    - ( )

    , 7 68 , ,

    , , ,

    - ( )

    , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    1 , , , 2

    , , , ,

    3

    4

    5

    6 7

    :

    m

    2016-2020()

  • - 267 -

    - 2017 1

    (2016-2020)

    - , , , ,

    9

    -

    , ,

    ()

    -

    -

    ()

    - 2016 12 27

    -

    ,

    -

    9

    ()

    - 2016 7 2050

    3

    - 10

    , ,

    2050 ,

  • - 268 -

    -

    -

    ,

    5 ()

    - () () China Daily "

    "

    - 2016~2020 13 5 '(135)

    ' IT '

    - 2004 2015 5,000

    2,000 CCTV

    - 180 CCTV

    12.5 (2011~2015) () ,

    - , , ,

    , ,

    , , ,

  • - 269 -

    )

    ,

    ,

    , , ,

    , , , ,

    , ,

    , , ,

    :

    (National Development and Reform

    Commission), (Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, MIIT),

    ,

    -

    , ,

    -

  • - 270 -

    , ,

    -

    - ,

    ,

    -

    )

    (CCC)

    - (CCC) 2003 8

    , , , 19

    132

    -

    CCC CCC

    - DVR CCC DVR 2012 2

    CCC CCC

    (ISSCC)

    - (CNCA) 2010 5

    IT (ISCCC)

    - , , CCC

    - (CCC) , ,

    8 , ,

  • - 271 -

    , ( )

    ,

    ( ), ,

    , ,

    IPSec/SSL , , , ,

    IC (COS)

    IC(COS) COS

    , ,

    ,

    , ,

    , ,

    ,

    , , WEB

    , , ,

    ,

    KOTRA KBC

    (Personal Data Protection Guidelines for Public and

    Commercial Service Information Systems)

    - 2012 4, (MIIT)

    (Personal

    Data Protection Guidelines for Public and Commercial Service Information

    Systems)

    - (MIIT)

  • - 272 -

    SW (China Software Testing Centre, CSTC) 30

    , - , , , ,

    - 8 ,

    , , ,

    , ,

    -

    , ,

    -

    ,

    - SW , 70~80%

    ,

    1.

    2.

    3.

    ,

    ,

    4.

    5.

    3

    6.

    7.

    : cn-c114.net

  • - 273 -

    )

    , (2017.07)

    -

    ,

    ( )

    - ,

    , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    , (2017.06)

    - 2016 11 () (

    ) 2017 6 1

    - , 7

    29

    -

    -

    ,

    , (2017.05)

    -

    2017 6 1

    - 2

    16 ,

    - , , , , , ,

    ,

  • - 274 -

    ,

    -

    ,

    , ,

  • - 275 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    23

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.683 23

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 175

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 2.69 138 8.84 1

    (Access) 3.32 139 8.99 8

    (Use) 0.85 135 8.57 3

    (Skills) 4.29 122 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.683 23 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.464 107 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.8 91 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) ,

    86%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 24,404 1.9 28,035 56.1

    18,733 1.4 20,556 41.1

    1,127,809 86.9 61,295 122.7

    29.5% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 2,454.50

    17 () 1,266,884

  • - 276 -

    1)

    )

    ,

    - (Ministry of Home Affairs) (National Crime

    Bureau Records) , 2015 294

    3.4%

    - ,

    ,

    -

    CCTV GPS

    - 2016

    - 100 Tier 1 100

    Tier 2

    - , , , CCTV,

    KOTRA ,

    ,

    - , ,

    - , ,

  • - 277 -

    IT , ,

    -

    , 2025

    -

    , (CERT-In) , 2016

    12 1 2017 10 1

    - , , ,

    , , DDoS

    - , 2015

    30

    - (Islamic State, IS)

    - CIA Edwards Snowden WikiLeaks

    )

    ITU 2016 2,440

    1.9%

    - 2010 3,509 5

    6.2%

    - 2016 9.4% 1,873

    1.4% , 9%

  • - 278 -

    2016 7.9% 11 2,780

    - 2015 10 ,

    8.1%p 86.9%

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    -

    , 2008

    -

    ,

    - 2015 2019 1 1,950

    ,

    ,

    -

    - CCTV, GPS,

    GSM , , ,

    , , ,

    ,

  • - 279 -

    ,

    - 2015 , ID , /

    , , ,

    - , , IT

    m

    2016 111

    , 12

    - SDI 67), 2015

    102 2016 111

    - Gartner (Information security) 68)

    12% 2017 15 2018

    17

    - , (FICCI) , 2015

    61

    m

    Barnes & Co. Barnes Reports 2016 69) 54

    4,200 , 2018 63 5,100

    - 2014 49 5,400 6.4%

    67) SDI, "Homeland Security Expenditure in India to 2020: Market Review", 2015.8)

    68) Gartner, Gartner Says Information Security Spending In India Will Grow 12 Percent to Reach $1.5 Billion in 2017, 2017.8.29., , ,

    69)

  • - 280 -

    2014~2018 (: )

    : Barnes Reports (2017.1)

    SDI 2015 2 4,400

    2025 7.95% 5 2,500

    - 2015 9,700 2025 1 8,400

    6.64%

    - 2015 7,000 8.52%

    2025 1 5,800

    - 2015 5,000 2025 1

    600 , 7.79%

    - 2015 2,800 2025 7,700

    , 10.78%

  • - 281 -

    2016~2025

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the India to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    Ken Research ,

    2020 1,780 ( 2 7,735 )

    )

    m

    - IP CCTV , ,

    (, ), X ,

    - ,

    20~25%

    - KOTRA 70)

    CCTV(55%), (24%), (2%), (2%)

    2016 8 4,100 32.5%

    2020 24 71)

    - 68% IP

    70) KOTRA , ' '(2016.6.17)

    71) NCNOnline, Surveillance Market in India Increased Tremendously(2017.4.7.)

  • - 282 -

    IP

    - , , , , ,

    - , 87%

    13%

    , ,

    - , ,

    - CCTV ,

    ,

    - 20

    , (Jammu)

    10, 122.4

    -

    m

    2016 54 4,000 72)

    - 75~80%

    - Barnes Reports 2017 ,

    , 2017 59, 2018 64 7.8%, 8.2%

    m

    Gartner (/

    ) 2016 11 2,000 10 1,000

    72) Barnes Reports, 2017 World Industry & Markets Outlook (2017.01)

  • - 283 -

    10.6%

    - 2017 12 4,000

    - (/// ) 2015

    61% , 2020 66%

    - 2016 , , ID

    , , , ,

    //

    Gartner 2017

    21% 59 , 2020 17%

    90

    - , ID (IAM)

    - 2018 60%

    - SDI 2016 3 73) ,

    2015 40%, 2016 38% 2025 35%

    -

    , 2025

    - 11% ,

    2026 15%

    73) SDI, 'The Cyber Security Market in the India to 2025: Brief'(2016.3)

  • - 284 -

    2016~2025

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the India to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    2025 8.52% , 2015

    2025 13

    - SDI 5

    1 2,000 ,

    - ,

    , ,

    - (National Cyber Coordination Centre, NCCC)

    (CERT-In)

  • - 285 -

    2016~2025

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the India to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    2015

    11% 2025 15%

    2016~2025 (: %)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the India to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

  • - 286 -

    )

    m

    ,

    -

    (OEM)

    - KOTRA (organized)

    700 , (unorganized) 1,500

    - , ,

    - Honeywell Automation India Bosch Security India

    (OEM)

    -

    IoT BYOD APT(Advanced Persistent

    Threats)

    -

    - (MSS), (SVM)

    - (Nasscom) , 2025

    100

    m

    Zicom India

    - 1 3 1

  • - 287 -

    - CCTV , , , , ,

    ,

    - 2016 7,800 5

    Zoom Technologies India

    -

    ,

    - Kaspersky, NETASQ, egosecure ,

    - ,

    Honeywell Automation India

    - 2005 CCTV ,

    - , , CCTV

    , , ,

    Tyco Fire & Security India Private Limited

    - 2012 350

    , , , , , ,

    - , , CCTV

    Bosch Security India

    - , ,

    - , , ,

    ,

  • - 288 -

    Godrej Securities

    - Godrej Group ,

    - ,

    - 360 CCTV,

    - 2017 1 4,24 21.3%

    ,

    Aditya Infotech

    - 20 CCTV

    - ACTi, Avtech, CP Plus, Cynix, D-max, Yoko, Eyeview,

    Honeywell , Canon, Panasonic, Sony, Eureka Forbes, Godrej,

    () CCTV

    ECD Global

    - 2008 IT , , ,

    - , , , ,

    ,

    i3indya

    -

    ,

    - , (IIT)

    Capgemini

    - ,

  • - 289 -

    - , , ID

    , (CERT),

    ,

    )

    (Aadhaar)

    - 2009 Aadhaar (, ), 2017 3

    11

    - ,

    - Techsci , 31%

    2021 3

    1 Zicom India

    - Zicom 4G

    (electronic security-as-a-service,

    E-SaaS) 2020 5

    - 2012 (E-SaaS)

    Zicom , 2014

    Ziman'

    - 2016 12 CCTV Make Your

    City Safe(MYCS) ,

    Lockheed Martin

    (Data Security Council of India, DSCI)'

  • - 290 -

    -

    - , (Department of Electronics & Information Technology,

    DeitY) ' (Digital India)'

    - Lockheed Martin 2017 6 F-16

    10

    - 2016 10 , (ASSOCHAM)

    ,

    - 11 200 , CCTV ,

    , RFID, , ,

  • - 291 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Information Technology Act)

    - (Ministry of Communications and Information Technology,

    MCIT) 2011 4 (Information Technology Act 2011)

    -

    , ((IS / ISO / IEC 27001)

    - ,

    -

    - 1

    (National Security Act)

    - 1980 '(National Security Act of 1980)'

    - (Jammu) (Kashmir)

    m

    2013(National Cyber Security Policy 2013)

    - 2013 7 ' 2013(National Cyber Security

    Policy 2013)' ,

  • - 292 -

    - (Department of Electronics & Information Technology, DeitY)

    (Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, MCIT)

    - , , ,

    ,

    - ICT

    , 24

    (Digital India)

    - (Narendra Modi) 2015 (IT)

    (Digital India)

    - ,

    - (Digital Infrastructure)

    (Governance & Services on Demand)

    (Digital Empowerment of Citizens) 3 74)

    - 2019 25 ,

    , ,

    , (IoT)

    - 180 ,

    661

    UID (Aadhaar)

    - (The Unique Identification Authority of India, UIDAI)

    74) , , , , . , , , , . , ,

  • - 293 -

    Aadhaar 12

    - 2016 3 UIDAI

    2016 3 26 (Aadhaar Act of 2016)

    - ,

    Aadhaar

    (Smart City)

    - 2015~2016 (Smart City) 9

    5,000 2022 100

    - 2016 1 26 (Ministry of Urban Development) 1

    20 ,

    - ICT

    ,

    - , , , (IFC)

    , 3 180 ,

    35

    - 2017 3 IT Ravi Shankar Prasad

    ,

    (National Knowledge Network) ,

    - 2015

  • - 294 -

    )

    (Indian Computer Emergency Response Team, CERT-In)

    - (Information Technology Act) IT

    - CERT-In

    4 30

    - , , ,

    , , , , ,

    (National Cyber Coordination Center, NCCC)

    - (National Cyber Coordination Centre, NCCC)

    - 2014 9 2015 2027

    1 5,400

    - NCCC

    ,

    - ,

    (National Disaster Management Authority, NDMA)

    - (Ministry of Home Affairs)

    - (Disaster Management Act) NDMA

    (National Critical Informational Infrastructure Protection Centre, NCIIPC)

    - 2014 NCIIPC

  • - 295 -

    , , ,

    -

    (CMS)

    - (National Telecom Network Security Coordination Board,

    NTNSCB)

    (Ministry of Electronics & Information Technology)

    - e-

    , (R&D) ,

    - ,

    ICT ,

    (Department of Telecommunication, DoT)

    -

    - ,

    ,

    )

    -

    ISO 27001 (Network Security Standard ISO 27001)

    -

    (Crisis Management Plan)

  • - 296 -

    )

    (2017.8)

    - Arun Jaitley 2017 6

    -

    (2017.8)

    -

    5-7 IT 1

    (2017.6)

    -

    ,

    (Indian Computer Emergency Response Team, CERT-In)

    Cyber

    Swachhta Kendra (2017.2)

    -

    ,

    - Digital India ,

    MoU (2017.1)

    - (Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology)

    (Department of Homeland Security)

    MoU

  • - 297 -

    - 2011 MoU , MoU

    (panic button) GPS

    (2016~2017)

    - (Ministry of Women&Child) (Department of

    Telecommunications)

    - 2017 1 ,

    2018 GPS

  • - 298 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.424 70

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 60%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 3.86 115 8.84 1

    (Access) 4.71 107 8.99 8

    (Use) 2.19 120 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.48 109 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.424 70 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.448 116 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.0 73 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    10,373 4.0 28,036 56.1

    4,898 1.9 20,556 41.1

    385,573 149.1 61,296 122.7

    25.4% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 1,020.51

    '17 () 261,989

  • - 299 -

    1)

    )

    m

    ITU 2017 4 (GCI) 2017

    0.424 167 70 ,

    16

    - , 5

    ,

    Kaspersky Lab 2016 Kaspersky Cybersecurity Index ,

    58-36-58 (74-39-29)

    - ,

    58%

    36% 58%

    - Avast ,

    35%,

    66.3%

    Trend Micro ,

    -

    - 2016 1 2017 6 33.77%

    - , 7.44%( 2.49%)

    , 3

  • - 300 -

    - , 2017

    2,000

    m

    , UL UL Safety Index(2017

    ) 63.63 187 81

    - (Safety Framework)

    (safety Outcomes) (Institutions &

    Resources)

    - (OSAC)

    ,

    - , 2016 61 59 , 1,596

    , 26 , 637 , 2,941

    - Jemaah Islamiyah ISIS

    CCTV

    - 2015 12 Tito Karnavian CCTV

    , CCTV

    (NTMC) , CCTV

    - Tito 2016 6,000 CCTV

    )

    We are Social Digital in 2017: Southeast Asia

    2017 1 2 6,200

    1 3,270 , 51%

  • - 301 -

    - Mckinsey 2015 2020 5

    - 1 2,330

    47% , (7%)

    (70%)

    - 2015

    LTE

    - Akamai 2017 1 (Q1 2017

    State of the Internet Connectivity Report) (IPv4)

    7.2 Mbps 77 ,

    12.8Mbps

    - 77% 1

    12% 1 7% 1 3%

    - PC 8.44,

    3.55

    : We are Social(2017.1)

    (SIM ) 3 7,140 ,

    - 91% ,

    47%

  • - 302 -

    - 2014 , 2015 3,300

    , 2019

    9,200

    - yStats 2016

    42.8% 34 , (52.5%) (47.5%)

    , Mckinsey 2016 60

    , 78%

    - yStats 2015 2025 39%

    , Macquarie Research 2020

    650

    - (APJII)

    - Nielsen 2016

    42% ,

    38%

    - 2017 8 Tokopedia IT SoftBank

    Alibaba 11

    : United Nations

  • - 303 -

    Telkomsel, Indosat, XL Axiata 3 ,

    3 80%

    - 2016 Telkomsel 45.2% 1 , Indosat(22.3%)

    XL Axiata(12.1%)

    - Telkomsel

    Indosat

    , ICT 2014~2019

    (Indonesia Broadband Plan, IBP)

    - IBP 232 , 2017

    150

    - IBP (Palapa Ring)

    , 2019 35,000km

    - 400 (regency) , 2018

    7Mbps 20Mbps

    - 2020 5G

    , , IoT, ,

  • - 304 -

    2)

    )

    m

    IT

    - IDI 2017 ICT 254 , 2016 4

    GDP 4.94% , 2020 295

    - , ,

    - SW ,

    2017-2019 (Roadmap for the National Electronic

    Commerce System for 2017-2019) (2017 74) 2017 8

    -

    ,

    -

    15 14 ,

    - IT TechCrunch

    50% , 2020 1,300 ( 143 5,200 )

    , ,

  • - 305 -

    , , , ,

    (National Payment Gateway)

    , ,

    ICT

    2018

    ,

    - , , ,

    , ,

    - ,

    - Asmag

    , IKEA, AEON, Lulu

    CCTV

  • - 306 -

    m

    IDC 2014 4 1,790 ,

    3 , 7

    1,770

    - ,

    - IDC Indonesia 2014 IT 350

    5 IT

    IT

    - 57% IT , IT 12% IT

    , 72%

    IT

    - , MarketLine 2016

    7,990 ,

    (9 3,610 ) 8.5%

    Barnes Reports 2015

    12 7,000 , 12 10%

    - 22,105 111,008

    - 7 4,300 5,200

    2,900 2,600

    - 2017 36 2,400

    , 2018 7.5% 38 9,600

    - 39,066

    664,501

    Frost & Sullivan /

    2014 7,600 ( 860 ) , 2020

  • - 307 -

    31% 2 9,400 ( 3,330 )

    - 2015 1,400 , 2020

    27% 6,000

    - 2015 1~3 4,000 ,

    30% ,

    (: , %)

    : Frost & Sullivan, Outlook Briefing(2016): Cyber Security(2016)

    (: )

    : Frost & Sullivan, Outlook Briefing(2016): Cyber Security(2016)

  • - 308 -

    6Wresearch

    , IT

    - 6Wresearch 2022 2 314

    - 2016 1

    , 6,000 CCTV

    - ,

    - 2018 MRT(Mass Rapid Transit) , ,

    , , ,

    SDI 2016 (Homeland Security

    spending) 11 5,551 , 2025 4.49%

    17 1,586

    (2016-2025)

    : SDI(2016)

  • - 309 -

    )

    m

    ,

    , ,

    - 2016 , ,

    2 9,400

    - , 3 9,397

    4 6,754

    , , , ,

    , , ,

    - CCTV, ,

    , , ,

    - ,

    - , , , , X-

    ,

    14

    , ,

    -

    - PT

  • - 310 -

    ,

    - 6Wresearch IP

    , 2022

    - , 2015

    m

    Kable 2016 245

    , 2019 6%

    - 2016 139 2019 3.58%

    (: )

    2016 2017 2018 2019 CAGR

    VPN 1.146 1.200 1.246 1.283 3.84%

    /SSL 0.494 0.528 0.562 0.595 6.40%

    0.431 0.472 0.516 0.560 9.17%

    0.280 0.308 0.336 0.362 8.99%

    0.108 0.116 0.122 0.128 5.72%

    2.458 2.623 2.783 2.928 6.00%

    : Kable(2016)

  • - 311 -

    (: )

    2016 2017 2018 2019 CAGR 0.2220 0.2335 0.2437 0.2525 4.38% 0.1452 0.1557 0.1663 0.1766 6.75%/VPN 0.1356 0.1417 0.1469 0.1510 3.64% 0.1279 0.1350 0.1416 0.1475 4.88% 0.1202 0.1273 0.1340 0.1401 5.22% 0.0969 0.1016 0.1057 0.1091 4.05% 0.0949 0.0998 0.1044 0.1083 4.52% 0.0928 0.0984 0.1037 0.1086 5.36% 0.0550 0.0572 0.0589 0.0602 3.04% 0.0491 0.0473 0.0447 0.0415 -5.44%SWG 0.0458 0.0445 0.0425 0.0398 -4.60% 0.0430 0.0437 0.0439 0.0440 0.76% 0.0374 0.0380 0.0383 0.0385 0.98% 0.0357 0.0363 0.0366 0.0368 1.00% 0.0356 0.0365 0.0371 0.0373 1.59% 0.0241 0.0250 0.0258 0.0263 2.99% 0.0172 0.0167 0.0159 0.0148 -4.99%PKI 0.0123 0.0123 0.0125 0.0128 1.42%

    1.3907 1.4505 1.5026 1.5456 3.58%

    : Kable(2016)

    ,

    ,

    , , ,

    -

    ,

    -

    ,

    4

    ,

    - SW B2B

  • - 312 -

    (SI)

    - , 2015

    (The Software Alliance, BSA)

    84% ,

    12

    - 2010

    ,

    ,

    )

    m

    q

    IT IT ,

    - IT EMC, HP, Cisco, VMware, Redhat, Radware,

    Sophos, WildPackets, RUCKUS

    - Check Point, Trend Micro, Fortinet, ARUBA Networks,

    McAfee, HP Security

    -

    ,

    - ,

    , ,

    - ,

    ,

  • - 313 -

    q

    ,

    AvTech, Axis Communications, Bosch Security Systems, Dahua,

    Hikvision, Hanwha( Samsung) Techwin, Honeywell, Mobotix, Panasonic, Pelco by

    Schneider, VIvotek

    - Survey Indonesia 2015 CCTV Sony

    55.2% , (7.7%), Panasonic(5.8%), Bosch(5.7%), LG(4.8%),

    AVtech(3.2%)

    Global Safety and Security Resource Guide

    ,

    , , ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    - ,

    , ,

    - ,

    ,

    m

    q

    Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro 10%

  • - 314 -

    - 2011

    ,

    - Trend Micro 2013 2 Telkom

    Fortinet

    - Fortinet Unified Threat Management(UMT) 2011 UTM

    19.6%

    - Fortinet

    , 8

    ,

    Q2 Technologies

    - IT ICE ACTIMIZE, Paladion, MarkAny, RSA

    Security, IBM, ACTIVE Identity

    PT. Piranti Nusantara Teknologi(PIRANUSA)

    - IT , ZWCAD

    ZWSOFT, Microsoft Adobe

    Kaspersky Lab, Symantec

    Astra Graphia Information technology (AGIT)

    - AGIT TELKOM Microsoft, Ericsson, Cisco

    , IT

    Insig2

    - Insig2 2017 10

    (UGM)

    , /

  • - 315 -

    q

    Bosch Security Systems

    - , Bosch 1919

    , 2008 PT Robert Bosch

    - Bosch (Surabaya), (Medan), (Bali)

    (Cikarang), (Bekasi) ,

    200

    - Bosch Security Systems , ,

    , ,

    PT. Handal Solusitama (Handal Security)

    - PT. Handal Solusitama (Handal Security) ,

    CCTV, EAS ,

    - Handal Security Checkpoint Systems

    ADV

    - ADV CCTV

    - , , () CCTV

    Certis

    - Certis Jakarta, Bandung, Batam, Bogor, Denpasar, Lampung, Makassar,

    Medan, Semarang and Surabaya ,

    )

    2,500 (2016.02)

    - Norton Cybersecurity Insights 2015

  • - 316 -

    2,550

    - 21%

    , 57% SNS

    - SNS ,

    45%

    -

    , 81% ,

    20%

    - 1,946

    (147 )

    - Norton Cybersecurity Insights 2015 2 2016 1

    18 1,074

    (2017)

    - ID-SIRTII Indonesia Cyber Security Report 2017 2016 1 3,567

    - 2015 8,969 50% , DNS

    Port53

    -

    - , 2016 6, 2015

    IT 33% , 54.5%

    2(2016.6)

    - 2016(Malware Infection Index 2016)

    -

    - 2 , 2015 4

    40% (

    20.8%)

  • - 317 -

    - Gamarue, Trojans Skeeyah, Peals ,

    Gamarue 2015 4 20%

    - Cisco , 20%

    ,

    (2017.4)

    10 (2017.5)

    - DDoS ,

    - 1

    - , ,

    - 200

  • - 318 -

    3)

    )

    m

    Mandate Act 36 of 1999 Government Regulation no.

    52 of 2000 , 2008

    (Law No. 11 2008)

    -

    , , , , ,

    ,

    -

    (Law No. 11 of 2008) (2016.11)

    - Law No. 19 of 2016 (Penyelenggara Sistem Elektronik)

    (state administrator)

    ,

    -

    6 10

    4 7 5

    12

    20 4 7 5

    -

    -

    - , 2016 11 25 ,

  • - 319 -

    -

    (Ministerial Regulation No. 4 of 2016)

    -

    (strategic electronic system)

    (high electronic system)

    (low electronic system)

    -

    (Certificate of Management System of Information Protection)

    Mandate Act 36 of 1999 Article 39.

    Government Regulation no. 52 of2000 chapter 82.

    , ,

    Law No. 11 of 2008 , ,

    Ministerial Regulation No. 20 of 2016

    : ID-SIRTII

    2016 11 (KOMINFO)

    (Ministerial Regulation No. 20 of 2016)

    - 2016 12 1 (Law No. 11

    2008) / (Government

    Regulation no. 82 of 2012)

    -

    ,

  • - 320 -

    - 2016 12 1 ,

    2

    , //

    ,

    ,

    ( )

    5( /

    )

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    , , ,

  • - 321 -

    m

    2007

    Regulation No. 26/PER/M.KOMINFO/5/2007'

    , ID-SIRTII/CC'

    -

    ,

    - ,

    IT , (CIP) , ,

    -

    , ,

    Born to Protect (2017.8)

    - Born to Protect

    , PTXynexis

    - , , , ,

    10 1

    - 100 , 2

    , /

    (KOMINFO) (2015-2019)

    (Jokowi) 9 (Nawacita)

  • - 322 -

    [] 9

  • - 323 -

    )

    (BSSN: Badan Siber dan Sandi Negara)

    - (Presidential Regulation No. 53 of 2017) (2017.5)

    ,

    - (LSN) (KOMINFO)

    (Id-SITII/CC) , , ,

    BSSN

    - (Kemenko Polhukam) ,

    - , , ,

    - ,

    ,

    - ,

    (KOMINFO)

    - ,

    - Gov-CSIRT ,

    - Id-SIRTII/CC ,

    - KOICA PKI ,

    - (CIIP) ,

    ,

    (Kemenko Polhukam)

    -

  • - 324 -

    , Joko Widodo

    (DCN) (14)

    DK2ICN(Desk Ketahanan dan Keamanan Informasi Cyber Nasional)

    DCN(Desk Cyberspace Nasional) (16.6)

    - ,

    , , , /

    (DCN)

    -

    - ( )

    - 75)

    16

    ,

    - (CAMP: Cybersecurity Alliance for

    Mutual Progress)

    Id-SIRTII/CC

    - 2007 5 4

    ID-SIRTII' , 2007

    Regulation No.

    26/PER/M.KOMINFO/5/2007'

    - Regulation No. 26/PER/M.KOMINFO/5/2007' 1)

    ID-SIRTII' , 2)

    , 3)

    , 4) Clock

    Synchronization

    - Id-SIRTII/CC ISP (NAP) 35

    24 (//) ,

    75) (Badang Cyber Nasional, BCN)

  • - 325 -

    50~70%

    - (National CSIRT) ISP CERT ,

    -

    - (APCERT), CERT(OIC-CERT)

    (CAMP)

    - (NEC) SOC MoU (15.9),

    ID-CERT(INDONESIA COMPUTER EMERGENCY RESPONSE TEAM)

    - 1998 ID-CERT

    - ID-CERT (2012.12.6.)

    (2013.1.10.),

    - , ,

    CSIRT

    National Id-SIRTII/CC (KOMINFO )

    Government

    : Gov-CSIRT (KOMINFO )

    : (Jawa), (Jatim), (Yogya) CSIRT

    () : Mil-CSIRT

    Community ACAD-CSIRT : 40 CSIRT

    ID-CERT : CERT

    Private (ISP, , )

    : KISA

    CISSReC (Communication & Information System Security Research Center)

    -

    2015

  • - 326 -

    - ICT ,

    ,

    /

    -

    ( )

    -

    )

    ISO 27001:2013 ,

    SNI ISO/IEC 27001:2009

    - (BSN) ISO 27001 SNI ISO/IEC 27001

    , ,

    ISO/IEC 15408

    - , IT ISO/IEC 15408-1/2/3:2014

    CC

    - CC

    - CC(Common Criteria) 20

    , EAL 5

    - CC

  • - 327 -

    )

    (2017.2)

    - ,

    - , 40 100

    , (2017)

    - 35

    47 (CAMP: Cybersecurity

    Alliance for Mutual Progress) (POLHUKAM)

    Id-SIRTTI/CC (2016.7)

    - (KISA) (DCN) -

    ,

    (2016.12)

    - (KISA)

    (2017.6)

    - - (2017.2)

    , 5

    ,

    (2017.5)

    - , ,

    (2017.7)

    -

    (2017.8)

    - ,

    (2017.8)

  • - 328 -

    (CIIP)

    (2017.8)

    - , , , , /, , ICT, 8

    - , , ,

    , 5

    (SATSIBER)

    - (TNI) (No. 62 of 2016)

    , (SATSIBER) ,

    2017 4 (Letter Decree, No.Kep/295//2017) ,

    SATSIBER ()

    - SATSIBER ,

    / ,

    (PT. PINDAD)

    - PT. PINDAD /

    , / ICT PT. Multimatics 3

    - ,

    , , / / ,

    TUV SUD CISSP

    -

    , ,

    , 2018 /

  • - 329 -

    - (KOMINFO)

    (No. 14 of 2017)

    2017 10 31 (SIM)

    , 1 (SIM) 3

    - , 2018 2 (NIK)

    ,

    , ,

    - (KOMINFO) , , , //

    , ,

    - (2017.9), 1,940 ( 161

    ) /

    ISP

    - ,

  • - 330 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 5 ,

    ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.245 101

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 4.28 105 8.84 1

    (Access) 4.60 110 8.99 8

    (Use) 3.51 92 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.25 114 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.245 101 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.514 89 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.9 79 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    5,598 5.9 28,036 56.1

    9,335 9.9 20,556 41.1

    120,600 128.0 61,296 122.7

    46.5% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 215.80

    '17 () 95,261

  • - 331 -

    1)

    )

    , , ,

    Kaspersky Lab, Symantec 10

    - Microsoft 2016 12 Security Intelligence Report(SIR), Volume 21

    5 , (45%) (21%)

    - (VNCERT) 2016

    4 13 4,375 ,

    (Deface) 46,664 77,654

    - 2015 12

    , 2016 7

    - 2012 25

    , Banknet 15

    -

    ,

    IT

    - , , SNS IT

    , /

    ,

  • - 332 -

    )

    We are Social 2017 1 9,500

    5,050 ,

    40% 4,719

    - 1 26.2

    2 , 15~24 42%, 25~34

    32%, 35~44 14%, 45~54 8%

    - , 2016 1 6 1

    5.0Mbps , Thanh Nien News

    - 21,870kbps,

    2,380kbps , 160kbps (Ericsson

    Mobility Report)

    : We are Social(2017.1)

    2008 , VNPT, Viettel, FTP Telecom 90%

    , 10% HTC, EVN, SCTV

  • - 333 -

    - Research and Markets 2016

    69 , 78.5%

    2015 7 24 Decision No.1168/QD-TTg , 2020

    , 70%

    - 2 FTTH 300~400%

    ADSL ,

    (Authority of Telecommunications) 2016 4 , 460

    FTTH , ADSL 1.6

    - FTTH Viettel ,

    2016 10 Viettel FTTH 200

    , Viettel Vinaphone, MobiFone, Gmobile 4

    4G , Viettel 2017 4 4G

    - MobiFone 2017 7 4G 4G

    2)

    )

    m

    IT (VINASA) (ICT)

    2010 20 2015 30 ,

    10 16

    -

    10%

  • - 334 -

    , 20

    - 1996 (Foreign Investment Law)

    (Ministry of Planning & Investment) (Foreign Investment

    Agency) 9,500 (980 )

    - ,

    - 30~35% , 2006 WTO

    ,

    BKAV, CMC

    - 50%

    m

    (MIC) Vietnam Information and Communication

    Technology White Book 2014 2012

    2,850 , 2013 3,364

    - 15% 2016 6,750

    , 72.5%

    10%

    - 2016 (Secutech VIetnam) 2016

    15% ,

  • - 335 -

    - SI Techpro ,

    6Wresearch 2016~2022

    12.4%

    - ,

    ATIGA(ASEAN Trade in Goods Agreement)

    ,

    - 6Wresearch

    , IP

    , HD ,

    - 2016~2022 IP ,

    , 6

    -

    )

    m

    ,

    - Barnes Report 2015 1 9,600

    , / 1 1,500 ,

    5,700 , 800 , 500

  • - 336 -

    , ,

    / ,

    , , , CO2

    m

    IDC 2014 1,660

    11.9% ,

    2015 10%

    - IDC

    , 2014

    12.4%

    - 2014 2.3% 1.2% ,

    / 15.4%

    - 2013

    2%

    - 2014 74% ,

    2014

    : IDC, Vietnam News, 'Businesses spend more on data security'(2015.6.13)

  • - 337 -

    (Secure

    Content and Threat Management Solutions, SCTM)

    - (IAM, Identity Access Management),

    (SVM, Security and Vulnerability Management)

    26

    SCTM

    -

    -

    - , ,

    ,

    )

    m

    q

    Symantec, IBM, McAfee, Cisco 4

    10%

    -

    ,

    Norton Antivirus(Symantec),

    Kaspersky, McAfee, Trend Micro, Bit Defender, Avira

    BKAV, CMC

  • - 338 -

    - 2009~2010

    ,

    10

    - CMC BKAV

    ,

    - 2013 7 EMC IT

    - Symantec ,

    2013 600

    Kaspersky(47.6%) , BKAV(32.%), Symantec(14.7%), McAfee(13.3%)

    - CMC BKAV 2013 1

    50%

    - 2010

    ,

  • - 339 -

    : MIC, 'Vietnam Information and Communication Technology White Book 2014'

    Cisco 34.1% ,

    Fortinet(10.0%) Juniper(8.4%), Check Point(8.3%)

    : MIC, 'Vietnam Information and Communication Technology White Book 2014'

    IDS/IPS Cisco 20.9% ,

    Check Point(6.8%) Juniper(4.4%) , IDS/IPS

    37.9%

  • - 340 -

    IDS/IPS

    : MIC, 'Vietnam Information and Communication Technology White Book 2014'

    10

    - Kaspersky, Trend Micro, Symantec, Bitdefender

    BKAV, CMC

    q

    1,000 ,

    1,000~2,000, 700~800

    - ,

    - , Vantech, VDTECH, Questek,

    Seavision, Escort ,

    CCTV

    / ,

    (20~25%), (10% )

    - Avigilon Corporation, Axis Communications,

    Bosch Security Systems, Hikvision, Hanwha( Samsung) Techwin, Panasonic, Sony,

    Pelco by Schneider

  • - 341 -

    - CCTV 300 IP

    CCTV

    / 95%

    , , , ,

    -

    - IP CCTV , , ,

    ,

    m

    q

    BKAV

    - BKAV

    5 ,

    1,000

    - BKAV 1) Tran Anh

    , 2) Pico Nguyen Kim

    , BKAV Gia Long An Phat

    - BKAV

    , 80%

    - BKAV 26 ,

    Bphone

    CMC

    - IT CMC SI, CMC Software, CMC Telecom,

    CMS, CMC Infosec

    - 2006 6 CMC Infosec R&D

  • - 342 -

    ,

    - CMC Mobile Security, CMC Internet Security, CMC Endpoint

    Security, CMC Antivirus ,

    - HP, Honda, Dell, Cisco, Emerson, Acer, APC

    Symantec

    - ,

    2008 Security Management

    - Thakral One, FPT, Ingram Micro Symantec

    Kaspersky Lab

    - ,

    , 2013 4 Kaspersky Lab Nam

    Truong Son Group (Kaspersky Endpoint Security for Business)

    - IT , , , ,

    , ,

    IBM

    - , ,

    - (Vietnam Post and Telecommunication Corporation, VNPT)

    VDC(Viet Nam Datacommunication Company) IBM

    SmartCloud Managed Backup (V-Backup)

    - /

    , V-Backup

    - FPT

  • - 343 -

    q

    AVer

    - 2008 100

    - ABM Distribution Vietnam

    - Maritime Bank, SeABank ATM

    - IP DVR AVer hybrid

    DVR(HD NVR)

    AVer HD NVR

    : AVer

    ACTi

    - IP

    , Chinfon Cement Corporation 25

    D1(720x576) MPEG-4 IP

    - LOIKHA

  • - 344 -

    Honeywell

    - , 2005

    - (PetroVetnam), (Vietnam Airlines), ,

    Honeywell , CCTV , ,

    - 2010 Honeywell 3,000

    )

    , (2017. 07)

    - 5,300 BullGuard

    - PC , , , ,

    , , ,

    ,

    - BullGuard Bao Tin Technology

    1,000 1+1 6

    VNPT, (2017. 04)

    - VNPT

    Novicom MOU

    - MOU (Truong Minh Tuan) ICT

    , MOU

    ALSOK, (2016. 08)

    - ALSOK 2016 9 Hai Phong Royal

    Security , 49% 957

    - Hai Phong Royal Security 4 ,

  • - 345 -

    1,000

    - ALSOK 2009

    ,

    - IT

    - 1 Secom

    (2016.08)

    - 2016 7 29

    - 21

    ,

    41

    - '1937CN'

    - ,

  • - 346 -

    3)

    )

    m

    - 2015 11 19

    , 2016 7 1

    - 8 54 , ,

    , ,

    , ,

    - ,

    ,

    ,

    , ,

    - 2 31

    m

    2010

    - 2010~2015

    , ,

    (Vietnam E-commerce

    Association) (Ministry of Industry and Trade)

    'TrustVn'

  • - 347 -

    - TrustVn APEC

    , ,

    - (Government Information Security Commission, GISC)

    2012 6 2015 15

    - (GISC) 2,500~3,000 (1,200~1,440 )

    2013 8 (National Centre for Network

    Security Technology) 4,200

    - (Ministry of Public Security), (Government

    Secrecy Committee), (Ministry of Industry and Trade)

    )

    (Ministry of Public Security)

    - (People's Public Security Forces)

    - (People's Security Force) (People's Police

    Force)

    - , ,

    - ,

    ,

    (Vietnam Computer Emergency Response Team, VNCERT)

    - 339

    - 2005 12 20, (Ministry of Information and Communication)

    - , ,

  • - 348 -

    - ,

    , (CERT)

    - VNCERT

    50% , Symantc,

    Kaspersky, McAfee

    (Vietnam Information Security Association, VNISA)

    - VNISA 2011 11 17,

    - , , ,

    , , ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    ,

    (Government Information Security Commission, GISC)

    - (Ministry of National Defence)

    ,

    - (Government Information Security Commission, GISC)

    2012 6 2015 15 ,

    (Department of Network Security)

    - 2014 9 ,

  • - 349 -

    )

    IDC

    - , 10

    - 1% ISO27001

    , ,

    - ,

    ISO

    - , ISO 27001

    ISO/IEC 27001:2005

    - 2013 2, ISO 27001

    CMMI(Capability Maturity Model Integration)

    1

    - ISO 27001 2

    - 2014 CMMI/ ISO 27001

    18 , ISO 27001 40

    , SGS 1989

    , ISO 20000

    - ISO 20000(IT ), ISO 22301( ), ISO

    27001:2005( ), ISO 28000( ), ISO

    31000(), ISO 50001( ), ISO 9001( )

  • - 350 -

    SGS Vietnam

    SGS Vietnam Ltd.

    SGS Building 119-121 Vo Van Tan, District 3 Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

    Tel: 848 3935 1920Fax: 848 3935 1921

    http://www.sgs.vn/

    )

    , (2017.06)

    - 2017 6 6 6 8 8 8

    -

    , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    , ,

    ,

    , (2017.03)

    - (Nguyen Xuan Phuc)

    - , ,

    ,

    -

    ,

  • - 351 -

    , (2016.08)

    - (MIC) Truong Minh Tuan

    - 8 15 Verint Systems VNPT,

    Mobifone, VTC

    - Tuan Verint Systems

    PTIT(Post and Telecommunications Institute of Technology)

    - 7

    , 7 29

    41

    2016 21.6% (2016.08)

    - 2016 21.6%

    - , To

    Lam

    - IT

  • - 352 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 5

    , , ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.283 92

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 3.12 127 8.84 1

    (Access) 4.21 122 8.99 8

    (Use) 2.09 121 8.57 3

    (Skills) 3.00 149 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.283 92 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.259 158 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.4 109 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    256 1.6 28,036 56.1

    97 0.6 20,556 41.1

    19,916 124.9 61,296 122.7

    25.6% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 20.953

    '17 () 15,957

  • - 353 -

    1)

    )

    ITU 2017 7 Global Cybersecurity Index(GCI) 2017

    0.283

    ,

    - Kaspersky Security Bulletin 2015

    20 15 , Kaspersky Lab

    61.66%

    - 2013 Microsoft 96% PC

    , WTO

    2021 8

    - 2014 10 Microsoft, FBI

    ,

    - Microsoft

    ,

    ,

    - (OSAC) 2016

    ,

    , ATM (

    )

    - 2015~2016 ,

  • - 354 -

    )

    , IT BuddeComm

    2014 0.4% 2016 0.6%

    - 2014 8 KOICA, , LG CNS

    ICT Masterplan , 2020

    100%

    70% 30%

    - BuddeComm 2021 2.2% 2.7%

    - , Khmer Times 2015 8

    29 ,

    , 50%,

    33%, 10%

    , (The Asia Foundation) Mobile Phones and Internet in

    Cambodia 2016 ,

    96%

    - 48% ,

    (48%)

    - SNS

    , 3%

    , 80%

  • - 355 -

    2013~2016

    : The Asia Foundation, 'Mobile Phones and Internet Use in Cambodia 2016'(2016.12)

    37% ,

    15 25 60%

    - , 74%

    , (33.2%), (, )

    (30.2%)

    - 33% ,

    2015 15%

    2013~2016

    : The Asia Foundation, 'Mobile Phones and Internet in Cambodia 2016'(2016.12)

  • - 356 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    -

    , 2016 5 Ou

    Phanarith ICT

    - Phanarith

    , ICT

    - ASEAN

    ,

    2016 IDC 5

    - 500 IT IT

    - 2015 IT 5.8% 2,892

    ,

    , Robert Bosch SEA

    10% 400 ,

  • - 357 -

    - , 2015

    , , 915 ,

    8 800

    -

    - ,

    2016 500 , 2014 7

    Two Kingdoms, One Destination 2020

    750

    )

    m

    /

    , ,

    - / 1 SI

    First Cambodia , SAP, Microsoft

    - 2, 3

    ,

    m

    CCTV, ,

    -

  • - 358 -

    ,

    - NKDesign Cambodia Sovan Hok

    ,

    )

    m

    q

    ,

    SI

    - , IT

    q

    KOTRA , 2014 40,

    CCTV 30

    - 2011~2013

    CCTV , ,

    ,

    - ,

    CCTV 15~50

  • - 359 -

    m

    q

    CambodiaSoft

    - CambodiaSoft 2005 IT , , ,

    , ,

    - , ,

    First Cambodia

    - First Cambodia , ,

    ,

    - Cisco, Temenos, Thales, IBM, HP, SAP, Oracle, Checkpoint

    , Thales

    Checkpoint

    Trust Global Service

    - (SMB) SI , IT

    - , ,

    , , , Kaspersky

    q

    GES Cambodian

    - GES Cambodian 2010 IT ,

    IT

    - CCTV , , ,

    , , , , , , ,

    - GES Cambodian BOSCH, Dahua, Samsung

  • - 360 -

    , , CCTV, ,

    BOSCH

    PROTEK Cambodia Security Company

    - PROTEK 1996 6 , , ,

    , 4 2,000

    - , , ,

    , , , , ,

    - CCTV, , / ,

    CY Tech

    - 2009 CCTV , ,

    , GSM

    - CY Tech CCTV , Safer

    )

    , CCTV (2017.07)

    - (Pub Street)

    CCTV

    - ,

    ,

    - 20 ,

    30 ,

    5,000~7,000

    IT Lantium, (2016.09)

    - IT Lantium KH Niron

    - Lantium Jeff Middleton CEO

    ,

  • - 361 -

    - Middelton

    ,

    500

    3)

    )

    m

    , 2014 4

    2 (cybercrime law)

    ,

    2017 7

    - ,

    - 28

    - 2014 12

    - 2017 7 ICT (Tan Sopheak)

    -

    m

    (National Strategic Development Plan, NSDP) 2014~2018

  • - 362 -

    - 2014 9 ( NSDP) 2014~2018

    , NSDP 2009~2013

    3

    - 2004

    , (MDGs) ,

    - NISP ICT

    ICT

    ,

    ICT

    , ,

    ICTopia Cambodia 2014~2020

    - ICTopia Cambodia KOICA ICT

    , ,

    (Empowering People) (Ensuring Connectivity) (Enhancing

    Capabilities) e- (Enriching e-Service) 4

    - ICT HRD ,

    , ICT , ICT

    - , ,

    , TV , ,

    - ICT , ICT

    , , ICT

    - e- ,

    , e- , e-

  • - 363 -

    ICTopia 2020

    : Cambodias ICT Masterplan 2020

    )

    (Ministry of Posts & Telecommunication, MPTC)

    - , , ICT

    ,

    - ICT(Department of ICT Security)

    CamCERT(Cambodia Computer Emergency Response Team)

    - CamCERT (National ICT Development Authority,

    NiDA) 2007 12 2008 10

    - CamCERT IT ,

    , ICT

    - CamCERT , , IT

    , CERT IT

  • - 364 -

    )

    , 6 (2017.03)

    - 2017 2 20 3 3 ,

    , , ,

    - (JICA) 3 ,

    - JICA

    , , ,

    , (2016.05)

    - (Por Pheak)

    (To Lam)

    - ,

    Microsoft, ICT (2016.08)

    - Microsoft ICT MOU

    ICT , , ICT

    - Microsoft

  • - 365 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.684 22

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 5.18 82 8.84 1

    (Access) 5.50 89 8.99 8

    (Use) 4.33 71 8.57 3

    (Skills) 6.21 80 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.684 22 0.782 13

    UN (EGDI 2016) 0.5522 77 0.8915 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.2 62 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) ,

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    4,706 7.0 28,035 56.1

    7,219 10.7 20,555 41.1

    116,606 172.7 61,296 122.7

    47.5% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 432.9

    '17 () 68,414

  • - 366 -

    1)

    )

    m

    ITU 2017 1 Global Cybersecurity Index(GCI) 2017

    0.684 22 ,

    3

    - , 5

    , , ,

    ,

    2 (Allianz Global) 76)

    - BitDefender 5, 11

    ( , , , )77)

    - 2016 8 1 8 (Government Savings

    Bank) ATM 346,000

    - (Ministry of Digital Economy) (Electronic Transactions

    Development Agency, ETDA 2015 4,300 ,

    87%

    - 20% , 10

    4% 100 1

    - ,

    76) Bangkokpost. 2016.6.8.

    77) TECHINASIA, 2017.4.10

  • - 367 -

    - 25 ,

    Microsoft 35%

    , 21% (Microsoft SIR, 21)

    - (25%),

    (7%)

    -

    . 80%

    m

    , Thailand 4.0

    - ,

    (Eastern Economic Corridor)

    - IT

    ,

    )

    We are Social 2017 1 6,822

    4,600 , 21%

    - 9,094 133% ,

    800 10%

    - ,

    - 2016 2,400 , 2017 2,600 , 2020

    2,930

  • - 368 -

    : We are Social(2017.1)

    - OpenSignal 87

    70

    - 6.09Mbps 1

    37.5Mbps

    -

    (e-Commerce) (Cash-on-delivery)

    - 10 ,

    3 , 4

    - 2015 10 CAT 2020

    .

    (IIG)

    - (National Statistical Office of Thailand)

    6 47.5% ,

    5~7 80%

  • - 369 -

    - 90%

    ,

    (M-Commerce) 2018

    : Statistica

    e-Payment

    - P2P , e-Payment

    PromptPay 2016 8

    - PromptPay

    -

    , ,

    - Alibaba

    - , CAT Telecom SK

    , NHN KCP e-Payment

  • - 370 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    - Technavio 2014 2 7

    MarketsandMarkets 2017 37

    ( 1 1 ) , 2018 10~12%

    3

    30% , 30%

    - RNCOS CCTV 2013~2017 21.5%

    ,

    - ,

    )

    m

    Trend Micro, McAfee, Check Point, Symantec, Sophos, Kaspersky

    , SafeComs, Nod32, BitDefender, Panda

  • - 371 -

    ,

    Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro (, ,

    , ) , PC

    Threat Meter'

    Trend Micro

    : TrendMicro.co.th

    Bitdefender

    - Bitdefender

    ,

    Freelance Engineering

    - : , , , ,

    ,

  • - 372 -

    Bitdefender

    : Bitdefender.co.th

    SafeComs

    - SafeComs 2004 , 5

    - , 90%

    - , , & ,

    Fortinet

    - Fortinet AsiaSoft

    BAAC(Bank of Agriculture and Agricultural Cooperatives)

    - : , ,

    Cyberoam

    - Cyberoam ,

  • - 373 -

    E-Rong Consultant Co., Ltd ITessential, Infrotonic

    - Cyberoam IDC, Gartner IT

    , Kaspersky Lab

    - :, IPS, , , VPN

    SIMENSE

    - ISA-99, IEC62443, DHS, BSI

    - Portal

    - VPN

    Fujitsu

    - Fujitsu 24 SOC()

    - , PalmSecure ID Match

    BAE Systems

    - SOC() (MSS)

    -

    )

    Thailand 4.0

    - 2016 5 Thailand 4.0

  • - 374 -

    - Thailand 4.0

    4-5%

    -

    , , / , ,

    , (Food Innopolis), , ,

    - ICT

    /

    - Thailand 4.0

    - (ETDA) 10%

    , ,

    (CISSP, Certified Information

    System Security Professional) 200

    , 2,800, 1,600

    - ETDA Surangkana Wauparb

    CISSP 800

    - (Thailand Information Security Association)

    IT ,

    CISSP 2017 500, 2022 1,000

  • - 375 -

    3)

    )

    m

    Computer Crimes Act of 2007

    - 2016 12 16 Computer Crimes Act

    -

    -

    : (Ministry of Information and Communications

    Technology) (Ministry of Digital Economy and Society)

    20

    ,

    , , 5

    .

    .

    , ,

    (Computer data Screening Committee)

    90 ,

  • - 376 -

    , 90 2

    - Thai Netizen Network( )

    30

    (Data Protection Act)

    - (Data Protection Act)

    -

    , , :

    . (, ) .

    3

    ( )

    .

    3 , , ,

    5 10

    3 , ,

    5

    10

    m

    IT2010, ICT Master Plan(2002-2006),

    ICT Mater Plan Extended(2007-2008), ICT Policy Framework 2020(2011-2020,

  • - 377 -

    ICT2020), National Digital Economy Policy and Plan(2016-2020)

    - IT2010 Technoloby Achievement Index(TAI)dynamic adopters

    potential leader , 2010

    30% , GDP 50%

    - (MICT) 10 ICT

    ICT2020

    ICT2020 ICT

    - IT2010 (Ministry of Information and

    Communication Technology) ICT2020 10(2011-2020)

    - , , , ICT

    ,

    , ,

    ICT 2020

    : (MICT)

  • - 378 -

    - ICT 2020(Smart Thailand 2020)

    ,

    ICT2020

    - ICT2020 7

    , : ICT

    ,

    ,

    , ICT ICT :

    , ICT : ICT

    ICT

    .

    , ,

    , :

    , ICT

    . CIO

    CIO . e-

    ,

    R&D

    , ,

    ICT :

    ICT ,

    R&D

    , ICT :

    .

    , TV . e-

  • - 379 -

    .

    ICT

    , Green ICT :

    ICT ,

    ICT

    2014 ICT2020

    ICT (Digital

    Development Plan for Economy and Society(2016-2020))

    - (National Digial Economy Master

    Plan) , , ,

    ,

    - 20

    ,

    Digital Thailand

    ()

    -

    , 2001 ,

    , ,

    m

    - ,

    CC

    CC(Common Criteria) 20

    , EAL 5

    - CC

  • - 380 -

    )

    (Ministry of Digital Economy and Society: MDES)

    - MDES 2016 (Draft CCA 2016)

    (Ministry of Information and Communication Thchnology: MICT)

    - MDES ,

    -

    -

    -

    (Electronic Transaction Development Agency: ETDA),

    (Electronic Government Agency: EGA),

    (Digital Economy Promotion Agency: DEPA)

    (Electronic Transaction Development Agency: ETDA)

    - 2010 ETDA

    - EDTA ,

    , , ,

    - (ThaiCERT) ETDA

    ,

    (Thailand Computer Emergency Response Team: ThaiCERT)

    - ThaiCERT

    - 2000 (National Electronics and

    Computer Technology Center) 2011 ETDA

  • - 381 -

    - ThaiCERT

    . , ,

    , (Forum of Incident Response and

    Security Teams: FIRST), (Asia-Pacific Computer

    Emergency Response Team: APCERT)

    -

    )

    - 2017 6, Tobias Feakin

    -

    -

    - 1 2,356 ( 380 )

    1

    ,

    - ,

    - 2014 Facebook

    -

    ,

  • - 382 -

    - 20%

    - ,

    15%

    -

    ,

  • - 383 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) GCI 1

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.925 1

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 10%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 7.95 20 8.84 1

    (Access) 8.70 11 8.99 8

    (Use) 7.54 19 8.57 3

    (Skills) 7.27 56 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.925 1 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.883 4 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 6.0 1 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) ,

    ( ) 100 ( ) 100

    2,003 35.0 28,036 56.1

    1,455 25.5 20,556 41.1

    8,400 132.4 61,300 122.7

    81.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 291.9

    '17 () 5,889

  • - 384 -

    1)

    )

    m

    ITU 2017 7 Global Cybersecurity Index(GCI) 2017

    0.925 ,

    1

    - , 5

    ,

    2017 2, 850

    - 2016 10 Starhub

    2 DDoS

    - 2016 3 SingPass 293

    , 5 2

    2017 8 Microsoft Microsoft Security Intelligence Report(SIR)(22)

    2017 1~3

    - 2017 1~3 5.3%~7.9% 20.2%

    - 4.68%

    , (0.75%), & (0.53%)

  • - 385 -

    (2017 1~3)

    : Microsoft, SIR 22(2017.8)

    m

    WEF (Global Competitiveness Report, 2012-13)

    3,

    - (EDB) (Ministry of Home Affairs,

    MHA) (Safety and Security

    Industry Programme Office, SSIPO)

    - MHA ,

    , EDB PPP

    )

    We are Social 2017 1 574

    471 ,

    82%

  • - 386 -

    - 844 147% ,

    446

    - , 91% SNS

    4

    : We are Social(2017.1)

    - OpenSignal 87

    , , 30Mpbs

    20 (2016.12~2017.1)

    : OpenSignal(2017)

  • - 387 -

    WEF (Global Information Technology

    Report, GITR) 2015, 2016 1

    - 2015 1,896

    12% ,

    72% , 73%

    : Singapore IDA(2016)

    - 2016 (Infocomm Development Authority, IDA)*

    (Smart Nation) ,

    , , , , ,

    (Immersive Media)

    * (IDA) 2016 10, Media Development Authority(MDA)

    Info-communications Media Development Authority(, IMDA)

  • - 388 -

    IT

    - IT Google, IBM, Microsoft Singapore, Red Hat, Netflix, Razer,

    Ubisoft and ViewQwest

    - Twitter, Linkedin, Facebook

    - Carousell, Lazada, Zalora, Reebonz, Beeketing

    - SW TradeGecko, ReferralCandy, Collabspot, Pie.

    Augment

    Flipit

    2016 21 10 54

    - , 5 3

    , 82%

    - 60% ,

    Qoo10, Amazon, Lazada

    (: )

    : eMarketer(2016.8)

  • - 389 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ITU 1

    -

    : BAE Systems, Microsoft, Palo Alto

    Networks

    :

    R&D : 1 9,000

    National Security R&D

    :

    ,

    200

    , ,

    - Thales

    Bosch R&D ,

    NICE Systems

    - ST Engineering,

    IT NCS(National Computer Systems),

    () Certis CISCO

  • - 390 -

    - , ,

    - INTERPOL Global Complex for Innovation

    m

    - PwC 2020 9 ( 6 )

    - IT 9.3%

    - IT

    - PwC

    1/4

    ,

    - 1

    103

  • - 391 -

    (: )

    : PwC(2016.12)

    1 (2015)

    (: )

    : PwC(2016.12)

  • - 392 -

    (2015~2020)

    (: )

    : PwC(2016.12)

    )

    m

    Security-as-a-Service(SecaaS)

    - SecaaS

    ,

    , FTP, ,

    - , ,

  • - 393 -

    m

    q

    ,

    -

    ,

    -

    -

    4 8 OEM

    -

    ,

    - OEM Teli-DVR4, NEON

    q

    , , ,

    Sony, Panasonic

    - Sony

    )

    m SW

    ,

  • - 394 -

    - McAfee,

    Kaspersky Lab, Websense, Trend Micro, Norman

    (McAfee) , , ,

    McAfee

    (Kaspersky Lab) Kaspersky Lab 2009

    - Kaspersky Byteworks International

    - Byteworks International Kaspersky

    (SI)

    (Websense) , ,

    Websense , , ,

    m SW

    ,

    ,

    - ,

    Tel

    Ingram Micro +65 9848 1332 McAfee, Symantec, Trend Micro, CA htt://sg.ingrammicro.com

    M.Tech +65 6516 0088 Check Point, Proofpoint, Sophos, Trend Mcro http://www.mtechpro.com

    ACA Pacific Technology +65 9107 8074 McAfee, Trend Micro, Cleaswift http://www.acapacific.com.sg

    ZoneOne +65 6337 6510 McAfee, Symantec http://www.zoneone.com.sg

    :

  • - 395 -

    (Ingram Micro) IT

    Synnex ,

    - Ingram Micro Ingram Micro Asia

    , , 90

    24,000

    - Ingram Micro , ,

    (M.Tech) IT M.Tech 2002

    , ,

    - Standard Chartered, DBS Bank, Singapore Exchange ,

    Check Point, Proofpoint, Sophos, Trend Micro

    - M.Tech Multi-Chem

    , , , , , ,

    10 25

    (ACA Pacific Technology) 1986 ACA Pacific Technology

    IT ,

    , ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    - ACA Pacific 800 ,

    Safenet, Ruckus Wireless, HP, Trend Micro, Watchguard

    (ZoneOne) 2003

    , ,

    - Acer, HP/Compaq, IBM, Lenovo, Toshiba ,

    Aztech, Linksys, Alcatel, Netgear, D-Link, 2Wire, Zywall

    Microsoft, McAfee, Symantec

  • - 396 -

    - /IP , ,

    SW SW

    ,

    SW

    : KOTRA

    )

    (Smart Nation) 2017 24

    - 2016.10

    4 ,

    - (MCI) 2018

    2,500

    -

  • - 397 -

    2017 3

    (Defence Cyber Organisation, DCO)

    - , 2,600

    24 ,

    - (Defence Science and Technology Agency, DSTA)

    2017 10, Kaspersky Lab (APT)

    - 2016 11 (R&D)

    (NUS) Kaspersky Lab

    -

    ,

    - , 1,560 9

    , 9

    (Cyber Security Agency, CSA) 2017 7

    18 11 (CII, Critical Information Infrastructure)

    - CSA 7 18

  • - 398 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Personal Data Protection Act 2012, PDPA)

    - 2012 10 , 2014 7

    - , ,

    (Personal Data Protection Commission, PDPC)

    (Data Protection Advisory Committee)

    -

    PDPA

    - , ,

    -

    , PDPA

    - PDPA ,

    ,

    - 2017 9 PDPA

    PDPA

  • - 399 -

    (Computer Misuse and Cybersecurity Act)

    ()

    - 2017

    7 10

    - (CIIP)

    (CSA) CIIP

    - CIIP ,

    , , , , , , , , ,

    , 11

    - CSA

    -

    - ,

    (SOC)

    - , , ,

    -

    m

    (Smart Nation) 2017 24

    - 2025

    - 5 , ,

    , ,

    - ,

    , , , (geospatial)

    , IT , M2M(Machine-to-Machine)

  • - 400 -

    - 2017 5

    (The Smart Nation and Digital

    Governament Office, SNDGO)

    - SNDGO

    IoT

    - (Government Technology

    Agency, GovTech)

    2016 (National Cybersecurity Strategy)

    - (National

    Cyber Security Masterplan) ,

    - 4

    - : (, , ,

    )

    (National Cyber Incident Response Team)

    (National Cyber Security Centre)

    2016 5 (CSA)

    (TTX: table-top exercise)

    2017

    ,

    , 2017

    - :

    (National Cybercrime Action Plan)

    4 : , ,

  • - 401 -

    ,

    - : IT

    (Institutes of Higher Learning)

    ,

    - :

    CSA , , , ,

    )

    m (MCI, Ministry of Communications and Information)

    (MCI) , ICT

    . (ICT)

    (IDA) (MDA) , 2016 10

    - (MCI) 2012 (Ministry of Information and the

    Arts, MICA) . (MICA) 2004 (Ministry of

    Communications and Information Technology, MCIT)

    (Ministry of Information and the Arts, MITA)

    - (IMDA)

    (GovTech)

    - (Cyber Security Agency of

    Singapore, CSA), (Personal Data Protection Commission, PDPC)

  • - 402 -

    (MCI)

    :

    m (IMDA, Infocomm Media Development Authority)

    (IMDA) (MCI)

    (MCI) 2016 10 . (ICT)

    () ,

    - (IDA) ICT

    (MDA)

    - (ICT) , ,

    ,

    - 2015 8 2025(Infocomm Media 2025)

  • - 403 -

    (IMDA)

    :

    m (Cyber Security Agency of Singapore, CSA)

    (CSA)

    - 2015 4 1 (Singapore Infocomm

    Technology Security Authority, SITSA)

    - CSA ,

    (CII)

    - CSA (MCI)

    David Koh

    m (Defence Cyber Organisation, DCO)

    (SAF) 24

    (2017.3.3.)

    - 2017 2 (MINDEF) 850

    - 2016 2

    , Cyber Security Operations Centre 2.0

    - 2017 3, Ng Eng Hen (DCO) 4 ,

    2,600

  • - 404 -

    - Cyber Security Division, The Policy and Plan

    Directorate, Cyber Security Inspectorate,

    , Cyber Defence Test and Evaluation Center

    Cyber Defence Group

    - ,

    (Cyberdefenders)

    )

    ,

    - CC(Common Criteria)

    NSS

    )

    ,

    MOU

    - 2 , ,

    , ,

    ,

    - , , , ,

    6

    - (CSA) David Koh

    - 2016 10

    (ASEAN Cyber Capacity Programme)

    - , ,

  • - 405 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) , 3

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.893 3

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.22 61 8.84 1

    (Access) 6.75 66 8.99 8

    (Use) 5.86 46 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.87 94 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.893 3 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.618 60 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.9 32 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) 100 ( ) 100

    4,510 14.5 28,036 56.1

    2,719 8.74 20,556 41.1

    43,913 141.2 61,300 122.7

    78.8% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 309.9

    '17 () 31,381

  • - 406 -

    1)

    )

    ITU 2017 7 Global Cybersecurity Index(GCI) 2017

    0.893 3

    - , 5

    , (0.96) (1.00)

    - , GCI ICT (IDI) UN , WEF

    - (GCI) 2 3

    (Information Security Certification Body)

    CyberSecurity Malaysia CEO Dr. Amirudin Abjul Wahab

    10,000 ,

    2015 2016 20%

    - (MOSTI) 2012 2016 50,789

    , 1 6 3,928

    - 2015 1,714 , 2017

    1,705

    -

    Symantec (ISTR) 2016

  • - 407 -

    - 2016 131

    , 2015 427

    2017 Unisys Security Index 88% ,

    , 87%

    - 77%

    )

    We are Social 2017 1 3,096

    2,200 71% ,

    4293 139%

    - 2016 1 7% ,

    1%

    - , 81%

    2,200

    : We are Social(2017.1)

  • - 408 -

    ( ) 2010 55.6% 2016

    77.9% 3,700

    2,800 , 2,700 (

    , 2016.12)

    : (2016.12)

    Akamai

    2016 2 6.8Mbps 9 , 68

    - 27Mbps 1 , 19.5Mbps,

    17.2Mbps, 17.1Mbps, 156Mbps

    Kable

    2019 7 4,137

  • - 409 -

    (: )

    : Kable(2016.8)

    - ,

    - (CAGR) 8.21%,

    47.2%

    : Kable(2016.8)

  • - 410 -

    3

    - Maxis 28% 3

    40.8%

    3 ( : )

    (B2C) (3,100 )

    (2016 1 GDP 9,526), ( 77%)

    - 2020 GDP

    6 11

    (2016 National eCommerce Strategy Roadmap)

    - 2015-2020

    GDP

    - IT eMarketer

    5

  • - 411 -

    2)

    )

    m

    IT

    -

    - IDC 2017 Annual Business and IT Services Survey

    65% ,

    - ,

    ,

    - IT

    -

    - SI

    - , ,

    ,

  • - 412 -

    m

    IDC 2016 2 4,290

    (2016) 5 21.1% 2021 6 3,260

    : IDC(2017.8)

    - (Managed Security Service) 2016 7,320

    2021 2 2,390 25.1%

  • - 413 -

    : IDC(2017.8)

    )

    m

    - Kaspersky Lab, Avira

    ,

    - Wholesaler/Distributor(1), Reseller(2)

    ,

    -

  • - 414 -

    : KISA(2013)

    m

    1) SW

    Kaspersky Lab, Symantec, Websense, ClearSwift, Trend Micro, Panda

    Security ,

    - IT

    Kaspersky Lab Panda Security

    - Websense, ClearSwift, Consentry Networks

    - , , ,

  • - 415 -

    Kaspersky Lab

    - 70%

    - 2013 Kaspersky Internet Security(KIS) Kaspersky Anti-Virus(KAV)

    , KIS KAV 30 22

    - Kaspersky Tech Tian Ltd , T-Drive

    Pro USB Tech Titan T-Drive Pro with

    USB KAV 8GB T-Drive Pro 55

    - Kaspersky 20102012 65~70%

    Websense

    - Websense

    - Websense , , (DLP)

    - SaaS

    Websense ,

    ,

    - 2012 11, Transition Systems

    Group

    Avira

    - (Avira Sdn Bhd)

    - Avira 500 1

    - ,

    , , PDA,

  • - 416 -

    - 2013 6 , OS , Mac OS X

    Windows

    - 2013 8, Avira Android Security 2.0 , Android 2.2

    , ,

    Cyberoam

    - ID UTM

    Elitecore Technologies

    - Cyberoam Anti Spam Engine

    Spam Detection Center

    - Span Detection Center RPD(Recurrent Pattern

    Detection) , ,

    - Secure One

    2)

    AIMS

    - . 80%

    /

    - (MSS) ,

    AKTI Consulting Group

    -

    2009 300

    , ,

    - (MSSP)

  • - 417 -

    ASK Pentest

    -

    -

    -

    Cyber Intelligence

    -

    - CyberSecurity Malaysia

    - , , , ,

    DNex

    - (SOC)

    - FORTRESS Managed Service

    24 SOC

    Firmus

    - 2008 SI

    - OSSTMM Test Execution Standard and Penetration Testing Framework

    HeiTech

    -

    ICT

    - , Tier4 .

    - ISO 27001, ISO 9001-2001, ISO 20000-2011

  • - 418 -

    Kaapagam Technologies

    - MSS, SOC, , , , ,

    - VALARI:

    - VALAI: 7 ,

    LGMS

    - , , , , , ,

    - . , . LGMS

    Mesiniaga

    - 1981 Bumiputera( )

    NEP

    - , . 24

    SOC

    NetbyteSEC

    - IT

    - , , .

    Nexagate

    - ISMS/ISO 27001 .

  • - 419 -

    (SPA), (DLP)

    - (DLP), ,

    Quann

    - e-Cop MSSP CISCO

    2016 Quann

    - , .

    Cyclops SIEM

    VADS

    - , MSS

    - (MUTM): , ,

    - (MWAF):

    )

    ,

    - ,

    Negara 2016

    . , , , IoT

    - (Personal Data Protection Act 2010)

    (European Data Protection Directive)

  • - 420 -

    - 3 (MSSPs)

    (Security Operation Center)

    - , , ,

    , ,

    -

    - AIG 2016 9 Dimension Data

    Dimension Data

    AIG

    - Symantec

    Chubb

  • - 421 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Personal Data Protection Act 2010)

    - 2013

    , EU

    -

    - ,

    ISO/IEC 27001 (ISMS) ,

    (code of conduct)

    - (Ministry of Communication and

    Multimedia) (Department of Personal Data Protection)

    - ,

    -

    - ,

    - 11

  • - 422 -

    //////

    (The Communications and Multimedia Act 1998)

    - ,

    - , (Malaysian

    Communications and Multimedia Commissions, MCMC)

    - ,

    -

    - Ahmad Zahid Hamid ,

    -

    (National Cyber Security Agency, NCSA)

    (Communication and Multimedia Act 1998), (Defameation Act

    1957), (Sedation Act 1948) , ICT

  • - 423 -

    - 2017 2 (NCSA)

    (, National Security Council, NSC) ,

    CyberSecurity Malaysia

    m

    (NCSP, National Cyber Security Policy)

    -

    (CNII)

    - 10

    , , , , , , , ,

    , ,

    - --

    , ,

    , ,

    ,

    , R&D ,

    , ,

    - (CNII) , ,

    , ,

    - 8

  • - 424 -

    (National eCommerce Strategic Roadmap)

    - 2016 10

    - 2020 GDP 20%

  • - 425 -

    - (National

    eCommerce Council, NeC) , 6 11

    - 6 ; , , ,

    , , , , , ,

    , ,

    -

    (Digital free trade zone) , e ,

    , e

    )

    (National Cyber Security Agency, NCSA)

    - 2017 1

    ,

    - 2017 6 ,

    (NSC)

  • - 426 -

    - CyberSecurity Malaysia

    NCSA

    (CyberSecurity Malaysia)

    - CyberSecurity Malaysia

    2009

    - , ,

    - MyCert(Malaysia Computer Emergency Response Team):

    . Cyber999 Help Centre

    - Digital Foresics(CyberCSI):

    , , , , ,

    - MySEF(Malaysian Security Evaluation Facility): Common Criteria

    . ICT .

    - (ISCB): .

    2008 179

    (MOSTI)

    - ICT

    8 4

    - ICT

    , (CNII)

    - (CyberSecurity Malaysia) ,

  • - 427 -

    (Ministry of Communication and Multimedia)

    -

    (Department of Personal Data Protection)

    . 11

    - (Malaysian Communications and Multimedia

    Commission)

    (Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission, MCMC)

    - (98) (KKMM) (KCC)

    * 9(1, 3, 5)

    - , ,

    - , ,

    - ( ) ,

    - , (BNM), (SC), (SSM)

    - ISP .

    - (MOSTI) CyberSecurity Malaysia ,

  • - 428 -

    )

    MyCC(Malaysian Common Criteria Evaluation & Certification

    - ICT ISO/IEC15408

    - MyCC MySEF(Malaysian Security Evaluation Facility)

    CSM27001(CyberSecurity Malaysia Information Security Management System Audit and

    Certification)

    - ISO/IEC27001 ISMS

    Malaysia Trustmark for Private Sector(MTPS)

    - e-Business , e-Business

    / (Trustmark Alliance)

    )

    2017 7 CREST(Council of Registered

    Ethical Security Testers) PPKS(Association of Cyber Security Testers

    for Kuala Lumpur, Selangor and Putrajaya) MOU ,

    CREST

    - PPK Mohammed Fadzil Haron

    ,

    CREST

    - CREST 43 2018 10

    ,

    - 2016 10

  • - 429 -

    - 2016 4 5,500

    - , ,

    - Datuk Seri Dr Salleh Said Keruak 2017 7

    -

    (Malaysian Digital Economic Corporation, MDEC)

    PGI (Protection Group International)

    (2016.12)

    - PGI , ,

    , GCHQ

    - , 2019 2

    ,

  • - 430 -

    3.

    m

    (Latin America and the Caribbean)

    8 12, 13

    - 2,055, 6 4 , GDP 5 4,000

    -

    - ,

    (2016 )

    (US$ )

    (US$ )

    1962.1 9,721 3,695, , ,

    , , ,

    1962. 8. 217 133, ,

    ,

    ,

    1962. 3. 830 430,

    , ,

    , /, , ,

    1962. 4 1,611 3,704,

    , ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    1962. 1 128 12,

    , ,

    /, /, /

    : Kotra-, KITA.net

    ICT (IDI) ,

    , ICT IT

  • - 431 -

    - 2016 ICT (IDI) ICT

    50 ICT

    - ICT ,

    , 2016 IDI

    56 57

    ICT(IDI)

    IDI(2016) (access) (use) (skill)

    92 4.87 97 5.08 74 4.24 99 5.74

    57 6.30 73 6.44 48 5.80 61 7.04

    83 5.16 86 5.83 86 3.85 74 6.44

    56 6.35 61 6.81 64 4.91 25 8.30

    131 2.88 124 4.08 151 1.00 124 4.23

    1 8.84 8 8.99 3 8.57 3 9.08

    : ITU, 'Measuring the Information Society Report 2016'(2016)

  • - 432 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 2017 28 ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.660 28

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 175

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 4.87 92 8.84 1

    (Access) 5.08 97 8.99 8

    (Use) 4.24 74 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.74 99 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.660 28 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.619 59 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.0 76 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    60%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    19,599 15.18 28,035 56.1

    16,049 12.67 20,556 41.1

    111,724 88.23 61,295 122.7

    59.5% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 1,004

    17 () 124,574

  • - 433 -

    1)

    )

    m

    (US Department of Commerce) 2017 9 ,

    IT 2016 221 , 2017

    238

    - 2016 IT ,

    55%, IT 28%, 17%

    - 2014 2016 IT 4.8%

    - IT (CAGR) 5.3% IT

    ,

    4.1%, 5.0%

    2014 2015 20162017()

    IT ( US$) 19.2 20.6 22.1 23.8

    : US Department of Commerce, export.gov

    m

    (National Institute of Statistics and Geography) 2016 5

    , 57.4%, 6,200

    - 73.6% 6-34 ,

    25-34

    - , (Mexico City),

    (Nuevo Leon), (Baja California Sur), (Sonora),

    (Quintana Roo) 50%

    (Oaxaca), (Chiapas) 15%

  • - 434 -

    m

    ITU Global Cybersecurity Index 2017 , GCI 0.660

    28

    - NAFTA(North America Free Trade Agreement, )

    , ,

    - , IT

    ,

    - ITU ,

    Cisco Systems 2017 8 ,

    2

    (2017 8 )

    ( : )

    2017 8

    8.4

    7.6

    7.4

    7.4

    7.2

    7.1

    6.9

    6.7

    : Cisco Systems

  • - 435 -

    Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams (FIRST)78) 4

    , Mexicos Computer

    Emergency Response Team (CERT-MX)

    - 2010 Mexicos Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-MX)

    , , ,

    ,

    Kaspersky Lab , 2014

    2

    78) 1990 17 396 CERT

  • - 436 -

    (2014)

    (%) ()

    38 32 22,123

    63 28.7 4,537

    64 28.5 930

    74 27 17,514

    80 26.5 458

    90 25.4 440

    92 24.9 311

    95 24.6 3,157

    97 24.4 4,992

    98 24.2 1,813

    : Kaspersky Lab Report 2014

    Symantec 2013 , 2013

    70%

    , , , ,

    80%

    : Symantec report 2013

  • - 437 -

    m

    Eset

    - 1992 ESET

    , ,

    , ,

    - ESET 2004

    - ESET Nod32 AntiVirus , ESET Smart

    Security , , ,

    OS

    - : http://www.eset.com.mx

    AlienVault

    -

    , 2009 IT SegIif

    - SegIif AlienVault OSSIM(Open Source Security Information Management)

    - OSSIM , , ,

    20

    - : http://mx.westcon.com/content/vendors/alienvault

  • - 438 -

    Trend Micro

    - Trend Micro

    - 2013 5,

    - : http://la.trendmicro.com

    Kaspersky Lab

    - 1997 Kaspersky Lab

    7.6% 4

    - Kaspersky Lab ,

  • - 439 -

    - : http://latam.kaspersky.com/mx

    )

    m

    ,

    - IHS Markit Global Trade Atlas 2016 ,

    31.6 GDP 1.2%

    : Global Trade Atlas (2016)

  • - 440 -

    2011 30%

    - (National Council of Private Security) 2016

    1,103, 73,000 ,

    2005 173, 419 10 530%,

    17,000%

    - 9,

    25 60

    - 32

    ,

    - (National Institute of Statistics and Geography) 2016 3

    , 18 70%

    , 67.5%, 61.9%

    - , (80%),

    (73%), (65%), (61%), (55% ),

    (54%)

    - 2016 12 ((ENSU:

    Encuesta Nacional De Seguridad Publica Urbana)

  • - 441 -

    : , National Institute of Statistics and Geography, (2016. 12)

    - ,

    72.1% , 10%

    : , National Institute of Statistics and Geography, (2016. 12)

    , , CCTV,

    ,

    -

    - ,

    , CCTV,

    ,

  • - 442 -

    - ,

    , IP

    CCTV

    - ,

    ,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    - , ,

    , CCTV

    m

    79)

    - ,

    , LockState, Rocky Mountain

    - MKM, TOVER ,

    NAV-LOCK, Honeywell

    - ,

    79) , KOTRA, 2013.03.14.

  • - 443 -

    CCTV80)

    ,

    - 70%

    - CCTV 4% ,

    ,

    - CCTV

    - CCTV , IP CCTV

    - CCTV (HS Code 852580 ) , , , ,

    ,

    : JLM , KOTRA

    80) CCTV , KOTRA, 2013.04.16.

  • - 444 -

    m

    (The American Chamber of Commerce in Mexico) 330

    2015-2016 ,

    85%

    CCTV 80%

    66%

    65%

    57%

    51%

    : AmChams 2015-2016 Security Report

    m

    MULTISISTEMAS DE SEGURIDAD INDUSTRIAL, SA DE CV

    - 30 34 ,

    - ,

    - : www.multisistemas.com

  • - 445 -

    CORPORATE PROTECTION GROUP OF PATRIMONIAL, SC

    - ,

    ,

    - : www.protecpatrimonial.com

    PROTECCIN Y ALARMAS PRIVADAS, SA DE CV - , CCTV

    ,

    - : www.paprisa.com.mx

    EULEN DE SEGURIDAD PRIVADA, SA DE CV

    - , , , 14

    -

    - : www.eulen.com/mx

  • - 446 -

    CONSULTORES EN SEGURIDAD INTEGRAL, SA DE CV

    - , CCTV ,

    , GPS

    - : www.consultoresenseguridad.com

    Mexico Unido Contra la Delincuencia(MUCD)

    - : Emerson 243, Piso 7, Colonia Chapultepec Morales. Delegacin Miguel Hidalgo. C.P. 11570. Mxico D.F.

    - : 5515 6759, 5277 8311- : mucd@mucd.org.mx- : http://www.mucd.org.mx/-

    Consejo Nacional de Seguridad Privada(CNSP)

    - : Consejo Nacional de Seguridad Privada A .C. Mariano Escobedo 543 piso1 despacho 102

    - : 55 26243534- : cnsp@cnsp.org.mx - : http://cnsp.org.mx/- - CCTV, , ,

  • - 447 -

    2)

    Microsoft Security Intelligence Report vol. 22 2017 1,

    2, 3 14.1%, 12.8%, 12.1%

    , 10.3%, 9.1%, 7.8%

    )

    2017 8 Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22.

    , Microsoft PC

    (encounter rate)

    - (encounter rate)

    PC (2017 1 ~ 2017 3)

    2017 1 2017 2 2017 3

    14.1% 12.8% 12.1%

    10.3% 9.1% 7.8%

    : Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22. (2017.8)

  • - 448 -

    PC (2017 1~3)

    : Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22. (2017.8)

    2017 3 6.07%

    , 5.57% 0.5%

    - , 2.34%

    2

    - , 0.75%

    3

    2017 3

    : Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22. (2017.8)

  • - 449 -

    2017 3

    Win32/Fuery 0.94%

    - Win32/Fuery , USB

    PC

    JS/Bondat 0.74% 2

    - Win32/Skeeyah Win32/Vigort 0.71%

    0.69% 3 4

    2017 3 TOP 10

    1 Win32/Fuery Trojans 0.94%

    2 JS/Bondat Worms 0.74%

    3 Win32/Skeeyah Trojans 0.71%

    4 Win32/Vigorf Trojans 0.69%

    5 Win32/Spursint Trojans 0.68%

    6 Win32/Swrort Trojans 0.48%

    7 VBS/Jenxcus Worms 0.47%

    8 Win32/Dynamer Trojans 0.45%

    9 Win32/Gamarue Worms 0.40%

    10 JS/Nemucod Downloaders & Droppers 0.39%

    : Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22. (2017.8)

    ,

    ,

    - 1,000 1.1, 6.3

    - 1,000 7.7, 14.8

    - URL 1,000 Drive-by 0.07, 0.17

  • - 450 -

    (2016 1 2016 2)

    URL 1,000 Drive-by ( )

    0.07 0.17

    1,000 ( )

    1.1 6.3

    1,000 ( )

    7.7 14.8

    : Microsoft Security Intelligence Report Vol 22. (2017.8)

  • - 451 -

    3)

    (Direccion General de Computo y de TIC)

    (Subdireccion de Seguridad de la Informacion) ,

    UNAM-CERT

    )

    (Subdireccion de Seguridad de la Informacion)

    (General Directorate of Computing and Information and Communication

    and Technology) ,

    ,

    - : https://www.seguridad.unam.mx/

    UNAM-CERT (UNAM-CERT Equipo de Respuesta a Incidentes

    de Seguridad Informtica)

    -

    - : http://www.cert.org.mx/index.html

  • - 452 -

    )

    2011 7,

    12

    -

    3

    -

    ,

    - , ,

    , , 3

    -

    ,

    - 3 3

    ,

    - , -

    - - , , , , 3

    - , - , -

    3

    - 3 3 - 3

    - 3

    : (COFETEL), KISA(2013.09)

  • - 453 -

    4)

    (The Mexican Federal law on Metrology and

    Standardization) NOM

    NMX

    NOM ANCE

    , IT NYCE

    : (NOM)

    (The Mexican Federal law on Metrology and

    Standardization) NOM (Normas Oficiales Mexicanas)

    NMX (Normas Mexicanas)

    - NOM NOM

    - NOM NMX

    NOM NMX

    NOM(Norma Oficial Mexicana)

    - (Mexican Regulation)- (National Consultative Committees) -

    NMX(Mexican standards)

    - - - SE ()

    : expertcenter.go.kr

    NOM HS code

    - , , ANCE NYCE

  • - 454 -

    4

    - NOM (Secretaria de Hacien)

    NOM

    - - , , - , EMA (Entidad

    Mexicana de Accreditacion) - MRA(Mutual Recognition Agreement)

    ,

    - , (Certificate of Compliance)

    - - NOM ( , , ) - , NOM

    ,

    - . 1 (verification testing)

    - , - , .

    file - ,

    NOM

    ANCE

    NYCE

  • - 455 -

    NOM 1992 , ,

    , 1993 10 (The Mexican Federal

    law on Metrology and Standardization) 3

    (SDOs) (CBs)

    - NOM 1992

    (The Mexican Federal law on Metrology and Standardization)

    NOM (Normas Oficiales Mexicanas) NMX (Normas

    Mexicanas) ,

    NOM

    - (Mexican Standards Developing Organizations; SDOs)

    SDOs

    NORMEX , ,

    IMNC ,

    NNTEX ,

    ONNCE

    COFOCALEC

    CNCP

    ANCE

    NYCE

    - (Certification Bodies)

    CBs

    ANCE , ,

    OMNCE ,

    NYCE ,

    NORMEX

    CCOFOCALEC

    IMNC

    CRT

    CERTMEX

  • - 456 -

    -

    ANCE, CANIETI, ITS (De Mexico)

    * NYCE : UL, CSA, TUV-R, ITS, ETL, SEMKO, NEMKO

    * ANCE : UL, CSA, ICONTEC, NEMKO, KEMA, INEN, SENCAMER

    NOM ANCE NYCE

    - ANCE (Asociacion de Nomalizacion y Certificacion A.C.) :

    (www.ance.org.mx)

    - NYCE (Normalizacion y Certificacion Electronica A.C.): , IT

    (www.nyce.org.mx)

    ANCE (Asociacion de Nomalizacion y Certificacion A.C.)

    1992

    - NOM() NMX()

    - ANCE IECEE CB Scheme Member Body CBTL ,

    a.

    - : NMX , NOM

    , , ,

    ,

    - : ISO/IEC 65

    , NOM() NMX()

    - : (EMA: Mexican Entity of Accreditation)

    ISO/IEC17025

    b. ANCE Test Laboratory

    - Safety Testing :

    (Household)

  • - 457 -

    (Electronics)

    (Electrical Devices)

    (Ballast)

    (Lighting Fixtures)

    - (Energy Efficiency) :

    (Refrigerators)

    (Washing Machines)

    c. ANCE : , ,

    Electrical Products

    Household AppliancesElectrical DevicesStartersLightingWire and CableConnectorsFuse connectorsFusesCircuit BreakersRotating MachinesBatteryControl system for generating centralsSwitchboardsTransformerTerminologyIsolatorLighting rodsCapacitorsSwitch bladesDangerous areas accessoriesRestorers and SeccitionersPower switchesInsulation coordinationInsulating materialsVoltage regulatorsHand held electric tools

    Gas products

    Water HeatersStoveHosesValves

  • - 458 -

    d.

    ANCE (Asociacion de Nomalizacion y Certificacion A.C.) Av. Eje Central Lazaro Cardenas No. 869 Col. Nva. Ind. Vallejo Mexico, D.F. 07700 MEXICO

    Cesar E. Silva csilva@ance.org.mx

    / +52 5747-4550 xt. 4701 / +52 5747-4560 http://www.ance.org.mx

    NYCE(Normalizacin y Certificacin NYCE, S.C.) NYCE (Certification Body),

    , (NOM, NMX) (ISO, IEC)

    - , IT

    - : https://www.nyce.org.mx/

    a.

    -

    -

    -

    -

    -

    -

    b. NYCE

    NOM-001-SCFI-1993 ; - -

    IEC 65(1985) :

    NOM-016-SCFI-1993 ; -

    IEC 335 Part 1: - Part 1 ISO 4882:

    NOM-019-SCFI-1998

    UL 478(1980): , IEC 60065 IEC 60950

  • - 459 -

    - Homologation

    (Secretaria de Comunicaciones y Transportes)

    NOM-151-SCT1-1999 ;

    2048Mbps ITU-T Rec. G. 703, Rec. G. 704, Rec. G. 823

    NOM-084-SCT1-2000 ;

    ITU-R Rec SM.329, SM.1045, SM.328

    NOM-088/1-SCT1-2000 ;Point to point and point to multipoint microwave systems-Part I: Radio multiple access

    ITU-R Rec SM.329, SM.1045, SM.328

    NOM-088/2-STC1-2000 ;Point to point and point to multipoint microwave systems-Part II: Transport

    ITU-R Rec SM.329, SM.328, SM.1045

    NOM-121-SCT1 ;Spread spectrum

    FCC Part 15, RSS-210

    NOM-154/1-SCT1 ;Cellular radiotelephony TDMA on 800MHz

    RSS-128, SM.329 ITU-R Rec, CCP.III/REC.21, TIA/EIA IS-136, TIA/EIA IS-137, SRSP 503

    NOM-154/2-SCT1 ;Cellular radiotelephony CDMA on 800MHz

    RSS-112, SM.329 ITU-R Rec, CCP.III/REC.21, TIA/EIA 97-D, TIA/EIA 98-B, TIA/EIA IS-95-A

    NOM-155/1-SCT1 ;Equipment with technology GSM on 1,900 MHz systems

    TIA/EIA/J-STD-007 3GPP

    NOM-158-SCT1 ;Equipment used personal communication on narrow band

    CCP.III/REC. 18

    EMC

    NOM-125-SCT1-2000 ;EMC for information technologies equipment

    CISPR 22

    c.

    Normalizacion y Certificacion Electronica A.C. AV. LOMAS DE SOTELO 1097 COL. LOMAS DE SOTELO C.P. 11200 MIGUEL HIDALGO MEXICO D.F. MEXICO

    nyce@nyce.org.mx/ +52-5395-0777 / +52-5395-0700 http://www.nyce.org.mx

  • - 460 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 5

    ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.336 86

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.20 57 8.84 1

    (Access) 6.30 70 8.99 8(Use) 5.12 52 8.57 3(Skills) 8.18 53 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.336 86 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.631 53 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 4.5 44 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 827 16.3 28,036 56.1 587 11.6 20,556 41.1 8,063 159.2 61,296 122.7 66.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 57.689

    '17 () 4,873

  • - 461 -

    1)

    ) /

    -

    - , ,

    ,

    -

    -

    - ,

    -

    -

    , CCTV

  • - 462 -

    ) ICT /

    m

    -

    ,

    (2016 GDP 4.3%)

    - , 51 , 500

    2014 24% 2016 3%

    113

    - GDP 3%

    - 2005

    (teledensity, 100 )

    -

    2010

    - 2007 2011

    (ICE, Instituto Costarricense de

    Electricidad)

    - 2009 ICE TV

  • - 463 -

    PSTN (Public Switched Telephone Network)

    m

    2010

    2013 2014 2015 2016* 2017*

    ( ) 3.47 4.02 4.24 4.38 4.47

    (%) 69.9 86.0 88.0 91.0 93.2

    : Buddecomm(2017.06)

    *2016, 2017

    -

    - (Fonatel, Fondo Nacional

    de Telecomunicaciones)

    ,

    34

    - 2013 11 Fonatel 2,000 Guatuso, Los Chiles,

    Upala, San Carlos Sarapiqui 200,000

  • - 464 -

    / (2013)

    ( )

    ( ):A

    ( ):B(%,B/A)

    4,667 1,327 414(213) 31.1(16.1)

    3,075 878 349(115) 40.0(13.1)

    234 69 13(11) 19.6(15.5)

    270 74 12(13) 16.9(17.4)

    289 84 11(24) 12.8(28.6)

    316 91 11(23) 12.5(25.4)

    484 136 17(28) 12.1(20.9)

    ) ( )

    :

    m

    - 2006

    -

    - DSL, HFC

    98% WiMAX,

    2%

    - (CAATEC) 2009

    ,

    512Kb / s ~ 1Mb / s 2007

    16 % 2009 37 %

  • - 465 -

    (2013)

    ()

    ():A

    ():B

    (%:B/A)

    4,667 1,327 297 22.3

    3,075 873 254 29.1

    270 74 10 6.8

    234 69 8 11.5

    289 84 8 9.2

    316 91 7 7.6

    484 136 9 4.6

    :

    81)

    - (2015-2021)

    2021 80%

    - 4

    - 2016 ICE 3,300 (Next Generation

    Network) 103,000

    2017 180,000

    9,100 100Mb/s

    81) MICITT, Plan Nacional de Ciencia, Tecnologa e Innovacin 2015-2021

  • - 466 -

    (: , %)

    2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    2,011,244(11,62)

    2,166,330(12.40)

    2,295,169(13.03)

    2,489,717(14.01)

    2,719,439(15.17)

    2887000 (15.97)

    3,348,142

    (7.11)3,938,657

    (8.26)4,537,621

    (9.39)5,028,595(10.28)

    5,525,511(11.16)

    5,912,968 (11.80)

    419,782(8.86)

    448,594(9.34)

    484,883(9.95)

    515,859(10.45)

    558,656(11.17)

    587,000 (11.59)

    2,243,036

    (4.09)2,390,778

    (4.81)2,563,356

    (5.31)2,723,502

    (5.74)3,142,281

    (6.42)2,120,762

    (6.72)

    120,101(1.83)

    136,152(2.04)

    156,576(2.30)

    185,125(2.68)

    220,858(3.14)

    239,499 (3.35)

    85,092(1.44)

    101,312(1.69)

    131,687(2.17)

    111,409(1.81)

    116,308(1.86)

    177,024 (2.79)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    m

    2011

    America Movil Claro Costa Rica Telefnica Movistar Costa Rica ICE

    - 2011 ( ) 2015 2.2%

    2016 3%

    2014~2016

    ( )

    2014 7.02 147%

    2015 7.53 156%

    2016 8.33 170%

    : Buddecomm(2017.06)

  • - 467 -

    2014~2016

    2014 80% 20%

    2015 79% 21%

    2016 78% 22%

    : Buddecom(2017.06)

    2)

    )

    - ,

    GDP 3.5%

    82)

    )

    (Ministerio de Seguridad Pblica) (Direccin de Servicios de Seguridad Privados) 83)

    82) http://www.crhoy.com 2017.10.17, La Republica, lvarez y Castro reduciran dficit fiscal

    eliminando el crimen

    83) http://www.seguridadpublica.go.cr

  • - 468 -

    -

    Control Pas, Segupriv

    ,

    84)

    -

    - Eset 42% ,

    Microsoft

    4~10% ,

    - IDC Fortinet

    80% IT (intermediate)

    )

    m

    - 2017 6 Control Pas 737 557

    2 4

    m

    - , , IBM, HP

    84) 2017 4 30 El Financiero Los ataques informticos ms frecuentes en

    Costa Rica

  • - 469 -

    SOC ,

    - IT SPC International

    (2015.6)

    (, , , )

    - Ciberlegal

    - CRISTHIAN FERNANDO CARBALLO SANCHEZ :

    - GRUPO MR DOS SEGURIDAD S.A : ,

    - KRUMA CONSULTORES RD S.A : (, ,CCTV, )

    - PROARSA S.A :

    - R.S SEGURIDAD DIGITAL INTERNACIONAL S.A :

    - SC SECURITY S.A : CCTV, , ,

    ,

    - SEGURIDAD CONTINENTAL SECO S.A : (CCTV,

    TV ), , ,

    - SEGURIDAD DELTA : , , CCTV,

    - SEKUNET S.A : ,CCTV,

    - SENSORMATIC DE COSTA RICA S.A : CCTV,

    ,

    - TECNASA : ,

    - CEWTEC : ,

    )

    - , , 3

    ,

    - 2017 1 30 5 30 ,

    2 9

  • - 470 -

    (PCD) 6,738,087kg,

    3,378,600kg 10

    -

    - 2016 577, 10 11.8%, 2017 6

    30 278

    2021 706

    -

    - -

    ,

  • - 471 -

    3)

    )

    m

    q (Ley de delitos Informaticos)

    :Ley No. 8148(2012. 11. 26)

    -

    (Ley No. 4573L 1970. 05.04)

    - 167: 10

    - 196: , , , 6

    - 217:

    - 229: , ,

    4

    - 230: (Wikileaks)

    3~8

    - 231: 3-6

    q (Ley de Proteccin de la Persona frente al Tratamiento de sus Datos Personales)

    : Ley No. 8968(2011. 09. 05)

  • - 472 -

    - : ,

    ,

    - : , ,

    , ,

    - : , ,

    , , , ,

    m

    - 2015 3 (OAS)

    , 2017 10 12

    - ,

    , , , ,

    - , ,

    (SUTEL) , ,

    -

    -

    -

    - ,

    - , , ,

  • - 473 -

    )

    m

    (MICITT : Ministerio de Ciencia y Tecnologia)85)

    - 2012 (CSIRT.CR)

    , 2013 ICE DoS

    (OAS)

    ,

    :

    m

    q (CSIRT.CR : Centro de Respuesta de

    Incidentes de Seguridad Informatica)

    85) www.micit.gob.cr

  • - 474 -

    2012

    -

    -

    - (No 37052-MICIT)

    -

    - CSIRT.CR

    -

    -

    (Asociacion de Organizaciones de

    Seguridad de Costa Rica) (CR-CERT)

    ,

    q (Tribunal Supremo de Elecciones Normativa:)86)

    ,

    q (PRODHAB : Agencia de Proteccion de Datos de los Habitant)87)

    : Ley No. 8968(2011. 09. 05) 15-20

    -

    - ,

    -

    - , ,

    , ,

    -

    86) www.tse.go.cr87) www.mjp.go.cr

  • - 475 -

    -

    )

    -

    - ISO/IEC 27001

    )

    2017 10 12

    -

    ,

    - ICT

    , 2014-2018

    2015-2021

    2018 2016

    22% ,

  • - 476 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.569 46

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 5.16 83 8.84 1

    (Access) 5.83 86 8.99 8(Use) 3.85 86 8.57 3(Skills) 6.44 74 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.569 46 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.628 57 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 4.9 66 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) 10%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 7,116 14.2 28,036 56.1 5,913 11.8 20,556 41.1 58,685 117.1 61,296 122.7 58.1% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 306.4

    17 () 47,699

  • - 477 -

    1)

    )

    1964

    - ITU ICT (IDI)

    ,

    -

    , ICT

    88)

    2016 11

    - , FARC

    89)

    2010 (Plan Vive Digital, 2014-2018)

    - Ministry of ICTs ICT

    60% 90)

    - , IT

    IT

    - (e-government)

    88) GIS Watch, Colombia, 2016(: https://www.giswatch.org/node/5882)89) , , 2017.3.90) GIS Watch, Hacking information on the peace talks in Colombia, 2014

    (https://www.giswatch.org/en/country-report/communications-surveillance/colombia)

  • - 478 -

    ICT (IDI) (2016)

    ICT

    47(52)

    6.79(5,12)

    48(55)

    7.25(6,15)

    39(51)

    6.20(2.63)

    62(43)

    7.02(8.39)

    52(54)

    6.52(5.02)

    65(59)

    6.77(5.94)

    57(62)

    5.45(2.22)

    28(27)

    8.18(8.76)

    56(59)

    6.35(4.90)

    61(65)

    6.81(5.67)

    64(57)

    4.91(2.36)

    25(39)

    8.30(8.45)

    83(83)

    5.16(3.92)

    86(86)

    5.83(4.36)

    86(83)

    3.85(1.61)

    74(58)

    6.44(7.62)

    92(86)

    4.87(3.70)

    97(94)

    5.08(4.18)

    74(81)

    4.24(1.67)

    99(98)

    5.74(6.80)

    101(101)

    4.42(3.38)

    104(101)

    4.80(4.04)

    106(90)

    2.94(1.37)

    69(67)

    6.60(7.40)

    109(108)

    4.08(3.11)

    111(109)

    4.59(3.69)

    105(108)

    2.96(0.83)

    113(105)

    5.28(6.54)

    131(123)

    2.88(2.40)

    124(121)

    4.08(2.84)

    151(126)

    1.00(0.43)

    124(119)

    4.23(5.47)

    57(80)

    6.30(4.07)

    73(83)

    6.44(4.55)

    48(73)

    5.80(1.93)

    61(68)

    7.04(7.38)

    63(73)

    5.99(4.29)

    74(76)

    6.42(5.01)

    52(68)

    5.60(2.31)

    91(74)

    5.89(7.23)

    ) ( ) 2010

    : ITU, 'Measuring the Information Society Report 2016'(2016.9)

    - 2016 (FARC) 2017 6 FARC

    - 2018 5 ICT

    -

    - , ,

    -

  • - 479 -

    -

    -

    - (IADB) (OAS)

    91)

    (GDP) 0.5% 5,750

    900

    92)

    -

    (Ministry of ICTs) (MSPI)

    93)

    - ICT

    91) Observatory of Cybersecurity in Latin America and the Caribbean:

    (http://observatoriociberseguridad.com/graph/countries//selected//0/dimensions/1-2-3-4-5)

    92) Dialogo, Cyberdefense and Cybersecurity in Colombia, 2016 (https://dialogo-americas.com/en/articles/cyberdefense-and-cybersecurity-colombia)

    93) (MinTIC), Modelo de Seguridad (http://www.mintic.gov.co/gestionti/615/w3-propertyvalue-7275.html)

  • - 480 -

    (GCI : Global Cybersecurity Index)

    GCI 2017

    38 0.593

    29 0.647

    46 0.569

    63 0.482

    81 0.367

    86 0.336

    28 0.660

    79 0.374

    87 0.326

    125 0.146

    : ITU, 'Global Cybersecurity Index & Cyberwellness Profiles(GCI)'(2017.7)

    )

    -

    ,

    ICT

    - ICT

    2016 1,500 (2010 7 )

    - 96%

    ,

  • - 481 -

    ITU 2016 , 711 6 ,

    14.20%

    - 2000 18% ,

    (: , %)

    : ITU(2017.6)

    - ,

    - ,

    11%

    - ,

    94)

    -

    2018

    - IT

    94) Brookings, Digital Colombia: Maximizing the global internet and data for sustainable and inclusive growth, 2016. (https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/global-20161020-digital-colombia.pdf)

  • - 482 -

    (Plan Vive Digital)

    -

    2009 30% 2014 65% ,

    24% 81%

    UN (E-Government) 2016

    193 57

    (: , %)

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    1,789,355(10.43)

    2,011,244(11.62)

    2,166,330(12.40)

    2,295,169(13.03)

    2,489,717(14.01)

    2,719,439(15.17)

    2,887,000(15.97)

    2,643,033

    (5.69)3,348,142

    (7.11)3,938,657

    (8.26)4,537,621

    (9.39)5,028,595(10.28)

    5,525,763(11.16)

    5,912,968(11.80)

    396,262(8.49)

    419,782(8.86)

    448,594(9.34)

    484,883(9.95)

    515,859(10.45)

    558,65(11.17)

    587,000(11.59)

    73,279(1.26)

    85,092(1.44)

    101,312(1.69)

    131,687(2.17)

    111,409(1.81)

    116,308(1.86)

    177,024(2.79)

    89,493(1.39)

    120,101(1.83)

    136,152(2.04)

    156,576(2.30)

    185,125(2.68)

    220,858(3.14)

    239,499(3.35)

    2,126,689

    (3.19)2,243,036

    (4.09)2,390,778

    (4.81)2,563,356

    (5.31)2,723,502

    (5.74)3,142,281

    (6.42)2,120,762

    (6.72)

    ) ( )

    : ITU(2017.6)

  • - 483 -

    2)

    )

    m

    - 1964 52

    - , , , , ,

    - 50%

    - 2014 ,

    4.9% , , 4 ,

    9.1% 3

    -

    - (CERT Colombiana)

    ( : %)

    58.0 12.4 6.2 4.9 18.5

    36.3 18.1 5.5 9.1 31.0

    )

    : Trend Micro(2014)

  • - 484 -

    m

    2014 1 3,580

    - 8,330 , 5,250

    - ,

    2

    - The Safety and Security Resource Guide

    4~5%

    2017 6 17 (Andino) 2

    - 250

    - (FENALCO) ,

    CCTV

    -

    CCTV

    - , ,

    -

    -

    - , , ,

  • - 485 -

    m

    , 30%

    -

    - ,

    5 95)

    -

    -

    -

    - , ,

    ,

    -

    -

    , ,

    -

    -

    ,

    95) Banco de Repblica , colombiadigital.net

  • - 486 -

    )

    m

    - CCTV

    - , , , ,

    ,

    CCTV ,

    - ,

    - , ,

    , ,

    CCTV 50%

    , ,

    - 1%

    - CCTV 98.84% LG

    , 2017 CCTV 2013 99% 96)

    - CCTV - FTA

    - (UNMAS) "

    "

    -

    96) KOTRA , CCTV , 2017 (http://news.kotra.or.kr/user/globalAllBbs/kotranews/album/2/globalBbsDataAllView.do?dataIdx=159447&column=title&search=&searchAreaCd=&searchNationCd=&searchTradeCd=&searchStartDate=&searchEndDate=&searchCategoryIdxs=&searchIndustryCateIdx=&page=1&row=10 )

  • - 487 -

    CCTV

    - CCTV 2014 1.2% 2016

    0.7%

    : 1.2%(2014) 0.8%(2015)

    0.7%(2016)

    4G

    5,524km 10m CCTV

    CCTV (HS Code 852580)

    2016 2017 4

    1 7,046 9,143

    2 1,132 913

    3 1,007 1,297

    4 468 1208

    5 432 11

    6 374 726

    7 212 470

    8 113 64

    9 110 114

    10 87 30

    ( : )

    : SCIEX

  • - 488 -

    CCTV (2014~2017 4)

    : SCIEX

    m

    -

    ,

    -

    -

    )

    m

    , , , , ,

    -

  • - 489 -

    ,

    - 2016 , , 3,500-3,600

    - ,

    - 2012 9 Kaspersky Lab , 1~9

    39% ,

    Microsoft ,

    2 CyberArk

    -

    - 2-3% 10-11% ,

    1 7-8%

    5

    - 1~10 500 50

    - 500 100~249

  • - 490 -

    2014 2015 2016 2017() 2018()

    5,007 5,232 5,433 5,625 5,863

    1,080 1,115 1,148 1,218 1,297

    / 0.22 0.21 0.21 0.22 0.22

    / 12,679 12,524 12,423 12,729 13,008

    85,175 89,003 92,416 95,684 99,721/ 17.0 17.0 17.0 17.0 17.0

    : Barnes Reports, '2017 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2015.12)

    2015

    -

    2015

    () () ()

    705 76.5 13,779

    1,641 218.5 10,545

    106 39.2 3,981

    207 266.3 7,208

    850 476.8 45,644

    322 23.3 3,072

    223 18.3 2,913

    26 1.2 196

    1,486 66.2 7,949

    : Barnes Reports, '2017 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2015.12)

    - 50 100

    , 2014 250

    300

  • - 491 -

    ()

    1-4

    5-9

    10-19

    20-49

    50-99

    100-249

    250-499

    500

    2016 415 185 215 238 163 165 62 37 3,952 5,433

    2017 430 192 223 247 169 171 64 38 4,091 5,625

    2018 448 200 232 257 176 178 67 40 4,264 5,863

    ( )2016 6 7 20 59 89 242 307 390 29 1,148

    2017 6 7 21 63 94 258 327 410 31 1,218

    2018 7 8 23 67 101 276 350 433 34 1,297

    ()2016 1,038 1,074 2,930 7,166 9,699 20,843 18,087 27,627 3,952 92,416

    2017 1,075 1,112 3,034 7,420 10,042 21,580 18,726 28,604 4,091 95,684

    2018 1,120 1,159 3,162 7,733 10,466 22,490 19,516 29,811 4,264 99,721

    : Barnes Reports, 2017 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2015.12)

    m

    7TECH SECURITY S.A.S: , , CCTV,

    AGM BUSINESS LTDA: , CCTV,

    CIBERSOFTWARE AUTOMATIZACION LTDA: , ,

    H/W S/W

    COLVISEG DEL SARIBE LTDA: , , , , ,

    DOINTECH AUTOMATIZACION S.A.S: , ,

    ,

    FERTOX TECNOLOGIA LTDA: , , ,

    ,

    GLOBAL NETWORK SYSTEMS S.A.S: , ,

  • - 492 -

    , WIFI , CCTV, POS

    HELITEB S.A.S: , , , WIFI,

    CCTV, POS

    MARNELL SECURITY LTDA: , , CCTV,

    NAVARANDA TECHNOLOGY S,A,S: , , CCTV, ,

    OPTELCOM S.A.S: , , ,

    , ,

    OPV SECURITY TECH S.A.S

    ROBOTEC COLOMBIA S.A.S: 27 , , /

    SEGURIDAD FORT S.A: (CCTV, ,

    , , ),

    ASEGURIDAD TECNICA COLOMBIANA SEGURTEC LTDA: , ,

    CCTV, , , ,

    )

    2016 (FARC) 2017 6

    FARC

    - ,

    ,

    -

    -

    -

    - ELN

  • - 493 -

    FARC ELN

    -

    - (FARC-EP) (ELN)

    ,

    - ,

    ,

  • - 494 -

    3)

    )

    m

    - : Ley Estatutaria No. 184/10 Senado 046/10 Camara

    - 2011 10 2012 10

    17 (La Proteccion de datos personales ; Ley 1581

    del 17 de Octubre de 2012)

    - Ley No. 1266 (2008)

    - 2008 5 (CRC: Comisin de Regulacin de Comunicaciones)

    - : Let 1581(2012. 10.17) , Decreto No. 1377((2013. 06. 27)

    -

    - Ley No. 1273(2009. 01. 05)

    -

    -

    - Ley No. 1266 (2008.12): , , ,

  • - 495 -

    m

    q

    EU

    q

    5

    ,

    1377

    1377 26,27

    3

    , , ,

  • - 496 -

    ,

    ,

    q

    269A : -

    48 96

    10%

    269B :

    48 96 10%

    269C : -

    36 72

    269D : -

    , , , 48 96

    10%

    269E : -

    , , , , 48

    96 10%

    269F : - , 3

    , , . , , , , , , ,

    48 96 10%

  • - 497 -

    269G : -

    , , , , , , 48

    96 10%

    269H :

    - 3/8

    ,

    3

    ,

    3

    3

    )

    (MINTIC : Ministerio de Tecnoligas de la Informacin y las Comunicaciones)

    -

    - - (CSIRT-CCIT :

    Centro de Coordinacin Seguridad Informtica Colombia- Camara Clombiana de Informtica y Telecomunicaciones)

    : - (CSIRT-CCIT : Centro de Coordinacin Seguridad Informtica Colombia-Camara Clombiana de Informtica y Telecomunicaciones)97)

    97) www.csirt-ccit.org.co

  • - 498 -

    -

    - (ATcsirt-ccit.org.co)

    - ( )

    -

    (CERT Colombiana)

    -

    - , DNS ,

    - (Camara Clombiana de Informtica y Telecomunicaciones)

    CSIRT-Ponal, ETB

    CSIRT-ETB(Computer Security Incident Response Team - Empresa de

    Telecomunicaciones de Bogot S.A.)

    )

    : ONAC(Organismo Nacional de Acreditacion de Clombia)

    - : www.onac.org.co

    - e-Mail : onac@onac.org.co

    - PBX : 742 7592

    - , , , ,

    ,

    -

    - ) SGS Colombia : www.sgs.co

  • - 499 -

    )

    FARC

    - FARC (2016. 8. 24) 9 26

    (Cartajena)

    - 2016 10 2

    2016 11

    - ,

    - 2018 5

    -

    - , ,

    -

    3 98)

    (ELN)

    - 2017 2 7 (ELN)

    , FARC ELN

    99)

    - 2012

    2015 96,084 100)

    - 2 42% .

    - 2016 188 .

    98) KOTRA , 2017 , 2016.1199) , , 2017.03.100) The Guardian, Colombias coca production soars to highest level in two decades, US says, 2017

    (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/14/colombia-coca-cocaine-us-drugs)

  • - 500 -

    - , 30

    () 2015 10 1

    - ,

    -

    -

    - ,

    - - 2015 8 19

    - 2016 7 10

    12 , 35

    -

    - ,

    ,

    2017 8

    - 2017 8 16 ~ 18 2017

  • - 501 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 0.367 81 ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.367 81

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 30%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.35 56 8.84 1

    (Access) 6.81 61 8.99 8(Use) 4.91 64 8.57 3(Skills) 8.30 25 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.367 81 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.695 42 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 4.6 38 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) ,

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 3,446 19.2 28,036 56.1 2,887 16.0 20,556 41.1 22,974 127.1 61,296 122.7 66.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 251.2

    '17 () 17,789

  • - 502 -

    1)

    )

    5 2

    101),

    - (Santiago Chamber of Commerce) , 2017

    B2B 2012 12 33

    - , 2014 12 4,000 20

    - Kaspersky 2014 ,

    (2014)

    (%) ()

    32 22,123

    28.7 4,537

    28.5 930

    27 17,514

    26.5 458

    25.4 440

    24.9 311

    24.6 3,157

    24.4 4,992

    24.2 1,813

    : Kaspersky Lab Report 2014

    101) KOTRA (2015)

  • - 503 -

    ,

    - (Bureau of Diplomatic Security) Chile 2017 Crime & Safety

    Report ,

    -

    - CCTV 20%

    ,

    - ,

    - (US Department of Commerce) , 2017

    GDP 3%

    - 2020, 4.5%

    , 7~8%

    - , 2015

    2020

    m

    ,

    0.367 81

    : ITU, Global Cybersecurity Index (GCI) 2017

  • - 504 -

    -

    -

    ITU

    -

    - ,

    GCI 2016

    0.66 28

    0.647 29

    0.593 38

    0.569 46

    0.485 62

    0.482 63

    0.466 66

    0.374 79

    0.372 80

    0.367 81

    : ITU, Global Cybersecurity Index (GCI) 2017

    )

    ,

    - 2016

  • - 505 -

    -

    (2001-2017)

    ( )

    2001 0.067 1.60% n/a

    2002 0.188 4.30% 182%

    2003 0.352 7.90% 87%

    2004 0.479 10.60% 36%

    2005 0.757 15.50% 48%

    2006 1.087 21.70% 43%

    2007 1.332 27.30% 29%

    2008 1.439 29.20% 10%

    2009 1.695 33.10% 18%

    2010 1.819 35.10% 7%

    2011 2.025 38.80% 11%

    2012 2.186 40.90% 8%

    2013 2.31 41.40% 5%

    2014 2.503 43.30% 8%

    2015 2.729 48.50% 9%

    2016() 2.904 50.80% 6.80%

    2017() 3.09 53.20% 6.20%

    : Subtel, BuddeComm (2017)

    ,

    - 40 %

    ,

    50% ,

  • - 506 -

    VTR, Movistar, Entel,

    GTD Manqueshue 25 , Movistar, VTR, Claro 80%

    (2007-2015)

    Movistar VTR Claro GTD

    2007 46.0% 39.0% 1.0% 7.0%

    2008 46.0% 41.0% 1.0% 8.0%

    2009 45.0% 39.0% 6.0% 8.0%

    2010 43.0% 38.0% 7.0% 8.0%

    2011 42.0% 38.0% 10.0% 8.0%

    2012 41.0% 37.0% 10.0% 8.0%

    2013 39.1% 38.2% 11.3% 7.8%

    2014 39.0% 37.2% 11.2% 8.4%

    2015 37.8% 36.7% 11.9% 8.7%

    : Subtel, BuddeComm (2017)

    -

    ,

    ,

    - ,

    (2016)

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    3,446 19.2 28,883 58.1

    22,974 127.1 58,935 118.5

    : ITU Statistics DB (2017.6)

  • - 507 -

    4G

    - 2015 2 , LTE 50% 4G

    3G

    - 2017 Movistar, Claro, Entel 700 4G

    ,

    - 700 4G ,

    - 4G 1,281 13 4G

    - 2014 20.2% 19.2 %

    - 100 2010 115.8% 2014 133.3%

    , 2016 127.1%

    -

    100 100

    2010 2014 2016 2010 2014 2016

    20.2 19.2 19.2 115.8 133.3 127.1

    5.6 5.4 5.2 91.7 105.6 104.8

    15.5 14.7 14.2 95.8 113.1 117.1

    10.8 9.9 9.7 99.5 105.8 117.1

    22.7 17.8 16.3 67.0 143.8 159.2

    4.4 5.5 5.8 68.1 114.6 122.1

    21.6 21.8 20.4 100.9 139.6 118.9

    : ITU Statistics DB (2017.6)

  • - 508 -

    ,

    - ITU 16%,

    -

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    1,789,355(10.43)

    2,011,244(11,62)

    2,166,330(12.40)

    2,295,169(13.03)

    2,489,717(14.01)

    2,719,439(15.17)

    2,887,000(15.97)

    2,643,033

    (5.69)3,348,142

    (7.11)3,938,657

    (8.26)4,537,621

    (9.39)5,028,595(10.28)

    5,525,511(11.16)

    5,192,968(11.80)

    396,262(8.49)

    419,782(8.86)

    448,594(9.34)

    484,883(9.95)

    515,859(10.45)

    558,656(11.17)

    587,000(11.59)

    73,279(1.26)

    85,092(1.44)

    101,312(1.69)

    131,687(2.17)

    111,409(1.81)

    116,308(1.86)

    177,024(2.79)

    89,493(1.39)

    120,101(1.83)

    136,152(2.04)

    156,576(2.30)

    185,125(2.68)

    220,858(3.14)

    239,499(3.35)

    932,503(3.19)

    1,211,767(4.09)

    1,442,784(4.81)

    1,612,812(5.31)

    1,767,057(5.74)

    1,999,459(6.42)

    2,120,762(6.72)

    (: , %)

    ) ( )

    : ITU Statistics DB (2017.6)

    ITU 2015 ICT

    ,

    - ITU 16%

    2016 GDP 102)

    31.22%

    - 2010 ,

    102) 2016 GDP

  • - 509 -

    ICT

    ICT (2016)

    2016 2015 2015

    47 6.79 6.44 49

    55 6.52 6.21 56

    56 6.35 6.11 57

    57 6.3 6.03 59

    63 5.99 5.72 65

    64 5.98 5.8 63

    79 5.27 5.22 75

    83 5.16 4.98 81

    92 4.87 4.45 96

    93 4.87 4.63 91

    98 4.56 4.54 94

    101 4.42 4.23 100

    109 4.08 3.88 107

    111 4.02 3.49 117

    118 3.73 3.64 113

    126 3.09 3 124

    131 2.88 2.74 130

    135 2.73 2.64 133

    : ITU, 'Measuring the Information Society Report 2016'(2017.6)

  • - 510 -

    2)

    )

    m

    (US Department of Commerce) ,

    2014 2% ,

    GDP

    - 2012 2013 14% ,

    3

    - 2017 , , ,

    ,

    - ,

    - , , ,

    , , CCTV

    ,

    - , 2015 ,

    28% , , , 22%, 8%, 3%

    -

    , 2006 -

    - DVR, CCTV

    , , CCTV

  • - 511 -

    CCTV ( ) (2013-2016)

    ( : , %)

    2013 2014 2015 2016

    85.4 71.5% 65.5 65.3% 52.2 66.1% 35.6 59.6%

    12.0 10.0% 9.8 9.8% 8.4 10.6% 10.6 17.7%

    8.3 7.0% 6.7 6.7% 4.3 5.5% 6.6 11.1%

    11.7 9.8% 13.4 13.3% 9.7 12.3% 4.4 7.3%

    1.9 1.6% 5.0 5.0% 4.3 5.4% 2.5 4.2%

    : UN Comtrade Database

    (2013-2016)

    ( : , %)

    2013 2014 2015 2016

    16.69 85% 14.89 87% 16.78 87% 17.44 89% 0.87 4% 0.72 4% 1.05 5% 0.44 2%

    0.02 0% 0.01 0% 0.01 0% 0.01 0% 0.06 0% 0.17 1% 0.03 0% 0.10 0% 1.94 10% 1.36 8% 1.35 7% 1.56 8%

    : UN Comtrade Database

    -

    - ,

    , ,

    -

    - /

    -

  • - 512 -

    - (Mapuche)

    , ,

    -

    - ,

    2020 , ,

    -

    103)

    - , ,

    B2C

    3

    - 6.2% ,

    3

    m

    3

    - 2014 2 5,000 15%

    2016 3

    - 2014 , 8,500 , 1 6,300

    - , 3

    - , ICT

    - ICT

    103) KOTRA

  • - 513 -

    (2014)

    ( : )

    730.5 1,157.5 1,888.0

    387.1 613.4 1,000.5

    85.1 162.5 247.7

    68.8 123.4 192.2

    52.5 83.3 135.8

    37.4 59.2 96.6

    7.5 13.5 20.9

    605.2 1,217.4 1,822.6

    1,966.6 3,416.7 5,283.3

    : KISA, ' '(2015.9)

    - , , ,

    -

    - ,

    ,

    - 5 11%

    2014 12 4,000 104)

    -

    m

    10%

    -

    104)

  • - 514 -

    -

    ICT 4G

    ,

    )

    - ,

    -

    ,

    CCTV

    -

    - 1,560

  • - 515 -

    CCTV 10 (2016) (HS 852580)

    (US$)

    1 35,600,539 47.9%

    2 10,594,075 14.3%

    3 6,605,801 8.9%

    4 4,386,753 5.9%

    5 2,519,476 3.4%

    6 1,784,139 2.4%

    7 1,211,071 1.6%

    8 1,105,012 1.5%

    9 918,925 1.2%

    10 858,198 1.2%

    : UN Comtrade DB

    -

    , A/S

    - A./S

    - ,

    ,

    -

    CIF 19% ,

  • - 516 -

    )

    m

    2016 2,515

    - 100

    120

    m

    2-3%

    - 2014/15 7.8%

    2-3% ,

    10-12%

    - 7-8%

    2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    1,337 1,365 1,402 1,511 1,564

    $ 268 296 327 364 407

    / $ 0.20 0.22 0.23 0.24 0.26

    / $ 38,118 41,117 44,281 47.928 51,820

    7,041 7,189 7,385 7,590 7,852

    / 5.3 5.3 5.3 5.0 5.0

    : Barnes Reports, '2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2014.12)

  • - 517 -

    -

    1-4

    , 500 1

    - 250 3,000-5,000

    100

    - 20-49 250

    300 600

    - , ,

    ()

    1-4

    5-9

    10-19

    20-49

    50-99

    100-249

    250-499

    500

    2014 209 73 59 41 14 8 1 1 998 1,402

    2015 225 78 64 44 15 8 1 1 1,075 1,511

    2016 233 81 66 45 25 8 1 1 1,112 1,564

    ($)

    2014 17 16 32 58 43 64 33 48 17 327

    2015 19 17 36 65 48 71 37 52 19 364

    2016 21 19 40 72 53 80 41 58 21 407

    ()

    2014 582 468 896 1,356 899 1,056 373 646 1,110 7,385

    2015 598 481 920 1,394 924 1,085 384 664 1,140 7,590

    2016 618 498 952 1,442 955 1,123 397 687 1,180 7,852

    : Barnes Reports, '2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2014.12)

  • - 518 -

    AUTOMATEC:

    CASMAR ELECTRONICA CHILE S.A: . , .

    DAVANTEC TECNOLOGIAS Y CONSULTORIAS LIMITIDA: , CCTV

    LABORATORIO LABEE CHILE LTDA: , CCTV, ,

    , , ,

    SEGURIDAD, INFORMATICA Y TELECOMUNICACIONES LTDA

    SEING INGENIERIA S.A : , CCTV, ,

    SERCATEL SPA: , , ,

    SUPPORT SERVICES LIMITIDA :

    TECSEL LTDA.: CCTV, , , ,

    VISION SEGURIDAD INTEGRAL LTDA: CCTV, , ,

    ,

    )

    2020

    - 2015

    , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    - 2020

    ,

  • - 519 -

    -

    2017 1

    - ,

    -

    - 2017 12 2018 3

    (Mapuche)

    - ,

    - ,

    - ,

    2013 , (Michell Bachelet)

    , 2017

    5

    - , 3

    39 ,

  • - 520 -

    3)

    )

    m

    - : Ley 19223 (1993. 06. 07)

    - : (Ministerio de Justicia)

    - ,

    ,

    - : Ley 19799(2002. 03. 25)

    - : (Ministerio de Economa, Fomento y Reconstruccin) - . ,

    (Ley de Proteccin de Datos de Carcter Personal) - : Ley No. 19628 (1999. 08. 18)

    - : (Ministerio de Secretaria General de al Presidencia)

    - ,

    - , , , , ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    -

    2018 3

    - Alejandro Micco

  • - 521 -

    ,

    m

    - (TIC)

    , ,

    - (TIC)

    , ,

    -

    - , , , , , , ,

    -

    -

    -

    105)

    - 83(Decreto Supuremo No. 83, 2005)

    , ,

    -

    - 3 , , , ,

    - 3

    -

    -

    ,

    -

    105)(web.minsal.cl)

  • - 522 -

    )

    m

    ((Ministerio de Secretaria General de al Presidencia)

    - ,

    ,

    (Mnisterio del Interior y Seguridad Pblica) -

    -

    (Ministerio de Economa, Fomento y Reconstruccin)106) - ,

    m

    (CSIRT)107)

    - :

    -

    (www.internetsegura,cl)

    - : , , ,

    106) www.economia.gob.cl107) www.csirt.gob.cl

  • - 523 -

    (Subsecretaria del Ministerio de Economa, Fomento y Reconstruccin) - ,

    (Carabineros de Chile)

    - :

    -

    e-Mail : os10per@carabineros.cl

    : www.carabineros.cl

    Contact Point : Teniente Jorge Muoz Tel : 56) 2 670 1456

    )

    -

    - , EU UL CE

    )

    (Expo Hospital 2017) .

    - 1

    (ICT)

  • - 524 -

    - 2015 4 (MOU)

    , 150 ICT

    ,

    -

    - 2017 7 31, -

    -

    2020 5 63 ,

    - 6 () (

    ) ()

    - 2017 8 28, 800 (Los Rios)

    29

    -

    (Araucania)

    - (Araucania)

  • - 525 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.146 125

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 20%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 2.88 131 8.84 1

    (Access) 4.08 124 8.99 8(Use) 1.00 151 8.57 3(Skills) 4.23 124 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.146 125 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.380 123 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 2.8 128 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 366 5.78 28,035 56.1 177 2.79 20,555 41.1 7,745 122.1 61,295 122.6 24.6% 92.7%

    16 GDP() 7.57

    '16 () 5,967

  • - 526 -

    1)

    )

    ,

    - 60%

    - 2014

    - (Daniel Ortega)

    - 2016 11 ,

    - 2014 53%

    - 54%

    , 108)

    -

    1%

    - 20% 16%

    -

    - CCTV DVR

    108) http://revistaitnow.com/nicaragua

  • - 527 -

    )

    m 109)

    - 100 (teledensity) 5.7%

    2017 2%

    - 2009

    (TELCOR)

    - 368 30 , 71

    , 133,000

    2010 2011 2013 2015 2016

    258,325 287,618 324,917 354,017 366,636

    100 4.4 4.9 5.4 5.7 5.8

    -

    -

    -

    3,962.247

    (35,585)

    (3,627,913)

    (297,555)

    4,823,534

    (41,547)

    (4,512,137)

    (266,537)

    6,808,930

    (1,643)

    (6,344,451)

    (396.701)

    7,264,151 7,745,512

    100 68.1 81.9 112.0 116.1 122.1

    73,279 85,092 131,687 116,308 177,024

    100 1.3 1.4 2.2 1.9 2.8

    : , Plan de buen gobierno 2016, ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    109) BuddeComm(2017.6), ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 528 -

    2016 36

    - ITU 2006 247,862 2016

    366,636 48% 100 5.7

    -

    , 2016 774

    122.14%

    -

    - ,

    America Movil(Claro), Telefonica(Movistar), Xinwei Intelcom

    Telssa, Newcom Nicaragua, Siemens Enterprise S.A.

    - Xinwei

    2016 110)

    - Amrica Mvil Claro , , TV

    - Telefnica Movistar Claro 1/3 10%

    - 64%

    36%

    - spread spectrum cable

    coaxial 38.3%, XDSL 29.1% 111)

    110) www.telcor.gob.ni111)

  • - 529 -

    - 2016 1,194,300 , 19.4%

    Dial Up (Movil) (Fix)

    2006 16.2 15.5 68.3

    2010 - 35.0 65.0

    2011 - 36.0 64.0

    : , Plan de buen gobierno 2016

    m

    ITU

    100 2.79 BuddeComm 1.9%

    -

    - 2016 11 2018 3,500km

    (Inter-American Development Bank,

    IDB) 1

    - Caribbean Regional Communications Infrastructure Program(CARCIP)

  • - 530 -

    (: , %)

    2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

    2,011,244(11,62)

    2,166,330(12.40)

    2,295,169(13.03)

    2,489,717(14.01)

    2,719,439(15.17)

    2887000 (15.97)

    3,348,142

    (7.11)3,938,657

    (8.26)4,537,621

    (9.39)5,028,595(10.28)

    5,525,511(11.16)

    5,912,968 (11.80)

    419,782(8.86)

    448,594(9.34)

    484,883(9.95)

    515,859(10.45)

    558,656(11.17)

    587,000 (11.59)

    2,243,036

    (4.09)2,390,778

    (4.81)2,563,356

    (5.31)2,723,502

    (5.74)3,142,281

    (6.42)2,120,762

    (6.72)

    120,101(1.83)

    136,152(2.04)

    156,576(2.30)

    185,125(2.68)

    220,858(3.14)

    239,499 (3.35)

    85,092(1.44)

    101,312(1.69)

    131,687(2.17)

    111,409(1.81)

    116,308(1.86)

    177,024 (2.79)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    100

    - 2014 1.4

    -

    , 2017

    100

    100

    2010 2016 2010 2014

    1.4 3.6 2.7 4.2

    5.7 11.8 2.4 45.1

    10.4 15.9 8.4 50.5

    3.2 6.7 0.9 13.7

    8.5 11.6 7.2 56.9

    1.3 2.8 0.7 1.4

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 531 -

    m ITU

    ITU

    2010 , ,

    (Least connected countries)

    -

    ICT (2016)

    ICT

    47(52)6.79(5,12)

    48(55)

    7.25(6,15)

    39(51)

    6.2(2.63)

    62(43)

    7.02(8.39)

    55(54)6.52(5.02)

    65(59)

    6.70(5.94)

    57(62)

    5.45(2.22)

    28(27)

    8.18(8.76)

    56(59)6.35(4.90)

    61(65)

    6.81(5.67)

    64(57)

    4.91(2.36)

    25(39)

    8.30(8.45)

    57(80)6.30(4.07)

    73(83)

    6.44(4.55)

    48(73)

    5.80(1.93)

    61(68)

    7.04(7.38)

    63(73)5.99(4.29)

    74(76)

    6.42(5.01)

    52(68)

    5.60(2.31)

    91(74)

    5.89(7.23)

    83(83)5.16(3.92)

    86(86)

    5.83(4.36)

    86(83)

    3.85(1.61)

    74(58)

    6.44(7.62)

    92(86)4.87(3.70)

    97(94)

    5.08(4.18)

    74(81)

    4.24(1.67)

    99(98)

    5.74(6.80)

    101(101)4.42(3.38)

    104(101)

    4.80(4.04)

    106(90)

    2.94(1.37)

    69(67)

    6.60(7.40)

    109(108)4.08(3.11)

    111(109)

    4.59(3.69)

    105(108)

    2.96(0.83)

    113(105)

    5.28(6.54)

    131(123)2.88(2.40)

    124(121)

    4.08(2.84)

    151(126)

    1.0(0.43)

    124(119)

    4.23(5.47)

    ) ( ) 2010

    : ITU, Measuring the Information Society Report 2015(2017.11)

    m

  • - 532 -

    2001 2006 2010 2011 2012 17 23 25 27 29 31 27 20 20 22

    18 27 25 27 18 7 36 127 113 91

    25 104 185 218 147 1 1 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 4 2 3 2 2 2 - - 11 12 11

    : (TELCOR)

    m

    -

    - ,

    112)

    -

    -

    , ,

    ITU 125

    -

    112) www.bnamericas.com

  • - 533 -

    - IDB,

    ICT (CEABAD)

    - 2015 8 224, 2016 14 539 ,

    , ,

    -

    -

    300-400 10

    -

    2)

    )

    m

    -

    - ,

    - 53%

  • - 534 -

    - ,

    -

    -

    -

    m

    Technavio 2014

    750

    m

    10%

    -

    10% 113)

    -

    , ,

    -

    113) www.forodeseguridad.com

  • - 535 -

    -

    3,000~5,000

    114)

    )

    )

    m

    - ICT

    9

    m

    Intelligente Solution : , , CCTV, ,

    NORTHTECH S.A : , , CCTV

    , ,

    SEGURIDAD C Y B : : ,

    SEGURIDAD DELAT S.A : , , .

    114) www.forodeseguridad.com, www.centralamericadata.com

  • - 536 -

    1

    SERVIPRO S.A :

    SISTEMS ENTERPRISE S.A : , CCTV, ,

    ULTRA DE NICARAGUA S.A : CCTV, , ,

    VANGUARD SECURITY S.A. VSN : , , , CCTV,

    , ,

    WACHENHUT DE NICARAGUA S.A : ,

    )

    (TELCOR) ICT (CEABAD) KISA

    2016 6

    3)

    )

    m

    q (Ley de Acceso a la Informacin Pblica) : Ley No. 621(2007. 05.16)

    - , , , , ,

    -

    -

    -

    -

  • - 537 -

    -

    -

    q (Ley Nicaraguense de Proteccin de Datos Personales) : Ley No. 787(2012. 03. 29)

    - :

    -

    - : , , , , , ,

    - ,

    - : 3 , , , , , ,

    , ,

    m

    -

    - (CONICYT)

    (Commission for Electronic Government for NIcaragua)

    (CSIRT)

    - CONICYT

    ,

  • - 538 -

    )

    m

    q : (TELCOR ; Instituto Nicaragense de Telecomunicaciones y Correos)115)

    :

    - Decreto No. 1053(1982. 06. 05)

    - Ley No. 165, 200, 210,293, 326(2005.12.22.), 389(2006.02.06.), 573 (2007.09.16.), Ley

    de Incorporacin de Particulares en la Operacin y Ampliacin de los Servicios Pblicos de Telecomunicaciones

    :

    - , ,

    - ,

    - , ,

    -

    - (FITEL : Fondo de Inversin en Telecomunicacin) : - Decreto No. 238(2004. 12. 07)

    q

    ICT , Centro de Estudio Avanzado en Banda Ancha para el

    Desarrollo (CEABAD)

    - : ,

    , IDB,

    -

    115) www.telcor.gob.ni, Tel: 505) 2222 7350

  • - 539 -

    (CONICYT, Consejo Nicaraguense de Ciencia y Tecnologia)

    - :

    -

    ,

    -

    (COBeNIC)

    )

  • - 540 -

    )

    116)

    (2017 11 5 ) 1(PLC)

    - 2017 9 Jinotega San Jos de Bocay 1(PLC) (CxL)

    2017 7 27 4 5 Ileana Ros-Lehtinen 25

    (: Nica Act)

    - 2

    86 ICJ (80

    )

    116)

  • - 541 -

    4.

    m

    (Middle East)117) ,

    ,

    - (The Persian Gulf): (gulf)

    , UAE, , , , , ,

    - (Maghreb):

    , , , , ,

    - (Levant): , 1920

    , , , , ,

    (2016 )

    (US$ )

    (US$ )

    1974. 3 616 2,367, , , ,

    , , ,

    UAE 1980. 6 5,870 6,941, , ,

    , , LPG, ,

    1974. 4 536 10,081, , ,

    , , , , LPG,

    1962.10 3,717 4,640,

    , ,

    , , , , LPG,

    1962.10 5,644 15,742, , ,

    , , LPG,

    1962. 4 1,275 865, , ,

    , ,

    : Kotra-

    117) (Middle East) 1990 (Orient) (Near East),

    (Middle East), (Far East) .

  • - 542 -

    IDI GCC UAE,

    , , ICT

    - ICT UAE 2016 IDI

    38, 46 ICT

    ICT(IDI)

    IDI(2016) (access) (use) (skill)

    59 6.27 46 7.37 58 5.39 96 5.83

    UAE 38 7.11 24 8.14 27 6.82 105 5.63

    46 6.90 33 7.91 35 6.32 88 6.03

    89 4.99 79 6.26 110 2.74 65 6.96

    45 6.90 47 7.29 36 6.32 55 7.30

    30 7.40 18 8.28 42 6.02 22 8.38

    1 8.84 8 8.99 3 8.57 3 9.08

    : ITU, 'Measuring the Information Society Report 2016'(2016)

  • - 543 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.871 4

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 33%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.27 59 8.84 1

    (Access) 7.37 46 8.99 8(Use) 5.39 58 8.57 3(Skills) 5.83 96 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.871 4 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.596 66 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 4.3 52 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 422 9.8 28,035 56.1 266 6.2 20,555 41.1 6,866 159.2 61,295 122.7 69.8% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 71.90

    '17 () 3,424

  • - 544 -

    1)

    )

    2000

    2015

    - ITU Measuring the Information Society 2016 ,

    ICT (ICT Development Index, IDI) 175

    59 6

    -

    - IT ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    - 2015 , Symantec

    Trojan.Laziok ,

    (UAE, 25%),

    (10%), (5%) (5%)

    -

    , IT , SMAC118)

    IT

    2016 ,

    66.2% 1

    - ICT , , ,

    118) SMAC : Social. Mobile, Analytics, Cloud

  • - 545 -

    (IoT)

    ,

    (IS)

    ,

    - 2001 911 ,

    ,

    * IS

    - ,

    (Ibadi)119)

    )

    - 2016 42 ,

    26 23 15%

    - 43.98% ,

    77.62% (2015 )

    - (Telecommunications Regulatory Authority, TRA) ,

    25Mbps , 10Mbps

    6750, 97% 2~10Mbps

    , IT (2015

    )

    -

    119) Ibadi : , , , , (Mzab) , , , ,

  • - 546 -

    ,

    ,

    - Netflix 2016 GCC( 6 , UAE, ,

    , ) , 25Mbps

    (ultra high dehinition service)

    - (National Broadband Strategy)

    (Oman Broadband Company) 7

    , 2040

    - Omantel Ooredoo

    FTTH(fibre-to-the-home)

    - Omantel 51% , 2015

    1 2,000 ( 3 1,170 )

    - 2014 Omantel (TRA) 250

    104

    - Ooredoo 5,500km 1 2,500 ( 3

    2,460 ) , 120

    enclave Musandam( UAE ) Madha 800

    - ITU 2016

    686 159.2%

    - Oman Mobile Ooredoo 2 ,

    Oman Mobile 272 (2013 12), Ooredoo 247

    (2014 2)

    - Oman Mobile Omantel 99%

    , GSM-900MHz(GPRS, EDGE), 900/2,100MHz UMTS,

    HSPA+, 1,800MHz FD-LTE, 2,300MHz TD-LTE

    * Omantel 51%

  • - 547 -

    - Omantel(Oman Mobile) Ooredoo 800MHz 2.6GHz

    , 4G LTE

    - (Ministry of Transport and Communications) 2016

    3 ,

    (: , %)

    2005 2010 2015 2016

    13 0.5 59 2.1 233 5.6 266 6.2

    265 10.5 284 10.1 435 10.5 422 9.8

    1,333 52.9 4,606 164.3 6,647 159.9 6,866 159.2

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 548 -

    2)

    )

    m

    IT Information Technology Authority(ITA)

    , ITA Centre of Information Security(CIS)

    (OCERT)

    - ITA 2015 (KISA)

    - CIS IT ,

    - (Information Technology Authority, ITA) ,

    2015 500 , ITA Information

    Security Devision 480

    39 8,000

    -

    - ITA () ,

    1980

    ,

    - GCC120)

    120) GCC(Gulf Cooperation Council): . 6 1981

  • - 549 -

    , Foreign Military Financing(FMF)

    - F-16 , ,

    , , , / ,

    , , , ICT

    - ICT ,

    (Petroleum Development Oman, PDO) , ,

    ICT

    - , , CCTV

    ,

    ROP( ), RPO( ), (Sultan Armed Forces),

    , , ,

    , , , ,

    : KOTRA, CCTV (2014)

    75%

    10%

    10%

    5%

    : KOTRA, CCTV (2014)

  • - 550 -

    m

    2,550 ,

    4,830 7,380

    - , 400

    GCC 7,000

    (2014 )

    (: )

    25.5 48.3 73.8

    : KISA, (2015.9)

    ITU 2016 (Global Cyber

    security Index, GCI) 6 4.94

    6.27

    - , , ,

    ,

    - Ernst and Young(EY)

    (Global Information Security Survey, GISS) ,

    , , , , , ,

    - IT (OCERT)

    ,

    350

    121) 400

  • - 551 -

    - CCTV

    - ,

    ,

    OCERT 2015 (Security

    Threat Notification and Alerts, TNAS) 1,292 , 449

    - , (ITA) 2015

    509

    2015

    2015 () 1 2 3 4

    509 139 107 86 177

    : Information Technology Authority

    121) (2014), "KISA, ", ZDnet Korea, 2014.10.24

  • - 552 -

    m

    GCC

    2014~2017 GCC 40%

    - 2014~2017

    GCC 8 3,400

    15%

    GCC (2014~2017)

    (: )

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

    GCC 2014~2017 42 ,

    5.41

    GCC (2014~2017 )

    (: )

    UAE

    1,299 (31%) 994 (24%) 595 (14%) 569 (14%) 541 (13%)

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

  • - 553 -

    )

    m

    GCC CCTV , 2~3

    ( ), IPTEC, Pinetron, Camtron

    - ()

    - ,

    ()

    ,

    - , ,

    ZKTeco(), Matrix Security

    Solutions(), HID Secure()

    m

    () Kaspersky

    Lab Symantec Norton

    - , Dell Cisco

    Cyberoam

    - ,

    (IT )

    IT

    - (ITA) 2015 (KISA)

  • - 554 -

    112

    - , ,

    ( ) IT

    - , Ooredoo 2015 5

    DDoS

    )

    m

    ,

    ,

    - Thales Lockheed Martin

    - ,

    UAE,

    ,

    m

    q

    IT

    ,

    - IT ,

    ( ) UAE

  • - 555 -

    IT

    UAE 2014 70 IT ,

    3

    UAE UAE

    5%

    IT

    ITWork IT ,

    Khimji Ramdas IBM IT

    OHI Electronics Hangzhou HikVision

    Al Seeb Technical

    Establishment IT

    SACTECH , IT

    : KOTRA (2016.10)

    - IT , ,

    2009 FTA

    3 IT FTA

    q ( )

    First Information Security (First Info Sec)

    - , ,

    ,

    - MENA , 2008

    - , , , UAE,

    Sachin Technologies LLC (SACTECH)

    - , , , , , , , , ,

    Fortune 500

  • - 556 -

    Vision Innovative Technologies LLC (VIT)

    - 2007 , CCTV

    - , , , , CCTV

    ,

    Gulf Business Machines (GBM) Oman

    - 1990 IBM IT 1,200

    (, , , , )

    - UAE (), UAE(, ), ,

    , , ,

    - ,

    , ,

    - GBM Oman ,

    1990

    Thales

    - 1970

    , 135

    - (Ministry of Transport and Communication, MOTC),

    (Oman Air), (Omani Armed Forces) the Security Agencies

    of Oman , , ,

  • - 557 -

    )

    OCERT FIRST(Forum of Incident Response and Security Teams)

    (2017.6)

    - FIRST ,

    -

    , , ,

    Thales, 2014 , Musat

    Grand Mall Al Tilal Complex ,

    (2015. 7)

    - 2015

    Master System Integrator(MSI) ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    - ,

    , 1,200

    - 2015 6 15

    1

    - A380

    Oman Airports Management Company(OAMC)

    Lockheed

    Martin BEONTRA Suite (2016. 3)

    - Oman Air

    Oman Airports Management Company (OAMC)

    BEONTRA Lockheed Martin 7

    - 2015 1,000 ,

    OAMC 2020 18% TOP

    20

  • - 558 -

    - OAMC BEONTRA Tool ,

    -, (2015. 10)

    - ,

    ,

    - , ,

    ,

    (OCert) NTRA(National Telecom Regulatory

    Authority) Egypt, Nispana

    (2016. 8)

    - 2016 10 30 ~ 11 1 5 Regional Cyber Security

    ,

    - ITU-Arab Regional Cybersecurity Center (ITU-ARCC)

    22

    3)

    )

    m

    (Electronic Transactions Law)

    - Royal Decree 69/2008

    - ,

    , , ,

    , , ,

  • - 559 -

    -

    , ,

    ,

    (Cyber Crime Law)

    - (Royal Decree No 12/2011)

    , ITA IT

    - , &

    (Personal Data Protection Law)

    -

    -

    (Royal Decree No 101/1996)

    (Criminal Protection Law )

    - (Oman Information Technology Authority, ITA)

    3

    2017 11

    (Telecom Act)

    - 2002 Royal Decree No. 30/2002 ,

    -

    ,

    ,

  • - 560 -

    (E-Commerce)

    - (ITA) 2006

    - 2008 E-Commerce

    m

    (eGovernment Transformation Plan)

    -

    2008

    ,

    ,

    - 2012 6 12, (eGovernment Transformation

    Strategy)

    (eService) ITA

    - eService ,

    - eGovernment Transformation ePresence Stage (2013 6),

    Interaction Stage (2013 12), Transactions Stage (2014 12),

    Transformation Stage (2015 12), eParticipation Stage( ),

    eBorder/eRegional Stage ( ) 6

    (National Infrastructure Development); PKI

    - ITA , eVisa, Public Key Infrastructure(PKI),

    ePayment Gateway, National Data Center, Oman Government Network,

    National Contact Center

    - , PKI (National Digital Certification

    Center, NDCC) ,

    - 2015 NDCC ITA 13 PKI ,

    ID/

  • - 561 -

    PKI

    (Time Stamping)

    OCSP PKI

    - NDCC 12 (Ministry of Commerce and

    Industry, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Manpower, Bank Dhofar,

    Public Prosecution, Muscat Municipality, Al Raffd Fund, National Center

    for Statistics & Information, ROP DG of Customs, Public Authority for

    Social Insurance, ITA, Ministry of Environment and Climate Affairs)

    22 PKI

    - ID/( ) 6 Omantel

    Ooredoo PKI SIM 1,271 MPKI(Mobile PKI)

    SSL 91 PKI

    86

    (Oman eGovernance Framework)

    - Oman eGovernance Framework eOman

    - IT IT

    IT

  • - 562 -

    : Oman Information Technology Authority(ITA)

    )

    (OMAN National Computer Emergency Response

    Team, OCERT)

    -

    2010 4 IT

    - OCERT e-service

    R&D

    CERTs

  • - 563 -

    - OCERT Training & Awareness Proactive Service Reactive

    Service 3 30

    - Proactive Service

    , Reactive

    Service

    Oman National CERT (OCERT)

    - OCERT OIC-CERT

    OIC-CERT

    - OIC-CERT , OCERT

    16,118 685

    486 OCERT

    15

    , , USB

  • - 564 -

    141 39

    OCERT (IOS 10.1, macOS, Sierra 10)

    OIC-CERT(Organization of the Islamic Cooperation Computer Emergency Response Team)

    (ISD, Information Security Division)

    - IT (ISD) e

    -

    - ISD e

    - ISD ,

    ,

    ,

    , ,

  • - 565 -

    (Telecommunications Regulatory Authority, TRA)

    - 30(Royal

    Decree No. 30/2002) (Telecommunications Act)

    2002

    - TRA ,

    -

    (Information Technology Authority, ITA)

    - (Digital Society)122)

    2006 42(No: Decree 30/2006)

    - (ITA) (Minister of National Economy, MoNE)

    eOman

    - eOman Gaboos

    bin Said ,

    --

    - , ,

    ,

    122) 2003 3, 2020(Oman Vision 2020)

  • - 566 -

    (Information Technology Authority, ITA)

    : Information Technology Authority

    (Ministry of Transport & Communications, MOTC)

    - ,

    2040 10

    - , 3

    . Ministry of transport

    and communications(MOTC)

    , Telecomm.Regulationauthority , Telecomm. service

    providers

    (National Digital Certification Center, NDCC)

    - 2013 12 24 ITA

  • - 567 -

    - eSignature

    - PKI

    )

    ,

    (UL, CE)

    ITA

    ISO 27001

    - ISO 27001

    (Network Security Standard ISO 27001)

    OCERT

    ,

    - OCERT

    - ISC, SANS EC-council

  • - 568 -

    )

    (2017.4)

    -

    (Forensic Testing) ISO/IEC 17025

    - , ISO/IEC 17025 (ITA)

    , , ,

    5

    (2016. 2)

    -

    - 2015 570 229

    ,

    ITA Ernst & Young(EY), 15 IT graduates

    MOU (2016. 1)

    - IT 15 IT IT

    - Ernst & Young IT

    , Ernst & Young ITA IT

  • - 569 -

    . UAE

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) UAE ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    UAE 0.566 47

    0.782 13

    ICT UAE ICT 20%

    UAE

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 7.11 38 8.84 1

    (Access) 8.14 24 8.99 8

    (Use) 6.82 27 8.57 3

    (Skills) 5.63 105 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.566 47 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.752 29 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.3 26 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) UAE

    UAE

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    2,286 23.4 28,036 56.1

    1,298 13.3 20,556 41.1

    19,905 204.0 61,296 122.7

    90.6% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 407.20

    '17 () 5,927

  • - 570 -

    1)

    )

    UAE

    -

    - UAE ,

    ,

    2000

    , ICT

    - UAE 7 , 2008

    2008 2030

    - 2010 2 , , IT , UAE -

    UAE Vision 2021

    - 2014 7 Vision2021 ICT

    ICT ICT Strategy 2021

    - Vision2021 UAE IT ,ICT

    Strategy 2021 2021 20

    ,

    IT , UAE

    - Symantec 2015 Internet Security Threat Report , UAE

    2015 1, 8

    - Kaspersky Security Bulletin 2016 , UAE (Banking

    Trojans) TOP 10

    - (Norton) , 2016 UAE

  • - 571 -

    253 , 20%

    - 2013 1,419 , 2011 588

    UAE ICT ,

    ,

    - 2014 3, Vision2021

    2017

    - , ,

    - 200% 100% UAE

    - 2013 10 Bain & Company UAE 15%

    ,

    - RFi 2015 UAE

    82%

    - UAE ,

    /

    UAE UAE

    ,

    - 2016 8 SDI 123) , UAE

    35 2025 46

    - 2016 2.4

    2025 3.3 3.8%

    - 2017 3 124) , 2017

    113.8 2022 221.4 14.2%

    123) SDI(Strategic Defense Intelligence), United Arab Emirates Defense Spends on Homeland Security:

    2016 to 2025, 2016.8

    124) MarketsandMarkets, Middle East Cyber Security Market by Solution, Service, Security Type,

    Deployment Mode, Organization Size, Vertical, and Country - Forecast to 2022, 2017.3

  • - 572 -

    )

    - 2016 90.6%, 358 ,

    129.8 , 228.6

    - UAE 2007 Etisalat du 2 ,

    ,

    ,

    - 2015 10 (TRA, Telecommunications Regulatory Authority)

    - Etisalat , UAE

    (%)

    ()()

    ()

    (%)

    UAE 90.6 1,297,585 2,285,809 19,905,093 91

    UAE (2016 )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - ITU UAE 2016 1,990 ,

    926 (2016 6) 214%

    - Fast Telecom , 2015 UAE

    68 Dh(), 2016 3% 70 Dh()

    - UAE WAM 125), 2017 UAE

    1,870 1,826 2.4%

    - 2017 Etisalat 1,050 3%

    , 57.5%

    - 2 Du 2017 6 820 ,

    125) Telecompaper, UAE mobile subscription base reaches 18.7 mln in H1, 2017.8.14

  • - 573 -

    1.5% 42.5%

    - 2017 317 Dh() , Etisalat 253 Dh, Du

    64 Dh, Etisalat 80%

    ( )

    EtisalatGSM-900MHz(GPRS, EDGE)2100MHz UMTS, DC-HSPA+

    1800,2600MHz LTE

    10.50(2017

    6)

    UAE (40%) (60%)

    du

    GSM-900/1800MHz(GPRS, EDGE)

    2100MHz UMTS, DC-HSPA+800, 1800MHz LTE

    8.2(2017

    6)

    UAE (39.5%) Mubadata Development

    Company(19.75%)TECOM Investments(19.5%)

    (60%)

    UAE

    : (TRA, Telecommunications Regulatory Authority)

  • - 574 -

    2)

    )

    m

    SDI United Arab Emirates Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025

    UAE (Homeland)

    d (critical Infrastructure security)

    3

    - CCTV, ,

    , (Forensic Science Laboratories)

    - (Physical Security) (Network

    Security)

    - /

    - , ID

    ,

    - , , , ID

    , , SCADA

    - , , ,

    UAE ,

    - UAE 2013 ATM

    , 4,500

    - 2014 Etisalat ,

    126)

    - 2016 6 , UAE , ,

    15% 127)

    126) KOTRA , UAE (2015)

  • - 575 -

    - Kaspersky Security Bulletin 2016 , Kaspersky Security UAE

    2.3%

    Top 10

    1 4.8% 6 2.6%2 4.7% 7 2.4%3 4.5% 8 UAE 2.3%4 4.5% 9 2.2%5 3.8% 10 2.2%

    : Kaspersky Security Bulletin 2016

    IT

    - 2017 5 31

    (Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum)

    - ,

    (Dubai Electronic Security Center)

    - IT

    UAE , ,

    - 2017 3 49 UAE(UAE Banks Federation)

    - UAE

    90 % 128)

    - , 50 %

    (60%) (63%)

    -

    127) ystat.com, Fraud and Security in Global Online Payment, 2016.10

    128) The National, 'WannaCry' online attacks a wake up call for cyber security, 2017.5.26

  • - 576 -

    m

    SDI United Arab Emirates Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025

    2016 UAE (Critical

    Infrastructure Protection Spends) 16.6

    - 13.6 , 2.4 , 6

    82%

    - 2017 13.8 , 2.5 , 6

    16.9

    - 2016~2017 , 1.3% ,

    5.1% ,

    UAE 2017 GDP 0.42%

    , 1% , ,

    - UAE , ICT

    - ,

    Kaspersky Lab UAE

    19, KPMG 2015 UAE 33%

    - UAE 10

    , UAE ICT

    NESA

    - , , ,

    , , ,

  • - 577 -

    m

    SDI , UAE 2025 22

    , 2016 2015 3.2%

    - 2025 18.1 , 3.3

    , 6

    - 2025 3.8%

    (3.2%) ,

    - UAE

    - UAE IT

    , 2018

    UAE (2016~2025)

    (: )

    2016 1362.49 236.00 60 1658.49 -

    2017 1,380.49 248.00 60 1,688.49 1.81%

    2018 1,552.59 261.00 64.00 1,877.59 11.20%

    2019 1,597.59 281.00 68.00 1,946.59 3.67%

    2020 1,636.69 303.00 71.00 2,010.69 3.29%

    2021 1,687.69 318.00 74.00 2,079.69 3.43%

    2022 1,736.79 316.00 60.00 2,112.79 1.59%

    2023 1,734.99 319.00 64.00 2,117.99 0.25%

    2024 1,781.19 336.20 68.00 2,185.39 3.18%

    2025 1,814.69 330.00 60.00 2,204.69 0.88%

    CAGR 2016~2025 3.21%

    : SDI,United Arab Emirates Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025

    UAE 2017 GCC 40%

  • - 578 -

    GCC (2014~2017)

    (: )

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

    GCC 2014~2017 42 , UAE 9.9

    GCC (2014~2017 )

    (: )

    UAE

    12.99 (31%) 9.94 (24%) 5.95 (14%) 5.69 (14%) 5.41 (13%)

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

    , , ,

    - ,

    , , , ,

    , , ICT, , , 129)

    - UAE 2014 256 , 2015

    7.3% 275 130)

    129) Newswire Today, http://www.newswiretoday.com/news/151154/

  • - 579 -

    UAE

    ( , %)

    2012 2013* 2014** 2015** 2016** 2017**

    22,527.2 24,182.3 25,655.7 27,530.0 29,455.4 31,346.7

    2.9 7.3 6.0 7.3 7.0 6.5

    : BMI, UAE Defense &Security Report (Q1, 2015), KOTRA(2015)

    ) * , **

    )

    m

    CCTV

    - UAE

    , CCTV

    - 2014 UAE

    409 50%

    - 6,000 2018 9,000

    78 , ,

    UAE

    - ,

    CCTV , GCC

    CCTV

    UAE ,

    - ,

    - 2021 UAE 2 9,300

    131), IP

    130) BMI(2015)(www.bmiresearch.com)131) 6Wresearch

  • - 580 -

    - UAE IP

    m

    ,

    - ,

    -

    UAE , , 2012

    5,300 2015 7,100 132) 2019

    7,230

    - 2014 1,290 2019 7,230

    133) 2019 12.7%

    -

    132) Kaspersky, 2012.01133) Frost &Sullivan, 2013.05

  • - 581 -

    UAE

    (: )

    : Frost & Sullivan(2013.05), KISA(2013)134)

    )

    m

    UAE ,

    - Kaspersky Lab, Trend Micro

    , /

    (1), (2)

    - , ,

    - UAE CCTV ,

    , Honeywell,

    Pelco, Bosch, Siemens, Sony, Panasonic

    CCTV 1 Hikvision, Dahua

    134) , , 2013 4

  • - 582 -

    UAE GCC , Thales,

    IBM, UTC( GE Security), Honeywell, Schneider/Pelco, Siemens, Johnson Controls,

    Cisco, ARINC Axis Communications

    - UAE GCC

    - UAE ,

    Thales(), Narus(Boeing ) ,

    - ,

    - (96), (206),

    (103)

    GCC

    : http://www.sourcesecurity.com

  • - 583 -

    2015 UAE

    Major 1: , Minor 2:

    : Barnes Reports, '2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2014.12)

    m

    Techno World LLC

    - , ,

    Open Source Computer Solutions(OSCOMP)

    - IT Consultancy, Project Management, Information Security, IT

    Infrastructure Services, Wireless & Structured Cabling, Cloud Services, PABX, IP

    Telephony, Audio/Video Solutions, CCTV / IP Security, Managed Services

    - 2003 ,

    Pan Cyber Information Technology LLC

    - 1997 , UAE

    - Pan Cyber IT ,

    VERINT Voice/Screen Recording, Quality Monitoring & Analysis,

    Thales

    - , HP Mubadala

    Development Company Injazat Data Systems

    - , 2013

    3

    ( )

    (Major 1) 1,005 322 5,135

    (Minor 2) 150 159 1,062

    & 34 11 198

    148 22 675

    33 13 152

  • - 584 -

    2013 Injazat Data Systems UAE

    Narus(Boeing )

    - 2013 11 Dubai Airshow

    - Narus Boeing, IBM,

    Maxtera, HP, NEC, Secure Tech, Giza Systems, Dell

    DarkMatter

    - DarkMatter ,

    - ,

    & SI

    Kaspersky Lab

    - , Kaspersky

    - , 37%, 30~40%

    )

    , 135)

    - 2017 5 23 Smart Grid Security Summit

    -

    , IoT

    - , 2020 100

    ,

    135) The Nation, Cyber security a priority for utilities, 2017.5.23

  • - 585 -

    du,

    - 2016 10 UAE du ,

    ,

    - du(du Enterprise Security Operations

    Center)'

    DarkMatter-Symantec,

    - 2016 4 UAE Darkmatter

    Symantec

    - DarkMatter UAE Symantec

  • - 586 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Law No.9 of 2004)

    - 2004 UAE , 1971

    (UAE Constitution of 1971) (Federal Law No.5 of 1985)

    - 2004 , 2007 4

    (DIFC Law No.1 of 2007)

    - 2004 (Office of Commissioner of Data

    Protection. DIFC)

    (Federal Law No. (1) of 2006 on Electronic Commerce and

    Transactions)

    - 37 , , , ,

    (DIFC Law No.1 of 2007)

    - 2007 (DIFC Law No.1 of 2007) , ,

    , EU (EU Directives) OECD

    - 11 12 , UAE

    (DIFC Law No.1 of 2007) UAE

    UAE

    - , UAE

    10

  • - 587 -

    - UAE , ,

    37

    (Federal Law by Decree No. 5 of 2012 regarding Cyber Crimes)

    - 2012 ,

    6, 50

    - , ,

    2015 6 UAE WhatsApp

    25

    CCTV

    - 2011 , , , ,

    CCTV

    m

    , (2017.5)

    - 2017 5 31 UAE

    (Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum)

    - 'UAE

    2021'

    -

    (Dubai Electronic Security Center)

    - (Cyber Smart Nation)

    (Innovation) (Cyber Security) (Cyber resilience)

    (National and International cooperation) 6

  • - 588 -

    : Gulf business

    UAE Vision 2021

    - 2010 UAE UAE Vision 2021 UAE -

    - (Ministry of Cabinet Affairs and the Future) ,

    , , IT IT

    , ,

    " "

    , ,

    IT

  • - 589 -

    Cabinet Resolution No. 21 of 2013 On the Regulation of Information Security at the

    Federal Entities

    - IT , IT

    - IT

    - , IT IT

    ,

    e-Security Centre(Dubai Centre)

    -

    , 2020

    Dubai Centre

    - 2014 UAE , Sheikh Mohammed bin

    Rashid Al Maktoum E-Security Dubai Centre Law no

    11/2014

    - mGovernment Magazine , Dubai Centre ,

    - Dubai Centre ,

    e-security

    )

    (Telecommunications Regulatory Authority, TRA)

    - TRA UAE Federal Law by Decree No. 3 of 2003 Telecom Law ,

    - TRA

    IT

  • - 590 -

    UAE ICT UAE R&D

    (aeCERT)

    - UAE (TRA)

    - aeCERT , ,

    4 30

    - aeCERT

    ,

    CSIRITs

    aeCERT

    (aeCERT, UAE Computer

    Emergency Response Team)

    : aeCERT

    (National Electronic Security Authority, NESA)

    - NESA UAE ,

    UAE

    - NESA UAE

    , UAE

    - NESA Compliance UAE IA(Information Assurance)

  • - 591 -

    UAE

    - NESA

    UAE IA

    (Dubai Electronic Security Center, DESC)

    - 2014 6

    ( No. 11 in 2014)

    - DESC ,

    - DESC ,

    - DESC 2017 5 (Dubai

    Cyber Security Strategy)

    )

    UAE ,

    - UAE

    UAE

    - CE(Confirmity European)

    , , ,

    - CE European Union(EU) European Free Trade Area(EFTA)

  • - 592 -

    UAE

    CE(Confirmity European), US standards

    , UL, BS, TUV

    USFDA, EU, GCC specs

    : (www.sme-export.go.kr)

    )

    UAE 7 (Sharjah) e DeG(Department of

    e-Government) TRA MoU (2017.08)

    - , ,

    - (Shikh Khalid Al Qasimi) TRA

    , ,

    TRA, IT VPN (2016.07)

    - 2016 7 TRA IT ,

    (VPN)

    - , UAE UAE WhatsApp, Snapchat,

    Viber VPN

    - TRA VPN UAE

    IP

  • - 593 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.676 25

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 20%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.90 45 8.84 1

    (Access) 7.91 33 8.99 8(Use) 6.32 35 8.57 3(Skills) 7.05 90 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.676 25 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.670 48 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 5.2 27 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 467 19.3 28,036 56.1 260 10.7 20,556 41.1 3,552 147.1 61,296 122.7 94.3% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 166.3

    '17 () 2,314

  • - 594 -

    1)

    )

    2022

    -

    2,000

    - 2,000

    - , 2006 (Q-CERT)

    ,

    - ITU 2016 , 94%,

    - 147% , 1.4

    , ICT

    - 10% ,

    , ,

    - , UAE ,

    - ,

    - 2012 RasGas , 2013

  • - 595 -

    -

    Qatar National Vision 2030

    - (National Information Security Center)

    )

    - ITU 2016

    26 , 47

    - Qatar National Vision 2030 QNBN(Qatar National

    Broadband Network)

    (%)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2002 2015

    27% 18%

    - 2002 28% 2015 17.6% ,

    2016 19.34%

  • - 596 -

    (%)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2002 42.3%% 2015 159% 2016

    147% ,

    - Ooredoo( Q-tel) Vodafone

    GSM-900/1,800 MHz (GPRS, EDGE), 2,100 MHz UMTS, HSDPA, 800/1,800 MHz

    LTE, LTE-A , Ooredoo

    LTE, LTE-A 2,600MHz

    - BuddeComm , Oredoo 2015 350 , Vodafone

    2016 154.8 136)

    136) BuddeComm, Qatar - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband - Statistics and Analyses, 2017.8.7

  • - 597 -

    (%)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    2)

    )

    m

    2013 IT Digital Qatar , (ICT)

    2011 155 (42 ) 137)

    - 2016 247 (67 ) 2011~2016 10%

    - ICT IT 2011 58 (15.76 ) 2016 117

    (31.8 ) 15%

    - 2011 97 (26.3 ) 2016 130 (35.3 )

    6%

    - IT ,

    IT 2011 37.4% 2016 47%

    137) Digital Qatar, Thinking of Investment In the ICT Sector? Think No More, 2013.5.8

  • - 598 -

    2011~2016 ICT

    : Digital Qatar, Thinking of Investment In the ICT Sector? Think No More', 2013.5.8

    Fujitsu , IT 2013 5.36

    , 2018 9.44 11.7% 138)

    2013~2018 IT ( : )

    : Mukul Naskar,IT Market in Qatar, 2015.9

    IT 2014 8.26

    138) Mukul Naskar, IT Market in Qatar, 2015.9

  • - 599 -

    - IT 2014 5.97 2019 7.06

    3.4% , 2014 2.29 2019 3.43

    8.4%

    - PC ,

    2014~2019 IT / ( : )

    : Mukul Naskar,IT Market in Qatar, 2015.9

    m

    SDI Qatar Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025

    2016 ,

    (Critical Infrastructure Protection Spends) 6.75

    - 2017 5.2 , 1.2

    , 4 6.86 1.6%

    - 2016~2018

    2017 1.55%, 2018 2.29%

    - 2017 9.17%, 2018 7.56%

  • - 600 -

    ,

    - ,

    - , , , ID

    , , SCADA

    m

    SDI , 2025 1.58%

    (2016~2025)

    (: )

    2016 516.04 109.00 40.00 675.04 -

    2017 524.04 119.00 43.00 686.04 1.6%

    2018 536.04 128.00 46.00 710.04 3.5%

    2019 505.04 128.00 40.00 673.04 -5.2%

    2020 515.04 138.00 41.00 694.04 3.1%

    2021 505.44 135.00 37.00 677.44 -2.4%

    2022 521.44 144.00 40.00 705.44 4.1%

    2023 536.44 158.00 43.00 737.44 4.5%

    2024 564.04 166.35 46.00 776.39 5.3%

    2025 576.04 161.00 40.00 777.04 0.1%

    CAGR 2016~2025 1.58%

    : SDI, Qatar Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025, 2016.10

    - 2025 5.76 , 1.6

    , 4

    - 2025 4.43% ,

    1.23%

    - 2025 (

    1.28%)

  • - 601 -

    - 2022 3.17%,

    6.67% ,

    )

    m

    CCTV

    -

    CCTV

    - CCTV 33

    15

    2010 , ,

    , , , ,

    6,650

    - 3,430 41.5%

    (1,260 , 15.2%), (520 , 6.3%), (510 , 6.2%),

    (490 , 5.9%)

    m

    - BMI 2014 2019

    14%

    - IT

    - , 2022 , ,

    , ,

  • - 602 -

    -

    - 34%

    2012~2019

    (: )

    : BMI research(2015)

    )

    m

    GCC

    -

    -

    - GCC 5

    5

    -

    GCC 5

  • - 603 -

    , , IT ,

    ,

    G4S

    m

    Bin Arbaid Group

    - , ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    Ooredoo

    - (68%)

    - , ,

    - , , , ,

    2015 9 1 1,400

    - , ,

    Informatica Qatar

    - (iQTM) ,

    IT

    - , , IT,

    Teyseer Security Service

    - 1994

    - , , , , CCTV ,

    , ,

  • - 604 -

    Arecont Vision IP, CCTV

    AxxonSoft

    LILIN CCTV

    MOBOTIX AG CCTV

    Sony Professional Solutions Europe CCTV

    TDSi

    Vicon Industries CCTV

    Avigilon Corporation CCTV

    Bosch Security Systems CCTV

    Dallmeier electronic GmbH & Co.KG CCTV

    GEUTEBRUCK GmbH CCTV

    HID Global

    Milestone Systems

    Surveon Technology Inc IP

    Vanderbilt Industries

    VIVOTEK IP

    G4S

    : www.sourcesecurity.com

    )

    2017 5 UAE (2017 5)

    - , (UAE), , 2017 6 5

    - 2017 5 24 ' '

    ,

    QNA

    - 45 " " QNA

    , ,

    (UAE), ,

  • - 605 -

    - , 2017 7 16 (WP) (UAE)

    139)

    - UAE , , 4 19 QNA

    , ID ,

    Skype

    2016 4 (QNB) 1.4GB

    - ,

    MI6

    - 40

    2015 2 2022

    - 2012

    - (Digital Defence)

    2009

    - (Qatar

    Science and Technology Park, QSTP)

    - Cisco Microsoft

    QSTP

    - QSTP

    139) Washington Post, UAE orchestrated hacking of Qatari government sites, sparking regional

    upheaval, according to U.S. intelligence officials, 2017.7.16

  • - 606 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Cybercrime Prevention Law)

    - 2014 9

    -

    (Commercial Registry Law No.25/2005)

    -

    (Ministry of Business and Trade MOBT)

    - MOBT

    - MOBT

    m

    National ICT Plan 2015

    - ictQATAR(Supreme Council of Information and Communication )

    ICT

    National ICT Plan 2015

    - National ICT Plan 2015 5

    ICT

    ICT

  • - 607 -

    - National ICT Plan 2015

    - , , ICT

    (assurance), , , ,

    NCSS (Qatar National Cyber Security Strategy)

    - 2014 ictQATAR NCSC 2018

    - 5

    Qatar National Vision 2030

    - 2008 , , ,

    - Qatar National Vision 2030

    - ,

    - eGovenrment Hukoomi (www.hukoomi.qa)

    - Hukoomi , ,

    - 2003 2008

    Hukoomi(www.hukoomi.qa)

    - 2017 20 232 1,100

  • - 608 -

    )

    (Q-CERT)

    - Q-CERT(Qatar Computer Emergency Response Team)

    - Q-CERT

    Qatar State Security

    - 2004 GIS(General Intelligence Service), ,

    -

    (Ministry of Transport and Communications)

    - ICT 2016 1

    27,

    - ICT 2013 ictQATAR,

    ictQATAR National ICTPlan

    2015, National Vision 2030, National Development Strategy 2011-2016

    , ,

    - ictQARTAR

  • - 609 -

    )

    National Information Assurance Framework (NIAF)

    - NIAF

    -

    (Crisis Management Plan)

    ISO 27001

    - ISO 27001

  • - 610 -

    )

    / (2017 7)

    -

    140)

    - 2017 5 QNA(Qatar News Agency), 6 Al Jazeera Media Network

    Qatar TV /

    - (zero) ,

    ,

    - 2016 1 (Personal Information Privacy Protection

    Law) , 2016 11 13

    141)

    - Q-CERT

    (Critical Information Infrastructure Protection Law)

    Arab Ministers of Communications and Information Technology

    - 2016 9 Arab Ministers of Communications and

    Information Technology( ICT )

    - , ,

    140) The Peninsular, Call to enhance cyber security after QNA hacking, 2017.7.24

    141) Ministry of Transport and Communications, Qatar issues Personal Data Privacy Law, 2017.11.6

  • - 611 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.494 60

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 4.99 89 8.84 1

    (Access) 6.26 79 8.99 8(Use) 2.74 110 8.57 3(Skills) 6.99 65 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.494 60 0.782 13UN (2016) 0.465 106 0.892 3WEF (NRI 2016) 3.7 92 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 30,818 38.3 28,036 56.1 9,319 11.6 20,556 41.1 80,520 100.1 61,296 122.7 53.2% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 412.30

    '17 () 82,801

  • - 612 -

    1)

    )

    ,

    - 1(0.0001)

    , ,

    - ,

    2017 5 (WannaCry)

    - 2017 7 2 PC

    - MAHER( ) ,

    , 2,000 PC 142)

    2016 8

    - (National Cyberspace Council) 2016 7~8

    - (civilian defense)

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    2016 2016 8

    ,

    142) Financial Tribune, Second Malware Attack Hits Iran, 2017.7.15

  • - 613 -

    )

    m

    BMI 2016 1

    (FDI) , 2016 2.9%

    GDP 2020 4.8%

    - 2014 , 3G 4G 2020

    -

    ICT

    2013 2014 2016 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

    () 28,462 29,316 30,049 30,650 31,120 31,587 32,050 32,509

    (%) 36.9 37.5 38.0 38.3 38.4 38.6 38.8 39.0

    () 100,966 114,410 129,055 137,701 143,209 147,506 150,456 151,960

    (%) 130.9 146.4 163.1 172.0 176.9 180.3 182.1 182.2

    3G &

    4G

    () 1,600 9,920 23,213 33,659 41,737 47,997 53,037 57,916

    (%)1.6 8.7 18.0 24.4 29.1 32.5 35.3 38.1

    () 3,695 4,531 5,417 6,403 7,482 8,642 9,865 11,127

    (%) 4.8 5.8 6.8 8.0 9.2 10.6 11.9 13.3

    : BMI research 2016

    BMI MVNO

    2020 1 5,200 (182.2%)

    - 2015 2/4 TCI(Hamrahe Aval) 3G

    , 3G/4G

    2020

  • - 614 -

    - , 2016

    2020 15.5% 2020 1,110 (13.3%)

    Techrasa ,

    , 2016 52%

    - 2010 1,100 2013 2,300 , 2016 4,200

    - ,

    : Techrasa(2016.11)

    Techrasa , 3G 4G

    ,

    143)

    - Techrasa 2016 2013 20

    40

    143) Techrasa, Iran ADtech Overview, 2016.11.11

  • - 615 -

    ( : )

    : Techrasa(2016.11)

    2G 3G 4G ,

    - 3G 4G (bandwidth) ,

    - Techrasa 2016 1,600 , 2017

    2,800

    ( : )

    : Techrasa(2016.11)

  • - 616 -

    ICT SWOT

    (Strengths) (Weaknesses)

    3G 4G

    ARPU ( )

    ( )

    (Opportunities) (Threats)

    2016 1,

    (FDI)

    3G

    3

    (MVNO)

    : BMI research(2016)

    , Telecommunications Company of Iran(TCI)

    - TCI , Hamrahe

    Aval

    - (Iran Electronic Development Company) Mobile Telephone

    Networks(MTN1 MTN Irancell TCI

  • - 617 -

    ()

    TCI

    (Telecommunications

    Company of Iran)

    (:

    Hamrahe Aval)

    Etemad Mobin: 50%

    Equity Shares Brokerage Companies: 20%

    : 19.9%

    TCI : 5.09%

    : 5%

    MTN Irancell

    Iran Electronic Development Company:

    51%

    MTN: 49%

    Taliya RIC(Rafsanjani industrial Complex)

    MTCE(Mobile

    Telecommunications

    Company of Esfahan)

    Telecommunications Company of Esfahan

    Province

    : BMI research(2016)

    m

    2014 51 , 2019 71

    -

    -

    PC -

    - , , (

    LG )

    - 1/3 , , ,

  • - 618 -

    m IT

    Frost & Sullivan 2015 IT

    12 , 10

    - Frost & Sullivan 2015 ICT 194

    137 (70.6%), IT 57(29.4%)

    - IT 2014~2020

    12.7%

    - IT

    IT

    ( : , %)

    2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

    ICT 17.9(100)

    19.4(100)

    21.2(100)

    23.1(100)

    25.1(100)

    27.4(100)

    29.8(100)

    ( ICT )

    12.8(71.5)

    13.7(70.6)

    14.7(69.3)

    15.8(68.4)

    16.9(67.3)

    18.2(66.4)

    19.4(65.1)

    IT ( ICT )

    5.1(28.5)

    5.7(29.4)

    6.5(30.7)

    7.3(31.6)

    8.2(32.7)

    9.2(33.6)

    10.4(34.9)

    - IT 1.1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.3

    - 0.9 1.0 1.2 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.9

    - 3.1 3.5 3.9 4.4 4.9 5.5 6.2

    : Frost & Sullivan(2015.12)

    ICT IT

    : Frost & Sullivan(2015.12)

  • - 619 -

    m

    BMI , 2019 6.5%

    - 6 0.8% , TV(45.9%),

    (35.6%), (18.2%), (4.9%)

    2019 6.2% , 2019 32

    - , , , , ,

    TV

    - LCT, , 46 TV ,

    TV

    - TV

    2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019

    ( ) 2,182 2,246 2,352 2,503 2,661 2,832 3,002 3,173

    - 1,658 1,707 1,787 1,902 2,022 2,152 2,282 2,412

    - 524 539 564 601 639 680 721 762

    LCD TV () 631 757 893 1,072 1,286 1,543 1,801 2,058

    () 317 320 326 339 356 374 392 410

    : BMI Research(2015), KITA, '(2015.6)

  • - 620 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ,

    ,

    m

    Barnes Reports, '2017 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2015.12)

    2015

    ( )

    Major1 1,326 95.3 25,906

    (guard) Minor1 3,086 271.9 19,825

    Minor2 199 48.8 7,484

    Minor2 13 1.1 188

    Minor2 15 1.0 209

    , Minor2 389 331.5 13,552

    Minor2 1,597 593.4 85,814

    Minor1 605 29.0 5,775

    Minor2 419 22.8 5,477

    Minor2 49 1.4 369

    Minor2 86 2.0 404

    () Minor2 2,794 82.4 14,945

    Major 1: , Minor 2:

    : Barnes Reports, '2017 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems'(2015.12)

  • - 621 -

    m

    ,

    )

    yStats 2016 IRAN B2C E-Commerce Market

    ,

    - B2C , , ,

    - 2016 B2C 77

    ,

    - 10%,

    ( 27%, 25%)

    - 2016 40% , 3G

    4G ,

    2016 B2C

    : yStats Report(2016.05)

  • - 622 -

    2015

    : (2015), yStats Report, Iran online payment security'(2016.5)

    - 61%

    - 2014 , GDP

    2

    2014

    : (2016.2), yStats Report, Iran online payment security'(2016.5)

    - ,

    2014 45%

  • - 623 -

    - 2013 210 9.8%

    - 2016 1

    (34%), (27%), 2016 (65%) (21%)

    2016 1 Top 5

    : yStats Report, Iran online payment security'(2016.5)

    2016 Top 5

    : yStats Report, Iran online payment security'(2016.5)

  • - 624 -

    - 92% , 87%

    . ,

    - 2016 1 35%

    ,

    Top 5

    : yStats Report, Iran online payment security'(2016.5)

    - 2015 Digikala

    80% , Digikala 2016 3, 2,000

    3

    - Alibaba.com 2016 4

    , Aliexpress.com

  • - 625 -

    )

    Arecont Vision IP

    BCD Video CCTV

    CLIQ - ASSA ABLOY Locks

    Dahua Technology Ltd Digital video recording

    Delta Scientific Corporation (Thermal imaging)

    FLIR Commercial Vision System CCTV

    Hikvision CCTV

    MOBOTIX AG CCTV

    Pelco Digital video recording

    Promise Technology Digital video recording

    Seagate Technology /

    Vanderbilt Industries (Access control)

    Vicon Industries CCTV

    Akuvox Networks

    Anviz Global Inc. (Biometrics)

    ASSA ABLOY (Access control)

    Avigilon Corporation CCTV

    Bosch Security Systems CCTV

    Dallmeier electronic GmbH & Co.KG CCTV

    DSX Access Systems, Inc. (Access control)

    FUJIFILM Europe GmbH CCTV

    GEUTEBRUCK GmbH CCTV

    HID Global (Access control)

    Milestone Systems

    Mirasys Ltd CCTV

    Nextchip

    Optex (Intrusion detection)

    SurveonTechnologyInc IP

    : www.sourcesecurity.com

  • - 626 -

    3)

    )

    m

    - The Computer Misuse And Cybercrime Act 2003

    ,

    - ,

    - BAFI (Banking and Financial Institution Acts)

    ,

    m

    - ,

    )

    -

    BASIJ (The Organization for Mobilization of the Oppressed)

    IRGC (Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps)

    (Ministry of ICT)

  • - 627 -

    Irans Passive Defense Organization

    Information Technology Organization on Iran

    MAHER( )

    IRCERT( )

    CYBER POLICE ( )

    * (High Council of Cyberspace) : , , ,

    ** (Cyber Police) :

    - 2011 , ,

    - 2012

    - ,

    *** (IRCERT) : ,

    : (http://cyber.police.ir)

    : MAHER(Iran National CERT, Team Coordination Center

    Computer Emergency Response)

    - MAHER

    - MAHER (Ministry of ICT) ,

    - MAHER

  • - 628 -

    , ,

    (CSIRT)

    - 2017 12 MAHER 2 7

    MAHER

    - MAHER

    : www.certcc.ir/english

    : +(98) 021-42650000

    : cert@certcc.ir

    )

    m

    (Ministry of ICT)

    - ,

    (Communications Regulatory Authority)

    -

  • - 629 -

    m

    2016 UN

    0.3333 0.3514 0.7101 0.4649 106

    0.9420 0.8530 0.8795 0.8915 3

    : NIA

    2016 UN

    E-

    0.2034 149

    0.9661 4

    : NIA

    (UN )

    ICT ICT (Skill)

    6.26 79 2.74 110 6.96 65 2.94 78

    8.99 8 8.57 3 9.08 3 8.84 1

    : NIA

    m

    - G-G

    - 2002

  • - 630 -

    , ,

    , ICT

    - 5

    1:

    2:

    3: ICT

    4:

    5:

    : NIA

  • - 631 -

    )

    -

    -

    -

    -

    )

    - 2017 5

    144)

    - "Padvish"

    - Iran Telecommunication Research Center

    ,

    - 2017 8

    145)

    144) Iran Front Page, Iran Develops Software to Stop WannaCry Ransomware, 2017.5.18

    145) Financial Tribune, IT Collaboration With Thailand, 2017.8.9

  • - 632 -

    - Pichet Durongkaveroj

    Mahmoud Vaezi

    - Mahmoud Vaezi IT, ,

    ,

    (IoT) IPv6

    - Amir Hossein Davaie (deputy minister) 2017 7 IoT

    IPv6

    - Davaie (Faculty of Information and Communications

    Technology) IoT

    - IPv6 IoT

    " "

    - IoT ,

    - Davaie IoT IoT

    ITE(2016 11 1~3)

    - ITE(Iran Transaction Exhibition) FABA(

    ) , , ,

    - 26, 4 ,

    Bank Melli Iran(BMI) 1927 , 6

    - ,

    - SSL ID/PW, OTP

    ,

    - , , , OTP, 3

    /

  • - 633 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.569 46

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 6.90 45 8.84 1

    (Access) 7.29 47 8.99 8

    (Use) 6.32 36 8.57 3

    (Skills) 7.30 55 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.569 46 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.682 44 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 4.8 35 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) 10%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    3,677 12.0 28,035 56.1

    3,287 10.8 20,555 41.1

    47,932 157.6 61,295 122.7

    73.8% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 707.4

    '17 () 28,571

  • - 634 -

    1)

    )

    World Economic Forum The Global Information Technology Report 2016

    (NRI) 4.8 139 35

    - ITU , 2,800 , 4,793 ,

    73.75%

    2030(National Transformation

    Program and Saudi Vision 2030)

    - 400

    40% 10%

    - ,

    2020

    : http://globalriskinsights.com(: world bank, 2016.6)

    2016 11 2017 1 Shamoon

    (W32.Disttrack) 5 (W32.Disttrack.B)

  • - 635 -

    - 2012 Aramco

    Aramco 3

    , 1500

    - , 2013

    1 4 4 146)

    3.1% 12

    - (National e-Security Center)

    147)

    -

    , Lockheed Martin

    GCC ,

    ,

    - ICT UAE

    - 2015 2 2100 2025 3.1%

    2 9900 , (IT)

    - 10% ,

    , 2013

    60 (VEDP, Saudi Arabia 2014)

    CCTV

    146) (Computer Emergency Response Teams, CERT)

    147) (, 2014)

  • - 636 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 0.57% 363 7

    , 11.96%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 0.31%

    328 7 , 10.81%

  • - 637 -

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 19% 4,793 2

    , 157.6%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 638 -

    2)

    )

    m

    GCC , UAE, , ,

    , 6 5

    19 63%

    IT , , , UAE, ,

    7%

    . UAE IT 0~1%

    CCTV

    - GCC , ,

    39% 16 2,300

    7 2,200 8 3,400

    GCC (2014~2017) (: )

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

  • - 639 -

    , , ,

    2014~2017 42 , 10 4

    - 12.9 , UAE 9.9 , 5.9

    , 5.6 , 5.4

    GCC (2014-2017 ) ( : )

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

    (2014) (: )

    262.6 336.2 598.8

    UAE 154 219.3 373.3

    55.5 114 169.5

    * 44.7 70.9 115.6

    25.5 48.3 73.8

    ** 366.8 654.8 1,021.6

    909.1 1,443.5 2,352.6

    (* : , , , )

    (** : BMI research IT )

    : Technavio(2015) BMI research(2015)148)

    148) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)

  • - 640 -

    2015 6 3 2015~2025

    3.07% 2025 8 5500

    - 5(2011~2015) , ,

    -

    -

    - , 2007~2018

    330

    (2015~2025)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the Saudi Arabia to 2025: Market Brief, 2016.3

    35% , 35%,

    30%, 17%

    -

    - ,

  • - 641 -

    (: )

    2015 2025

    (2015-2025)(2015-2025)

    221 299 2,800 3.10%

    191 257 2,400 2.99%

    113 154 1,500 3.10%

    107 145 1,400 3.10%

    632 855 8,100 3.10%

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the Saudi Arabia to 2025: Market Brief, 2016.3

    (2015~2025)

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the Saudi Arabia to 2025: Market Brief, 2016.3

    2015 2 2,100 2025

    3.1% 2 9,900

    -

    ,

    - ,

  • - 642 -

    2015 1 9,100 2025

    2.99% 2 5,700

    - C4ISR

    -

    -

    80%

    , (Managed Security Services,

    MSS) 2020 35 149)

    -

    ,

    , IT

    5 9

    -

    - ,

    - , .

    (bill) , ,

    - ,

    , , .

    149) Newswire Today, http://www.newswiretoday.com/news/151154/

  • - 643 -

    -

    , , ICT

    - 2012 Aramco (cyber defense)

    3 IBM, Mobily, Symantec

    150)

    CCTV

    - CCTV , 2019 CCTV

    2014~2019 23%

    - CCTV , IT , IP

    - , 50 , Medical City, Economic City

    ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    2014 CCTV GCC 0.7% 3,200

    UAE 14.8%,

    3% 1,400 , 1,300

    150) VEDP, Saudi Arabia 2014

  • - 644 -

    )

    m

    , ,

    ,

    IT

    - , UAE IT

    ,

    , , ,

    /contractor,

    - ,

    . -

    (MOI-SSD), (CNIA), ,

    (DPS), UAE (GCAA)

    , ,

    -

    Contractor

    60% , 40%

  • - 645 -

    GCC

    : MEED Insight(www.meed.com)

    -

    , , DDoS,

    - IT

    ,

    - ,

    IS

    CCTV

    - , ,

    CCTV CCTV IP CCTV

    - 2013 CCTV CCTV

    - , 2014 CCTV

  • - 646 -

    IP , CCTV

    , , ,

    m

    GCC Thales, IBM, UTC( GE

    Security), Honeywell, Schneider/Pelco, Siemens, Johnson Controls, Cisco, ARINC

    Axis Communications

    - UAE GCC

    - IT

    - Injazat Data Systems, Saudi

    Telecom Company(STC), IBM, Etihad Etisalat Company(Mobily), Booz Allen

    Hamilton, Cassidian Cybersecurity Company, Cisco Systems, FireEye,

    Fortinet, Kaspersky Lab, McAfee, Symantec, Trend Micro, Cyberoam

    RedCherry, Light's Ray Technologies,

    Commercial Technologies Plus, AFI Infotech, Redington

    - Redington Fortinet, Trend Micro, Symantec

    IT

  • - 647 -

    Injazat Data Systems LLC , ,

    Saudi Telecom Company(STC) ,

    IBM IT ,

    Etihad Etisalat Company(Mobily) ,

    Symantec

    Redington Fortinet, Cisco, NEC

    : 151)

    IT Redington

    : www.redingtonmea.com

    - 1977 , ,

    , , ,

    151) Newswire Today, http://www.newswiretoday.com/news/151154/

  • - 648 -

    - .

    Commercial

    Registration

    -

    ARAMCO(), SABIC(), SEC(

    ), STC()

    (Pre-Qualification)

  • - 649 -

    3)

    )

    m

    2007 70

    - 1 10 1

    300

    - , ,

    ,

    2013 2, (MCIT) (National

    Information Security Strategy, NISS)

    - ,

    ,

    , , ,

    ,

    2017 9 , (MCIT) NISS Draft 7

    - NISS

  • - 650 -

    NISS

    NISS 5 ()

    : http://www.mcit.gov.sa/En/

  • - 651 -

    m

    , , 2013 6

    (National e-Security Center)

    - 2012 8 (Aramco)

    3

    - 2012 12 , ,

    - 2013 5,

    ,

    , IP

    ,

    )

    (Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, MCIT)

    - ,

    -

    -

    2011 (MCIT)

    (National Information Security Strategy) ,

    , , , ,

    - (Anti-Cyber Crime Law),

    (Electronic Transactions Law)

  • - 652 -

    (Computer Emergency

    Response Team, CERT)

    - (CERT) 2007 , 2008 3 14 (Anti-Cyber Crime Law) ,

    , ,

    - 1) , 2) , 3) , 4)

    , (CITC)

    )

    1995 (SASO)

    - 2004 8 68

    -

  • - 653 -

    )

    (NCSC)

    - NCSC 2 (International Cyber Security

    Conference: ICSC) 2 27~28

    - 600 ,

    CEO, CIO IT

    2017 1, 2016 11 Shamoon

    - 2012 Aramco Shamoon

    Shamoon2 2016 11 6 . Saudi

    Arabian Oil Dow Chemical

    Dallah Al-Baraka Group 2

    , 8 ,

    , (2013 8 )

    - Dallah Al-Baraka Group ICT

    ICT

    - Dallah Al-Baraka Group 1969 , , , , , ,

    ,

    100 5

  • - 654 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.691 20

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 20%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 7.40 30 8.84 1

    (Access) 6.02 42 8.99 8

    (Use) 8.09 9 8.57 3

    (Skills) 8.38 22 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.691 20 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.781 20 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 5.4 21 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2017 6 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    3,340 41.6 28,036 56.1

    2,258 28.1 20,556 41.1

    10,570 131.7 61,296 122.7

    79.8% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 340.0

    '17 () 8,300

  • - 655 -

    1)

    )

    ITU 20 (mature)

    - 2017 11 ITU

    20 , , , , ,

    , , , 9

    ,

    -

    ,

    - , ,

    - 2011 (INCB)

    ,

    - ,

    - ----

    - KOTRA 2016 152)

    10% , 60 , 15%

    - 2016 350 , 15%

    , 250

    152) KOTRA , 2017 , 2016.11.

  • - 656 -

    25%

    - , , 3,

    )

    m

    (IDI; ICT Development Index)

    - ITU 2016 30

    , 0.15 7.40

    - 42, 9, 22

    ,

    - 1 , 3

    ,

    10 , 153)

    - GDP OECD

    , 2016

    GDP 4.25% 1 154)

    - 2014 ICT 18%

    1 2,900 NIS( 3 ) ,

    2015 2014 20% 5 4

    - ,

    - ITU155) 2016 100 28.1%,

    93.4% , 79.8%,

    153) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

    154) OECD Data, Gross domestic spending on R&D

    https://data.oecd.org/rd/gross-domestic-spending-on-r-d.htm

    155) ITU, The State of Broadband: Broadband catalyzing sustainable development, 2017.9.

  • - 657 -

    2015 75.7%

    - ,

    m

    2012 5.4%

    - ITU

    2012 2012 47.02% 2016 41.61% 5.4%p.

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    2016 28.13%

    - ITU 2016 28.13% 2015 0.69%

    -

    - 2000 , BEZEQ Group

    156), 2017 2 91% 47.2Mbps

    - ,

    156) BEZEQ Group, Reports second quarter 2017 financial results, 2017.8.24.

  • - 658 -

    (2,000 )

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    m

    2016 131.67%

    - ITU 2016 1.8% 131.67%,

    1,057

    - 2004 100% , 2015

    133.47%

    - 2001 157),

    2016 68.9% 158)

    157) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

    158) OECD Broadband Portal, http://www.oecd.org/sti/broadband/oecdbroadbandportal.htm

  • - 659 -

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 5

    , non-voice 3G/4G

    - 2017 5 3 Cellcom, Pelephone, Partner Golan, MIRS

    MVNO , Golan MIRS

    3

    159)

    - 2017 5 LTE 4G

    , 3 3G

    - MVNO ,

    159) The International Trade Administration of U.S., Israel Telecommunications, 2017.5.30.

  • - 660 -

    2)

    )

    m

    - , , ,

    ,

    ,

    - Israel Aerospace Industries Rafael Advanced

    Defense Systems, (Ministry of Defence), (Israel

    Defense Forces)

    , C4(command, control, communications networking and

    computing)

    -

    , , , ,

    - 8200(Unit 8200)

    - ,

    ,

    - , , ,

    - IT,

    , ,

  • - 661 -

    - 160),

    , ,

    - ,

    (anti-fraud), , ,

    - IoT

    - ,

    Check Point, CyberArk, Microsoft 2015 2 5

    Adallom, IoT

    Rafael

    - , , ,

    - , , Seed, A,

    ,

    , 2016 1/3 161)

    - ,

    ,

    - , R&D

    , , , ,

    ,

    160) Israel: The Next Key Player in the Cybersecurity Industry, Forbes, 2017.2.27.

    161) Israel: The Next Key Player in the Cybersecurity Industry, Forbes, 2017.2.27.

  • - 662 -

    m

    SDI 162) 2015 1 8,700

    , 3.73% 2025 2 7,000

    -

    ,

    -

    ,

    McAfee 1

    - R&D, ,

    2016 8 8,240

    2.31% 2025 10 8,400 163)

    -

    ,

    - (, ID ), (

    , ), , //,

    / , /

    2016 2 5,320

    2.92% 2025 3 2,800

    164)

    - / ,

    162) SDI, The Cyber Security Market in Israel to 2025: Market Brief, 2016.3.

    163) SDI, Israel Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025, 2016.8.

    164) SDI, Israel Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025, 2016.8.

  • - 663 -

    - , , , ID

    , , (SCADA) ,

    (Physical Security Information Management, PSIM),

    2016 2 5,861

    2.77% 2025 3 3,061

    165)

    -

    - , CCTV// , /, ,

    /, , , ,

    (ISA) 2017 8 , 8

    110 7 222 50%

    - 8 2, 83,

    24, 1

    - 8 , , 107

    82 , (Improvised Explosive Device, IED)

    21, 1 , 2, 1

    165) SDI, Israel Defense Spends on Homeland Security: 2016 to 2025, 2016.8.

  • - 664 -

    2017 7-8

    : ISA, Monthly Summary-August 2017

    Start-up Nation Central 166) 2016

    5 8,100 2015 9%

    - ,

    2 ,

    15%

    - 2016 365, 2016

    65 25% 160 A

    - 2016 (SCADA)

    (OT) (ICS) 5,500

    4

    - IoT

    19 , 2016

    166) Start-up Nation Central, finder insights series: Israels cybersecurity industry in 2016, 2017.1.

  • - 665 -

    : Start-up Nation Central,finder insights series: Israels cybersecurity industry in 2016,

    2017.1.

    - 67 1,

    48, // 43

    : Start-up Nation Central,finder insights series: Israels cybersecurity industry in 2016,

    2017.1.

  • - 666 -

    )

    m

    , (Homeland Security)

    - , / , /

    / , ,

    ,

    ,

    - , , , ,

    - ( ) , SI,

    600

    Foreign Military Sales(FMS) Foreign Military

    Financing(FMF)

    - ,

    ,

    - , , ,

  • - 667 -

    Safe Cities

    - ,

    GIS

    - ,

    ,

    2016 , CCTV

    , , 167)

    (HS Code) 2013 2014 2015CCTV (852580) 137,038 126,061 142,925

    (847160) 27,305 28,918 30,200(8517692) 17,996 26,152 18,713

    (852190) 21,866 18,291 17,699(830140) 10,168 11,730 12,227

    ( : )

    : Global Trade Atals(GTA)

    - CCTV 2015 1 4

    13% , 25%, 10%, 1%

    - 2015 3

    4.4% , 54%, 7%, 1%

    - 2015 18

    , 28% 50%, 12%,

    1%

    -

    2015 1 7 3% ,

    75%, 9%, 1.7%

    - , 2015 1 200

    4.2% , 40%, 13%

    0.1%

    167) , KOTRA , 2016.3.28.

  • - 668 -

    m

    2015-2025 3.75% 168)

    - SDI

    2015 1 8,700

    - 6,500 ,

    5,700 , 3,300 , 3,200

    - 4.09%

    2025 5,000

    - 4.04% 2025 4,700

    , 2025 9,300

    8,000

    2015 2025

    (2015-25)

    (%)

    (2015-25)

    65 93 884 3.63

    57 80 759 3.45

    33 50 456 4.09

    32 47 430 4.04

    187 270 2,500 3.73

    ( : )

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the Israel to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    m

    2015~2025

    - SDI 2015~2025

    168) SDI, The Cyber Security Market in Israel to 2025: Market Brief, 2016.3.

  • - 669 -

    35%, 30%, 18%,

    17%

    (2015-2025)

    (%)

    35

    30

    18

    17

    100%

    : SDI, The Cyber Security Market in the Israel to 2025: Market Brief(2016.3)

    - 2015 6,500

    3.63% 2025 9,300 , 2015~2025 8

    8,400

    - , ,

    -

    -

    (National Cyber Defense Shield),

    , IDF

    - , ,

    ,

  • - 670 -

    - , , , BYOD(Bring Your Own Device)

    ,

    - 2015 5,700 , 3.45%

    2025 8,000 , 2015~2025 7

    5,900

    - , ,

    - ,

    -

    - (Israeli Defense Forces, IDF)

    , ,

    (IDF)

    - 2

  • - 671 -

    )

    m

    q

    , 350

    -

    , ,

    - Safe City Smart City ,

    ,

    - L3,

    Morpho Trust, Raytheon, FLIR, Smiths Detection, SAIC

    9.11 , , , RF

    - Nice Systems, EL-FAR Electronics Systems 2000,

    Electronics Line 3000

    q

    ,

    - CheckPoint

    CyberArk

  • - 672 -

    - Huawei Hexatier , Volkswagen CyMotive Technologies

    - IoT,

    m

    Check Point

    - 1993 (UTM)

    - , , ,

    - Fortune 500 100

    , 130

    - , , , ,

    - : Home Page https://www.checkpoint.com/ Tel: +972-3-753-4555

    e-mail: me_info@checkpoint.com

    CyberArk

    - CyberArk 2014 IPO 8,600

    Fortune 100 50%, Global 2000 25%

    , ,

    - , ISO/IEC 27002 GDPR

    ,

    - , , , , ,

  • - 673 -

    - : Home Page https://www.cyberark.com/

    Comsec

    - 1987 , ,

    600

    - , IT , , , ,

    - , , , , , , ,

    - , , ,

    , , , ERP

    - : Home Page https://comsecglobal.com/ e-mail: info@comsecglobal.com

    F5 Networks

    - F5 Networks

    Application Delivery Networking(ADN)

    - F5 Networks

    - , , DDos

    - : Home Page https://f5.com/

    CyKickLabs

    - ,

    (Telepath)

    - (Telepath)

    - : Home Page https://www.cykicklabs.com/

  • - 674 -

    Tel: +972-72-370-0362

    e-mail: sales@cykicklabs.com

    Kaspersky Lab

    - Kaspersky 2017 20

    , , , ,

    - Kaspersky 2001

    , 2013 6 ,

    , IT

    - PC, , PC

    ,

    - Kaspersky

    2017 6 , IoT, ,

    ,

    R&D

    -

    , , ,

    - : Home Page https://www.kaspersky.com/ e-mail: info@kaspersky.com

    Bynet Data Communications Ltd

    - 1975 IT RAD Group IT

    , , , , ,

    ,

    Bynet Reseller

    - ICT

    , , ,

    , , , , ,

    (SCADA) ,

  • - 675 -

    - : Home Page http://www.bynet.co.il/en/ e-mail: info@bynet.co.il

    NICE Systems

    - 1986 NICE Systems ,

    (anti-fraud)

    3

    - NICE Systems 150 25,000

    , Fortune 100 80 ,

    , , ,

    - NICE

    ,

    - IP , , ,

    - /

    - , , , , ,

    - : Home Page http://www.nice.com/ Tel: +972 9 775 3777

    EL-FAR Electronics Systems 2000

    - (smart fence) ,

    30 , 8

    - EL-FAR 28 , 100

    150

    - (Perimeter Fence) ,

    - ,

  • - 676 -

    Illusive Networks

    - 2014 8200

    ,

    - Illusive Networks 2015 500 8(Team 8)

    , NEA, Citi Ventures , 2017 1

    Microsoft

    - : Home Page https://www.illusivenetworks.com/

    Argus Cyber Security

    - 2013 Argus

    - 2015 9 B 2,600 , 24

    , , ,

    ,

    - Argus R&D , , ,

    ,

    - : Home Page https://argus-sec.com/ e-mail: contact@argus-sec.com

    Cato Networks

    - 2015 Cato Networks

    (Network security as a service, NSaaS)

    - Cato Networks

    WAN

    - Cato Networks 2015 10 A 2 , 2016

    9 B Greylock Partners 3 ,

    - : Home Page https://www.catonetworks.com/

  • - 677 -

    CGS Tower Networks

    - 2014 CGS Tower Networks

    , SmartNIC

    - ,

    - CGS

    - , , , , , , , ,

    - : Home Page https://www.cgstowernetworks.com/ e-mail: info@cgstowernetworks.com

    Coronet

    - 2015 Coronet Wifi , ,

    - Coronet , Windows, Mac, Android, iOS

    IoT SDK

    - Coronet 2015 + 15

    , CRN 2017 30

    - : Home Page https://coro.net/

    Cyberbit

    - 2015 Cyberbit Elbit Systems , ,

    SCADA IP

    - IP SCADA CyberShield Suite ,

    , ,

    - , , , WiT

    - : Home Page https://www.cyberbit.com e-mail: info@cyberbit.com

  • - 678 -

    )

    TD (2017 10)169)

    - TD(Toronto-Dominion) Bank

    -

    TD , TD

    ,

    - ,

    TD

    (holy site) (2017 7)170)

    - ,

    - (Shin Bet)

    - ,

    - 12 ,

    2016 5 8,100 171)

    - , 2016

    ,

    2016 , 5 8,100

    169) TD Opens Cybersecurity Office in Israel, Markets Insider, 2017.10.4.

    170) How Smart Are the New 'Smart Cameras' Israel Wants to Install Near the Temple Mount?,

    Haaretz, 2017.7.26.

    171) Israel: The Next Key Player in the Cybersecurity Industry, Forbes, 2017.2.27.

  • - 679 -

    ,

    15%

    - 2016 Huawei Hexatier , Volkswagen AG

    CyMotive Technologies

    - Accenture

    Malgan ,

    - 2015 Arm Holdings IoT

    Sansa Security

    - PayPal

    (malware) CyActive

  • - 680 -

    3)

    )

    m

    172)

    -

    1995 (Computer Law)

    1981 (Protection of Privacy Law)

    ( ) 5777-2017

    1984 (Encouragement for Industrial Research and

    Development Law)

    2007 (Defense Exports Control Law)

    1982 (Communications (Telecommunications and Broadcasting Law)

    1998 (Law for Regulating Security in Public Bodies)

    2001 (Electronic Signature Law)

    (Biometric Database Law)

    - 2009 Knesset( ) ID

    ,

    ,

    - 2013 ,

    2017

    (counter-terrorism law)

    - 2016 8 Knesset , ,

    ,

    172) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

  • - 681 -

    -

    - 2017 2 (Antitrust Authority)

    - (cyber security measures)

    Directive 361 2015

    ,

    ,

    - 2016 8 (directive on Cyber Risk

    Management)

    - 2015 2

    m

    (Digital Israel)173)

    - 2013 1Gbps ,

    ,

    174)

    - (Ministry of Science)

    (National Cyber Initiative) 2010

    11

    - , ,

    173) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

    174) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

  • - 682 -

    , , 80

    -

    - 12 2011 8 (Advancing

    National Cyberspace Capabilities) 3611

    - (INCB)

    - 2016 , (INCB)

    ,

    - 3611

    4

    (1)

    (2)

    (3)

    (4) , ,

    - , 2443 2444

    , (INCB) (NCSA)

    (National Cyber Defense Directorate)

    -

    , ,

    :

    : Magshimim

    - 2011

  • - 683 -

    - 2 ,

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    - , ,

    - (Magshimim Leumit)

    - , ( R&D

    , 50), ( 25), ( 6, 3)

    ,

    (Talpiot), (Havatzalot), Brakim Excellence

    - (Talpiot) : , , ,

    (IDF)

    1979 (IDF)

    50

    ,

    , IDF

    - (Havatzalot) : ,

    (IDF)

    3

    , , , , ,

    (IDF)

    - Brakim Excellence :

  • - 684 -

    (IDF) (Technion)

    ,

    ,

    )

    (National Cyber Defense Authority)175)

    - 2002

    ,

    - ,

    -

    ,

    - ,

    - ,

    (Israel National Cyber Bureau, INCB)176)

    -

    3611(Government Resolution No. 3611) 2011

    (INCB) ,

    175) National Cyber Defense Authority:

    https://www.gov.il/en/Departments/national_cyber_security_authority

    176) http://www.pmo.gov.il/English/PrimeMinistersOffice/DivisionsAndAuthorities/cyber/Pages/default.aspx

  • - 685 -

    - (Ministry of Finance)

    , 2011 40 (New Israelis Shekel, NIS)

    - (Civil Service Commission)

    -

    ,

    INCB

    INCB (National Cyber Situation

    Room)

    ,

    (The Science and Technology Ministry) 5,000 (

    1,400 ) ,

    - , , ,

    ,

    - ,

    -

    (Israel Security Agency, ISA, Shin Bet)177)

    - ISA , , ,

    - 1948 ,

    2002

    -

    177) https://www.shabak.gov.il/english/pages/about.html

  • - 686 -

    ,

    IT ,

    IT

    ,

    - ,

    (Ministry of Economy)

    - 2014 ,

    (Office of the Chief Scientist, OCS)

    R&D

    -

    ,

    - R&D , ,

    - IT

    (Israeli Cyber Event Readiness Team, CERT-IL)

    - CERT-IL (NCSA) , 2444

    -

    CERT ,

    - 2012

  • - 687 -

    - (Lahav 433)

    )

    m

    -

    m

    q

    : (Standards Institution of ISRAEL, SII)

    - (Standards Institution

    of ISRAEL, SII)

    - SII ,

    , ,

    - , , ISO 9000

    - (Standard Mark) : SII ISO Guide 65

    ,

    ,

    ,

    1

  • - 688 -

    SII SII

    - (Israeli Green Label) :

    - (Safety Mark):

    - (Management Systems) : ISO 26

    ISO/IEC 27001( ), SI OHSAS 18001(

    ), SI 9301( )

    )

    (2017 7)178)

    - 2017 7 17 (Knesset)

    (Clean Internet Bill)

    - ,

    -

    (INCB) (2015 2)179)

    - 2015 2 (INCB)

    - ,

    178) , , Vol.118, 2017.7.

    179) National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense Centre of

    Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

  • - 689 -

    (National Cyber Security Authority, NCSA)

    - (INCB) (NCSA) (National

    Cyber Directorate)

    - 2443180)

    ,

    , (INCB)

    - 2444181) (NCSA)

    - (NCSA)

    , ,

    - (NCSA)

    , ,

    , ,

    - , CERT , ,

    ,

    - 2443 2444 2017

    (INCB) (NCSA)

    (National Cyber Directorate, Maarach)

    : National Cyber Security Organisation: ISRAEL, NATO Cooperative Cyber Defense

    Centre of Excellence(CCDCOE), 2017

    180) 2443: Advancing National Regulataion and Governmental Leadership in Cyber Security

    181) 2444: Advancing the National Preparedness for Cyber Defense

  • - 690 -

    - ,

  • - 691 -

    5.

    m

    3,210, 1/5

    , 11 54

    - , , ,

    , , , 5

    - 49 34

    . 1 GNI 1,000

    - 6 (, , , ,

    , ) 35%, GDP 64%,

    60%

    (2016 )

    (US$ )

    (US$ )

    1992. 4. 139 42 , , ,

    , , , ,

    1963. 3. 20 1.4,

    , , ,

    1964. 2 162 104,

    ,

    , ,

    1962.10 15 298 , TV, PVC ,

    1962.10 250 74, , , PVC, TV

    , /

    1963.12 97 53, ,

    ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    : Kotra-, KITA.net DB

  • - 692 -

    ICT ,

    - 2016 ICT (ICT Development Index, IDI) 17

    , , 120

    - , ,

    ICT(IDI)

    IDI(2016) (access) (use) (skill)

    167 1.65 158 1.58 172 0.30 162 2.33

    150 2.13 159 2.65 136 1.47 161 2.42

    129 2.99 133 3.54 123 2.05 133 3.76

    124 3.12 126 3.98 124 1.92 132 3.81

    141 2.53 132 3.59 133 1.64 166 2.17

    169 1.51 170 2.11 158 0.82 172 1.71

    1 8.84 8 8.99 3 8.57 3 9.08

    : ITU, 'Measuring the Information Society Report 2016'(2016)

  • - 693 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 11

    88

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.317 88

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 5%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 1.65 167 8.84 1

    (Access) 2.65 158 8.99 8

    (Use) 0.30 172 8.57 3

    (Skills) 2.33 162 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.317 88 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.353 130 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 2.9 123 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2017 6 ) 1% 74.4%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    130 0.2 28,036 56.1

    137 0.3 20,556 41.1

    40,044 74.4 61,296 122.7

    13.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 51.19

    '17 () 52,482

  • - 694 -

    1)

    )

    ICT

    - ICT

    -

    , 182)

    - , , IP, ATM

    , , 183)

    - (Cybercrime Act) 2015 9

    2016 85 184)

    - ICT ,

    - 98% 5,000

    - Microsoft ,

    , ,

    185)

    - 2010 1 2013 6

    (NBS), (TCU),

    182) Cyber criminals can be stopped, Dailynews, 2017.3.2.183) Saidi M. Kalunde, The status of Cybercrime in Tanzania", Octopus Conference on Cooperation Against

    Cybercrime, 2015.06.

    184) Tanzania Cyber Security Report 2016, SERIANU, p. 8.185) Dar, Seoul team up against rising cases of cybercrimes, dailynews, 2017.4.20

  • - 695 -

    (NACTE), (OUT), Chemi and Cotex Industries Ltd.,

    186)

    - M. Mshangi et al.(2014) 187) ,

    12.8% ,

    63.29%

    - (mobile money) M-Pesa, Tago-Pesa,

    Aritel-Money ,

    - Bill and Melinda Gates InterMedia ,

    2015 2/3 188)

    - 2015 1

    ,

    84% 68% 189)

    2015 11 190)

    - Check Point Software Technologies 191), 2015

    11 20 7

    , ,

    Top 20 (1), (4), (5),

    (7), (8), (9), (12) 7

    , ,

    192)

    186) Tanzania is one of the most cyber-attacked countries in the world, 2015.11

    187) M. Mshangi et al., The Rapid Growth of Cybercrimes Affecting Information Systems in the Global: Is this a Myth or Reality in Tanzania?", International Journal of Information Security Science, Vol. 3, No. 2(2014)

    188) Tanzania Daily News, Tanzania: Digital Payment Platform Vital for Poverty Alleviation, 2016.10.7.

    189) , 5 , , KOTRA , 2017.2.17.

    190) Tanzania is one of the most cyber-attacked countries in the world, 2015.11,

    191) Bizcommunity, "More African countries exposed to mobile malware192) U.S. OSAC, "Tanzania 2017 Crime & Safety Report"

  • - 696 -

    - Dar es Salaam , Arusha,

    Mwanza, Stone Town

    - , ,

    ,

    - , ,

    ,

    - , ,

    , ,

    ,

    )

    - ITU 2016 , 12 9,597

    , 2015 14 2,819 9.3%

    - ,

    - TTCL(Tanzania Telecommunications Company

    Limited) Zantel(Zanzibar Telecom Limited)

    - 2017 6 TTCL 12 8,191, ZANTEL

    1,528 193)

    - TTCL Zanzibar

    , Zantel 2005 2 Zanzibar

    194)

    193) TCRA, Quarterly Communications Statistics Report, 2017.06.194) ITU(2014), "Cyber Security in Tanzania-Country Report"

  • - 697 -

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB (2017.6)

    - ITU 2016 2015 1%

    4,004 4,186 74% , 2010 2016

    (CAGR) 11.4% 195)

    - 2017 6 , 3 Vodacom(31%), Tigo(28%), Airtel(26%)

    , Halotel(9%)

    Zantel(3%), Smart(2%), TTCL(1%)

    196)

    195) ITU, "Mobile-cellular subscriptions"196) "Quarterly Communications Statistics", Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority, 2017.3

  • - 698 -

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    (2017 6 )

    ()

    Vodacom 12,611,043 31%

    Tigo 11,370,493 28%

    Airtel 10,349,345 26%

    Halotel 3,800,530 9%

    Zantel* 987,848 3%

    Smart 828,772 2%

    TTCL* 410,000 1%

    40,358,031 100%

    * Zantel( ), TTCL( )

    : TCRA(2017.6)

    - ,

    - 2016 36% 3G/4G , 2021

    67% 197)

    -

    197) Business Sweden in Eastern Africa, Opportunities in the ICT Sector in East Africa, 2017.4.26.

    p15.

  • - 699 -

    - 3G Ericsson

    -

    - Vodacom

    15 2

    5 1 2,000

    -

    , , (Hello Food)

    - (interoperability)

    ,

    - 2016 7~2017 4 10 50

    ( 224 )198) 199)

    (2015.4~2017.4)

    : Governor Bank of Tanzania, "Monetary Policy Statement 2017/18", p.34. 2017.06.

    198) 2017 11 : 1 = 2,234.3

    199) , [ ] , 2017.10.16.

  • - 700 -

    - , , , ,

    , /, TV, ,

    - 2017 6 , 2

    , M-Pesa(41.4%) 1 ,

    Tigo Pesa(31.6%), Airtel Money(25.4%), Ezy Pesa(1.6%) 200)

    (2017 6 )

    ()

    Vodacom M-Pesa 7,697585 37.9%

    Tigo Tigo Pesa 6,055,879 29.9%

    Airtel Airtel Money 5,927712 29.2%

    HalotelHalotel

    Money358,217 1.8%

    Zantel Ezy Pesa 246,417 1.2%

    20,285,810 100%

    : TCRA(2017.6)

    - TCRA 201) 1,801 ,

    90.7% ,

    6.1% 3.2%

    (2016 12 )

    18,014,358 90.7%

    1,218,693 6.1%

    629,474 3.2%

    19,862,525 100.0%

    : TCRA(2017.6)

    200) TCRA, Quarterly Communications Statistics Report, 2017.06201) TCRA, Quarterly Communications Statistics Report, 2017.06

  • - 701 -

    - TCRA 202) 2016 40%, 2

    , ITU Internet World Stats203)

    13%

    (2016 12 )

    : TCRA(2017.6)

    202) TCRA, Quarterly Communications Statistics Report, 2017.06203) Internet World Stats:http://www.internetworldstats.com/af/tz.htm

  • - 702 -

    (.tz) : 14,446

    co.tz 11,687 80.901%or.tz 1,194 8.265%ac.tz 649 4.493% go.tz 627 4.434%sc.tz 171 1.184%ne.tz 61 0.422%me.tz 25 0.173%tv.tz 10 0.069%

    hotel.tz 7 0.048%mil.tz 7 0.048%info.tz 6 0.042%mobi.tz 2 0.014% 14,446 100%

    : www.tznic.or.tz (2017.11.5.)

    - : 54

    AptusSolutions TwigaHostingLtd ZalongwaTechnologies

    StartelTLTD UhuruOne Systems2000LTD

    Simbanet(T)LTD AmazingSolutionsLTD FoundationforCivilSociety

    HabariNodeLTD Netways MephicsTLTD

    ExtremeWebTechnologies Digiplus AsanteWorld

    1AND1InternetSolutions TanzaniaYouthAlliance E-GovtAgency

    KilihostLTD ITSales&ServicesLTD ZEECOMMUNICATIONSLTD

    ITFarm TrilabsCoLTD TrybenCompanyLimited

    UniversityComputingCenter AdvertisingAfrica JonsoftGroupLimited

    Spicenet(T)LTD EcosystemEastAfrica TwigaTech

    WebTechnologiesCoLTD MASOKO INFOCOMTECHNOLOGIES

    BensonInformaticsLTD PowercomputersTechnology DUXTE

    AfricaOnlineTanzaniaLTD ENTERSOFTSYSTEMS EVMAKTANZANIALTD

    SihebsTechnologiesCoLtd RANATECHNOLOGIES CAPITALTECHNOLOGIES

    AsyxGroupCoLTD LexsynergyTZRegLimited BONGOLIVE

    BestcomCompanyLTD DUDUMIZITechnologies TECHNOPROEA

    INCOTECHNOLOGIES CATS-NET SmartcodeCompany

    ASKTechnologies DUDUMIZISolutions TWENTY4&CO

  • - 703 -

    2)

    )

    m

    2014 380, 2015 1,823

    204)

    - 9% , 1%

    ,

    - 2016

    8,500

    - , 23% ,

    32% , 26%

    : www.serianu.com , [ ]

    , 2017.10.16.

    204) , [ ] , 2017.10.16

  • - 704 -

    2015 1,823

    - 2016 1 205) ,

    2015 1,823 2014 380 379.7% ,

    2013 2015

    - 2015 Arusha(561), Morogoro(271),

    Shinyabga(226), Pwani(212), Tanga(145), Mtwara(123), Katavi(100)

    - ATM ,

    , , , SIM

    (: )

    : The United Republic of Tanzania, Crime and Traffic Incidents Statistics Report'(2016.1)

    IT SERIANU 206) 2016 (e-payment

    and e-commerce fraud), / , (

    ), , , ,

    -

    ,

    (card skimming)

    205) Crime and Traffic Incidents Statistics Report", The United Republic of Tanzania, 2016.1.206) Tanzania Cyber Security Report 2016, SERIANU, pp. 35-36.

  • - 705 -

    - 2016

    WhatsApp 5

    , TZ-CERT

    ,

    (cyber law)

    - , , PC,

    ,

    - 2016 80%

    ,

    , , , 2016

    50% ,

    -

    , 2016

    6 5 5

    2 ( 25 8,000)

    - (IoT) , , ,

    , IoT

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    -

    ,

    SERIANU 207) ,

    , , ,

    207) Tanzania Cyber Security Report 2016, SERIANU, pp. 32-33.

  • - 706 -

    - ,

    (card skimming),

    -

    , 2016

    (TCRA) 5

    - Sacco ,

    , PR ,

    ,

    - , ,

    , , , , ,

    , ,

    , WiFi ,

    -

    , ,

    POS(point-of-sale)

    ,

    ,

    m

    - 1 1,071

    1 450 ,

    208)

    - , , , ,

    209)

    208) Crime and Traffic Incidents Statistics Report", The United Republic of Tanzania, 2016.1.

  • - 707 -

    CCTV 2016 397 210)

    - 2015 0.5% 2016 5.6%

    (: )

    2015 2016 4,000 3,967 -0.8%

    0.5% 5.6% -

    CCTV (2015 vs 2016)

    ) HS 852580 Television cameras, digital cameras and video camera recorders

    : UN Comtrade DB

    2017 750

    - Technavio 2015 211), 2014

    678 , 2017

    , 2017 750

    212)

    )

    m

    - CCTV , , , ,

    Bio-Lock, Bio-Metric

    CCTV

    209) U.S. OSAC, "Tanzania 2017 Crime & Safety Report"

    210) UN Comtrade DB (2017)211) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)

    212) GDP . p GDP , GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193

  • - 708 -

    CCTV (2010-2016)

    (: ) 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 483 139 225 498 602 1,002 1,220 138 197 290 201 286 317 513 30 5 8 20 2 20 220

    ) HS 852580 Television cameras, digital cameras and video camera recorders

    : UN Comtrade DB

    m

    - , , ,

    ,

    )

    Tera Technologies and Engineering Ltd.

    - Tera Technologies and Engineering Limited 2011 9

    , , ICT, ,

    - , CCTV, , Bio lock, Bio-metric ,

    - CRDB Bank , CCTV

    , EXIM Bank Cisco Access , , ,

    - : Home Page : http://www.teratech.co.tz

    e-Mail : info@teratech.co.tz

    Tel. : + 255 22 2701612, Mobile: +255 713 899 309, +255 754 912281.

    CATS Tanzania Ltd.

    - CATS Tanzania Ltd. 1986

    , , ,

    , , , IT,

    - , ,

  • - 709 -

    - : Home Page : http://www.catsgroup.co.tz/

    e-Mail : sales@catsgroup.co.tz Tel. : T. +255 22 213 7915

    NRD East Africa Ltd.

    - NRD(Norway Registers Development) East Africa Ltd. 2013 3

    ,

    - IT , ICT

    , ,

    - ISACA Tanzania Chapter

    - , CERT,

    , ,

    - Lumension, IBM Security, AccessData, Qualys,

    FireEye, Fortibet and Vasco

    - : Home Page : http://www.nrd.co.tz/

    e-Mail : info@nrd.no Tel. : T. +255 222 110 895

    Cyberoam

    - Cyberoam

    Mart Networks Tanzania Limited

    - 1996 Mart Networks ,

    213)

    - : Home Page : https://www.cyberoam.com/emeatz.html

    e-Mail : poonam.bhatti@mart-networks.com

    Tel. : + 255 683 901 203, Mobile: +255 784 444 490, +255 658 344 490

    SCI

    - SCI 50

    , 1,500 ATM , ,

    213) http://www.mart-networks.com/products-solutions

  • - 710 -

    - , , NGO, , , ,

    , ,

    - : Home Page : http://www.sciafrica.net

    e-Mail : sales@scitz.com Tel. : +255 22 2198600

    Softnet Technologies Limited

    - Softnet , ,

    2002 2014 70 IT

    -

    2 11

    - : Home Page : http://softnet.co.tz

    e-Mail : info@softnet.co.tz Tel. : +255 222 515 100

    )

    3 Tigo

    (2017 2)214)

    - 10

    - ,

    ICT Huawei (2016 6)215)216)217)

    214) , 5 , , KOTRA , 2017.2.17.

    215) http://exchange.co.tz/4-5g-now-in-tanzania-courtesy-of-huawei-and-ttcl, 4.5G now in Tanzania courtesy of Huawei and TTCL(2016.11.3)

    216) http://www.china.org.cn/business/2016-10/01/content_39413931.htm, Huawei offers scholarships to Tanzanian students(2016.10.1)

    217) http://en.yibada.com/articles/39757/20150620/huawei-ict-advisor-tanzanian-government.htm, Chinas Huawei Chosen to Become ICT advisor to Tanzanian Government(2015.6.20)

  • - 711 -

    - ICT Huawei

    (TTCL) 4.5G-LTE

    - Huawei TTCL 10 ,

    Prof. Faustino Kamuzora Huawei

    TTCL

    Huawei 2001 , 230

    , 67%

    - Huawei ICT , Huawei

    ICT Outstanding ICT Leadership

    and Contribution

    2015 6 Huawei ICT

    - , Huawei 2016 2017 ICT

    10 2016.9.30

    - Huawei e-education

    ICT 10 100

    2016 10 2 Huawei

    - , 3

  • - 712 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (The Cybercrimes Act 2015)

    - 2015 2 20 (The Cybercrimes Act, 2015)

    218) 2015 9 1 219)

    -

    , , ,

    - , , , , , ,

    (The Electronic Transactions Act 2015)

    - 2015 5 (The Electronic Transactions Act 2015) 220)

    - , , ICT , ,

    ,

    (CERT Regulations)

    - 2011 CERT 221)

    - CERT

    ,

    , CERT , ,

    - ,

    218) "The Cybercrimes ACT, 2015", The United Republic of Tanzania, 2015219) Recognising significance of cyber security awareness, DailyNews, 2015.10.1.

    220) The Electronic Transactions Act, 2015", The United Republic of Tanzania, 2015221) The Electronics and Postal Communications(Computer Emergency Response Team) Regulations, 2011", The

    United Republic of Tanzania,

  • - 713 -

    m

    (Vision 2025)

    - 2025(Vision 2025) 1

    2025

    - 2025 ICT ICT ,

    ,

    5 (2016/2017 2020/2021)222) -

    2015/2016 2020/2021

    (%) 7.0 10.0 (USD) 1,005 1,500

    (TZS/USD 1) 1,985.39 2,185.62 (TZS, billion) 14,604 32,663

    - ICT

    - ICT (E-Gov) : 37,322.36(TSHS, Billion)

    222) NATIONAL FIVE YEAR DEVELOPMENT PLAN 2016/2017 2020/2021(2016.6)

    18

    2021 6

    (TSH, Billion)2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    327.41 65.48 65.48 65.48 65.48 65.48

    ICT , , e- ()

    ICT

    / ;ICT

    ICT 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

  • - 714 -

    (TSH, Billion)N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

    ICT , (EPZA)

    BOQ

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    3.51 1.00 0.63 0.63 0.63 0.63

    ICT (3 2 )

    (IDC)

    ICT

    2020.6

    (TSH, Billion) 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    794.73 158.95 158.95 158.95 158.95 158.95

    : 92

    -

    (TSH, Billion) 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    57.88 14.40 14.40 14.40 14.40 -

    (TSH, Billion) 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    1.50 - 0.70 0.80 - -

    (TIRDO) TIRDO :

    (TSH, Billion) 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    0.50 0.20 0.30 - - -

    (Open)

    , ,

    ICT

  • - 715 -

    -

    , ,

    ICT

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    5.00 1.00 3.00 1.00 - -

    -

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    11.00 - 4.00 3.00 2.00 2.00

    -

    , ,

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    (TSH, Billion) 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    2.50 0.50 1.00 1.00 - -

  • - 716 -

    223)

    - (Tanzania Police Force) "Crime and Traffic Incident Statistics

    Report 2015" 2016 1 ,

    - 1) ,

    2) ,

    3)

    , 4) , 5) , 6)

    223) The United Republic of Tanzania, Crime and Traffic Incidents Statistics Report'(2016.1)

    26.00 10.00 16.00 - - -

    -

    (, ,

    )

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    5.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 -

    -

    (TSH, Billion)2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    25.00 - 8.00 7.00 10.00 -

    (TSH, Billion)

    2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21

    944.62 188.05 215.98 191.78 186.98 161.58

  • - 717 -

    )

    (Tanzania Computer Emergency Response Team, TZ-CERT)224)

    - 2015 5 (TZ-CERT)

    , ,

    - TZ-CERT , ,

    , ,

    - TZ-CERT , ,

    - CERT

    (Electronic and Postal Communications Act,

    EPOCA) 2010 225) TZ-CERT (TCRA)

    (Ministry of Works, Transport and Communication), MWTC)

    - (MWTC) 2008 ICT ,

    - , , , ICT,

    - ICT 2016(NICTP2016) , , ,

    (Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority, TCRA)

    - (TCRA) (quasi) ,

    ,

    (Tanzania Communications Regulatory Act No.12 of 2003)

    - ICT

    - TCRA 2003 11 1 (TTC)

    (TBC)

    224) https://www.tzcert.go.tz/225) Amos Nungu, "Cyber firm to boost network security in Tanzania", 2012.6.26.

  • - 718 -

    (Cybercrime Unit)226)

    -

    2012 ,

    )

    -

    )

    (TCRA)

    (2017 10)227)

    -

    - () , 2017(Electronic and

    Postal Communications(Online Content) Regulations, 2017) ,

    -

    , 5 ( 2,300)

    12

    - , , ,

    - ,

    CCTV 24

    - , TV,

    -

    226) UNIDIR, "The Cyber Index, International Security Trends and Realities", 2013. p88227) Tanzania: Government to regulate social media, IT News Africa, 2017.10.2

  • - 719 -

    (2017 7)228)229)

    - ((Personal Data Protection Act)

    (Cybercrimes Act 2015) (Electronic Transactions Act 2015)

    1

    - (MWTC) Edwin Ngonyani

    ,

    - (CERT)

    (National Cyber Security Strategy)

    - -

    ,

    (2016 12)230)

    - (MWTC) Kamuzora

    - ,

    , ICT

    - (Dar es Salaam Internet Centre, DIC)

    3,500 , 25

    - , , ,

    228) Tanzania continues to fight cybercrime, ITnewsafrica, 2017.7.28

    229) New law to plug cyber-crime, dailynews, 2017.7.26230) Tanzania: Data Protection Law Coming, allafrica.com, 2016.12.1

  • - 720 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) (0.6), (0.71), (0.79), (0.66), (0.28)

    , , (0.83) 2

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.602 36

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT 14%

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 2.13 150 8.84 1

    (Access) 2.65 159 8.99 8

    (Use) 1.47 136 8.57 3

    (Skills) 2.42 161 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.602 36 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.339 138 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.9 83 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%) 13 0.1 28,036 56.1 22 0.2 20,556 41.1 8,922 69.9 61,296 122.7 20.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 8.92

    '17 () 12,988

  • - 721 -

    1)

    )

    2016 1 231)232)

    - BNR(National Bank of Rwanda)*

    2015 2,500

    * ISO27001:2013 2017 8

    -

    -

    ,

    - , 2016 70

    233)

    ITU 2017 7 Global Cybersecurity Index

    0.602, 36 ,

    (Mauritius) 2

    - , 5

    , 0.79 ,

    0.28

    -

    ICT ,

    - ICT ,

    ,

    234)

    231) KTPRESS "New Bill Allows Rwanda to Launch Cyber Attacks at Any Threat", 2017.3.27.

    232) Symantec, Cyber Crime &Cyber Security Trends in Africa, 2016.11. p84

    233) IGIHE, "Rwanda bank survives a Rwf500 million cyber-heist", 2017.1.17

    234) SMART Rwanda Master Plan 2015~2020, p60

  • - 722 -

    - ICT , ,

    , e-Banking, ICT ,

    , , , ICT

    - ,

    - 2014 (Rwandan National Police, RNP) 35

    91.4% 235)

    - 2014

    5 4

    236)

    237)

    - ,

    (National

    Computer Security Incident Response Centre) 2014 238)

    - 2015 ,

    - (Korea Information Certificate Authority) 2016

    3

    239)

    - 2017 8 ICT4D

    (RISA) 240)

    - , 2017 5 (NCSA) ,

    (National Cyber Security Bill) ,

    NCSA , NCSA

    241)

    235) The NewTimes, "Public urged to be vigilant against cyber attacks", 2015.08.30.

    236) The NewTimes, "Public urged to be vigilant against cyber attacks", 2015.08.30.237) SMART Rwanda Master Plan 2015~2020, p60

    238) The NewTimes, "Public urged to be vigilant against cyber attacks", 2015.08.30.239) Kigali installs $3 million cyber security system to curb online crimes, The East African, 2016.5.21.

    240) RDB passes ICT roles to RISA, Hope Magazine, 2017.7.17

    241) Senate adopts Law establishing National Cyber Security Authority, Republic of Rwanda

    Parliament, 2017.05.11.

  • - 723 -

    242)

    -

    - Rw-CSIRT

    - ,,

    ICT

    -

    - ICT , ,

    , , , ,

    , 243)

    - ICT , ,

    ICT

    -

    (Internet Security Center) ,

    (National Public Key Infrastructure, PKI),

    (National Computer Security and Incident Response

    Team, CSIRT)

    - (National Backbone, NBB), (National Data

    Center, NDC), 4G LTE last mile , , ,

    - ,

    ,

    242) Symantec, Cyber Crime &Cyber Security Trends in Africa, 2016.11. p84

    243) Republic of Rwanda, "National Cyber Security Policy", 2015.3.

  • - 724 -

    )

    - ITU 244) 2016 , 1 3,403

    , 2015 1 6,983 21.1%

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    (17 6 )

    ()

    TIGO 4,214 60.6%

    MTN 1,906 27.4%

    Liquid Telecom 829 11.9%

    Airtel 11 0.2%

    6,960 100%

    : RURA(2017.6)

    - 2017 6 TIGO 4,214, MTN

    244) ITU, "Fixed-telephone subscriptions"(2017.6)

  • - 725 -

    1,906, Liquid Telecom 829, Airtel

    11 245)

    - 2017 6 Tigo(60.6%), MTN Rwanda(27.4%),

    Liquid Telecom(11.9%) 246)

    - ,

    ,

    - , 2016 12 13,403 2017 6 6,960

    ,

    - ITU 247) 2016 892 1,533

    69.92%, 2015 0.6% , 2010

    2016 (CAGR) 16.6%

    (: , %)

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.7)

    245) RURA, Statistics and Tariff Information in Telecom, Media and Postal Service as of the Second Quarter 2017, 2017.6.

    246) RURA, Statistics and Tariff Information in Telecom, Media and Postal Service as of the Second Quarter 2017, 2017.6.

    247) ITU, "Mobile-cellular subscriptions"(2017.6)

  • - 726 -

    (17 5 )

    ()

    MTN 3,518,801 42.1%

    Tigo 3,252,765 38.9%

    Airtel 1,581,375 18.9%

    8,352,941 100%

    : RURA(2017.5)

    - MTN Rwanda, Tigo, Airel 3

    , 2017 5 MTN Rwanda(42.1%), Tigo(38.9%),

    Airtel(18.9%) , MTN Rwanda 1

    - Tigo 4G LTE

    Wi-Fi 248)

    - 4G LTE 2014 11 , 2016 9 20

    , 4G LTE

    - 80% , Airtel

    , (balloon)

    249)

    - 2013 3 (RDB) KT (Olleh Rwanda

    Networks) LTE , , LTE

    2015 5 4G LTE

    - 2015 3 ICT (Kigali City), ORN(Olleh Rwanda

    Networks) 4G LTE 250)

    248) Business Sweden in Eastern Africa, Opportunities in the ICT Sector in East Africa, 2017.4.26.

    p13.

    249) , , 820 , KOTRA, 2015.12.01250) , , KOICA , 2015.03., p.8.

  • - 727 -

    (: )

    : Business Sweden in Eastern Africa, Opportunities in the ICT Sector in East

    Africa, p.13. (2017.4.26.)

    -

    , 251)

    (17 3 )

    ()

    Tigo Tigo Pesa 2,854,382 43.5%

    MTN M-Pesa 2,264,394 34.5%

    Airtel Airtel Money 1,449,793 22.1%

    6,568,569 100%

    : RURA(2017.3)

    - Tigo

    43.5%

    - 2017 3 650

    251) Business Sweden in Eastern Africa, Opportunities in the ICT Sector in East Africa, 2017.4.26.

    p13.

  • - 728 -

    - RURA 252) 412 ,

    99.5% , 0.5%

    (2017 3 )

    3,921,207 85.53%

    663,258 14.47%

    4,584,465 100.0%

    : RURA(2017.3)

    252) RURA, Statistics and Tariff Information in Telecom, Media and Postal Service as of the Fourth Quarter 2016, 2016.12.

  • - 729 -

    2)

    )

    m

    ICT

    - (SMART Rwanda Master Plan 2015~2020) ICT

    (ICT Sector Strategic Plan 2013-2018) ,

    , ICT

    - 2015/16 953 RWF( 1 1,332 USD)

    20 RWF( 238 USD) 253)

    - 2017 (NCSA)

    ICT

    - 10 (2007-2013)

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.9 4.1 4.6 4.8 200.1 200.6 205.0 205.3 207.3 206.6 207.7

    : United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2016

    m

    2017 280

    - Technavio 2015 254), 2014

    192 , 2017

    , 2017 280

    255)

    253) Deloitte, Rwanda Economic Outlook 2016, p11. 2016.6.

    254) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)255) GDP . p GDP ,

  • - 730 -

    CCTV 2010 , 2016

    176.3 256)

    -

    -

    (: )

    2015 2016

    1,200 1,763 46.9%

    7.6% 33.2% -

    CCTV (2015 vs 2016)

    ) HS 852580 Television cameras, digital cameras and video camera recorders

    : UN Comtrade DB

    )

    Fodey Security & Alarm System (FOSES) LTD.

    - 2000

    , ,

    - , , CCTV

    - MTN, Agaseke bank, Fina Bank, East African Business Councul

    - : Home Page : www.fodeysecurity.com

    e-Mail : salesfodeysecuritykigali@live.com

    Tel. : 55106062, Fax : 55106063

    GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193

    256) UN Comtrade DB (2017)

  • - 731 -

    ISCO

    - ISCO 1995 , Intersec Security

    - , ,

    , 4G 4G

    - GTBank, EQUITY Bank, TiGo, MTN ,

    - : Home Page : www.isco.co.rw/

    e-Mail : info@isco.co.rw

    Cyberteq257)

    - Cyberteq ICT ,

    , Cybercom 2017

    - , IT , ,

    , , , , ,

    - , , , , ,

    - : Home Page : www.cyber-teq.com

    e-Mail : info@cyber-teq.com

    Tel. : +250 788 647 718

    KK Security Ltd.

    - KK Security Ltd. , , ,

    ,

    - CCTV , ,

    , , (biometrics system)

    - : Home Page : www.kksecurity.com

    e-Mail : kkkigali@kksecurity.com

    Tel. : +250(0) 788 907 867, +250(0) 725 404 601

    257) https://www.linkedin.com/company/cyberteq

  • - 732 -

    Sekanyolya Systems Ltd.

    - 1993 ,

    -

    ,

    - CCTV, ,

    - : Home Page : www.sekanyolya.com

    e-Mail : infor@sekanyolya.com

    Tel. : +250 788 699 000, +250 456 000 035

    Highsec Ltd.

    - 2009 , , Airtel, gulf energy, university of

    Rwanda, WorldWide e-learning campus

    - CCTV , ,

    - : Home Page : highsecltd.com

    e-Mail : info@highsecltd.com, highsecltd@yahoo.com

    Tel. : +250 788 309 751, +250 788 308 216

    )

    , Huawei (2017.3.)258)

    - ITU Huawei Technologies ICT

    (MYICT), (RURA),

    Paul Kagame

    - Kagame Huawei Ms. Sun

    Yafang(Chairwoman) ICT

    Huawei MoU

    - MoU Huawei , , ,

    258) President of Rwanda: Looking forward to Huaweis Participation in Information Construction in Rwanda, Huawei news, 2017.3.16.

  • - 733 -

    ICT

    - Huawei 10 80%

    Huawei

    WISeKey International Holding Ltd 17

    (Smart Africa initiative) /IoT

    (2017.3.)259)

    -

    (trusted

    blockchain as a service)

    - WiSeKey

    - WiSeKey WISeID , WISeID

    - WISeKey CEO Carlos Creus Moreira /IoT

    ,

    (2015.5.)260)

    - BNR(National Bank of Rwanda) ,

    2 5,700 (RWF)

    , 2015 1 1 7,400 (RWF)

    (2014.10)261)

    -

    259) WISeKey to launch blockchain/IoT centre of excellence in Rwanda, 2017.03.02., smartcitiesworld, 2017.3.2.

    260) Cyber threats risks could undermine financial sector, The East African, 2015.5.8.261) Rwanda's growing online shoppers fall prey to smart Internet fraudsters, The NewTiems, 2014.10.21.

  • - 734 -

    3)

    )

    m

    2013

    - Stop, Think, and Click ICT RDB

    , ,

    - IT

    - ,

    - 2013 2014 876

    (Rwanda Vision 2020)

    - 2000 Vision 2020' , ICT

    , , (Cross-Cutting Area)

    ICT (NICI Plan)

    - ICT 'NICI(National Information and Communication Infrastructure)

    Plan' 1998 UNECA(Economy Committee for Africa) AISI(African Information

    Society Initiative)

    - Vision 2020 ICT 4

    , NICI 1 2000

  • - 735 -

    ICT NICI I~III

    : Smart Rwanda Master Plan(2015~2020) draft, p37

    - NICI-Phase I (NICI-2005): 2000~2005

    ICT ,

    , , ICT , ,

    , ICT , , 8

    - NICI-Phase II (NICI-2010): 2006~2010

    , ICT

    , , ICT , , , ,

    , , , , 10

    - NICI-Phase III (NICI-2015): 2011~2015

    ICT ICT

    , , , , 5

  • - 736 -

    - NICI-Phase IV(NICI-2020): 2016~2020

    ICT

    NICI-Phase III (NICI-2015) 262)

    - NICI III 5 ( , , , ,

    ) ,

    ICT NICI-Phase III

    : National ICT Strategy and Plan NICI - 2015

    - ,

    ICT ICT

    -

    , ICT IT

    -

    ICT ,

    , ,

    262) National ICT Strategy and Plan NICI - 2015 pp15, 21, 25~26

  • - 737 -

    - 5 , ,

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    -

    (Rw-CERT/CSIRT263)):

    (Public Key Infrastructure, PKI) :

    :

    : ICT

    :

    :

    ICT NICI-Phase III

    : National ICT Strategy and Plan NICI 2015. p56

    - 2014 (SRMP 2015~2020)

    264)

    263) Rw-CERT/CSIRT: Computer Emergency and Security Incident Response Team264) Smart Rwanda Master Plan(2015~2020) draft, p40

  • - 738 -

    , , ,

    (SRMP 2015~2020)

    - ICT (SMART Rwanda Master Plan 2015~2020,

    SRMP) 2014

    - SRMP ICT , ,

    , 5

    - SRMP ICT , , , ,

    - SRMP

    ICT

    (NICI)

    - SRMP

    ,

    (Service-

    oriented), (Modern), (Accountable), (Real-Tim)

    (SMART)

    , ,

    , ,

    , , , ICT

    - SRMP 5 , ROI 142.3%

    17 2,200 GDP 21% 7

    - IT ,

    ,

    265)

    - ,

    265) SMART Rwanda Master Plan(2015~2020), p.60

  • - 739 -

    -

    - SRMP

    ,

    266)

    ,

    , CCTV, , ,

    ,

    - (SRMP) 10 ,

    8 ICT

    7

    SRMP ICT

    : Smart Rwanda Master Plan v2.1, Annex 3.(2015) 8p.

    - ICT (SRMP)

    IT Ericsson , ICT ,

    , 267)

    (RDB)

    268)

    266) SMART Rwanda Master Plan(2015~2020), p.61267) , , KOICA , 2015.03., p.8.

  • - 740 -

    - RDB ,

    - RDB , , ,

    ,

    - RDB

    (National Cyber Security Policy)269)

    - 2015 3 ,

    , ,

    - ICT , ICT

    ICT 3(NICI-Phase III)

    -

    - (Rwanda Vision 2020), ICT(NICI Plan)

    ICT

    , ICT

    -

    -

    :

    : , , ICT

    ,

    - :

    :

    268) ITU Manaho, 2014,269) Republic of Rwanda, "National Cyber Security Policy, 2015.3.

  • - 741 -

    : , ,

    : ,

    - (goal) (objective)

    , ,

    ,

    , ,

    (National Cyber Security Strategic Plan)270)

    - 2015 3

    ,

    : Republic of Rwanda, National Security Strategic Plan'(2015.3)

    270) Republic of Rwanda, "National Security Strategic Plan, 2015.3.

  • - 742 -

    - , 2015-2020

    168 5,500 (FRW)

    : Republic of Rwanda, National Security Strategic Plan'(2015.3)

    (The Smart Africa Smart Cities Blueprint)271)

    - 2017 5 Transform Africa Summit 2017

    ,

    - ICT (layer)

    ,

    IT , ,

    , ,

    , , ,

    271) Republic of Rwanda, "The Smart Africa Smart Cities Blueprint, 2017.5.

  • - 743 -

    : Republic of Rwanda, "The Smart Africa Smart Cities Blueprint(2017.5.) p.29

    - IT

  • - 744 -

    )

    (Rwanda Development Board, RDB)

    - ICT(Ministry of Youth and

    ICT) (Rwanda Development Board, RDB)

    - RDB ICT

    ICT NICI Plan

    - RDB IT ICT4D

    ICT

    - RDB ,

    - 2016 RDB (National Digital Certification, NDCC)

    (Certification Authority, CA) 272)

    - RDB ICT 6 , ,

    , , , IT 273)

    - RDB ICT (department) 5 (division) ICT , ICT ,

    , ICT ,

    - ICT , , , ,

    ICT / , ,

    - ICT(ICT Security division)

    IT , ,

    ICT

    (,

    , ) , , ,

    272) Rw-CSIRT: http://www.rw-csirt.rw/eng/about-us/history.php

    273) RBD : http://www.rdb.rw/departments/information-communication-technology/clusters.html

  • - 745 -

    ICT(Ministry of Youth and ICT, MYICT)

    - ICT ICT , ICT

    ICT ,

    ICT , ICT

    - ICT

    - ICT ICT

    - ICT

    ICT ICT

    ICT

    ,

    ICT

    - ICT

    ICT

    ICT

    IT pool

    (National Computer Security Incident Response Centre,

    Rw-CSIRT)

    - , ,

    2014 274) 2015 4

    - Rw-CSIRT 275)

    ,

    - RDB Rw-CSIRT Rw-CSIRT

    274) Rwanda Development Board news, "The Rwanda Development Board Meets Applicaion Developers over Cyber Security, 2015.4.28.

    275) http://www.rw-csirt.rw/eng/

  • - 746 -

    276)

    - , Rw-CSIRT

    (Rwanda Utilities Regulatory Agency, RURA)

    - ,

    , , , ,

    - ICT ,

    , , ,

    , , , ,

    ,

    277)

    -

    Rw-CSIRT

    (Rwanda Information Society Authority, RISA)278)

    - 2017 1 RISA 2017

    ,

    - RISA ICT4D

    (fast-track) ICT

    ICT (affordability)

    276) Symantec, Cyber Crime &Cyber Security Trends in Africa, 2016.11. p83

    277) Symantec, Cyber Crime &Cyber Security, 2016.11. p83

    278) RISA : http://risa.rw/

  • - 747 -

    ICT

    ICT

    ICT

    ICT

    - 2017 8 CEO Innocent Bagamba Muhizi,

    (Government Chief Innovation Officer) Antoine Sebera,

    (Government Chief Information Officer) Josephine Nyiranzeyimana

    - 2017 7 RDB (RISA) RDB ICT

    RISA ICT ,

    , RDB ICT , ICT

    279)

    - RISA ( CCTV, ,

    , RISA )

    (National Cyber Security Authority, NCSA)

    - 2017 5 (NCSA) (National

    Cyber Security bill)

    - 2017 8, NCSA ,

    )

    279) RDB passes ICT roles to RISA, Hope Magazine, 2017.7.17

  • - 748 -

    )

    ITU 2017

    2(2017.7.)280)

    -

    - ITU , , , , 5

    -

    5 ,

    - ICT Jean Philber Nsengimana ICT

    , , , ,

    - ,

    , , , , ,

    - 2017 193 36,

    2, 2014

    3

    (2017.5.)281)

    - (Rwanda Information Society Authority, RISA)

    - 150 ()

    ,

    - RISA

    , ,

    ,

    280) "Rwanda, Mauritius top Africa in 2017 global cyber security index, newtimes, 2017.7.7. 281) "Senate adopts Law establishing National Cyber Security Authority, Republic of Rwanda Paliament,

    2017.5.11.

  • - 749 -

    Windows 10

    , ,

    - RISA /PC

    , (Rw-CSIRT)

    (NCSA) ICT 38

    Rwf (2017.5.)282)

    - ICT Jean Philbert Nsengimana

    20

    ICT

    - ICT , 2016

    178Rwf( 2,120 ) , 38

    Rwf( 450 )

    - , ICT 2018/2019

    174 Rwf( 2,072 ) 4 2Rwf( 50 )

    (2017.5.)283)

    - (National Cyber Security Authority, NCSA)

    , , (National Cyber Security bill)

    -

    -

    ,

    - ICT

    282) "Rwf3.8 billion Cut from ICT Ministry Budget to Fund Cyber Security Agency, KTpress.rw, 2017.5.09. 283) "Senate adopts Law establishing National Cyber Security Authority, Republic of Rwanda Paliament,

    2017.5.11.

  • - 750 -

    - (National Cyber Security bill)

    284)

    (2017.5.)285)286)287)

    - Transform Africa

    Summit 2017 5 10~12

    - (Smart Cities Fast Forward)

    , ,

    , , , ,

    - Transform Africa , ,

    ,

    ICT

    - 3,500 ,

    - Africa Smart Cities Blueprint ,

    ,

    , , NGO, ,

    -

    , ,

    /

    - ,

    ,

    -

    ,

    284) "Rwf3.8 billion Cut from ICT Ministry Budget to Fund Cyber Security Agency, KTpress.rw, 2017.5.09.

    285) "Rwanda hosts Transform Africa Summit 2017, Republic of Rwanda, 2017.5.9.

    286) "Transform Africa Summit 2017 opens in Kigali, MYICT, 2017.5.10.287) "African leaders recommit to push the continent's digital transformation, MYICT, 2017.5.11.

  • - 751 -

    , Wi-Fi

    (RISA) (2017.1.)288)

    - (Rwanda Information Society Authority, RISA)

    , ,

    - 2017 1 , RISA

    , 2015 11 ICT , 5 ICT

    - RISA ICT

    ITU 2017 (2016.12.)289)

    - (Regional Preparatory Meeting, PGM)

    12 6~8

    - ITU (World Telecommunication

    Development Conference, WTDC-14)

    , 2018-2021

    - ITU Houlin Zhao 2017 10

    WTDC-17 ,

    - ICT Jean Philbert Nsengimana ICT ,

    , , ICT

    - 2018-202

    ICT

    288) "Law establishing ICT centre to make Rwanda a knowledge-based economy, newtimes, 2017.1.9.289) "Rwanda hosts regional preparatory meeting for ITUs World Telecommunication Development Conference

    2017, MYICT news, 2016.12.9.

  • - 752 -

    150 (2016.9.)290)

    - , ,

    (cyber-security centre) 150

    -

    (RNP), Cyber Enabled Crime Exercise' (2016.8.)291)

    - 100

    'Cyber Enabled Crime Exercise'

    - RNP Interpol 2016 8 28~9 2

    , , ,

    3 (2016.5.)292)

    -

    - (Korea Information Certificate Authority) 3

    3 ,

    ,

    - (Ministry of Finance) (Public Procurement

    Authority)

    (2015.10)293)

    - (RNP) Interpol 10

    28

    290) "New regional cyber security centre set for Rwanda, The EastAfrican, 2016.9.1.291) Rwanda National Police to Host EAPCCO-AGM and 'Cyber Enabled Crime Exercise', allAfrica,

    2016.08.28

    292) Kigali installs $3 million cyber security system to curb online crimes, The East African, 2016.5.21.293) Cyber crime investigation training for Africa in Rwanda,2015.10.30.

  • - 753 -

    , ,

    (2015.6.)294)

    - , , ,

    - 22% ,

    ,

    (2015.05)295)

    - (Stay Safe Online)'

    ICT

    - ITU

    ICT, (RDB),

    (RNP)

    294) CoW countries in cybersecurity pact, The East African, 2015.6.27295) Rwanda: Beware of Trends in Cyber Crime, Tech Developers Told, allAfrica, 2015.5.7.

  • - 754 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.570 45

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 2.99 129 8.84 1

    (Access) 3.54 133 8.99 8

    (Use) 2.05 123 8.57 3

    (Skills) 3.76 133 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.57 45 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.419 119 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.8 86 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    72 0.15 28,035 56.1

    157 0.3 20,555 41.1

    38,982 81.3 61,295 122.7

    26.0% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 75.1

    '17 () 46,791

  • - 755 -

    1)

    )

    World Economic Forum The Global Information Technology Report 2016

    (NRI) 3.8 143 86

    - CIA(Central Intelligence Agency) , 4,500 , 0-14

    41.6%, 69.6%, Facebook 500 ,

    3,750

    2017 4 6, 2016(Computer and cybercrime

    Bill)'

    -

    ICT

    2014 (National Cyber Security Masterplan),

    - Deloitte

    2016 180 ( 1,800 ) , 2017 30%

    234 ( 2,340 )

    - Kenya Security Survey 2016' ,

    2012 2016

    -

    (National Awareness Raising Campaign)

    - Google, Facebook

    , -

    , UN

  • - 756 -

    , SERIANU

    , 70%

    21%

    - Kaspersky Lab , CIO CISO

    ,

    125 Kenya Security Survey 2016' ,

    - 42%

    - 35% 1

    - 63%

    - 41%

    - 72% 5 , 88%

    - 96% 5,000

    - 62% PCI ISO

    Kenya Security Survey 2016'

    -

    -

    -

    -

    -

    Kenya Cyber Security Report 2016 1

    7,500 , ,

    - 2016

    - , ATM ,

  • - 757 -

    - ,

    - (

    ), Two Rivers

    (China National Aero Technology International

    Engineering Company)

    Kenya ISACA

    1,000 20

    , 73% 23% DOS

    - 68%

    - 61% BYOD 59%

    2015 2016

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5 Sacco's (E-commerce)

    6

    7

    8

    9 (, )

    10

  • - 758 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 0.03% 72,801

    ( 0.15%)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 0.05%

    157,878 ( 0.33%)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 759 -

    - 2016 2015 0.6% 3,898

    , 81.3%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    2)

    )

    m

    2014 7.9% / 8.4%,

    3.8%

    -

    2%

    2017 2,330

    - Technavio 2015 296) , 2017

    , 2017 2,330

    296) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)

  • - 760 -

    297)

    IT

    IT

    IT : 2014-2020

    : BMI Research(2016)

    - 2016 IT IT 21.5%, 28.4%,

    40%

    - IT

    - IT

    ,

    - Cyberoam

    297) GDP . p GDP , GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193 , Y 0.668571234 8 GDP

  • - 761 -

    - , MSS(Managed Security Service)

    - KE-CIRT

    ,

    SDI 2015 (Homeland Security)

    10 , , ,

    -

    2016 ~ 2020 3.94%

    : 2011-2015 vs. 2016-2020

    CAGR 2011-2015 CAGR 2016-20202015 ( )

    22.54% 10.74% 8.2

    8.42% 9.82% 5.9

    -2.87% 2.85% 4.0

    4.70% 4.44% 4.0

    2.60% 3.94% 1.0

    : SDI, Homeland Security Expenditure in Kenya to 2020: Market Review(2015.6)

    2016~2020

    : SDI, Homeland Security Expenditure in Kenya to 2020: Market Review(2015.6)

  • - 762 -

    )

    m

    Symantec Cyberoam

    ISP

    - ,

    - IT Naisoft

    Antivirus

    Content/Spam Filtering

    Network Management

    Change and Configuration Audit

    Data Leakage Protection

    Intrusion Detection & Prevention IDS/IPS.

    Firewalls

    Virtual Private Network (VPN)

    Integrated Security Appliance (UTMs)

    m

    Safricom

    - Safricom 149 (KES)(1 6,220 )

    18

    - 2014 6

    2013 9

    - ,

  • - 763 -

    Cyberoam

    - Cyberoam

    IT BusinessIT Africa

    (2014.10)

    - BusinessIT Cyberoam , UTM(Unified Threat Management Appliances)

    - Cyberoam ,

    - Cyberoam

    Cyberoam NetGenie

    Cyberoam Network Security AppliancesNext-Generation Firewalls(NGFW), Unified Threat Management Appliance(UTM)

    Cyberoam iView

    Cyberoam Central Console

    Cyberoam

    Symantec

    - Symantec SEACOM Pamoja

    - Symantec (Sub-Sahara) Pamoja

    - Pamoja

    AccessKenya

    - AccessKenya Security Risks Solution Internet

    Solutions Kenya (Managed Security Service, MSS)

    (2014.3)

  • - 764 -

    - 7 ,

    ,

    NetGuardians

    - NetGuarians IT Sofgen

    SW

    - NetGuarians Price Waterhouse Coopers(PwC)

  • - 765 -

    3)

    )

    m

    (Kenya Information and Communication Act CAP411A)

    - 1998 , 2013 2014

    - Communications Commission of Kenya(CCK) CIRT(National

    Computer Incident Response Team)

    - CCK KE-CIRT/CC

    ,

    2017 4 6 2016(Computer and

    cybercrime Bill)'

    - 2017

    - 2016 , , ,

    , M-Pesa, Airtel Money

    - 3 , 5 ,

    10 ,

  • - 766 -

    : simmons & simmons(2015.6)

    m

    ITU CIRT

    - CIRT

    - 2012 2, ITU

    -

    - (East African Community) , Common

    Market Protocol

    - 58

    , ,

    (National Cyber security Strategy)

    - Vision 2030 3

    ICT

    - ,

    ICT

  • - 767 -

    -

    : Kenya Information and Communications

    (Amendment) ACT, 2014 , National Kenya computer incident response Team

    coordination Center(KE-CIRT), Nation Certification Authority Framework

    -

    : Kenya Cybersecurity Report 2015

    4

    - 1) ,

    - 2)

    - 3) ,

    - 4) , ,

  • - 768 -

    : Kenya Cybersecurity Report 2015

    )

    (Kenya Computer Emergency Response Team, KE-CERT)

    - KE-CIRT

    CIRT, CIRT, CIRT

    , ,

    ,

    (PKI)

  • - 769 -

    - KE-CIRT/CC

    Ministry of Information and Communication(MOIC)

    Communications Commission of Kenya(CCK)

    Kenya ICT Board(KICTB)

    International Telecommunications Union(ITU)

    : www.privacyinternational.org

    )

    - ( )

    )

    IT Dimension Data(DiData)

    (2016.5)

  • - 770 -

    - 2016 5, Dimention Data (MSS)

    - (Security Operation Centres,

    SOCs)

  • - 771 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 5

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.139 128

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 167

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 3.12 124 8.84 1

    (Access) 3.98 126 8.99 8

    (Use) 1.92 124 8.57 3

    (Skills) 3.82 132 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.139 128 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.358 129 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 2.9 125 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 )

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    19 1.1 28,035 56.1

    13 0.7 20,555 41.1

    2,982 144.2 61,295 122.7

    48.1% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 14.58

    '17 () 1,739

  • - 772 -

    1)

    )

    World Economic Forum The Global Information Technology Report 2016 ,

    (NRI, Network readiness index)

    2.9 143 122

    - CIA(Central Intelligence Agency) , 170 , 0-14

    42.1%, 39.3%, Facebook 36 ,

    290

    -

    , ,

    Rapid7 2016 6

    50 12 298)

    : http://www.telegraph.co.uk

    Knoema ,

    28, 4 , ,

    298) Telegraph.co.uk, "Mapped: The countries most vulnerable to cyber-attacks", 2016.6.10

  • - 773 -

    Cyber Security Index : Gabon

    : https://knoema.com

    2013 6 ,

    - http://www.mines.gouv.ga/

    - http://www.affaires-etrangeres.gouv.ga/

    - http://www.budget.gouv.ga

    - http://www.dgsi.gouv.ga/

    - http://www.finances.gouv.ga/

    - http://www.economie.gouv.ga

  • - 774 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 0.02% 18,946

    , 1.05%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 0.1%

    13,115 , 0.73%

  • - 775 -

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 16.9% 2,582,542

    , 144.2%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 776 -

    2)

    )

    m

    2017 420

    - Technavio 2015 299) , 2017

    , 2017 420

    300)

    )

    m

    - Symantec Cyberoam

    IT

    - , Microsoft, IBM, Cisco IT

    m

    IPX Gabon

    - IPX Gabon , VSAT 30

    299) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)300) GDP . p GDP ,

    GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193 , Y 0.668571234 8 GDP

  • - 777 -

    , WAN LAN

    - IPX , , , PTT(Push to Talk) ,

    ,

    IPX Gabon 35

    : IPX Gabon

    - ( ) IPX

    , IPX

    VSAT IPX

    - ( ) IPX

    , IPX

    , ,

  • - 778 -

    - ( ) IPX ,

    , ,

    )

    Microsoft 2016 3 CityNext

    (2016. 3)

    - 2013 CityNext Program Microsoft

    Laura lpsen

    - Microsoft

    - CityNext Microsoft , , , ,

    , ,

    - CityNext UNAIDS

    CityNext 2015 CityNext 2

  • - 779 -

    3)

    )

    m

    - Draft Law on Cybercrime

    - Draft Law on Cybersecurity

    - Articles 255 and 263 of the Criminal Code

    : simmons & simmons(2015.6)

  • - 780 -

    m

    National Cybersecurity Strategy

    -

    -

    -

    /

    -

    -

    - ANINF(National Agency of Digital Infrastructures and

    Frequencies)

    -

    - ITU-IMPACT initiative

    - EU/ITU Support for Harmonization of the ICT

    Policies in Sub-Sahara Africa (HIPSSA)

  • - 781 -

    )

    ANINF(National Agency of Digital Infrastructures and Frequencies)

    - ANINF ,

    - ANINF

    : Ministry of Digital Economy, Communication & Post

    CIRT

    - CIRT

    - ITU 2010 CIRT

    )

    - ( )

  • - 782 -

    - (

    )

    )

    ANINF Kaspersky Lab MOU

    (2016.6)

    - ANINF , IT

    ,

    - 2016 6 23 Libreville ANINF Alex Bernard Bongo

    Ondimba Kaspersky Lab Veniamin Levtsov

    MoU IT

    - ANINF Kaspersky Lab MoU Kaspersky Lab

    ,

  • - 783 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI)

    ,

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.314 89

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 175

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 2.53 141 8.84 1

    (Access) 3.59 132 8.99 8

    (Use) 1.64 133 8.57 3

    (Skills) 2.17 166 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.314 89 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.325 144 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.4 107 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) ,

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    285 1.8 28,035 56.1

    98 0.6 20,555 41.1

    15,186 98.6 61,295 122.6

    25.7% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 14.87

    '17 () 14,320

  • - 784 -

    1)

    )

    World Economic Forum The Global Information Technology Report 2016

    (NRI) 3.4 143 106

    - CIA(Central Intelligence Agency) , 2017 1,466 ,

    0-14 41.51% 25.6%

    - (Autorit de Rgulation des Tlcommunications et des Postes, ARTP) 2017 3 103.2%

    Issa

    Diack

    10% 301)

    - 2016

    6 (CFCA)

    - 2014 47 2015 1

    (Agence de linformation de lEtat, ADIE)

    2017 GCI ,

    , , ,

    ,

    301) www.scidev.net,Les cyberattaques dans la cybercriminalit en Afrique, (2017.4.28)

  • - 785 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 0.15% 285,933

    ( 1.86%)

    (2013~2016)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 0.03% 98,353

    ( 0.64%)

    (2013~2016)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 786 -

    - 2016 2015 1.27% 98.68%

    (2013~2016)

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    5~6%

    - 2010 3G 16% 2015 94% 2017 3

    96.6%

    : ARTP(2017.3)

  • - 787 -

    2)

    )

    m

    - Henri Boumy Ciss

    , , , ,

    400

    302)

    2014 7.9% / 8.4%,

    3.8%

    -

    2%

    -

    (, , )

    Wifi

    ,

    2015 10,000

    302) Enqute+, Il y a 400 agences ou plus de scurit au Sngal,2016.6.29

  • - 788 -

    ICT ,

    - 2016 2025 GDP 10%

    ICT , , , , ,

    2025

    (Sngal Numrique 2025) 25 ( 69) - 2011 ICT

    CTIC Dakar 3 30 1 700

    - , coworking space,

    ICT

    2014 ITU

    2015 2018

    303)

    - (Nouveau Partenariat pour le Dveloppement de lAfrique, NEPAD)304)

    IT Microsoft, Cisco, IBM IT ,

    - 2KO Senegal Cisco Microsoft

    MCSA and MCSE ,

    4

    -

    IBM IT

    (: Trend Micro IBM )

    303) CEIS(),Lessor du numerique en Afrique de louest, 2015.11304) , , ,

    (AU)

  • - 789 -

    Trend Micro IBM

    : Trend Micro

    Cisco

    : http://www.2kosenegal.com/courses/cisco-courses-in-Senegal.html

    IT ,

    IT

    -

    ,

    (2016.1.22.)

    - , ,

  • - 790 -

    m

    2017 430

    - Technavio 2015 305) , 2017

    , 2017 430

    306)

    CCTV ,

    2016 57.8 307)

    -

    -

    (: )

    2015 2016 900 578 -35.8%

    0.03% 0.00% -

    CCTV (2015 vs 2016)

    ) HS 852580 Television cameras, digital cameras and video camera recorders

    : UN Comtrade DB

    )

    m

    - (www.antivirus-senegal.com)

    Kaspersky Lab, McAfee, Panda, Trend Mirco

    305) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)

    306) GDP . p GDP , GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193 , Y 0.668571234 8 GDP

    307) UN Comtrade DB (2017)

  • - 791 -

    : www.antivirus-senegal.com

    3)

    )

    m

    - Cryptology Law (No. 2008-41) : 2008.8.20.

    - Data Protection Law (No. 2008-12) : 2008.1.25.

    - Electronic Transactions Law (No. 2008-08) : 2008.1.25.

    - Law Guiding the Information Society (No. 2008-10) : 2008.1.25.

    - Law on Telecommunications Code (No. 2011-01) : 2011.2.24.

    - Law on Cybercrime (No. 2008-11) : 2008.1.25.

  • - 792 -

    : simmons & simmons(2015.6)

    m

    -

    2025

    (Infrastructures Nationales Critiques, INC) ,

    (CERT) ,

    - EU

  • - 793 -

    )

    (Autorit de Rgulation des Tlcommunications et des Postes, ARTP) - 2011 2 24 , ,

    , ,

    , , ,

    CIRT

    - ITU-IMPACT CIRT

    CIRT . CIRT

    , CERT

    (BSLC, Brigade Spciale de Lutte contre la Cybercriminalit) - : 2013

    , ,

    - , ,

    ,

    (Commission de protection des donnes personnelles, CDP) - 2008 1 25

    , ,

    (Agence de linformation de lEtat, ADIE)

    - 2004 , , ,

    )

    - ( )

  • - 794 -

    - (

    )

    )

    ITU 2016 1 (Cyber

    Security Awareness Initiative) (2016.1.19~21)

    - Global Cyber Security Capacity Center(GCSCC),

    Oxford GCSCC

    -

    - ,

    CFCE

    ITU , GSCSS

    GFCE

    (2016.4.12~13)

    -

    - ,

    -

    (KISA)

    (CAMPCyber-security Alliance for Mutual Progress) (2016.7.11.)

    - KISA CAMP

    - 37 49

    29 40 KISA

    - KISA CAMP (ECOWAS), , ,

    (ICT) ,

  • - 795 -

    KISA ,

    ,

    KISA

    (2016.11.24) (2016.11.22.-25)

    - BSLC

    (ADIE) ,

    2017 3 , ,

    (CDP) , 1 Dakar

    - CDP ,

    , ,

    - 2016.12.10. (IFACE) Dakar Hacking summit

    - 2017.4.26.~27 (ADIE) (Journes de la scurit numrique) Dakar

    - 2017.5.24.~26 9 AfricaCrypt 2017

    (ADIE) 2016 3

    Portail de Scurit du Systme dinformation du Sngal(PSSIS)

  • - 796 -

    .

    ITU (Global Cybersecurity Index, GCI) 0.267 99

    ( , , )

    2017 GCI

    5

    0.267 99

    0.782 13

    ICT ICT ITU 175

    ITU ICT (IDI 2016) 1.51 169 8.84 1

    (Access) 2.11 170 8.99 8

    (Use) 0.82 158 8.57 3

    (Skills) 1.72 172 9.08 3

    ITU (GCI 2017) 0.267 99 0.782 13

    UN (2016) 0.266 157 0.892 3

    WEF (NRI 2016) 3.1 130 5.6 13

    ICT (ITU, 2016 ) 1.13%

    50.5%

    ( ) (%) ( ) (%)

    1,147 1.13 28,035 56.1

    559 0.55 20,555 41.1

    38,982 50.5 61,295 122.6

    15.37% 92.7%

    17 GDP() 78.40

    '17 () 105,350

  • - 797 -

    1)

    )

    World Economic Forum The Global Information Technology Report 2016 ,

    (NRI, Network readiness index)

    3.1 139 120

    - ITU , 16 2015

    0.07% 559,000 , 0.55%, 114 7

    1.13% 3,898 , 50%

    - 2015 130 2016 120 10

    (INSA) 2017

    ( )

    - , 2016 , Facebook 450 (Buddecomm)

    10

    10% ,

    - 2007 120 2016 5,122

    - ZTE Huawei 4G

    2015 4G , (9)

    3G

    Check Point ,

    10

  • - 798 -

    (2016. 1)

    : Check Point, Top Malware & Threat Index Q1 2016' (2016.6)

    1997 , 2007

    Proclamation No.533 , ICT

    ,

    - ICT

    200 2500

    EthioICT Village 2015 6 - ICT

  • - 799 -

    - Business zone, Assembly warehouse zone, commercial zone, Administrative zone,

    Knowledge part zone 5

    - 5 , ICT ,

    - Chinas Zhongxing Telecom Corporation(ZTE), Techno Mobile and Security

    Innovation Network(CNET), Smadle, Techno 20

    - 30

    ICT

    - Huawei, ZTE ICT 2003 ZTE GSM

    (2900 )

    - 2006 3G ( 24 ) 3

    (ZTE, Huawei, CITCC) , 2007

    - 2013 1900

    - ZTE 1

    : (Ministry of Communication and Information Technology

  • - 800 -

    )

    - 2016 2015 0.23% 114

    7 , 1.13%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 0.07%

    559,000 , 0.55%

  • - 801 -

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

    - 2016 2015 7.7%

    3,892 2 , 50.5%

    (: )

    : ITU Statistics DB(2017.6)

  • - 802 -

    2)

    )

    m

    2017 2,410

    - Technavio 2015 308) , 2017

    , 2017 2,410

    309)

    CCTV 2016 436 ,

    1 4,031

    -

    (: )

    CCTV (HS852580)DVR

    (HS847150) (HS830140)

    (HS851769)

    4,364 6,327 8,227 140,305

    1.67% 0.08% 0.36% 0.08%

    (2016)

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    ICT ,

    - ,

    308) Technavio, Global Information Security Products and Services Market 2015-2019(2015)309) GDP . p GDP ,

    GDP LOG . 22 GDP 1.09544492562193 , Y 0.668571234 8 GDP

  • - 803 -

    , ,

    - , ,

    - , ,

    - , ,

    )

    m

    IBM, CISCO, Check Point

    ,

    m

    IT 2~3

    - , (INSA) Kaspersky

    Kaspersky (Managed Service Providers)

    - MSP IT

    SME

  • - 804 -

    )

    (Information Network Security Agency, INSA)

    (2016.7)310)

    - , National Bank of

    Ethiopia(NBE)

    3)

    )

    m

    1997 , 2007

    Proclamation No.533 ICT

    ,

    - ICT

    - ICT

    - ICT

    - ICT

    - ICT

    - (National Electronic Transaction Law)

    - (National Data Protection Law)

    - (E-Commerce Law)

    - (E-Signature Law)

    - (Computer Misuse and Cyber Crime Law)

    310) 2Merkato.com, "Ethiopia: Integrated Cyber-Security Solution for Banks Started", 2016.7.21

  • - 805 -

    : simmons & simmons(2015.6)

    m

    2017 2 22~23, INSA Critical Security Requirement Standard 311)

    - 2

    INSA IT

    - , INSA

    311) AllAfrica.com, "Ethiopia: INSA Issues Cybersecurity Standards", 2017.2.23

  • - 806 -

    )

    MCIT(Ministry of Communication and Information Technology):

    2010 ,

    -

    -

    -

    - ICT

    (INSA: Information Network Security Agency):

    (Ethiopian Cyber Emergency Readiness and Response Team)

    (Ethio-CERT)

    (Ethiopian Cyber Emergency Readiness and Response

    Team)

    -

  • - 807 -

    (Ethio-CERT)

    /

    ,

    /

    )

    - ( )

  • - 808 -

    )

    ENN News ,

    (2017.5)

    CISCO

    MoU (2017.3.24)

    - Cisco 10 Cisco Networking Academy(NetAcad) 35

    13,250 IT

  • - 809 -

    .

    1.

    .

    - 2X2

    GDP CAGR, 2X2

    - Technavio 2014

    2017 X, GDP CAGR

    Y

    2014 2017

    - 2017 2014

    , 2017

    - GDP312), , p

    - GDP , p

    , GDP LOG

    - 22 GDP 1.09544492562193

    Y 0.668571234 8 GDP - 2017 GDP 2017

    2014 , , ,

    , , , ,

    312) GDP

    Technavio

  • - 810 -

    .

    8

    - 8

    No. HS1 (CCTV) 852580

    2 DVR 847150

    3 847160

    4 853110

    5 852190

    6 851769

    7 830140

    8 ( ) 847190

  • - 811 -

    2. 30

    .

    GDP CAGR( ), IT CAGR313), (2017 )

    30 IT CAGR GDP CAGR 2X2

    30

    - IT CAGR GDP CAGR

    - ()

    - (, , , , )

    IT CAGR

    313) GDP (CAGR) 2014~2017(3) , IT 2014~2019(5)

    BMI

  • - 812 -

    5 . IT

    CAGR

    - A :

    - B : ,

    - C : ,

    - D : ,

    - E :

    , ,

    ,

    A

  • - 813 -

    .

    8 (2016 )

    (: )

    No.

    (830140)

    DVR

    (847150)

    (847160)

    (847190)

    (851769)

    (852190)

    CCTV

    (852580)

    (853110)

    1 839,679 19,711,803 2,863,096 793,665 1,544,724 1,329,358 5,856,408 689,174 33,627,907

    2 118,968 2,511,888 1,865,208 329,618 75,040 97,326 5,741,603 99,997 10,839,648

    3 212,379 2,575,595 853,880 507,215 364,310 219,892 2,164,328 486,555 7,384,154

    4 56,823 3,349,669 395,638 176,084 172,327 726,585 1,539,827 37,082 6,454,035

    5 148,994 1,796,509 490,749 388,493 252,466 228,472 961,325 362,786 4,629,794

    6 148,994 1,796,509 490,749 388,493 252,466 228,472 961,325 362,786 4,629,794

    7 42,159 1,178,494 154,230 40,413 1,262,423 111,496 620,753 26,879 3,436,847

    8 15,511 964,301 275,176 259,930 125,074 106,972 619,214 56,381 2,422,559

    9 90,803 1,179,414 433,954 39,695 62,628 132,579 371,163 43,418 2,353,654

    10 UAE 31,478 339,514 80,319 44,438 32,471 29,444 281,584 74,649 913,897

    11 38,409 231,745 61,130 143,208 66,766 26,049 156,986 13,450 737,743

    12 13,555 439,621 35,530 32,667 12,822 15,906 140,597 6,363 697,061

    13 27,517 184,328 28,461 47,298 57,156 36,468 110,363 30,027 521,618

    14 23,977 197,309 29,403 27,014 46,556 32,206 82,363 21,597 460,425

    15 14,780 112,007 18,991 20,302 14,032 33,893 61,697 6,932 282,634

    16 9,056 86,120 13,858 716 8,204 1,050 57,265 22,037 198,306

    17 8,227 6,327 3,892 1,683 140,305 580 4,364 5,899 171,278

    18 11,537 43,985 9,880 8,863 6,879 4,912 17,180 2,718 105,954

    19 3,067 35,519 5,022 17,657 3,319 2,146 9,729 5,164 81,623

    20 3,337 14,380 3,598 2,065 6,281 1,304 3,967 1,895 36,827

    21 345 1,905 7,753 1,676 5,413 646 1,015 5,443 24,196

    22 1,014 3,639 764 1,451 6,464 578 807 774 15,491

    23 1,011 2,545 466 790 4,636 375 1,763 330 11,916

    * , , , , , ,

    : UN Comtrade DB(2017)

  • - 814 -

    3.

    1)

    m

    () 18,047.8 1 (%) 4.6 18

    2017 GCI 0.919 2 B

    2016 IDI 8.17 15

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    180 4,700 30

    1 . GCI 0.9 167 2 ,

    IDI 175 15 .

    -

    , , ,

    -

    AS

    - ,

  • - 815 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 19,711,803 1 0.03

    852580 5,856,408 1 2.82

    847160 2,863,096 1 1.12

    851769 1,544,724 1 1.47

    852190 1,329,358 1 2.57

    830140 839,679 1 1.60

    847190 793,665 1 0.69

    853110 689,174 1 0.59

    - 33,627,907 1/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 336 2,791 2015

    6.5% , 1 .

    ,

    DVR

    1

    - 3 DVR

    NAFTA 1

    , 1

    - 1%

    , DVR(0.03%) (0.59%)

    DVR

  • - 816 -

    2)

    m

    () 3,122.1 2 (%) 5.1 17

    2017 GCI 0.624 32 A

    2016 IDI 5.19 81

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    31 2,200 30

    2 . GCI IDI

    -

    -

    ,

    -

    , ,

    . ,

  • - 817 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 2,511,888 4 0.27

    852580 5,741,603 2 14.21

    847160 1,865,208 2 1.00

    851769 75,040 9 0.68

    852190 97,326 9 0.38

    830140 118,968 5 30.98

    847190 329,618 5 5.07

    853110 99,997 5 2.30

    - 10,839,648 2/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 108 3,965 2015

    32.0% ,

    2

    - ,

    , 3

    -

    1

    , ,

  • - 818 -

    3)

    m

    () 3,098.8 3 (%) -2.0 27

    2017 GCI 0.786 11 B

    2016 IDI 8.37 10

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    30 9,800 30

    3 . GCI IDI

    -

    - , IOT

    ,

    -

    ,

    , SI , /2

    .

  • - 819 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 3,349,669 2 0.31

    852580 1,539,827 4 4.14

    847160 395,638 7 0.30

    851769 172,327 6 0.37

    852190 726,585 2 2.37

    830140 56,823 7 6.66

    847190 176,084 7 2.86

    853110 37,082 9 3.53

    - 6,454,035 4/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 64 5,404

    2015 5.1% , 4

    ,

    , 1

    - (6.66) (4.14)

    ,

    DVR

    .

  • - 820 -

    4)

    m

    () 2,113.8 4 (%) -5.0 29

    2017 GCI 0.783 12 B

    2016 IDI 8.57 5

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    21 1,300 30

    4 . GCI 167 12, IDI 175 5

    -

    -

    , ,

    -

    AS

    - , , ,

    ,

    R&D

  • - 821 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 1,796,509 5 0.04

    852580 961,325 5 2.46

    847160 490,749 4 0.30

    851769 252,466 4 0.37

    852190 228,472 3 2.37

    830140 148,994 3 0.20

    847190 388,493 3 0.25

    853110 362,786 3 0.07

    - 4,629,794 5/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 46 2,979 2015

    8.6 , 5

    ,

    ,

    1

    - 1% ,

    (2.46%), (2.37%)

    , 1 DVR

  • - 822 -

    5)

    m

    () 1,406.2 5 (%) -1.7% 26

    2017 GCI 0.819 8 B

    2016 IDI 8.11 16

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    14 600 30

    5 . GCI 167 8, IDI 175 16

    -

    -

    , , ,

    -

    ,

    , ,

    ,

    AS

  • - 823 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 1,796,509 6 0.06

    852580 961,325 6 1.81

    847160 490,749 5 0.53

    851769 252,466 5 0.11

    852190 228,472 4 0.54

    830140 148,994 4 0.07

    847190 388,493 4 0.52

    853110 362,786 4 0.07

    - 4,629,794 6/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2015 46 2,980

    6 .

    ,

    1%

    - 1.81%

    ,

    2016 0.5%

    , , DVR

  • - 824 -

    6)

    m

    () 1,342.0 6 (%) -1.3 24

    2017 GCI 0.679 24 B

    2016 IDI 8.31 12

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    13 4,200 30

    6 . GCI 167 24, IDI 175 12

    ,

    -

    -

    - (, , )

    4.0

    ,

    AS

  • - 825 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 2,575,595 3 0.09

    852580 2,164,328 3 1.66

    847160 853,880 3 0.75

    851769 364,310 3 0.37

    852190 219,892 5 1.22

    830140 212,379 2 0.02

    847190 507,215 2 0.75

    853110 486,555 2 0.09

    - 7,384,154 3/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 73 8,415

    2015 3.6% , 3 .

    -

    , 1

    - (1.66%), (1.22%)

    ,

    ,

  • - 826 -

    7)

    m

    () 1,160.8 7 (%) 8.8 7

    2017 GCI 0.683 23 A

    2016 IDI 2.69 138

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    11 6,000 30

    7 . IDI 175 138

    GCI 167 23 ,

    -

    -

    -

    ,

    ,

    , ,

    / .

    /

  • - 827 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 1,178,494 8 0.14

    852580 620,753 7 6.45

    847160 154,230 9 1.00

    851769 1,262,423 2 0.68

    852190 111,496 7 5.38

    830140 42,159 8 3.99

    847190 40,413 11 4.56

    853110 26,879 11 12.17

    - 3,436,847 7/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 34 3,685 2015

    1.8 , 7 .

    - 8 1%

    ,

    - 12.17%

    , (6.45%), (5.38%)

    DVR 0.14% 1

    , .

  • - 828 -

    8)

    m

    () 462.3 8 (%) 9.4 5

    2017 GCI 0.424 70 A

    2016 IDI 0.782 13

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    4 6,200 30

    8 . GCI 167 IDI 175

    13 ,

    -

    -

    -

    . 2016

    , , AS

    - , ,

    ,

  • - 829 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 184,328 14 0.28

    852580 110,363 13 0.89

    847160 28,461 14 1.07

    851769 57,156 12 0.42

    852190 36,468 10 8.90

    830140 27,517 11 1.50

    847190 47,298 9 2.45

    853110 30,027 10 3.82

    - 521,618 13/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 5 2,162

    2015 1.9% , 13 .

    , 1 ,

    - (8.90%), (3.82%)

    . 4

  • - 830 -

    9)

    m

    () 278.5 9 (%) -5.6 30

    2017 GCI 0.660 28 E

    2016 IDI 4.87 92

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    2 7,800 30

    9 . GCI 167 28 IDI

    175 92 .

    ,

    -

    ICT ,

    ,

  • - 831 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 1,179,414 7 0.15

    852580 371,163 9 2.26

    847160 433,954 6 1.41

    851769 62,628 11 2.37

    852190 132,579 6 0.71

    830140 90,803 6 1.31

    847190 39,695 12 0.41

    853110 43,418 8 1.06

    - 2,353,654 9/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 23 5,365

    9 .

    - (2.37%), (2,2,6%)

    ,

  • - 832 -

    10) 314)

    m

    () 247.4 10 (%) 10.6 3

    2017 GCI 0.569 46 E

    2016 IDI 6.90 45

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    2 4,700

    30 10 . GCI IDI

    -

    -

    2030(National Transformation

    Program and Saudi Vision 2030)

    ICT

    314) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 833 -

    11)

    m

    () 185.1 11 (%) -1.7 25

    2017 GCI 0.925 1 E

    2016 IDI 7.95 20

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 8,500 30

    11 . GCI 167 1, IDI 175

    20 ,

    -

    ITU

    1

    -

    - , SK, NSHC

  • - 834 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 964,301 9 0.26

    852580 619,214 8 2.06

    847160 275,176 8 4.93

    851769 125,074 8 0.22

    852190 106,972 8 0.65

    830140 15,511 13 2.84

    847190 259,930 6 0.49

    853110 56,381 7 0.63

    - 2,422,559 8/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 24 2,256

    8 .

    ,

    - (4.93%), (2.84%)

    ,

    ,

  • - 835 -

    12) 315)

    m

    () 157.3 12 (%) 6.4 14

    2017 GCI 0.684 22 E

    2016 IDI 5.18 82

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 5,700 30 12 .

    GCI 167 22 IDI 175 82

    .

    ,

    -

    315) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 836 -

    13) UAE

    m

    UAE

    () 155.3 13 (%) 9.7 4

    2017 GCI 0.566 47 E

    2016 IDI 7.11 38

    (GCI) (UAE vs ) (, , )

    UAE

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    UAE 1 5,500 30

    13 . IDI GCI

    ,

    - ,

    -

    , , ,

    , SOC,

    , UAE

  • - 837 -

    m

    UAE

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 339,514 11 0.07

    852580 281,584 10 1.98

    847160 80,319 10 1.80

    851769 32,471 14 1.80

    852190 29,444 13 22.63

    830140 31,478 10 0.65

    847190 44,438 10 0.54

    853110 74,649 6 9.35

    - 913,897 10/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2015 UAE 9 1,390

    2015 65.5% , 10

    -

    UAE 2015 10

    , 2016 3

    , 1

    ,

    - 2015( 11.06%)

    2016 22.63% ,

    - 2015 4.02% 2016 9.35%

    GCC UAE 40%

    .

  • - 838 -

    14) 316)

    m

    () 149.3 14 (%) -2.2 28

    2017 GCI 0.494 60 E

    2016 IDI 4.99 89

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 4,900 30

    14 . GCI IDI ,

    -

    -

    AS

    . , , ,

    .

    ,

    316) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 839 -

    15)

    m

    () 135.4 15 (%) 4.6 19

    2017 GCI 0.893 3 E

    2016 IDI 6.22 61

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 3,500 30

    15 . GCI 167 3 ,

    IDI 175 61

    , ,

    -

    ,

    .

  • - 840 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 231,745 12 0.14

    852580 156,986 11 0.80

    847160 61,130 11 5.79

    851769 66,766 10 0.29

    852190 26,049 14 2.51

    830140 38,409 9 5.03

    847190 143,208 8 2.04

    853110 13,450 14 1.75

    - 737,743 11/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 7 3,774

    11

    ,

    - (5.79%), (5.03%)

    ,

    -

  • - 841 -

    16)

    m

    () 123.8 16 (%) 6.8 13

    2017 GCI 0.691 20 E

    2016 IDI 7.40 30

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 2,300 30

    16 . GCI IDI

    ,

    -

    , Check Point,

    CyberArk, Imperva, BioCatch

    - R&D

  • - 842 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 439,621 10 0.23

    852580 140,597 12 0.84

    847160 35,530 12 0.86

    851769 12,822 16 0.08

    852190 15,906 15 0.68

    830140 13,555 15 0.02

    847190 32,667 13 0.44

    853110 6,363 16 0.58

    - 697,061 12/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 6 9,760

    12

    , 1%

    - ,

    0.86% 0.84%, 0.68% ,

    0.5%

    . , , DVR

    ,

  • - 843 -

    17) 317)

    m

    () 117.0 17 (%) 7.2 12

    2017 GCI 0.245 101 A

    2016 IDI 4.28 105

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1 1,700 30

    17 . GCI IDI

    - 10

    - 2~3

    -

    .

    ,

    317) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 844 -

    18)

    m

    () 83.4 18 (%) 1.7 22

    2017 GCI 0.367 81 E

    2016 IDI 6.35 56

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    8,300 30 18

    . GCI 167 81

    ,

    -

    - 10

    ,

    - ,

    ,

    .

  • - 845 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 197,309 13 0.07

    852580 82,363 14 3.06

    847160 29,403 13 0.49

    851769 46,556 13 0.01

    852190 32,206 12 2.31

    830140 23,977 12 0.40

    847190 27,014 14 0.68

    853110 21,597 13 0.99

    - 460,425 14/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 4 6,043

    2015 18.1% , 14

    - 8 2015 2 7,400

    DVR 2 (

    27.9% )

    ,

    - 3

    - (3.06%) (2.31%)

    - A/S

  • - 846 -

    19)

    m

    () 57.0 19 (%) 10.8 2

    2017 GCI 0.676 25 C

    2016 IDI 6.90 45

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    5,700 30 19

    . GCI 167 25, IDI 175 45

    -

    - 2022

    ,

    -

    , , AS

    - , ,

    .

    , ,

  • - 847 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 86,120 16 0.06

    852580 57,265 16 6.03

    847160 13,858 16 1.51

    851769 8,204 17 0.15

    852190 1,050 19 2.26

    830140 9,056 17 0.08

    847190 716 23 1.51

    853110 22,037 12 0.18

    - 198,306 16/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 1 9,831

    2015 2.7% , 16

    -

    2015 2,380 2016 1,386 (

    41.8% )

    ,

    -

    (6.03%),

    (2.26%)

    DVR, ,

    -

  • - 848 -

    20)

    m

    () 29.3 20 (%) 8.5 8

    2017 GCI 0.569 46 C

    2016 IDI 5.16 83

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    2,900 30

    20 . GCI 167 46 IDI

    175 83 ,

    -

    -

    - ,

    () ,

    AS , (SI)

  • - 849 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 112,007 15 0.07

    852580 61,697 15 0.64

    847160 18,991 15 1.28

    851769 14,032 15 1.46

    852190 33,893 11 0.22

    830140 14,780 14 1.37

    847190 20,302 15 1.49

    853110 6,932 15 1.28

    - 282,634 15/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 2 8,263

    2015 12.7% , 15

    - 2015 2016

    7,620

    6,170 ( 19.0% ), 4,100

    3,389 ( 17.3% )

    , 1%

    - 3

    , DVR,

    -

  • - 850 -

    21)

    m

    () 24.1 21 (%) 8.1 10

    2017 GCI 0.267 99 C

    2016 IDI 1.51 169

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    240 30

    21 . GCI 167 99 , IDI

    175 169 .

    - ICT ,

    ,

    -

    , ,

  • - 851 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 6,327 20 0.08

    852580 4,364 19 1.67

    847160 3,892 20 1.54

    851769 140,305 7 0.08

    852190 580 21 1.45

    830140 8,227 18 0.36

    847190 1,683 19 0.54

    853110 5,899 17 1.03

    - 171,277 17/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 1 7,128

    17

    -

    - 1.67%,

    1.45%

    , DVR,

    - DVR 1

    AS

  • - 852 -

    22) 318)

    m

    () 23.3 22 (%) 9.0 6

    2017 GCI 0.570 45 C

    2016 IDI 2.99 129

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    2,300 30 22

    . GCI 167 45 IDI 175

    129 .

    -

    -

    ,

    - , , ,

    .

    , , AS

    318) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 853 -

    23)

    m

    () 22.9 23 (%) 12.9 1

    2017 GCI 0.871 4 D

    2016 IDI 6.27 59

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    2,200 30 23

    . GCI 167 4 , IDI

    175 59

    -

    -

    -

    , ,

    -

    ,

    , AS . 2016

    , GCC

    ,

  • - 854 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 35,519 18 0.00

    852580 9,729 18 2.24

    847160 5,022 19 0.00

    851769 3,319 23 0.00

    852190 2,146 17 0.83

    830140 3,067 20 1.31

    847190 17,657 16 0.00

    853110 5,164 19 0.04

    - 81,623 19/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 8,162 2015

    24.1% , 19

    - 2015 2016

    DVR 5,210 3,552

    ( 31.8% ), 1,900

    973 ( 48.8% )

    , UAE ,

    - UAE 1 FTA

    - 1%

    ,

    UAE, ,

  • - 855 -

    24)

    m

    () 17.7 24 (%) 2.9 21

    2017 GCI 0.336 86 C

    2016 IDI 6.20 57

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    1,700 30 24

    . GCI 167 86 , IDI 175

    57 .

    -

    -

    - ,

    .

    .

  • - 856 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 43,985 17 0.03

    852580 17,180 17 1.05

    847160 9,880 17 0.24

    851769 6,879 18 0.23

    852190 4,912 16 0.25

    830140 11,537 16 0.03

    847190 8,863 17 0.29

    853110 2,718 20 0.00

    - 105,954 18/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 1 595

    2015 3.8% , 18

    -

    , ,

    1

    - 3

    - 1.05% ,

    1%

    DVR,

  • - 857 -

    25) 319)

    m

    () 7.9 25 (%) 5.4 16

    2017 GCI 0.146 125 C

    2016 IDI 2.88 131

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    790 30

    25 . GCI IDI ,

    -

    , , ,

    -

    , IDC ,

    . ODA

    319) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 858 -

    26)

    m

    () 7.5 26 (%) 8.5 9

    2017 GCI 0.317 88 C

    2016 IDI 1.65 167

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    750 30

    26. GCI 167 88 , IDI 175

    167 .

    - 2015

    - 2015 11

    - ,

    , ,

    .

    , , AS

    .

    , ODA, EDCF

  • - 859 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 14,380 19 7.59

    852580 3,967 20 5.55

    847160 3,598 21 51.32

    851769 6,281 20 0.10

    852190 1,304 18 3.12

    830140 3,337 19 0.76

    847190 2,065 18 0.10

    853110 1,895 21 53.13

    - 36,827 20/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 3,683

    2015 51.7% , 20

    - 2015 2016

    3,350 628

    ( 81.3% ), DVR 2,380 1,438

    ( 39.6% )

    ,

    , 2016

    - 51.325 ,

    53.13%

    ,

  • - 860 -

    27)

    m

    () 5.7 27 (%) 8.0 11

    2017 GCI 0.283 92 C

    2016 IDI 3.12 127

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    570 30

    27 GCI IDI ,

    -

    - ,

    2021

    ,

    -

    , , , .

    , .

    . PKI

    , .

    ODA EDCF

  • - 861 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 1,905 23 0.55

    852580 1,015 22 0.26

    847160 7,753 18 0.00

    851769 5,413 21 0.00

    852190 646 20 0.00

    830140 345 23 2.72

    847190 1,676 20 0.09

    853110 5,443 18 0.04

    - 24,196 21/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 2,420

    2015 11.0% , 21

    - 2015 2016

    1,880 541 ( 71.2% )

    - ,

    - DVR

    ,

    - 3 91.45%

    1 66.8%

    - 0.5%

  • - 862 -

    28)

    m

    () 4.3 28 (%) 4.4 20

    2017 GCI 0.314 89 C

    2016 IDI 2.53 141

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    430 30 28

    . GCI IDI

    -

    , ,

    -

    ,

    . ,

    ODA, EDCF 2~3 .

    , , AS

  • - 863 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 3,639 21 0.00

    852580 807 23 0.04

    847160 764 22 0.21

    851769 6,464 19 0.00

    852190 578 22 0.00

    830140 1,014 21 0.00

    847190 1,451 21 0.26

    853110 774 22 0.00

    - 15,491 22/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 1,549 2015

    12% , 23 22

    - 2015 2016 DVR 710

    364 ( 48.7% )

    ,

    . , , 1

    - DVR, , 1

    .

    2

    - 0.0% 0.5%

  • - 864 -

    29) 320)

    m

    () 4.2 29 (%) -0.5 23

    2017 GCI 0.139 128 D

    2016 IDI 3.12 124

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    420 30 29

    . GCI IDI

    ,

    -

    , 1

    .

    320) UN Comtrade DB

  • - 865 -

    30)

    m

    () 2.8 30 (%) 6.1 15

    2017 GCI 0.602 36 C

    2016 IDI 2.13 150

    (GCI) ( vs ) (, , )

    1) 2017

    2) : 30 , GCI 167, IDI 175

    : ITU(2017), IMF(2017), (2017)

    280 30 30

    . GCI 167 36 IDI 175

    150 ,

    -

    -

    -

    SOC, PKI ,

    .

  • - 866 -

    m

    HS 2016 ()

    (%)

    DVR 847150 2,545 22 3.05

    852580 1,763 21 33.20

    847160 466 23 9.19

    851769 4,636 22 28.06

    852190 375 23 23.05

    830140 1,011 22 0.00

    847190 790 22 19.01

    853110 330 23 0.00

    - 11,916 23/23 -

    : UN Comtrade DB (2017)

    2016 1,192 2015

    29.9% , 23

    - ,

    -

    , .

    1, 2

    - , , ,

    ,

    - , ,

  • - 867 -

    1. Acquisdata, "China Information Technology", 2017.8.4

    2. AllAfrica.com, "Kenya: Cybersecurity Framework Set for Launch", 2014.6.24

    3. Apt Capital Management, "France - The sick man of Europe", 2016.4.12

    4. Article 19, "Kenya: Cybercrime and Computer Related Crimes Bill", 2014.7

    5. Australian Strategic Policy Institute, "Cyber Maturity in the Asia-Pacific Region

    2015", 2015.9

    6. Barclays, "Security, Design & VSS_Stock-Picker's Market in 2017", 2017.1.6

    7. Barnes Reports, "2015 World Industry & Market Outlook_Security Systems",

    2014.12

    8. Barnes Reports, "2016 Companies & Sales Outlook: Private Security Activities -

    France", 2015.10

    9. Barnes Reports, "2017 U.S. Security Systems Services Industry-Industry &

    Market Report", 2016.10

    10. BMI Research, "BMI Industry Forecast - Vietnam - Q3 2015: IT/Computers",

    2015.7.6

    11. BMI Research, "BMI Industry View - Vietnam - Q3 2015: IT/Computers",

    2015.7.6

    12. BMI Research, "Market Overview - France Security Overview - Q1 2015",

    2014.11.25

    13. BMI Research, "Market Overview - United Arab Emirates - Q3 2015:

    IT/Computers", 2015.7.8

    14. BMI Research, "Qatar security software", 2015.6.26

    15. BMI Research, "SWOT - Iran Security - Q1 2015", 2014.10.17

    16. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Cambodia - Telecoms, Mobile, Broadband

    and Digital Media - Statistics and Analyses", 2016.9.13

    17. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "China - Mobile Infrastructure, Broadband,

    Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.6.13

    18. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "China - Telecoms Infrastructure, Operators,

    Regulations - Statistics and Analyses", 2016.11.29

    19. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Colombia - Mobile Infrastructure,

  • - 868 -

    Broadband, Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2016.11.30

    20. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Colombia - Telecoms Infrastructure,

    Operators, Regulations - Statistics and Analyses", 2016.11.30

    21. "Buddecomm Telecoms Research, ""Costa Rica - Telecoms, Mobile,

    Broadband and Digital Media - Statistics and

    22. Analyses"", 2017.8.18"

    23. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Ethiopia - Telecoms, Mobile and

    Broadband - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.3.1

    24. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "France - Mobile Infrastructure, Broadband,

    Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.2.5

    25. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "France - Telecoms Infrastructure, Operators,

    Regulations - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.2.5

    26. "Buddecomm Telecoms Research, ""Indonesia - Fixed Broadband, Digital

    Economy and Digital Media - Statistics and

    27. Analyses"", 2017.5.9"

    28. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Indonesia - Mobile Infrastructure,

    Broadband, Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.5.8

    29. "Buddecomm Telecoms Research, ""Indonesia - Telecoms Infrastructure,

    Operators, Regulations - Statistics and

    30. Analyses"", 2017.5.9"

    31. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Iran - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband -

    Statistics and Analyses", 2017.4.19

    32. "Buddecomm Telecoms Research, ""Nicaragua - Telecoms, Mobile, Broadband

    and Digital Media - Statistics and

    33. Analyses"", 2017.8.7"

    34. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Qatar - Telecoms, Mobile and Broadband -

    Statistics and Analyses", 2017.8.7

    35. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "United Kingdom - Fixed Broadband Market

    - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.1.30

    36. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "United Kingdom - Mobile Infrastructure,

    Broadband, Operators Statistics and Analyses", 2017.1.31

    37. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "USA - Fixed Broadband Market - Statistics

    and Analyses", 2017.4.5

  • - 869 -

    38. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "USA - Mobile Infrastructure, Broadband,

    Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.5.22

    39. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Vietnam - Mobile Infrastructure -

    Broadband, Operators - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.3.21

    40. Buddecomm Telecoms Research, "Vietnam - Telecoms Infrastructure,

    Operators, Regulations - Statistics and Analyses", 2017.3.21

    41. Cowen and Company, "Cowen Security Global Reseller Survey, Volume VIII",

    2017.4.3

    42. Deutsche Bank, "China Internet - Clouds gather in the south", 2017.8.4

    43. Deutsche Bank, "Security_H1 2017 Previews", 2017.7.24

    44. Dubai Electronic Security Center, "Dubai Cyber Security Strategy", 2017.5

    45. First Research, "Security Products Manufacturing", 2016.8.29

    46. First Research, "Security System Services", 2017.9.11

    47. Gartner, Gartner Says Information Security Spending In India Will Grow 12

    Percent to Reach $1.5 Billion in 2017, 2017.8.29

    48. Global Partners Digital, "Mapping the Cyber Policy Landscape: India", 2016.2

    49. Governor Bank of Tanzania, "Monetary Policy Statement 2017/18", 2017.6

    50. HM Treasury, "Chancellor speech: launching the National Cyber Security

    Strategy", 2016.11

    51. Id-SIRTII/CC, "Indonesia Cyber Security Report 2015", 2015.9.15

    52. International ICT Policy in East and Southern Africa and Privacy International,

    "The Right to Privacy in the United Republic of Tanzania", 2015.9

    53. ITU, "Cyber Security in Tanzania Country Report", 2014

    54. ITU, "Global Cybersecurity Index (GCI) 2017", 2017.7.5

    55. ITU, "Measuring the Information Society Report 2016", 2016.11

    56. Jefferies, "Check Point Software-Firewall Pioneer, Cybersecurity Leader",

    2017.1.18

    57. Jefferies, "Cybersecurity Primer-Moderation, But Still Growth for Years to

    Come", 2017.1.18

    58. Jefferies, "Palo Alto Networks-Initiating at Hold - Next Generation Security

    Company", 2017.1.18

    59. Journal of ASEAN Studies, "Cybersecurity Policy and Its Implementation in

    Indonesia", 2016.8.9

  • - 870 -

    60. JP Morgan, "IT Services - The News Flow: NASSCOM estimates", 2017.6.28

    61. JP Morgan, "The Source Code-V82: Global Security Primer", 2017.4.19

    62. Jusfoun, "China IT Security Services Industry on Market Segment", 2017.2.10

    63. Kable, "Indonesia's ICT Spends - Future Perspective to 2019", 2016.8

    64. Kable, "United States's ICT Spends - Future Perspective to 2019", 2016.8

    65. Ken Research, "China Electronic Security Market Outlook to 2019", 2015.7

    66. Ken Research, "India Cyber Security Market Outlook to 2020", 2016.5

    67. Ken Research, "India Electronic Security Industry Potential to 2020", 2016.6

    68. Macquarie Research, "China Cloud Computing", 2017.7.25

    69. Macquarie Research, "RSA Security Conference - IT vs. the Perimeter-Less

    Digital World", 2017.2.20

    70. MarketLine, "Security Services in Germany", 2015.11

    71. MarketLine, "Security Services in the United Kingdom", 2015.11.25

    72. MarketLine, "Software in Indonesia", 2017.6

    73. Mckinsey, "Unlocking Indonesias digital opportunity", 2016.9

    74. Memoori Business Intelligence, "Access Control Leads the Way in the

    Physical Security Business", 2016.12.15

    75. Microsoft, "Microsoft Security Intelligence Report, Volume 22: January

    through March, 2017", 2017.8

    76. Morgan Stanley, "Data Privacy: EU GDPR 'Security Solution Stocks'", 2017.5.16

    77. Morgan Stanley, "Proofpoint_Emerging Above and Beyond Email Security",

    2017.9.8

    78. Morgan Stanley, "Software-2017 State of Security Spending", 2017.5.9

    79. Nomura Research, "_Zhejiang Dahua Technology - A meaningful step for

    globalisation", 2017.5.31

    80. Oppenheimer&Co., "Enterprise Endpoint Security", 2017.1.19

    81. Oxford Business Group, "Country Profile - Colombia", 2016.2.24

    82. Oxford Business Group, "Country Profile - Ethiopia", 2017.5.15

    83. Oxford Business Group, "Kenya Economy", 2016.1

    84. Oxford Business Group, "Oman ICT", 2017.2

    85. Oxford Business Group, "Qatar Trade & Investment", 2016.7

    86. Oxford Business Group, "UAE Security, Aerospace & Defence", 2017.5.14

    87. PAC, "La Cyber Scurit en France : un march toujours plus dynamique

  • - 871 -

    autour dune filire Cyber Scurit forte", 2016.9.27

    88. Pierre Audoin Consultants, "Competitive analysis of the UK cyber security

    sector", 2013.7.29

    89. Piper Jaffray, "2017 CIO Survey_Budgets Up 2.1%; Security, Software and

    Storage Top Priorities", 2017.1.9

    90. Piper Jaffray, "Datacenter Technologies - 2Q17 Security Reseller Survey",

    2017.7.17

    91. Prime Ministers Office of Brunei Darussalam, "e-Government development In

    Brunei Darussalam", 2010.5.11

    92. PwC, "Key Findings from the Global State of Information Security Survey

    2017", 2016.10

    93. RedBurn, "Securitas & G4S_Stars of CCTV", 2016.11.21

    94. Serianu, "Kenya Cyber Security Report 2015", 2016.3

    95. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Colombia Defense Spends on Homeland

    Security: 2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    96. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Homeland Security Expenditure in Oman to

    2020: Market Review", 2016.3

    97. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Indonesia Defense Spends on Homeland

    Security: 2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    98. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Qatar Defense Spends on Homeland Security:

    2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    99. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Saudi Arabia Defense Spends on Homeland

    Security: 2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    100. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "Thailand Defense Spends on Homeland

    Security: 2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    101. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the China to

    2025: Market Profile", 2016.3

    102. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the Israel to

    2025: Market Profile", 2016.3

    103. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the France to

    2025: Market Brief", 2016.3

    104. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the India to

    2025: Market Brief", 2016.3

  • - 872 -

    105. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the Saudi

    Arabia to 2025: Market Profile", 2016.3

    106. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the United

    Kingdom to 2025: Market Brief", 2016.3

    107. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Cyber Security Market in the United

    States to 2025: Market Profile", 2016.3

    108. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Oman Defense Industry - Competitive

    Landscape and Strategic Insights to 2020: Market Profile", 2016.3

    109. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Oman Defense Industry - Industry

    Dynamics to 2020: Market Profile", 2016.3

    110. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "The Oman Defense Industry - Market

    Attractiveness and Emerging Opportunities to 2020: Market Profile", 2016.3

    111. Strategic Defence Intelligence, "United States Defense Spends on Homeland

    Security 2016 to 2025", 2016.8

    112. Symantec, "Internet Security Threat Report 2017: Volume 22", 2017.4

    113. Technavio, "Global Cyber Security Market 2017-2021", 2017.8

    114. Telstra Global, "Telstra Cyber Security Report 2017", 2017.3.30

    115. U.S. Department of Commerce International Trade Administration, "The

    Safety and Security Resource Guide", 2013.2.18

    116. UBS, "China Software and Service - How will software companies evolve in

    the age of SMAC", 2017.1.10

    117. UBS, "CyberArk Software Ltd-Unique Asset in Cybersecurity, With a

    Valuation to Match", 2016.9.9

    118. UBS, "Cybersecurity Playbook - Recalibrating for 2017", 2017.1.31

    119. UBS, "European Security Services - UBS Evidence Lab: Secure in the digital

    era?", 2016.8.30

    120. UBS, "Hangzhou Hikvision Digital Technology - Downgrade to Sell on

    stretched valuation", 2017.7.13

    121. UK Cabinet Office, "The UK Cyber Security Strategy 2011-2016: Annual

    Report", 2016.4

    122. UK Department for Culture, Media & Sport, "Cyber Essentials scheme

    research", 2016.12

    123. UK Department for Culture, Media & Sport, "Cyber Security Regulation and

  • - 873 -

    Incentives Review", 2016.12

    124. UK Trade & Investment, "UKTI Venture Capital Unit", 2015.10

    125. UN, "e-Government Survey 2016", 2016.7

    126. Wells Fargo, "Security Software_The Resurgence of the Endpoint", 2016.7.1

    127. World Economic Forum, "Global Information Technoligy Report 2016",

    2016.7.6

    128. yStats.com, "Fraud and Security in Global Online Payments 2016",

    2016.10.13

    129. yStats.com, "Global Mobile Payment Methods_First Half 2017", 2017.8.31

    130. yStats.com, "Global Online Payment Methods_First Half 2017", 2017.8.25

    131. yStats.com, "Indonesia B2C e-Commerce Market 2017", 2017.4.7

    132. yStats.com, "Iran online payment security", 2016.5.11

    133. yStats.com, "Middle East B2C e-Commerce Market 2016", 2016.5

    134. , "", 2017.2135. (JNSA),

    "2017", 2017.6

    136. , " IT ", 2016.10.4

    137. , ", ", 2016.4.5

    138. , " 2016 - UAE", 2017.4

    139. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    140. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    141. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    142. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    143. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    144. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    145. , " 2016 - ",

    2017.4

    146. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    147. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    148. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    149. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    150. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    151. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

  • - 874 -

    152. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    153. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    154. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    155. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    156. , " 2016 - ", 2017.4

    157. , "Consultation on Information Security Policy in Costa

    Rica", 2013.12.20

    158. , "2013 ", 2013.12

    159. , "2016 ", 2016.12

    160. , " ", 2015.9

    161. , " ", 2016.11

    162. , " ", 2016.10.4

    DB

    1. CIA, The World Fact Book(www.cia.gov)

    2. IMF Data(www.imf.org/external/data.htm)

    3. ITU Statistics(http://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/stat/default.aspx)

    4. UN Comtrade(https//comtrade.un.org)

    5. (KOTRA) (http://news.kotra.or.kr)

    6. ICT(www.globalict.kr)

    7. (www.kita.net)

Recommended

View more >